Question Locked

PC's Turn Off or Leave Them On

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I get this question quite often and I hear what I believe to be the wrong answer cintinually.

A home pc not on a network per se; with the exception of the internet; should it be left on all the time indefinitely or use it during the day and turn it off at the end of the or night.

At night I turn my pc off. My rationale is that turning it off reduces wear and tear, reduces the amount of heat generated, stops the CPU from running thousands of bits of data even in hibernate mode. Might it also subject it to the possibility of being hacked while you sleep???

I compare it to my truck. I come home get out leave the truck idling until the next time I get ready to go somewhere. I feel the same rationale should apply to single non-networked pc's.

I understand the need to keep corporate, business, hopital, governmental network systems running at night. If you are on a Microsoft network, SMS pushes out updates, upgrades etc at night when the traffic is much lower.

Working for the SCDOT we replaced worn out computers every 3-4 years if they last that long. I had a 1995 Gateway that ran flawlessly for 10yrs. I honestly do not believe if I let it run 24 hrs day in and day out it would have lasted that long.

Can someone provide me with an acceptable rational answer to this question.
Randy Culbertson

6 replies

by raharr

This is what I remember from way back.

In the early years, it was better to leave them on because of the process that it took to start them up. The heads and platters were so close together that the turning on and off could cause the hard drives to crash. Also the mothers would ware out. Therefore, you lost everything.

Now of days,they have come a long way in the developement of hard drives. I am from SC Columbia, and the way the weather goes, I would turn them off not matter what. I have seen lighning and brown outs that would totally screw things up BIG TIME.

I too had a old computer that lasted for years. I turn it on when I used it and turned it off when I finished. After I finally purchased a new computer, I gave it away and to this day, it is still running.

Hope this answers your question.

Russ

by rcub2

At least I found one person who believes the same as I do. I live in Ninety Six SC.
Appreciate your response.

by Former member

Transistors, I.C's have a finite amount of time between failures MTFB. They are hardest hit during power up and power down when the highest voltage surges are present. The on/off cycle, from what now seems like centuries ago, was about 50,000 between failures. From this perspective, it would be best to leave a solid state device on. However, you must also consider that capacitors and resistors are affected by heat. Most resistors are carbon based and have a positive heat coefficient. This means that the resistance increases with heat. The increased heat creates a feedback cycle in which more heat is created and thus the resistance increases even more. This is not an unlimited feedback however because other elements come into play which limit this destructive runaway. With capacitors, it depends on the type whether they have a positive or negative heat coefficient.

While there are many discrete components, capacitors and resistors play the largest part in modern circuitry, outside of the solid state devices. Working together, these two components control the phase shift of the current, or rather the AC component of the voltage and current. Leaving out the math, which I can provide, if you really want it, say a circuit is stable and the supporting resistors and capacitors produce a phase shift of 45 degrees, then the ac component of the current and voltage is multiplied by the tangent of 45, which is one. The voltage/current variation is no more than the actual variation of the DC voltage/current. During power up and power down the thermal states of the solid state devices is not stable and it is not uncommon for the devices to achieve 270 degrees or more of phase shift until the devices thermally stabilize, which happens very quickly. During this time the voltage of a 12 volt circuit can reach over 200 volts for very short times. This is when the failure occurs. Again, in a solid state device to reduce the MTFB, the device should most often be left on. There are reasons to turn it off like brown outs or thunderstorms because the supplying voltage is not stable, but generally leaving a solid state device on, when properly cooled, contributes to longentivity.

There are exceptions to this which leads to CRT monitors. A Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) uses electron ejection striking a phosphor screen. Heat is required to eject the electron beam. The anode of most tubes (which is what a CRT is) is made of aluminum. Aluminum oxidized easily. The oxidization reduces the efficiency of the CRT to eject electrons and leads to failure. With this device your greatest longevity is achieved by turning it off when not in use. This does not, however, apply to a modern LCD display where other considerations, such as the material it is manufactured with, apply.

Regarding modern disk drives. Well, all disk drives not only have electronic components, but also moving components. The destructiveness of the friction out weighs the possibilities of electrical failure. For this reason, hard disk manufacturers allow HD's to spin down when not in use, you can also find settings in your OS that allow this after a set period of inactivity.

To try to tie this together with an example you provided; do you remember the Old's 98 which was diesel powered? The belief was that because the motors of commercial trucks often lasted 2 - 5 million miles that the diesel motor of the car would last as long. This was not the case. If fact, the motor. would often fail prior to 100,000 miles. The reason why they failed so soon, much sooner than a comparable gasoline motor, was found to be that a mechanical device has the greatest frictional forces when it is cold. A trucker seldom shuts off the motor to his rig and it therefore lasts longer. In a solid state device, the thermal and electrical stresses are similar to the friction forces of a mechanical device, vacuum tubes excepted.

Best wishes, Norman

by rcub2

Thanks for the "very" technical information. I found it very informative.

Some issues I failed to state is that the majority of people I know never clean their pc and rarely if ever run virus/spyware scans or for that matter have an up to date antivirus/antispyware program. I suspect that there are a combination of factors that influence the decision to leave on or turn off question.
Randy

This discussion is closed to new replies.