Discussion Locked

Protect networks from viruses and worms

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Do you train users to not open attachments from unknown sources? Do you allow users to receive all attachments? How do you handle the constant flow of viruses on the Web? Do you think updating SMTP to include authentication is an effective method for fighting viruses? Share your comments about protecting networks from viruses and worms, as discussed in the Feb. 6 Security Solutions e-newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Security Solutions e-newsletter, sign up today!
http://nl.com.com/acct_mgmt.jsp?brand=techrepublic

23 replies

by braunmax

Generally linux software supports servers - and clients do not use outlook/exchange variants even though moct clients use windows.

Best would be if Visual Basic could also be blocked in installations (to prevent macro viruses in documents)

PegasusMail (freeware and fully featured) and Netscape are still the most popular clients here.

The firewall actively disables all but essential ports.

by felipe_alfaro

We also refuse to use any kind of Microsoft
software, mainly their secureless inoperating
systens. We primarily use Linux systems and some
OpenBSD and Mac OS X systems, as we like
multiculture.

However, the problem is not itself in the fact
that Windows is so badly designed (from a
security point of view), due to it's nature of a
game platform, DOS-based graphical environment,
letter writting and so. The real problem is that
Windows has allowed nearly everyone to use a
computer, but most of those users haven't used a
computer before, don't know how to use it and a
have no serious security knowledge (some even
don't have common sense that stops them from
opening mails from an unknown sender).

Thus, nearly spontaneously, there is a great
number of unknowledgeable people using
complicated systems like computers running on
apparently-easy-to-use-but-severly-flawed OS.
Since we are not allowed to drive a car without
a license, I dont't understand why we should we
allow users to use a computer without a computer
license.

Education is the key to solve these problems
we're facing everyday, like clueless average Joe
User opening an e-mail with a virus attached,
and spreading its payload to half the world
since that Joe User doesn't use an antivirus
and/or a properly configured firewall.

That's the real problem. Computers are too
powerful and dangerous to let anyone use one
without any kind of knowledge.

by flee74

My customers keep calling me to say
"Hey, I got lots of mails from somebodies unkown that read [1.I had sent a MyDoom mail] + [2.They detected the worm and delete the mail]"

Because this worm spoofs [Sender] field and [Return-path] field, Somebody (whose only fault is that she/he has lots of friends :)) can suffer a time-loss with this spam-like "WARNING" messages.

With this all the support(security related) staffs also suffer a energy with all explanation(+ extra jobs) to make them feel safe.

The original motive of the MyDoom-Creator(I Love him!!!) might have nothing to do with this side-effect, IMHO, But This can be another type (annoying-sort-of) of worm-attack.

What do you think of this situation????

by jim_maclachlan

Why any administrator still has a warning coming back out of their system is beyond me. Several years ago, we quit sending an autoreply to the sender of a virus. I think it was the hybris virus where we first noticed the sender being spoofed ('Real story of Snow White...' with a sender of 'sexy@haha.com' or something like that.) We thought about it & decided not to clog servers by trying to send a warning to a non-existant address.
The previous poster made some great points about the problems with Windows security - a lot of it is ignorant users - but worse, there are ignorant sysadmins. Any kid off the street can set up a network with a Microsoft server & a few workstations & hook them up to a fast pipe to the Internet. Then the kid goes away & some secretary gets stuck trying to keep the server up. In this situation, there is no network security. This is a VERY common scenario among small businesses. The owner can't see spending real money on the network. I see it all the time.
Add that in with the old, open structure of email, the Internet & the hordes of ignorant people running an OS that was made to share everything - I'm constantly surprised we don't have more incidents than we do.
Thank goodness Novell, Linux & other NOS's are out there. If we could just get a lot of software written for secure NOS's, we'd be a lot better off. I want to move to a Linux desktop (Ximian from Novell should be awesome) but we can't move there unless the software support is there.

Jim

by phil

Surely the time has come to ask more of the ISPs in fighting both viruses and SPAM. All mail traffic passes through their servers - why is it not a matter of course for them to scan for viruses, authenticate senders, track senders of dubious mail etc? Used in addition to end-user's security tools (AV, firewalls etc) that would improve matters a lot. But few ISPs seem to be doing anything much?

by chrissaw

I agree with Phil. I think that everyone is concern with that plague. A good example of that would be if each enterprise send to their ISP a database or list or whatever the format adopted of their customer, advertising domain they want pass through their ISP. That database could be maintain by the IT administrator from the enterprise. So everything entering at the ISP is first filtered against the database for the destination domain.

by bhehmann

Oh, my ISP has a whole section dedicated to AV, and one of their suggestions is, that if I receive a suspect email, I should forward it as attachment to their junk_mail address. For the last 3 weeks, I've been receiving at least 2 emails infectied with the W32/Swen worm. I've forwarded these to my ISP as suggested, but I still receive them on a daily basis. They are supposed to stop these at the gateway!

by thomas.nilsen

I believe that the only way forward in these lawless times, both with regards to virus/worms and spam, is to force all ISPs to have a minimum of systems/routines in place:

1. Antivirus software on SMTP Gateways
However, the ISPs will need support from antivirus vendors in the form of free/low cost AV scanning tools. (I don't think AV vendors big market is from the ISPs anyway).

2. MTA that blocks connections from open relay sources.
If all ISPs agreed to block traffic from know (verified by a globally owned ISP database - not a "home-grown" source) open relay sources, SPAM would not be much of an issue, at least not like it is today.

3. Active monitoring of customers/users.
A global blacklist register of customers who keep violating ISPs usage policies. Force open relay customers to shutdown or patch/fix.

4. More active shutdown of violating customers/users.
It can be quite difficult to get a customer taken of an ISP by reporting to the ISPs helpdesk. Global ISP agreements on how this should be handled must be made. (www.Dshield.org could be used as a good source for violating customers)

(5. Block MS Netbois traffic! (I can't see any good reason for these ports to be open over the internet))

6. As for prosecuting spammers... Instead of prosecuting the "spammer" (as long as the spammer uses his own mail server and not an open relay), why not go after the source of the actual spam? If Acme Ltd hires a spammer, go after Acme LTD, not the spammer.

If the ISP won't take the responsibility, they should not be allowed to operate.

by robotech

How did so many people get this virus, when not one of the persons at the companies whose networks I manage got it. DO you know what this means? Bad network Administration. I have firewall, Antivirus, and I also educate my users.

These three combinations work for me and continue to work. Why are they failing for everyone else?

by kllw

We have had one or two infected PCs. And they are the result of poor management practices. As the network director, I have repeatedly requested that we be granted the ability to lock down workstations and restrict web browsing; as of yet, we are still not allowed to do so. As a result, users surf to their pop mail accounts, and through those can still download and run whatever they choose.
Through our corporate email system, which is NOT Microsoft, we've had no viruses. Our antivirus blocked them on heuristics before the definitions were released.

by gshollingsworth

"Do you train users to not open attachments from unknown sources?"
No. Not good enough. I train users not to open unexpected attachments, even if it's from their mother or boss or sibling or best friend or the system administrator or Microsoft . . . not from anybody. I tell them if they receive an unexpected attachent, they can delete it, or verify the sender intended to send them the attachment otherwise delete it. I also advise them not to send attachments without warning. The same advice goes for e-mailed links.

"Do you allow users to receive all attachments?" I'm not in a position to enforce this, but I would only allow a select few file types.

"How do you handle the constant flow of viruses on the Web?" Again, I'm not in a position to do anything directly about viruses entering networks. I do advise sysadmins to turn off sender notification of virus infected e-mails. The e-mail gateway virus tools do need to become more header aware. Too many blindly accept the to: field as authentic. Which leads to . . .

"Do you think updating SMTP to include authentication is an effective method for fighting viruses?" Yes. Not a magic bullet, but one of many tools for not only curbing e-mail virues, but curbing SPAM as well.

by bigwazza

Every new staff member gets an induction to our system here. Part of it is the Acceptable Use Policy, and part is about viruses.

I educate my users by saying if they're not directly named, or the attachement is explicitly described, don't open it. If in doubt, see me. This gets around family & friends sending funnies.

By luck or good management, more likely both, we've not had a problem for about 4 or 5 years. We block specific attachments, and this temporarily included ZIP's because of mydoom.

The best part is our executive users know and accept we know computers etc, so if we say we block executables, they say "Good Idea". They also know they can have more added to the list (eg MPEG's), and if they have a blocked attachment, we can still get it for them.

As for notifications, we ONLY notify the recipient, because:
- One virus received had a return address of the distribution list (we received 243 virus notifications)
- most return addresses are spoofed these days
- only the recipient need know what has happened to the attachment
- any dealings are likely to be through I.S., so it's better if we deal with the virus communications to other companies personally.

Education has been the key here, but we always explain the why's and wherefore's in plain English when we do things. We encourage users to talk to us, even if the "warning" they received is 3 years old. Lastly, we thank the users for any consideration they give us (we only roll our eyes when they're not around).

Oh yes, do a Customer Service course, live in their shoes for a while, and you'll see things differently.

by gshollingsworth

Consumer broadband ISP's should take on the role similar to an IT department. Blocking MS networking ports, blocking MTA traffic from non-mail server addresses on their net, implementing virus protection measures on their mail servers, etc.

ISP's should implement some measure of blocking of spoofed origin addresses eminating from their networks.

ISP's serving medium to large businesses really should not have much need to supplement their customer's own protections, but it wouldn't hurt.

The only question is how will this be paid for?

by w. radke

Compared to the multiple users, and ISPs, etc., the SMTP protol is a common starting point for all mail transactions. In computer time the 22-year-old SMPT is quite ancient. The trick would be to develop a replacement protocol that is backward compatible with SMTP.

The first word of SMPT is "Simple" and this protol was intentionally intended to function with little available computational and bandwith resources. It is as if today's transportation system were trying to run on roads designed for the model "T"

Re-doing SMPT with the knowledge gained over the past 22 years, and with the currently available hardware and software tools, would be of immeasurable value to the Internet community.

by mgordon

We have vulnerable, widely deployed "servers" in the homes of nearly every cable modem and DSL subscriber because it is what people think they want and hence are willing to pay for. Most of these computers operate in administrator mode.

How are you going to compel people to leave SMTP? We've had alternatives for years; X.400 comes to mind -- but it was most certainly not a "simple mail transport protocol."

Authenticating mail exchangers is going to be an enormous burden on certificate authorities. Besides which, such a thing may reduce present problems with spam and viruses, but the next wave will simply locate a forwarder or smarthost, though I suppose if all forwarders inspect outgoing as well as incoming mail, emailed viruses and spam could be pretty well stomped out permanently.

by randerson

If more IT departments refused to utilize Outlook or Outlook
express, there would be less virus activity. There are plenty of
email clients out there that do not carry the dangers of these
products. If these 2 programs alone were curtailed or even
discontinued from use by companies, virus activity would take a
severe blow. One of my favories to use on the Windows platform
is Mozilla, even though there are many great ones out there.

Let's call it Environmental Cleanup for the Internet.

by richard.m.reynolds

With out a doubt updating SMTP must be done as soon as possible. There are, with the exception of initial costs, very little down side to the update. With the soring costs of spam and viruses, any costs would be quickly over turned.

by pccpr

The end user is certainly the weakest link in the armour against viruses, but there are several things I do for all users however large or small.

Spambayes or other spam filter.

More than one virus scanner (not usually simultaneously, but full scasns off hours will alternate to gain the potential benefit of the different search engines)

Desktop firewall alerts to ALL email traffic. (depending on the end user you could add other alerts)

No immediate sending of mail, set it to send every hour or so. Good enough for communications but delays the wave of a new virus. Coupled with end user education and the alert it helps a bit anyway.

Mail client choices. Unfortunately OE and Outlook are the status quo and end users, especially of outlook don't want to change. Poco mail seems like a good alternative but pointless if they won't switch.

And as a last resort, wait at least a day or so, update your scanner, then download and scan attachment before opening.

I am not that advanced, but suspect that alerts can be set for abnormal port traffic through 25 with a lockout similar to password lockouts.

by g. iraola

At least to me the fact that someone can send an e-mail using a fake address is almost unbeleivable. This is happening in 2004 not 10 years ago. The day the originator of the message can be identified most of the garbage will go away. In the case of services that do not cooperate and take measures their name can be posted and users can block the whole domain.

by okster

I am so tired of all this rubbish about smtp authentication or reverse lookups or challenge response and all that crap! Are IT writers getting paid to spout this nonsense? Has no-one ever hacked someone elses machine? What about anonymously installing an unauthorised server on an employers machine?
What makes you think that a temporary smtp server can't be setup to initiate a virus. So they can't fake the from address - big deal.
Strewth, with all the unprotected mum&dad machines out there, someone could launch millions of smpt servers, all giving the correct responses.
All this crap about smtp is just another excuse to restrict peoples anonymity.
Let's use terrorism to introduce biometric scanning and spam and viruses to tighten up government/coporate control over the internet.
I just can't believe that no-one in the media challenges this nonsense. Oh wait a minute, no it's very believable.
Pardon me while I remove my brain.

by felipe_alfaro

We need to push for digital certificates for everyone, much like the Social Security Number or other methods of public identification. We need to press governments to start digital ID projects right now.

Then, once everyone has a digital certicate enabling him/her to digitally sign messages, we can configure SMTP servers or e-mail clients to refuse non-signed messages. Messages not signed simply will go the Junk mail folder for further inspection.

by jim_maclachlan

I sincerely hope you are kidding about everyone having digital certificates. Most of the users I deal with have no clue what one is. Most seem to accept any screen that pops up in front of them without bothering to read it. Most small businesses wouldn't know how to get or protect one. Half the larger ones would have problems with it, too - theirs would expire & millions of dollars would be lost due to lost productivity.

The fact is the Internet, including email, is a free-for-all. Tightening it up isn't going to happen by any single solution. One size won't fit all. I don't want the government or anyone else telling me how I have to secure my sites - it wouldn't work. I need to be able to receive emails from people on the street who are clueless since they're my customers & I have to get more emails from small businesses as well as large ones.

Yes, it can be frustrating to control our security situation, but the methods I use work pretty well & I can modify them as needed for our business. No one gets most attachments until I've decided it's OK. It can be frustrating for the users occasionally & takes up time, but we have an excellent security record. We block a lot of known spam & such, too. It's a living & living free, without government oversight.

by snap

Thank you.
I have for years now harassed my ISPs and web-mail providers to adopt some kind of sender authentication in order to minimise spam and virus proliferation.
I have even recommended to totally block messages from certain popular free e-mail providers until they would include measures of this nature into their services. Especially MSN.com and Yahoo.com should be in a position to write authentication into their code for e-mail services.
Regards,
Ole

This discussion is closed to new replies.