Real Value of IT Work?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by highthoughts
lots of great opinons for this discussion.
i know that right out of tech school with some college i worked for compaq doing tech support in the building for a couple of different departments.
not very rewarding.
after doing that for 2 year i took a job doing roaming tech and server support with a public school. the pay was less than compaq but the hours were flexable and those people were always glad to see me.
currently i am a network administrator at an independant school K-12. i do have some interactions with the more tech savvy students and know that i really do something.
in a profession where doing your job right means that no one knows your doing anything at all working in education is mentally and emotionally rewarding where other positions are not.
National Foundation for Teaching Entrepreneurship
Through entrepreneurship education, NFTE helps young people from low-income communities build skills and unlock their entrepreneurial creativity. Since 1987, NFTE has reached over 100,000 young people, trained more than 3,200 Certified Entrepreneurship Teachers, and continually improved its innovative entrepreneurship curriculum.
Will Mechem
Member Services Director
people.love.technology
www.MLGRocksIT.com
by apotheon
If you're trying to say that a libertarian-minarchist free market economy falls under the heading of "plutocracy", you have at minimum either not read very closely what I was saying or completely missed an accurate definition of "plutocracy". I don't even know where to begin, in pointing out the flaws in that.
Individual rights involve, in essence, those rights that are directly derived from the right of self-determination. Education is neither a "right" nor a "privilege": it is a pursuit. The misidentification of various and sundry contradictory desirables as "rights" is part of the reason this country is such an untenable mess. A right is something you have ethical justification for demanding from others. To demand education from others without offering compensation is [b]slavery[/b].
Safe working conditions don't constitute a "right" either. Endangerment of one's employees constitutes a violation of rights, however, as that's a coercive act and thus violates principles of self-determination. You have no right to impose danger upon another: he has a right to be free of such imposition. One may choose to endanger oneself (for instance, by taking on work doing underwater welding), but one may not (ethically) be forced to endanger oneself.
"What about governance of the commons, would it be a violation of my rights if your pollution destroyed my health or the land I live on?"
Yes. If you harm me (with my free consent), you've violated my rights.
"Do we exist, live and die, to serve the interest of business or did we invent such concepts to serve humanity? To which you answered that this question is unimportant to you."
Nonsense. It's not "unimportant" to me. It's based on incorrect assumptions, within the context wherein it was posed. Of course such mechanisms of a market economy "should" serve humanity, but I responded within context earlier, and to divest my statements of context in an attempt to make me out to be some kind of "plutocrat" is dirty pool.
by ericlundeen
You said; ?Recently I've been pondering a lot about the real true value of what I do for a living, that being IT of course. When I say real value, I mean, what can I point out to my children and say "look, dad did this and it helps people and is worthwhile because ______."
It seems that you might be mistaking ?the real true value of what I do for a living,? with the real true value of living, that is ?being?. If your mind cannot be stopped at will?to experience the value of being, then your mind runs your life, not the essential being that you are.
The mental dilemma that you are constantly rehashing appears to ignore a basic principal of life?life is! If your children say ?my father taught me the value of being? there is no greater gift you could give them. Using your being to ?weight the scales of justice? can lead to right action that is in itself justification for anything that you ?do for a living?.
Perhaps, your presence alone is the reason you do what you do for the people you work with?that when you have given those within your immediate sphere all the help that they need, you will move on to another place where your presence is needed more?
It is difficult, but not impossible in this day and age, to remember that all the answers that you seek are within you. The dissatisfaction you experience leads you to change the situation of life that creates disharmony. When you ?grow? it can be a painful process, but you will grow.
Dear Packratt,
I am always wondering about the same thing. I am starting to think that teaching people how to use computers may be better than actually working in IT. At least I will be able to trully help people and enjoy the feedback. IT is a thankless job with none of the old perks. I think a lot of us are rethinking our careers, especially those like me who have been relearning for 20 years.
by packratt
After all, what else could you call a system that, by design, withholds the ability to read and write from children just because they were born into a family that had no wealth and owned no property?
What else could you call a system that would generate a mass of easily exploitable workers who were illiterate and thus wouldn't understand the terms of any contract or agreement that they signed, inlcuding contracts that would potentially sell themselves into slavery.
What else could you possibly call a system that, by design, would torture others via the witholding of medical treatment simply due to socioeconomic status?
What you are describing is a caste based plutocracy where the poor would be exploited and prohibited from social advancement and the wealthy would hold all the reigns of information and power.
Perhaps this is something you deem "good". But hardly something I would willingly work towards enabling.
Take care.
by rsanchez
by james.chau
by pmercer
Hi Packratt!
I work for a nonprofit healthcare delivery system in IT. The wages are competitive with the community, and the work is always challenging and interesting. We are never on the bleeding edge of technology, and we take a pretty conservative approach to the new stuff, upgrades, etc. but, because we are rather large, there are lots of systems, and lots of avenues for growth. In addition, our organization is known (at least internally) for promoting within, and supporting folks that are interested/willing to look for opportunities to grow.
So, working for a nonprofit organization (i.e. Red Cross, Blood Banks, nonprofit hospitals, etc) does not necessarily mean having to work without the benefit of a competitive wage and benefit package.
Good luck in your quest for answers!
by phil perry
My first project at the government agency I work for was creating a web search page which enabled families in my state to locate affordable day care in their town. My next project was ongoing maintenance of a system that gave annual grants to child care workers based on how well (and for how long) they thrived at a given job (they don't make as much money as they should and every little bit helped). Other projects I've been involved with include a system which tracks government policies as they moved through the bureaucracy (that one turned into a death march, but was eventually rescued by a larger team), and ongoing maintenance of payroll applications which support state employees (who in turn help the people of the state).
Pretty much everything I'm involved with is very socially progressive and helpful to the people of my state. If you really want to make a difference, get into social services and help them help others. You'll find it very rewarding; it's much better than helping company X create a prettier widget for their next software release.
Just my opinion.
by james.chau
by nicknielsen
"...the public school system in the US forces you to teach to tests and to learn trades...not to develop critical thinking skills and how to learn."
Excuse me for asking again: What's wrong with learning a trade? Much as we would like to think otherwise, most major branches of IT do not qualify as traditional "professions" (i.e. medicine, law, engineering, or teaching), but do qualify as "trades." The people in "trades" (which the tone of your post implies are beneath you) are the construction worker who built your house, the electrician who wired it, the plumber, the air-conditioning mechanic, the mechanic who fixes your car, the cable guy, the satellite installer, the telephone repairman, and yes (dare I say it?), even the PC technician.
I am an electronics/PC tech with over 30 years of experience in electronics and over 20 years of experience with PCs. I am also a Career and Technology Education (i.e. vocational) teacher in a public school district, teaching courses in electronics, digital electronics, and PC repair. Students who successfully complete my courses can take (and pass) "trade" exams such as the A+ and CET (Certified Electronics Technician). Those who meet the requirements can also receive college credit for their work.
My primary task is to teach my students to apply the knowledge from their general education (math, science, english, etc.) to the course in progress. This includes: using problem-solving skills to derive and solve equations, isolate equipment faults, and design digital circuits; using research skills to locate technical data; and using communication skills to report on findings and results. I'm also required to introduce and reinforce concepts such as timeliness, personal responsibility, teamwork, tolerance for the differences between individuals, professional behavior, etc. I'm required to do this in courses with 135 scheduled contact hours (1-1/2 hours/day for 90 school days) or 270 hours (1-1/2 hours for 180 days) and usually half again as many hours of planned instruction for each course. What with fire drills, severe weather drills, announcements, homerooms, pep rallies, student organization meetings, teacher workdays, etc., we are lucky if we actually have 100 hours of instruction per semester. That we usually complete over 75% of the planned course work is amazing!
How well I succeed depends not only on my ability as a teacher, but also on the student commitment to the course (paying attention in class, doing the homework, asking for clarification on confusing issues, etc.) and the parent commitment to education (responding to teacher contacts, attending open house, requiring dedicated homework time, etc.).
What is amazing about our schools is not that they are failing, but that so many schools succeed so often using a model that has been outdated for almost 50 years.
by apotheon
What I discuss is not "a system that, by design, withholds the ability to read and write from children just because they were born into a family that had no wealth and owned no property," and if you weren't such an obviously brainwashed little socialist drone, you might be able to figure that out for yourself. I don't know if you're aware of this, but deliberate misrepresentation of what I say for the purpose of building straw men that you can very manfully knock down with the blunt instrument of your off-target blatherings doesn't amount to much of a logical argument.
One of the problems with social programs like you seem intent on [b]shoving down my throat[/b] is that it involves confiscatory taxation, which is (in short) [b]theft[/b]. I have [b]huge effin' prolems[/b] with anything that purports to be "for my own good" but involves pointing a gun at my head. Another one of the problems with that sort of thing is that it is [b]self-defeating[/b]. By removing reward for work, you demotivate workers, ensuring that wealth production will [b]dry up[/b] and there will be no more blood to squeeze from stone to fund your bread-and-circuses approach to governance. A third problem with that sort of thing is the fact that it [b]doesn't work[/b]. All your grand plans for "redistribution of wealth" will accomplish is rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic: people fall through the cracks of any complex system, and you just ensure that different people fall through different cracks at different times.
Actually (gasp!) [b]respecting my rights[/b] and assuming that I have some clue about what I want, allowing me the [b]opportunity to provide for myself[/b] rather than stealing that from me to provide for some parasite that lives off the fat of others, will provide motivation to produce wealth, deliver it to those who most deserve it, and (as I have already pointed out) [b]increase standard of living across the board[/b]. The industrial revolution would never have happened without some characteristics of a free market economy in place, and without the industrial revolution we'd all still be living in hand-built homes with all the sturdiness and earthquake-proofing characteristics of a beer-can pyramid in a dorm room, if we could afford them, living under conditions that make the lives of the homeless in the US seem positively luxurious by comparison. I don't know about you, but I like the fact that hospitals can provide complex medical aid like organ transplants, and the fact that I have indoor plumbing. I kinda like this Internet thingy, too. Maybe you've heard of it.
Without the effects of market forces and industrial ambition, we wouldn't even know, here in the States, about the tsunami and the obscene numbers of people killed by it, let alone been able to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars in aid money [b]through private charities[/b] to help them out. The United States, bastion of the Evils of Capitalism, is the single biggest source of charity money to help people worldwide, despite having a relatively sparse population.
What I'm describing is [b]not[/b] "a caste based plutocracy where the poor would be exploited and prohibited from social advancement and the wealthy would hold all the reigns of information and power." What I'm describing is a system of abiding by natural economic laws. What I'm talking about is the fact that [b]wishing that money grew on trees doesn't make it so.[/b] What I'm talking about is a system that A) works and B) doesn't treat human beings as inert resources to be put to work. Humans are ends, not means. I am [b]nobody's slave[/b]. Being poor, even if it's not your "fault", does [b]not[/b] grant you ownership over me and my labor. If you came to my door and attempted to force me to give you a percentage of my paycheck just because you live on the street, I'd load up my Glock 22 and put a couple rounds in your soft little head. Because you have the government commit robbery for you, I don't get that option. Thanks. I'm so glad you're such an altruistic savior of the human race.
Get off your high horse and realize that you're nothing more than an apologist for thieves.
by dony_bruk
by jrowe
by james.chau
by jrowe
by james.chau
by unclerob
Did you get it all out of your system? WOW, the amount of hot air you released with your last post could have easily powered dozens of REMAX balloons across the country for years. Moral or Professional rights? Who made you the lawmaker to determine moral & prof rights, what people can do or say. Take a step down from the pulpit, no one's asking for preachers or politicians in this forum. You still never provided a decent reply to the original post (probably because your incapable), ranted for ages on topics not even remotely related to the original post - you definitely like to hear yourself talk - that is a dead giveaway. You need to calm down, pop a few pills, do whatever it is you do to get in your happy place and walk away from this type of work. You're not suited for it whatsoever. When did the original post contain a request for info on CRM, CICS, DASD, TCP/IP or SNA base code or any other acronym you wanted to throw in there.
You must be a consultant - don't give the customer what they want, tell the customer what is you think they want and then provide zero of what you promised to deliver and charge a good fee for your time spent. Do you have a paypal account, maybe I can send you a donation (NOT!) for your good work on answering the original question in this discussion which wasn't really technical to begin with - in the future try to keep on track with the topic at hand. This will be my last reply to you, I hope you don't enjoy it.
by james.chau
Providing tangible business values to your paying customers is the reason why professions are created, IT is no exception. Understand the business requirements, know the trade, do the work professionally, deliver the products with ethics and quality. These are the real values of IT work, it is no different than any other trade.
Calling things that you don't understand "hot air" and making defensive statements while at the same time trying to talk about a profession you know little of is not an ethical thing to do.
by james.chau
by kenobi5
by aceskaraoke
Thanx for all your great responses, and thanx Packratt for your honest query.
I've been learning so much from all the regulars here in TechRepublic. I'm just glad TechRepublic is such a great resource for information, advice, and (most importantly) support for a lot of underrated, underappreciated, underpaid and/or underemployed IT professionals in some hard times which are forcing many to re-evaluate their career and life choices.
P.S. mitchlr it's not a pseudonym, it's my business I'm in financing my return to school at ITT (18 years after high school) pursuing my passion for a computer intensive career. Karaoke's been good to me, but now that the kids are starting to attend school full time, it's time for daddy to get a 'real' job. I gotta free up more time to spend with the kids and more nights 'fore my wife gives up on me.
Keep the faith that what you want to achieve is never too late to accomplish, long as you're willing to do the work.
by dgalen
Often IT is defining itself as what was "LOST" after the boom. Frequently we are
all talking about how we went from making X to making X - 20, 30 or even 50 thousand
less then we are now. We are really talking about the bubble, the bubble yields the
same answers as a bubble as it does a defunct industry, mostly what I see is people
complaining that they are not making what they were before or that they are now Unemployed. Reality is simple here, some (probably more than half) enjoyed cushy jobs at extreme rates because there were simply not enough bodies to occupy the
Needed positions. Unfortunately for these people they now need to understand that the quality of people is now scrutinized, and most of their goals and achievements are now a postscript or an internet cache file. The bottom line is that many people who got jobs in this era, just don't have the skills needed to do the job. I hate
to bring it up but since the majority of posts at techrepublic are how the world got
Horrible for people after the bubble, and sometimes not even the bubble but just A willingness to dump on the president. I feel it is necessary. By and far the entrenched "TECH" industry is still doing their job or finding ways to improvise about their Technical problems. In the end it?s really simple, there were not enough bodies to fill These positions so people filled them, even if they didn?t honestly meet the REAL requirements, the positions had to be filled faster than the needs. The reality is simple; more people were training to be IT/IS technical staff than were able to contribute to the reality. Most people need to seriously take a look at their skill set and decide whether they are IT professionals or IT/income-hopefll/wannabees. This is a difficult position to admit, but many people clearly are only associated with IT/IS/Information technology, because it was simply a popular income source.
by re-invention
I think what packratt was driving is not so easily dismissed. Of course, a pragmatic way around it is to look at a job or your work as a way to fund things you want to do, but that ignores the fact that you likely give 50% at least of all of your waking hours to this hollow vehicle for funding the areas of you life you consider more meaningful to yourself or society. There are also many small ways you can build meaning into your work, but again that does not provide some overarching value add to the world. For me, the only tangible benefit I can add to society as an IT manager for a large company is to continually teach employess and externals alike entrepreneurship and help push the evolution of how we get work accomplished. Hopefully, this helps us evolve faster towards working for ourselves, thus diffusing some of the enormous centralization of power and resources within huge multinational companies. It also aims to redefine work/employment and gear people for constant change so they have a chance to thrive (not just survive) into the future.
Of course, I could be wrong...perhaps packratt just wanted to know that his work is meaningless dilbert-esque BS, and that's fine as long as he squeezes in meaningful moment or two in his scant few hours of free time :-0
I work for a major airline in Atlanta. After 25 years with the company and a spotless record, my job is in the process of being outsourced. I have a semi-IT job in the training department.
To me, the corporate world is not the place to be if you would like safety. IT or no IT. The corporate world is all about money.
If you are not one that can make the decisions, then you are the one that gets a raw deal. Plain and simple.
To me, the IT jobs that we should be seeking are in small business, not the corporate world.
by jdmercha
All life is a balancing act. You have to take the bad with the good. There is no purely good occupation. You have to take from your life what you can. If you need justification for your occupation, then you have to weigh the good against the bad, and decide for yourself which outweighs the other. I challange anyone to come up with an occupation that I cannot show that it harms somebody.
1. Any occupation is benificial to someone. If it was not, then the occupation would not exist. By the same token, any occupation is also harmful to someone.
2. Any occupation requires rationalization to justify its beneifits.
3. Here's that balance question again. Someone will benefit and someone will loose every time.
4. Non-profit does not mean non-harm. Even the Red Cross's Tsunami relief effort causes harm to somebody.
by jthornberry
I have been in the IT field for 6 years or so now having changed careers at 40 from non profit management. I spent my 20's and 30's "making the world a better place" with organizations such as Red Cross, Cancer Society, Urban Corps and don't get me wrong; I loved every minute of it. But at 40 I was looking for a new challenge and IT seemed a good way to go. Since then, I've done IT for one of the largest international ministries; a HUGE (more 2000 students) private Christian school and for a small non profit running their technology center and doing tech support/network administration. In the past two weeks I took a job with our local county government as an IT Support Specialist. It isn't IT that is the problem. I find great satisfaction in knowing that what I do enables people; such as a nationally known Pastor and evangelist or our county commissioners; do what THEY do better. My heart every morning says what I do makes a difference because without me - the social workers and public health nurses and senior advocates and judges and DA's and so forth would have a harder time doing what they do.
Look around friend, find an IT position with an organization you believe in. You may take a pay cut - but the job satisfaction will raise immensely.
Julie
by packratt
Really now, even as the saying "a rose by any other name" goes, so too does it describe our little conversation. You wish to dress it up so that you may take it out in public by calling it 'libertarianism' or 'minarchy' when what you describe has already been done before and has names and titles ascribed to it... Dickensian, yankee trader, laizze faire, plutocracy...
Those ideas are not new or revolutionary, despite what Rand worshippers might wish to believe. The market is not some magical beast that will right itself and benefit humanity by letting it run itself much the same as a wolf would not hessitate to eat all the sheep if trusted to shepard them without intervention.
The industrial revolution you site was a prime example of industry unleashed and that progress could have been obtained without paying the prices that were paid for it back then via debtor prisons, forced child labor, high illiteracy rates, high working death and maiming rates, the rampant spread of preventable disease, and high mortality rates from treatable conditions.
But, you and I will not agree, you see such prices in terms of human suffering worth paying to progress because it means more profit for a few and I see it possible to move forward at the same pace while not paying such a high price.
All power in government is quite problematic, just as entrusting all power in the hands of nobility or the wealthy few would be as well. All forms of concentrated power give rise to tyranny and abuse, no matter if you give that power to that mythical beast call "the market" or government or an individual. Democratic overnment exists to buffer, to be the voice of all people and not just a segment thereof.
...Of course, that is unless you believe your form of governance, by whatever pretty name you wish to term it, to be better than democracy.
I think we'll talk again in some other place, but for now I think we're done in this thraead. Have fun with your rebuttal and take care.
by lumens
.
Excuse me for taking this off on an unrelated tangent, but something you said just BEGS for a "therefore" conclusion.
You said, "If hospitals had to process insurance claims manually it would take countless hours and higher costs which would get passed to patients through higher hospital bills and increased insurance premiums."
So true, and I agree 100 percent.
However, therefore:
If hospitals didn't have to process insurance claims at all, it would take NO hours and NO costs which would NOT get passed to patients through higher hospital bills and increased insurance premiums.
Therefore, insurance makes medical care MORE expensive, not less expensive. So let's do away with insurance totally.
No, I'm not kidding. Yes, I'm absolutely serious.
by james.chau
by james.chau
by packratt
by packratt
There is nothing at all wrong with learning a trade.
However
I do find fault with a primary level educational program that is designed to teach trades specifically without any balance regarding other skills and information, like critical thinking skills for example.
by apotheon
"You wish to dress it up so that you may take it out in public by calling it 'libertarianism' or 'minarchy' when what you describe has already been done before and has names and titles ascribed to it... Dickensian, yankee trader, laizze faire, plutocracy..."
There are five basic possibilities, as far as I can see, for what you are if you are spouting this crap: liar, hypocrite, moron, buffoon, and ignoramus. Take your pick. Which are you? Are you even reading what I've posted? Never mind, that's a rhetorical question. It's clear that you're not reading it with any interest in actually understanding what I'm saying. You don't even address my points: you just go right back to attaching pejorative, inaccurate terms to what you don't (won't) understand.
"Those ideas are not new or revolutionary, despite what Rand worshippers might wish to believe."
Who said any of the ideas I espouse are "new" or "revolutionary"? They haven't been revolutionary since the Revolutionary War. Of course, at that time they were [b]literally[/b] revolutionary.
"The market is not some magical beast that will right itself and benefit humanity"
Of course not. Considering your track record for actually assimilating the concepts I lay out for you, though, I'm not surprised you are running with that wholly erroneous assumption.
"The industrial revolution you site"
I'm sorry, when people comport themselves as morons on substantive issues, I tend to nitpick on the inconsequentials as well. This just begs nitpicking: [b]cite[/b].
"was a prime example of industry unleashed"
And here you go into your stereotypical "Utopian" Sinclair inspired rottings-on about how industry is evil. Yeah. You run with that, if you want to. Ignore the positive aspects, the fact that forced child labor is not a necessary component of profit, and that it's possible for humanity to better itself without resorting to magical incantations to squeeze blood from stones. Interestingly enough, you seem to completely miss the fact that literacy rates didn't [b]drop[/b] as a result of the industrial revolution: they [b]rose[/b]. Your primary problem with industry seems to center around educational issues, and yet without market forces and successful, ambitious business most of the country would still suffer the abominable literacy rates of Clinton's Arkansas governorship.
"But, you and I will not agree, you see such prices in terms of human suffering worth paying"
Thanks for telling me what I think, [b]even when it directly contradicts what I've already said[/b]. You're not just stupid: you're malicious. You are running around trying to "win" a "debate" by putting words in my mouth, drawing untenable conclusions, and insisting that conjuring wealth from thin air is more effective for relieving suffering than motivating people to produce wealth. You're clearly a product of the public education propaganda machine.
"All power in government is quite problematic,"
No sh*t, sparky.
"just as entrusting all power in the hands of nobility or the wealthy few would be as well."
No sh*t, sparky. Somehow, though, you seem to think I disagree with this. Gee, you must not be paying attention. Big surprise.
"All forms of concentrated power give rise to tyranny and abuse,"
Exactly. That's why a distributed-power free market is about the only thing going in terms of workable solutions. The alternative to not concentrating power is to ensure nobody has it, which pretty much involves nuking and paving the planet.
"no matter if you give that power to that mythical beast call 'the market'"
Maybe I was too harsh on you. Maybe you're not malevolent, after all. Maybe you just have no clue.
"Democratic overnment exists to"
Oh, I love these "democracy is t3h ru13z0rz" arguments. Democracy is the tyranny of the masses, pal. Thank goodness we don't live in a true democracy, else the problems we're currently having with the government would be much worse by now.
Here's hoping that's the last time you "respond" to me by attacking things I didn't say and "facts" that aren't true.
by admin
I do it anyway. It has a value to myself, and the world fluctuates on it's value constantly.
Refusing to work anywhere that is not fun severly limits your value in the eyes of the world though, but, as my old school biker bretheren used to say: "FTW". Perhaps original Christianity put it more kindly saying: "Be in the world, but not of it" but basically, what does matter that is valued by the world in the end?
IT is no different.
Do what ya want- Do what ya like. Don't expect anyone else to thank you but you. That's my Mantra today :>
by james.chau
by admin
As is labor. I like to till. I go home and till in my greenhouse for fun these days.
Of course, you could be saying we sit on chairs too much in IT and this is outside of God's plan... but if you believe that, why sit here and post :)
Of course its a drag about the sin thing and all, but hey, it's still fun for me to do work I like :)
by jennyn
This is the tip of the iceberg. I worked corporate the first 3 yrs of my IT career, then wanted to give something back. Started applying to all sorts of social & NP orgs, until I got a job in a large HIV services org in the 90s. It was the best job ever, and there was a very clear connection between what I did and what the org gave the clients. Supporting the staff was as good for me as providing the service. And if I ran an efficient ship and a stable network - I new charity money was being well spent.
Now I am what is called an eRider or Circuit Rider (see eRiders in previous list) - i have a grant funded position and travel around a pretty large territory providing a wide range of tech services to NP groups. Admittedly this is a fairly unusual job, but any large NP organization needs IT staff on board - so if you are in the city it is easier to find work (big nonprofits).
If your drive is political, of course there's work there too. As well as the job listings I mentioned, whatever your passion is, look for organizations in that field and contact them.
www.guidestar.org is a database of all nonprofits in the US, and you can search by geography or type.
You can spend days researching all the np tech resources. Have fun doing it.
by gdoc
Storytellers, cave painters, scribes, printers, computer and network engineers. This is a truncated list of "information technology" workers over a period of years. Though some actually came up with the content, it is the relay of this content that gives it significance to the world as a whole. Someone may be brilliant, but if they cannot relay the information how can it be of any import?
You work in an industry that permits the widest possible, to date, dissemination as well as correlation of "content". The uses of this content is varied, some good, some bad, but you are not directly responsible for the use anymore than a automobile manufacturer is responsible for a bank holdup if their product is used as a getaway car. You provide the conduit for information, or knowledge that is integral to modern communication. This includes research, critical support services, education, as well as the rich getting richer, the powerful getting more power, &c., but are we worse off than when books were rare, and few could read? I think we support the capability for people to make informed decisions, as to whether they use that capability??sigh.
by james.chau
You left out a key part of IT, that being electricity. Although it is still information, but IT would not work without electricity, yes, batteries are fine too. Is newspaper part of IT ? hmm.....how about the fingerprints on the newspaper which was used to conceal the weapon in a bank holdup ? or the CRT used to bonk the poor soul on the head ?
IT doesn't just make the rich richer, but also go bust, look at the dot com folks, or the news media or business form publishes, airlines, hotels, shops, etc...
by zlitocook
by bsod_420
To sum it up...
At work: I work in the IT field to do the exact functions you described, and more.
At Home: I work in the IT field to provide for my family. Also, when I am not at work, I engage in activities that make me feel like I am "Really Helping People".
.
Regardless of the extent to which insurance processing may or may not be automated, medical insurance makes the cost of delivering health care more expensive - much more expensive. The irony, however, is that the "insurance industry" is marketed to people who are looking for cheaper health care for themselves, but by its mere existence it's made health care more expensive for everyone.
by lumens
.
Let's assume that your doctor wants to make $750 a day, and she bases her fees accordingly. Let's further assume that she sees her patients for 20 minutes, and will see, on average, twenty patients a day. If she had absolutely no expenses, and divided her $750 salary evenly between the twenty patients, each patient would have to pay about $38.00 for the visit. In my opinion, that sounds like a really a pretty reasonable fee.
However, as we both know, she does indeed have expenses. She has rent and utilities, so add $5 per patient. She has a full time receptionist and a nurse on staff, so add another $10 per visit. She has all the other expenses, such as supplies and equipment, so add another $5. And she has the magazines (a little medical humor, there) so add a buck or two for those. So these expenses bring each patient's cost up to $60 per visit. But she ALSO has one or two people, not to mention additional equipment and office space, who do not contribute at all to the delivery of health care, but ONLY to process insurance claims. So add another $10 per patient per visit for that as well. So make that $70 per visit.
The necessity to process the insurance claims does indeed require your doctor to hire people whose sole function is anything but delivering "health care". If the doctor didn't have that expense, the office visit would be less. But now consider the huge HMOs and clinics and hospitals, who have to maintain entire departments for the processing of insurance claims. My guess is that the average hospital in America spends tens of millions of dollars each and every year simply processing insurance claims. Do you think those costs are taken out of the hospital's profits or doctors and nurses salaries? No, they're not. They are passed on to you and me -- the consumer of health care.
And do you want to consider the additional expense of medical malpractice insurance premiums? If you want to estimate what the average hospital might have to pay in premiums, just consider that your family doctor has to pay upwards of $100,000 per year just for the insurance premiums. That's another cost that's passed on to you and me -- the consumer of health care.
But wait. Because these doctors and hospital costs are getting so high, the consumer of health care, you and me, buy medical insurance. We pay thousands of dollars each and every year in insurance premiums so that we have the pleasure of having that insurance company nickel-and-dime everybody to death so they can make their profits as large as possible. Don't you just love it when you pay thousands of dollars every year to your insurance company so they can turn around and deny the $100 claim for lab work that your doctor recommended? Oh, you don't pay the insurance premium, you might say. Your company does. Well don't be fooled. Whether you actually write the checks for the premiums or your company does, it is indeed part of your overall salary package.
But what about the people who don't have insurance? Well, there's the free clinics and city hospitals that will take them for free. They provide FREE medical care for all those skinned knees and runny noses, and drug overdoses and abortions, and just about anything that happens. Isn't that just swell? Nope, those costs get passed onto the others who really DO pay.
Even looking at it in this simplistic way: You pay the medical insurance, and the medical insurance pays the doctor. But where you pay $100 for the insurance, the insurance company pays only $50 to the doctor. Why not eliminate the middle-man and you pay the doctor directly? Medical insurance is indeed part of the medical delivery system. And it's a cost that does absolutely nothing for the delivery of health care.
Don't fool yourself. Nothing is "free" and nothing is "cheap". Someone pays for it in the long run. And who might that be? The consumer of health care, you and me.
If we could wave our magic wand and totally do away with the "someone else pays" system of health care, and we purchased health care just like we might purchase our groceries, the costs would literally spiral - a downward spiral, that is.
by apotheon
Completely aside from maxwell's points about insurance increasing healthcare costs, the extant insurance industry increases insurance costs as well. The realities of an insurance system run within the resitrictions of corporate law in this nation do a lot to jack up prices behind the scenes. It takes a lot of bureaucrats just to keep the paperwork machinery moving, for instance. There's also the fact of insurance in a corporate system being more vulnerable to lawsuits than in a direct insurance (noncorporate) system, as the complexities of corporate law and the indeminification of individuals against personal litigation actually contribute to the prevalence of lawsuits directed at the corporation, which in turn increases insurance premiums across the board to "correct" for the losses to legal overhead. The most insidious problem of it all, though, is based in the simple fact that the people running the insurance industry actually prefer higher healthcare costs and will do what they can to increase them.
To think that they want healthcare costs to be lower is naive, I'm afraid. Lower costs do indeed increase the profit margin for a given insurance premium rate, but without volume of business that rate is meaningless for determining profit. Insurance companies cut down on their costs not by cutting healtchare costs, but by increasing volume of business. The more business they do, the more the process of dealing with it can benefit from automation. Automation procedures have a fairly static buy-in cost, with extremely small increases in cost for adding more "units" of service. That means that the more business they do, the more money they make above and beyond the initial buy-in cost (which is often measured by quarter or by fiscal year). Volume of business is increased by ensuring that healthcare costs are too high for anyone to reasonably afford without insurance.
Of course, without insurance businesses on the scale of major corporations like Blue Shield, the power to affect the base cost of healthcare wouldn't be there. Smaller providers (such as would exist in a system where only sole proprietorships existed, for instance) don't have that kind of across-the-board power, because there just isn't the ability to expand to fill out so much of the market and exert influence there.
When a business gets too big, it begins to be able to use coercive measures to alter the state of the market. For instance, insurance companies regularly sue doctors, ostensibly to get out of paying on a particular claim. Usually, the suit costs more than paying the claim would, though. One can only assume, I think, that the real reason for the suits is to help keep healthcare costs artificially inflated so that people will need insurance to be able to afford doctor visits.
Examples of how the insurance industry, its top providers being powerful corporate interests, manipulate the healthcare industry are numerous.
by qualasaida
My Greetings to you all
First of all I think you are very lucky being a father. The fact that you are using your knowledge and skills to perform networking tasks and thus making a living to support your family shows that you are doing a job of great value.
Please remember that no one can change the world alone. You might be able to change or affect a small part of it, and change it to the better. But even that requires a lot of time and effort...and sacrifice. I am sure that many of us do have the will, but do we have the means? Individuals like Mother Theresa did try, and some did make a difference. But that's only because they put aside their personal needs; no family, no car, no house, no kids or family...etc.
The problem is that money is so central in everyone's life. There is something wrong with the way our society is organized. That has worried me for a long time, and the fact that we are being so materialistic reminds me of other problems such as pollution, world resources...etc. And that's when I come to the conclusion that the world can only change when your and my boss change to less greedy individuals and start giving to the needy.
Just want to add that you seem like feeling guilty because you cannot see "the result". Have you considered working with Health Information Systems? Personally I think it is one of very few areas where IT does make a big difference.
Or perhaps you are the right person for a PhD degree where you can do research on solving a major global problem?
Only together we can achieve. Remeber the puzzle? You need all the pieces to solve it, just like you need every individual's resources and co-operation to make the world a better place.
by lumens
.
Absolutely not. I do not support even a hint of a public health care system. In fact, I would support just the opposite.
In my opinion, you should purchase your health care, and I should purchase mine.
There is no such thing as "free" health care, and especially not in Canada. Somebody pays for it, and in Canada's case, everybody pays for it whether they want to or not, and whether they use it or not.
And in my opinion, health care in America always WAS affordable until the advent of the insurance system. Whenever you have a third-party payer system for anything, the cost will increase.
I don't expect anyone else to pay for my automobile body repairs; and I don't expect anyone else to pay for my personal body repairs. And neither should anyone. That's what public health care systems do; and that's what our insurance system does, albeit to a lesser degree.
by ssebaugh
I sooo, agree with your point..having done exactly what you described for a boss that is now on his way to jail (Bernie from MCI/Worldcom). I saved them money and then trained my replacement who took the job out of the country to India!
I have asked this question myself, and I put in many 60-70 weeks for these dudes!! What a knuckle head heh?
by ssebaugh
I sooo, agree with your point..having done exactly what you described for a boss that is now on his way to jail (Bernie from MCI/Worldcom). I saved them money and then trained my replacement who took the job out of the country to India!
I have asked this question myself, and I put in many 60-70hr weeks for these dudes!! What a knuckle head heh?
by wtsantos
Mitchlr,
Thanks for your words of wisdom!
by biztechchick
by aussierob
by m_cg
First, this is an outstanding topic to raise. I will try to keep my two suggestions simple and direct.
One, we live in a society and world where it is difficult to make a large impact as a worker or small organization. Consider the other options out there. You can be in sales, accounting, law, or even environment resources; but, unless you are high in the food chain, your impact is likely to be with the small group of people you deal with. If you are making these people's jobs easier, what more can you do within the context of your job. If others reward your efforts by removing others jobs, primarily that is not in your control. I find this frustating, but neither you or I have the juice to impact our work environment more than our position allows.
Arguably we can do something to change the system, but I do not see that occurring from within the system at this time. Therefore my second suggestion is you may need to make this type of difference outside your job.
by qtmtn
I have read many discussions here at the center and find them informative and, of course, provocative. Much of the subject matter elicits emotional response, as it should. We (at least most of us) have varying amounts of passion for what we do. For many years now, I have also questioned where all this is going. My instinctive, quiet, self tells me our desitination is rough and rocky.
Even though Bucky Fuller was firm in his theory that computing power would eventually solve its own inherint problems, my own conclusions point to a totally different outcome. We continue to put great effort into increasing the power of computing to solve problems that seem to be created from greater computing power...
by apotheon
by t1g312
by apotheon
I frankly can't be bothered to read the rest of the exchange between the two of you very carefully right now. I will say this, however:
Taken as a statement out of context, I'm inclined to agree with your last post, james.chau@rogers.com . . .
by blueknight
How you look at the IT field can determine whether you see value or not.
The IT field constantly evolves as best evidenced by the advances in the hardware we work with and the many programming languages that have come and gone.
If you listen to the news and get wrapped up in the doom and gloom atmosphere surrounding all the reports of outsourcing and other personnel reductions, sure, you're going to think it not worthwhile. A lot of this can come from the very environment you work in... or at least from how you view the organization you work for. Much of the problem you express concern about comes from uninformed management that doesn't have the vision to see that when times get tough, they need to rely on us IT folks to give them the information to make it better... to help them make tough decisions.
It sounds to me like you need to work for a different type of organization where you can get a different perspective. Some respondents have suggested working for a non-profit, which would be worthwhile, but you'll probably not make much doing that. You can volunteer for a non-profit in your spare time and I'm sure they'd be greatful for the experience you bring.
I'd suggest a switch to something like law enforcement (my field) or maybe work in the IT department of a hospital, or something else that provides service to the public.
I worked in the private sector for the first half of my career and have worked in the public sector for the last 20 years. Before working with law enforcement, I worked in the school system. I enjoyed it at first, but the more I watched as the district simply wasted money on technology and consultants with nothing to show for it, I had to get out.
I enjoy law enforcement tremendously. The work I do helps law enforcement do its job to keep the public safe by getting the law breakers off the streets, helps the D.A. handle their cases and makes a very busy Court system run much smoother. I'm working with the most complex software I have ever worked with anywhere and it is simply a blast. What we do here makes life better for the citizens that live here. If it didn't take money to live, I'd do this for free --that's how much I enjoy it.
What you need to do is to take a long hard look at yourself to determine exactly what field of business would make you happy to work in... consider everything. Look at what the corporate mission is and whether it lines up with what would make you feel proud to work at. Try to cultivate some contacts in the field... go on some informational interviews to get more information.
Work is a lot like life in general. How you feel about it is a direct result of how you look at it.
Take off those blinkers and get back out there man!
Good luck,
Jim
(IT dude for 39 years and counting)
by lweight
I work in a small coastal Oregon library district, and every day I see the benefits that computers bring to many people in this community. Back in 1995, when we got our first link to the Internet, one of the first questions we were able to answer using resources not available in print was for a person who was considering being a bone marrow donor, but was afraid. We found discussion groups where people shared their experiences, as well as authoritative research articles giving a balanced report of many proceedures. The person decided to be a donor and the person who received the marrow lived. We now have over 30 computers, (both Mac and PC), for staff and the public and could not function without them. Small libraries do not have the budget to purchase all the reference books that we need, let alone the space to shelve them. All of our catalog and circulation records are on computer. As an "old-timer" I worked in the library BC (before computers) and remember how labor intensive typing and filing catalog cards and compiling daily circulation statistics were. I could go on and on, but I hope you get the picture. Libraries are a place for people to get all sorts of help, not just recreational reading (although that can be very helpful in many situations)and libraries need not only affordable hardware and software, which is made possible by all the IT workers out there, but libraries also need IT workers, both people with library degrees who specialize in IT and people without library degrees. If you really want to see the results of your IT work every day, consider working in a public library.
Linda Weight
Librarian I/LAN Admin
Siuslaw Public Library District
Florence, OR.
by j.penney
This is a huge discussion, but I've spent the last 15 years trying to find some kind of answer to it. What I've found it comes down to is this: if the company you work for is ultimately doing something you consider worthwhile and helpful to the world and you're contributing to their successful achievement of that goal, then you are spending your life wisely. You will be able to say to your kids: "I helped put a cure for disease X on the market". Alternatively, you could end up saying "I helped put VIOXX on the market".
So there's a risk, and the question becomes, "do we have some control over what our work is used for?"
Luckily, most of the time we do. All you have to do is look carefully and honestly at what your company produces, and what their practices are like. Hold yourself to a standard of only working for companies that fit your ideals and don't make big compromises.
For example, I ended up working at Harvard Clinical Research Institutes, a loose affiliate of Harvard University and Beth Israel Deaconess medical center. They manage clinical trials for stents - those little tubes you stick in someone's artery during an angioplasty. I worked there because I figured they were regulated by the FDA and were at least doing useful research. As you would predict, this was naive of me.
Although most of the people working for the company had the highest of moral values, there was a crucial point in the process where the integrity was horribly violated by the actions of one of the higher-ups. So I left, making lots of noise as I went.
The end result of this was that I found out they were not living up to my standard, and by leaving I removed myself from complicity. While I was working with the company I was carefully inspecting their process, getting to know the people involved, and refusing to compartmentalize my job. I considered myself responsible for the output of the company, and acted as if I was personally responsible. As a result, I left with a clean conscience and I had a hell of a time finding more work because, how much cleaner can you get than working for a hospital?
Anyway, I'm currently investigating the possibility that working for many small, local companies may hold more promise on the ethical/moral front, due to their limited political power and small area of effect.
As far as the money goes, IT has only monetary value in the eyes of a business, and it is viewed as a cost center. What we need to do is stop ASKING what our work is worth, and start TELLING them what it's worth - thus the idea of a guild, in the old sense of the word, has particular significance to everyone having these thoughts.
I've thought over the idea of a guild quite carefully and welcome contacts who are interested in discussing it.
j.penney@computer.org
Good Luck finding an answer.
by j.penney
This is the old Luddite problem. Some people blame technology. I blame social decision-making.
I am about to criticize some of the ideas you presented, please don't take this personally. I apologize in advance for the bluntness and lack of nuance intrinsic in the email mode of communication and assure you I mean you no disrespect.
---After we constructed a new network, centralized our phone system, established a nation-wide satellite network, etc... it took us about a year before we were down to about 300 employees.---
The problem is hidden in this sentence. The assumption that you want to get rid of employees is the cause of the problem. Eventually the managers would have done this - you just enabled them to achieve it quickly. And competition will always make this happen. This is the central problem in competitive economies in which financial capital is treated as valuable and labor capital is treated as worthless. Alone, you could not stop this from happening. Only by changing the decision making processes of the society could you stop it. However, the following rationalizations must be debunked.
--...those 300 employees were much better paid than before--
Were they 700/300ths better paid? Because if they weren't then the difference went into someone's pocket and the 400 other employees paid the price. Again, not your fault - but this must not be dismissed easily.
--were able to easily accomplish the work of the 700 prior employees--
but did the other employees get a say as to who gets the rewards of the work begin accomplished?
--had significantly improved working conditions, etc....--
Again, this is a decision made by people running the company. As time goes on, if no pressure is put on them to maintain good working conditions, conditions will worsen. A temporary gain at best.
--To those 400 people who were now without a job, you can say that IT was a key destructive force to them. --
IT isn't the problem, managers are the problem, centralized power is the problem, lack of political power of the laborer is the problem.
To the other 300, you can say that IT was a force that gave them the opportunity to shine. --
IT allowed the managers to pocket anything remaining of the 700/300dths of the workers' salaries, and you can be sure these 300 workers will also be eliminated in the future, the moment the opportunity arrives.
Again, the bluntness that comes across here is a result of email being a low-bandwidth communication, and I hope the tone of this is understood as being analytical, and not hypercritical.
Take care.
by j.penney
packratt said:
To the point, my skills increase the efficiency of business, as you correctly point out. However, this increase of efficient and profit margin result in more people being laid off and becoming unemployed as this is ultimately what businesses have done with those efficiency gains (do more with less)...
--------------
Well said, packratt. In fact, "fewer people doing more things" and "CEO's and investors making more profit for doing nothing" are two really good definitions I know for "efficiency". An interesting exercise to try with people who talk about "efficiency" is to ask them "efficient at what?" - after all, the word "efficient" should be an adverb. The definition in WordNet is "able to accomplish a purpose; functioning effectively" - both of these things require that the noun that is efficient must be DOING something, and that's actually what the adjective applies to - the amount of wasted X from activity Y - with an inverse proportional relationship.
So businesses that are "more efficient" - as you point out - are specifically more efficient at ELIMINATING COSTS - and everyone who's been to business 101 class knows that employees are the number 1 cost.
That's what we do - that's what business attempts to do - eliminate employees. So we do it, but so does everyone else who works for a business and tries to be "efficient" and "take on more responsibility".
So don't be hard on yourself, you're right - we are supposed to create unemployment - but we can stop it, if we want to.
The secret can be found by contacting me at j.penney@computer.org
Later.
by j.penney
Look, no offense, but this is just not true.
The CEO's job is to increase the shareholder value, and usually that's in the short term.
The easiest way for me to increase the shareholder's value of your company in the short term is to buy it, fire you and sell off the assets.
A big part of your manager's job is to eliminate your job (and thus you) if possible, and his motivation to do this is that if he does, he gets to keep part of your salary for himself.
I understand that if the company isn't profitable then people get fired and salaries go down, but it's a really big mistake to think that the CEO doesn't get a big chunk of any profits we create.
Interestingly enough, in several of the management schools I've looked into one of the mantras repeated by all the professors is "profit is the result of the activities of management" - I bet that's a surprise to all of you who work every day to make the company run.
Take care.
Don't go down the path of telling me what I "shouldn't" comment on. I believe in people having the right to say what they feel. It's an often overlooked little thing called "freedom of speech."
By the same measure, others are free to comment on, and even disagree with (gasp!), the things that I say. What's good for me is good for them. I believe in equality and personal responsibility--something that is very lacking in our nanny-state culture.
As for the rest of your comments, it seems as though you have a problem with "rich" people and companies, too. Sounds like you are the person who needs the hug.
If you don't care for your station in life, or your income level, do something to improve it. If you aren't willing to work hard to achieve what you want, I don't want to hear you whine about your circumstances.
I may come across as a bit harsh, but I am sick and tired of lazy crybabies in this country, and liberals (socialists/communists) who want to use the power of government to steal from the producers to give to those who are content to leech. Every time I hear someone start to whine about things like this, it sets me off.
As for the future, read over my comments again. I did not say that IT pros would be able to stop every little threat or attack. I simply believe that we may end up being the best hope, and last line of defense, for the future of privacy and security.
Without us, what's the alternative?
by apotheon
by apotheon
by james.chau
According to the Census Bureau the number of Americans without health insurance rose by 1.4 million last year to 45 million (15.6% of the population). A full report on the uninsured as well as the number of people living in poverty can be read at http://www.census.gov/prod/2004pubs/p60-226.pdf
About 28,000 Americans died every year as a result of medical problems requiring surgeries but were unable to afford them. This figure is also rising rapidly.
by apotheon
You've made some interesting assumptions, there. For instance, you assumed (or at least presented the assumption) that because someone was unable to afford a surgery, he or she was unable to afford insurance. That's not strictly the case.
Insurance, including government healthcare programs (regardless of the country in question), often doesn't cover a wide range of necessary surgeries. Furthermore, there are a great many people who accept lesser-quality healthcare because it's "cheaper", or even "free" in the case of government handouts. Government healthcare programs provide a strong disincentive for actually getting some health insurance of your own, even though the healthcare provided is necessarily (due to economic constraints on a strongly bureaucratic, not-for-profit system) of lower quality than actual paid-for health insurance provides.
Statistics can mean whatever you like, as long as you're willing to ignore important matters like motivating factors and social causality.
.
If there were 300 million Americans without health insurance, the cost of health care would plummit.
.
You said that, "Insurance helps those who cannot pay." And you went on to say that, "ones who can pay do not want to help the ones who cannot pay." And then you blamed "profit" motives for higher prices.
There are two things wrong with these statements.
First of all, it's a fallacy that private enterprise causes higher prices because of profit motives. Actually, private enterprise, when competition is allowed to exist unencumbered and without interference, actually results in LOWER prices, not higher. Monopolies -- whether they are private or government -- is what causes higher prices. To blame "profit" motives is silly.
Second of all, you make the assumption that people who can afford it "don't want to help". Again, that's silly. Lower prices will help everybody. And competition ALWAYS results in lower prices -- ALWAYS. Name one industry where competition has not resulted in lower prices.
Moreover, health care is not a right. It is a commodity. And what gives you the right to demand that someone else pay for your commodity -- your health care -- just because you can't afford it? I suppose you expect someone else to buy your computer as well?
by packratt
Of course, you are answering assumptions with assumptions, pots and kettles et al...
Allow me to explain what really happens, at least in my case, and you'll see it has nothing at all to do with your government bogeyman.
Family of four; me, wife, two sons. Wife has a painful and debilitating, but treatable chronic illness that prevents her from working but could be healed with surgery. Had one surgery that was successful for a few years but the condition returned after I had lost employment and medical coverage. The condition is due to a congenital defect, so it wasn't a result of neglecting one's health.
So, we have to live on one income. I haven't been able to find full time employment that pays enough to support a family on one income while offering insurance and the ability to take enough time off to care for my family while my wife has a major operation... Heck, can't find perm employment at all, been moving around to contract after contract after we lost the house.
Contracts do not offer medical insurance, and when they do it's at a high rate that I cannot afford, besides the ones I can get have pre-existing exclusion clauses. Private coverage is way too expensive (since group coverage is), and I do make just over the ammount that would qualify for government coverage.
My wife has endured this painful and debilitating and potentially life threatening curable disease for years because we cannot afford coverage and definitely cannot afford the treatment. Doctors only order tests we cannot afford and Emergency rooms refer her to a doctors office or specialist that we cannot afford, all the while those bills just add to the overwhelming debt.
For us, a government solution never entered into the equation, we don't have that option. But the private solutions don't exist and still wouldn't exist even without government.
Imagine, if you could, that you were forced to endure dibilitating pain, pain so bad that it made you curl up in a ball, for years. All the while knowing that someone could stop that pain but wouldn't just because you couldn't afford to pay that person. Doesn't that sound like the worst sort of extortion there is?
No wonder doctors and insurance companies can charge unpayable fees. Your money or your life. I shudder to think what it would be like without even the minimal government regulations that exist today as you would propose we have.
by apotheon
I haven't made any assumptions about it at all. Your statement that I made assumptions then went on to ignore the idea of actually identifying any assumptions in what I said. I have gone over what I said, looking for any accidental assumptions I made on the matter, and found none. As such, I dismiss it out of hand until such time as you actually identify an assumption I made. If and when you do so, I will consider the matter once more with an open mind.
You present your circumstances as somehow representative of the whole. Anecdotal evidence of one "test case" doesn't equate to strong evidence of prevailing trends. Without being able to show a fairly linear trend in similarity of percentages at different scales of supposedly representative population segments, there's just no justification for presenting any selection from the whole as being representative of that whole, and one single case proves nothing unless you're arguing against an absolutist argument. Since you're not, your anecdote serves no useful purpose in this discussion that I've discerned. I feel for you, really, but it doesn't change the facts of the issue at hand.
On the other hand, even making the assumption (for argument's sake) that your particular set of circumstances is representative of a significant segment of the population (which it may or may not be), it certainly doesn't provide any good reasons for going to a socialized healthcare system. You point out that some people fall through the cracks in our hybridized system, which is true. You assume that no fewer people will fall through the cracks in a truly free (that doesn't mean anarchic) market, and I quite disagree with that, but for the sake of the argument we'll just pretend you said "Even if less fall through the cracks in a free market economy, there are still some falling through the cracks," and with that I tend to agree.
None of that in any way indicates that a fully socialized medical system would make anything better. In fact, there's a great deal of evidence to the contrary, including the fact that Canada is hemmorhaging trained medical personnel, most of the best treatments in the world (not counting those that haven't been approved by the FDA) are available primarily (if not only) in the United States. Also keep in mind that using hospitals in countries with more-socialized medical care is like having to deal with the California Department of Motor Vehicles to get a doctor's visit (keep in mind that I've personally had to deal with both the CA DMV and hospitals in countries with heavily socialized healthcare).
To your statement that "private solutions don't exist and still wouldn't exist even without government," I say: Prove it. At least give me a logically sound explanation of why not. Then, if I don't decapitate your argument with ease, proceed to tell me how socialized healthcare would make things any better.
Another quote from your post: "Imagine, if you could, that you were forced to endure dibilitating pain, pain so bad that it made you curl up in a ball, for years. All the while knowing that someone could stop that pain but wouldn't just because you couldn't afford to pay that person. Doesn't that sound like the worst sort of extortion there is?"
Sure, it would if it were being inflicted on me by another person. If, however, it's the result of bad luck and genetics, I'd probably consider it to be, err, bad luck. Nobody has any "right" to violate the laws of physics, nor to be compensated for bad luck at the expense of other people just because they don't suffer the same bad luck. Stealing my money won't make your luck any better: it will only make mine worse, along with your integrity.
Doctors and insurance companies can "charge unpayable fees" because they exist in a controlled, monopolistic market, not because they address a necessary problem in the course of doing business. If nobody could pay their fees, and they weren't able to extort money using the government strongarm to shoehorn them into the industry, insurance conglomerates wouldn't be able to charge exhorbitant rates because nobody would be paying them. If government wasn't so involved in the insurance market, companies whose purpose is to provide healthcare coverage at various economic levels would be able to fill in the gaps in the system and provide various levels of insurance for various economic classes. True competition, where one can enter the market simply by being able to provide a needed service effectively, would cause prices to minimize at a level that covers expenses plus some nominal provit, whereas profits are maximized in the current system because direct competition doesn't exist.
I have wondered for years if IT was really the way to make a difference. I tell myself that you do make a difference every day when you help someone else achieve more. My clients over the years have provided validation of my efforts. The upper management just looks at how much we cost. I was recently downsized after 21 years of service. The director level guy told me that I should just realize that being an IT guy is just being a technical prostitute and that I should not be concerned about getting any respect.
When I left the company a dear friend told me that this change does not touch who I am because my job has never been the definition of me as a person. After 21 years, my job does not define who I am as a person, perhaps that is success!
by the admiral
The value of IT is a simple equation.
IT + Value = 0
IT + Value
---------- = Don't know what you had
cutbacks until it's gone.
Packratt,
What you are seeking is a true answer of where is the value lies, but what i see that there is no right or wrong which value you would like to choose.
What you asked is like which one is more valuable saving a person's life that is sit beside you or 1000 person's life that is far away than you if you have been given a choice by a terrorist. The questions lies back to what do u want it to be. What is right for you is what is count as a value to you. No one has the right of saying it's wrong for your choice, coz hey its not their life, its yours. Of course whatever thgs you choose it will have the opposite reaction of it. That is what they call life balance.
I dont see it as an IT value only, you put it in such a way that restricted to job only. Why not make it bigger as part of value of your life everyday. If you stand on as contributing to other people everyday, so let it be your value then, but you can't ctrl how people will use it to their own advantage, but at the same time you still can control what should be done next. The important thing is you believe on what you do is the right thing and you move on from there. If we just seek whether it is right or wrong before we take any action of it, we would never know the result, and if we dont know the result, we wont never learn and if we never learn we wont grow. Hey life is just a wasted if we choose not to grow everyday. Naturally life is about growing. That's my 2 cents worth.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending