Discussion Locked

Reassignment of duties

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What's the proper way to reassign a particular task from on person to another. You tell the person losing that task first - get his feedback... right? In my years of experience, that's been the norm.

I'm a network/security administrator at a medium sized agency. I was copied in on an e-mail from the boss to our helpdesk guy that he's to take over running mail/web filter reports that get submitted to HR every week. That's not a helpdesk function, and should remain in the realm of network security (which would be me). These reports contain _very_ sensitive information regarding employees (i.e., those who surf websites related to specific health or personal problems... one incident we had with a VP surfing kiddie porn, etc...). The less people who know these things - the better.

That's one thing that I hate - when you find out a duty has been reassigned to someone and you find out by being CC'ed in the e-mail, rather than being approached first.

I fired off an e-mail back to my boss raising my objections. His response should be interesting.

Am I on the money here - or should I just be happy I have one less chore to worry about? I'd much rather I continue performing this task because the reports also help me analyze trends in mail/web usage, detect patterns of abuse and possible network security functions. Of course, I can always re-run the reports I need - but why duplicate the effort and have another set of much more inexperienced eyes on what could be very damning information?

18 replies

by j.lupo

You may not like my answer, but here goes.

How did you phrase it in your e-mail to your boss? Did you explain why you felt this task should remain in your area from a business perspective? or where you "emotional" about it being given to someone else?

How you approach the issue is important. Generally, when this happens to me, I ask for a meeting between the involved parties (boss, you, other person doing task). Then I go over the business reasons for the task being where it was and ask for clarification of why it is being moved. I try to keep the conversation business oriented and not personal.

In your situation, your boss may think you are taking it personally and that will be the downfall of any conversation. It needs to be clear that you are focused on the business and keeping that successful. Your boss may have had a reason.

Now, it would have been NICE if he consulted you first as you were the one responsible in the past. But as he is the boss, he can pretty much do as he wants. All, you can do is try to educate him on WHY he might not want to do it his way. :)

Good Luck.

by angry_white_male

Your points are well taken, but if you want a happy and productive team - then the boss needs to be more communicative. Otherwise moving job duties around at will will only foster an environment of resentment amongst the staff.

E-mail to him was probably worded directly... I don't do pretty-pleases and all that good stuff.

Anyway, I just talked to him - got my ass chewed out... it was along the lines of "how dare you question my decisions" in earshot of the helpdesk guy. Great way to start the week.

Bear in mind my boss had NO management experience whatsoever before taking over for his boss - no people skills, no leadership skills, nothing.

by j.lupo

I can empathize with your pain. Poor management can demoralize and bring down the productivity of everyone. It is a shame.

I am afraid you got what usually happens. What a wonderful Monday. Don't feel bad, I got it too because a program that has been working for months in production suddenly is crashing and I was the last to touch it. Ugh!. Of course I had to be brought to "heel" in front of everyone. Doesn't matter that none of the other programs that had the same changes are just fine. . .

I feel your pain. All, I can say is you need to remain as professional as you can. Vent here in the discussion thread or with someone willing to be your sounding board. But at all costs you need to remain professional at the office.

BTW: I wasn't recommending "pretty please" as a way to speak to him. :) It is more of an "I would like to understand why we are changing this around because of A, B, C, business will be affected". I know it doesn't always work. At least you tried.

Oh, and document, document, document so that when things go "ca-plooy" ;) you have CYA'd yourself. Good Luck, and keep us posted.

by dbertsche

While I can empathize with you your last paragraph speaks volumes. You state he had no management experience etc. This should have served as a cue to you that you wouldn't be able to handle the situation like you could with someone with management experience.

Being direct probably got this guy's dander up and resulted in your ass-chewing. Don't get me wrong I'm not suggesting you suck up to him but perhaps a little diplomacy might have served your needs better.

One thing I've found in the past that has helped me several times was to write out what I was going to say and/or do then put it in my desk for at least a day. Then when I get it out and read it I can see the emotion and figure out a better way to go about it.

Perhaps when things "cool" down a little you can go and have a discussion with this person and get your relationship on track. I know it may not be easy but if you're going to be there and he's going to be there you'll need to figure out a way to get along or this will be something that will just eat and eat at you.

by angry_white_male

Yeah - when he started smacking his desk as he was yelling at me I just got up and walked out of his office. Don't need to take that kind of abuse. Of course he's acting like nothing happened.

I explained in my e-mail to him my concerns but he didn't want to hear it. You know how it goes - the boss is always right.

by j.lupo

It was a no win situation. You tried to create a win-win, but poor management from someone who doesn't get it. I can feel your pain. My only suggestion to you, is to try and keep your professionalism and don't let it beat you up. I know that after a really bad day, I head to the gym or go running with my dogs. It helps unwind and get me back in a positive frame of mind.

I think someone said on another discussion thread that ew can only take care of ourselves and we have to let other take care of themselves. In the business world this means doing your job to the best of your ability, staying professional, and documenting things that you believe affect the business that go against best practices.

Good Luck.

by angry_white_male

Sooner or later he'll come to realize that his style of management only builds a wall between him and us, and erases boundaries between the rest of us causing conflict.

Kinda like the parent who let's their kids run wild without supervision or discipline and then beats them when they happen to notice they're misbehaving.

by jkaras

I believe this is almost a mirror image of a situation you posted in another thread. Obviously egos are running between the two of you and it is more personal than professional. It is very difficult when you are forced to deal with someone who wont listen. I suggest either you invite him over for dinner or schedule a luncheon to discuss to bury whatever hatchet and focus on professional concerns of who, what, how, and why. Reiterate that you do respect him but that he needs to reciprocate especially infront of others, not putting you in your place. ( say politely mind you wording it in the discussion of communication)Give consessions of his point of view that you will work on as well as keeping you in the loop on decisions that effect your employees. Obviously he desires the Help desk to expand its scope, maybe to relieve you of mundane tasks and concentrate on more productive management experience and proper training of staff. I know its easy for me to say this not experiencing your frustrations, just making hypotheticals. Try the peace offering over a meal, it tends to work wonders and re-establish a proper working relationship, then who knows, if it fails then fire and ice just doesnt mix.

by j.lupo

jkaras

I don't think it was the same person. I think you are referring to R.Z on the other threads.

BTW: I took your advise with what I am seeing where I am. Didn't work, if anything they took it all wrong and that was how I found out they don't take feedback no matter how it is worded.

I can empathize with those in this position. All we can do, is remain as professional as possible and try to work things out. There are those however, who will never want to listen no matter how you say something.

Peace.

by jbaker

unfortunately, if the IT manager is not willing to hear the real business reasons that a task needs to be in your realm of responsibility, then there is very little that you can do about regaining control of that item. If you can, see about getting a copy of the report (maybe talk to the help desk guy and get him to BCC it to you, so that you can still use the data, and if it helps you to mitigate a future problem, then you can present that to the IT manager to get it back at a later date.
Just remember to archive all your correspondence on thios subject or anything else that might be touchy for your records.

by angry_white_male

I can still run the reports for myself - that's not an issue. My problem is that there's an extra set of eyes on information that that is very sensitive/confidential and is being moved from network security to the helpdesk.

by jbaker

If that is how "management" wants it done, you can only CYA by archivingyour emails. I seriously doubt this would constitute a HIPAA violation, as privacy should not be expected on a company owned internet connection.

by joetechsupport

Just wanted to offer a word of support for you.

The decision was foregone as you know. It shows disrespect or a fear to cinfront that he blindsided you.

He may be afraid and or jealous of you given he has taken responsibilities from you and what happened in his office.

When you say you should be happy the reports are gone, I know what you mean, paperwork isn't what excites most techs. At the same time, certain things are part of ones job, and it is not proper for people to without notice to start removing integral components without consultation.

Watch your back and take care.

by jkaras

Man I must be seeing things. Maybe I read the thread before leaving on Friday, that's why it looks familiar or he posted in the other thread the same issue, oh well egg on my face. Sorry it didnt work for you at your work. Sometimes things just cant work out the way it should or the way you want it. Maybe its frustrations in a powerless society that has us go mad on each other needing to ventilate our frustrations. I know in my past I was definitley guilty of power tripping because in any loss of power caused sooo many problems that I went nuts over compensating to aviod the management what went wrong speech during their daily "I'm responding to a problem" once a day for 2 minutes and walk away hiding from work. Shudder, shudder oh the past can haunt you.

What advice did go wrong? Just talking to them? Wow, that's sad, criticism supposed to work both ways, guess not. Maybe I got nothing to really complain about anymore. Interesting.

Anarchy. (hehehe I had to be childish in this depressing thread.)

by j.lupo

Well, when I said I took your advice, it was before you posted it. I always follow what you had posted. Bad me not wording my response correctly :) :) with a very :)

Basically, this is not a place that wants to change. What I see is a place that encourages negative interpersonal relationships, bias, prejuidice (sp?), cursing, off-color jokes, etc. The list is very long. It is very sad. Some would say report them to the Labor board. Personally, that is not my style.

I really wish it were ethical to videotape what goes on here so I could make a training videos - "How not to develop teamwork and encourage failure" :) Of course, just having it to laugh about the behaviors would be worthwhile also. But I won't do it because it is unethical. Still, the training idea is good. hmmmm....

by jdclyde

Many managers are people who worked their way out through the ranks and have never had any training on how to be a good manager or learned any people skills.

Managers (good ones) are made, not born.

I have seen this where someone will get their marching orders, and you are notified that this is what will be happening as the cc. At least you got in the cc.

by j.lupo

Ok, I can agree managers are made through education, training, etc. However, your comment made me laugh because LEADERS are another story.

A leader does not have to be a manager. A good manager does need to be a leader. Leaders are born and training only makes them better at what they do instinctively.

The argument over whether leaders are born or made is a long one in a lot of circles (Drucker, Bennis, Goldsmith, etc.) I believe that it takes both types of individuals to run an organization effectively. The problem is that leaders burn-out fighting the good fight (Bennis & Goldsmith, 2001).

Just some thoughts. Maybe we should start a different discussion about the qualities and requirements of managers and leaders. :) :)

by kenneth.godwin

the first question I would ask is not about was it right or wrong to tell you this but is now, HOW did you voice your objections. When you say "fired off" were you ticked off and did that get reflected in your expression.

Having been a manager controlling all financial applications for a global fortune 100 company, managing a staff of 23 at peak and 1.8 million budget (I only say this as a point of reference)I would never be bothered by a question from a staff, even if it questioned my decisions. But get pissy with me.....and that is a different story.

There are always things that we do not know what others above us are really planning. sometimes we can tell staff, but other times we cannot say for one reason or another.

That said, email has become to impersonal and I agree it is not the way to find out plans and shifts. However, you did and now you live with them. As for purpose, I think that with the number of different risks that you as a network guy supports, I would think that your boss was trying to do you a favor in releaving you of this review. If you are good at what you do, I want you doing the best you can. You are the front line for controlling who gets into my information and as for what person is viewing what porn, well while that is a pain, your primary job of support and protecting my assets is much more important.

If it was me, I would ask my boss to be copied on the reports, and explain why and suggest that the new person follow your procedures and controls that limit the sensitivy of the information. That way you responding as a team member.

But, that is me and me alone....

This discussion is closed to new replies.