Discussion Locked

Retracting users from playing live radio the Internet

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Dear All,

I am working on setting up policy in AD/IE to limit/stop users from playing live radio from the Internet on our Company's network.

To the subject, I would appreciate your assistance.

regards,

23 replies

by jaqui

you upgrade the office pc's, don't get them with sound cards.
then they can get the radio signals all they want, with no sound system on the computer it does them no good.

if you use webcasts / video conferencing, then have the units for that only available for during a scheduled cast. ( they are only units with multimedia abilities )

then no-one will waste time finding radio station online, and systems will not be used for "entertainment" purposes.

if you don't want them listening to music through the system, then you should have realised you are telling them they can by getting systems with multimedia capabilities.

by jamesrl

...Come with sound on the motherboard these days. Though you could disable it in the bios and then lock access to the bios.

At my last place, they blocked real audio through firewall manipulations. Pain to do, and someone always finds a way.

I understand the issue, if everyone used internet radio, the bandwidth increase would be enormous.

James

by hagar3

I haven't seen the authors reply to whether this a bandwidth or a control issue. If it s a bandwidth issue consider getting more band width. employees actually use the IT systems for more than entertainment.Listening to the radio on line may incresase production more than it costs.

by dr dij

to many apps nowadays. I listen to webcasts on IT topics at my desktop. If you write a veeb app it does much better with a sound card than the built in speakers. We in fact put in $5 sound cards in rows of lab data entry PCs as we have a custom written data entry program that uses sound card to notify users of various conditions.

if you have a blocking software, use this and notify users of policy. (and enforce it)
I suppose under windoze you can use groups in policy, one group might be allowed sound speakers and add people as needed for valid biz reasons?

by jaqui

demanding that there be system resources sucked up for non essenstials like sound on a desktop workstation is poor application design.

I did include that where it's a required part of someone's position ( webcasts for security.... ) to have it available, but if my word processor wants sound they can stuff it.

a flashing window will grab the eye on an error just as well as sound.

I'm saying that completely ripping even system speaker out of workstations for the majority is fine.

sound events are to be tossed out.
visual events work.
( unless you are talking a blind person's workstation, then accessability would be to enable sound events. )

but full multimedia on the clerical pools systems? a waste of resources. ( financial and system )

by robmcinnes

I think you need to have a written policy that all new and existing users have to read and sign. If users break these policies they need to know what sort of punishment to expect, written/verbal warnings. We have a similar policy for general internet usage. You need to talk to your users as well as setting up AD/IE policies. If you have MS ISA you can set a list of known and good web sites , as well as bad and not allowed websites, and people could access this list through your company intranet.

by hgbryan9

So far robmcinnes, your suggestion sound nice. Could you share with me your policy on general internet usage?

by robmcinnes

Hi again, have you seen the post by Frank entitled The Correct Way? I think this guy has hit the nail on the head.
The internet usage written policy does not have to be long or complicated because you need your users to be able to read and understand it. All you really have to outline is that the companies internet access is just that THE COMPANIES! And so whilst at work they should only use it for work purposes.

by djameson

you can get 90% of radio stations by pointing WMPlayer at a bogus proxy just go to windows components/windows media player/neworking and assign a proxy and hide the network tab. then go to streaming media protocols and disable it. that just leaves RealAudio player and a few others, the best way to track them down is to use a utility called pslist, you can list the processes running on a remote machine until you find them, this will become a big headache to manage if your users have rights to install software on the system.

by mjd420nova

The question of bandwidth was the first and
individual rights came second. Can't allow each
user to have their own genre streamed to them
and gobble up time. One station over the on hold and speakers on the phones was all we
allowed. Some tried their own portable radio
but the desktop monitors ripped up the
reception something terrible.

by too old for it

If the monitors are so cheap that they rip up the radios, and no audio was allowed other that the one company sponsored readio station, it sounds as if there were contol issues that needed to be addressed?

I've seen these control issues get out of control in law firms, and you can air condition the place with the revolving door of employees leaving.

by frank

Do the following:
1. Develop a written policy on Internet Usage.
2. Get Executive approval on the policy.
3. Announce the policy.
4. Purchase a Internet monitoring and filtering product. (Bluecoat Proxy is good and inexpensive)

Then you can filter pop-ups, im, porn, the works and really clean up your environment.

The sale to top execs is increase in productivity.

by too old for it

I'm not sure you would get the warm fuzzies that bring increased productivity by turing off audio, expecially if the "big metal building" syndrome kills the desktop radio idea.

Better to sell it for what it is, a bandwidth and people control issue.

Remember tho: Bandwidth control is not about bandwidth, but about control.

by jmgarvin

However, getting exec buy in is no easy process. Make sure you are able to create a policy that focuses on both productivity and security.

Make sure to train the user in WHY the policy is coming forth and WHY the user has to follow the letter of the law.

Also, a proxy is a most in almost any corporate setting anymore. You will squash a ton of bandwidth wasting crap....

by tonythetiger

It still seems presumptuous to me (maybe it's because I am in a small department of an organization that has multiple, parallel (on the table of organization) departments) for the IT department to be setting any policy (except for operational necessity) unless higher ups tell you to.

I know we often DO it, but somehow it doesn't seem quite right.

(besides, who wants to tell their boss's boss that he can't look at his stocks online if he wants to? The phrase "WRONG, CRETIN!" is echoing in my head for some reason :))

by dr dij

as I explained, it was a design decision. These people look at the data, not the screen and need audio feedback. Sound cards don't clog up the internet connection, playing stuff off the net does (guns don't kill people...:)

Like I said there are MANY valid uses for sound.
This sounds like the knee-jerk, dictatorial reactions I've seen on other topics, such as keylogging everyone.

Jacqui, I guess you don't do any rich media development or you'd agree sound cards are needed for many. So I'm not allowed to play KNAC.com anymore at work (if it's too loud, you're too old :)

But my webcasts (which often have only small video window, in addition to slides) do not appear to clog up our net, no one has complained.

However in some cases ANY streaming media could clog your network, I guess it depends on your network pipe and bandwidth already used, etc, so each individual situation is different.

by too old for it

Why not get PC's/motherboards without sound, and make it necessary to build a business case to have something custom built if you need it (blind potential employee)?

by hgbryan9

To your question, it more of control (management). we're working on plans to increase our current bandwidth, meanwhile, I would first like to put in place ways, and means to control the Internet usages else, the increment won't be of no good, and I'm affair after the increment we might still experience the same slowness in the near future.

With the issue of disabling sound card, and others, I think it's very time consuming, instead, I'm looking at implementing AD policy, or setting up IE Retraction.

Hope someone will assist.

Thanks

by djameson

you can do it through active directory for the most part the policy is under
user config/admin template/windows components/windows media/networking
disable the streaming media and point the network at a bogus proxy, then hide the networking tab, that will take care of most of it. the users can listen to CDs at their desk but can't listen to audio off the web.

for the rest of the players like real audio etc. build a softare policy under computer configuration/security settings/softare restrictions/ use the md5 hash of the .exe for the policy so even if they rename it it still won't work looks like this: 73b8b5915e8edb68aafbadcedb012f86:42573:32771 (you will have to install all of them on your machine or find them on someone elses machine to make this work right) the biggest ones being used right now on my network are. nullsoft realaudio winamp quicktime. that should get you started.

YOU HAVE TO MAKE SURE YOUR USERS DON'T HAVE ADMIN RIGHTS ON THE BOX OR THEY CAN JUST CHANGE THE REGISTRY SETTING BACK!

by chris_crumpton

We handle this through a rules-based approach at the internet proxy within our network. Some users have a legitimate need for online multimedia (training, webinars, etc.) Through the use of MS ISA or a third-party tool, you can limit who has access to what on the internet as a whole. If you're not running a proxy, you'll have to do it via AD.

This discussion is closed to new replies.