Say no to Free "IT Advice"
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by vltiii
by contact
>>>>>>>
Oh, one more thing... what's up with computer technician's / engineers compairing themselves to medical doctors?
>>>>><<
by cumminsd
I think you have to define the level of advice you are giving before you can lay down any "rules" on how to handle it. Is the advice on the level of asking how something works, or more like asking you to come over to their house to fix it?
By nature, we tend to ask questions of people who might know the answer. I play with cars as a hobby. When someone asks how often they should get their oil changed, it never crosses my mind to say "I can't help you". However, if someone asks me to come over and rebuild the engine in their old Ford, I tell them I don't have the time but I'd be glad to give them some pointers or some contacts of people who would be willing to help.
By the same token, I answer a lot of computer questions whether it be on a programming or hardware level. Sometimes it's with people I work with, or people I know outside of work. I don't have a problem explainging things to people, or even spending a little time with them to help them out. If it's a large, daunting task that I don't have time for, I'll tell them that.
I see a lot of IT people who think they should not answer a question unless there is money involved in one way or another.
I believe that as long as the situation isn't being taken advantage of (and I know it does happen), there is nothing wrong with helping each other out.
Building friendships and trust pay out a lot more in the future than a few bucks in the pocket now.
by gregsugg
by vltiii
by jb1
by dr dij
I used to tell people 'buy a Dell' or buy an HP.
Nowadays their service for non-IT depts borders on the ludicrous (goto resellerratings.com or epinions.com and select dell, read revu's)
So even a quick advice of what to buy or do is bad if the person then gets ticked off at you.
And many people simply want you to verify their decision then go do what they want.
I tell them instead to goto review sites and read up on what they want to buy and the seller. As long as I can do it quickly without them taking a bunch of my time.
by cdplayer
I agree with you Alacrity!
Firing off some advice is no sweat. It's only when they want you to perform the job for free is where I have a problem.
Example:
I have a good friend that I help from time to time with his computer. This is OK I help him with his computer he helps me with upgrades that I am doing in my house. It's a fair trade.
One day I received an email from one of his neighbors asking me how to get rid of a virus for a friend of his!!
I was polite and give him a link that provides an overview of how to remove the virus. I stated if his friend needed additional assistance I would be happy to help her. My fee is ....
I never got another call from him. You have to draw the line somewhere. If not I would be the computer person for a bunch of folks that are not even my neighbors!
by cavaughan
Well, first what can one say when someone wants advice but you
don't really want to. Depending on the person, one thing that I
often do is just tell people that they will have to physically bring
their computer to me. That often puts people off. Then, if they
agree to that, you can still just sit on the computer for days. And
if they ask you how the project is going, say, "Well, first I have to
finish company-related project A, B and C." etc. - which you
should point out from the start. Next time they ask, you could
add in new project or issues that have arisen that prevent you
from addressing their computer, ad nauseum.....
Another thing. I often make it a point to say, "You know so and
so paid me $xxx for doing the same thing." I've found a lot of
people - although you don't negotiate a price at the beginning
then compensate you for that figure - or close to it.
Also, I do computer work for one auto shop. However, they don't
pay me. They pay me in kind. Any oil changes, auto work, etc.
that I need they do for free.
Finally, depending on the relationship, I have often done work
for free. Especially if it's a non-profit. Being very pro
OpenSource, etc. I find personal enjoyment and satisfaction in
the fact that people refer to me for my skills and talents and that
they hopefully just appreciate what I have done. I hope they too
will take my 'good samaritan' service as an example and pay it
forward.
by sam01
I think that 98% of the responses are missing the point ... HOW TO SAY NO ...
As a self-employed Business IT Consultant, I have a different opinion on whether or not to say no. The question was how to go about saying no to people that ask for advice ...
by tlea
If the people are not asking for anything intensive, then it might be worth a few minutes of your time to help foster good relationships with the people in your company. Politics play an important role in getting what you want. After all, it is harder to say no to the guy that just saved your ass by helping recover those "deleted" files. Plus, being on good footing with the partners of the company is never a bad idea.
In those cases where you really just don't have the time just say, "I prefer not to do this as I don't have the time right now, but here is the number of someone who can help you."
If you have the time, but not the motivation, asking for compensation is entirely within your right. Try to be reasonable when setting the price and be prepared to backup the support you just sold your client.
Above all remember the old adage, "You scratch my back, and I'll scratch yours."
by overcharge
My wife is a Family Nurse Practicioner, with her own practice. Between the two of us, we can't shop in town without getting buttonholed by a patient, client, or whatever, continuously. Shopping at WallyWorld, even at 2AM, has gotten bad.
Best thing I can suggest: Tell your boss that the requests for help are getting out of hand, that you are creating a pt business, and that your comment will be, "Bring it to the shop." If he agrees, it's extra income, it shakes out the cheapskates, and it ends 50% of the interuptions.
Oh yeah, my wife's reply is: I don't have your chart, so I can't verify history. You need to call and make an appointment.
by ac2
by ddelano
Why on earth would you want to do that? If you need to stay busy, tutor high schoolers how to use the computer in a safe way?
Pretty Simple!
Ittech
One way is to tell them that it is very hard to implement a solution unless they are sitting in front of their home system.
I also tell people about this great help desk service I found called Answers-Now. They provide these kind of answers 24/7 for as low as $1.50 per minute and they get people off my back! All they need is a credit card and they call 888-870-4267.
I usually say something like, "I get these kinds of questions all the time and I find that you really need to be in front of your PC to really implement the solution. The best bet is to call this helpdesk called Answers-Now..."
It is an age-old problem. One I've never been able to completely get rid of. Good luck!
by pdpmurphy
I would generally never say no to bosses...
However with other people if the advice is easily given then I tend to give it. If its a matter of trying to fix their problems then I generally suggest to them that PC's are very complex nowadays (hence the need for IT people) and with such a lot of viruses, malware etc etc the problem could be caused by any number of issues. I end up by nicely pointing them in the direction of a local PC doctor shop.
Regards
by cfrankel
Every situation and person is differnt. Just have a heart and help outr a coworker. Use your head and don't get involved with USERS, that people who habitually use others. And be honest, say you don't have a lot of time, or want to take a chance of being wrong and getting sued, etc..
I was was goining to offer this advise - for a price, but deided not to.
by blackcurrant
Hi there
I get the occassional question at work and try to answer them all. If a problem can not be resolved by discussing it I ask the staff member to bring their PC into work and I will spend part of my lunch-break trying to fix it.
With regards to friends - I have got loads of people setup, online, recovered deleted files, fixed registries, removed viruses etc etc etc..... BUT! I have also had lots of meals, drinks, BBQ's freebies etc etc etc
Swings and roundabouts. Tit for Tat. Give and Take etc etc etc ;)
oooooh I've been censored over a false breast
by lwebb
I know a carpenter. He's one I can't say no to (non-revenue generating client a.k.a. my brother)
I have to fix his damnable fat-fingering every time I go over there AND put up with his wife (a baker) insisting that she knows more about how email passwords work than I do...
He owes me (still):
Fixing a broken chair.
Simple table that would take me 10min if I had my own Skillsaw.
He build me a small shelf, but never completed it.
A vacu-form box (looks easy enough, but he's got the tools and I don't)
I have ANOTHER carpenter (not my bro this time) who owes me...
The same chair fix
The same simple tabletop
Yes, I couldn't get one or the other to finish the carpentry I needed done, so I wound up doing "free" work for two different carpenters....and I still need carpentry work...
by robwaybro
I think you nailed it right here. It is character and some of the follow-ups prove it.
Some Doctors will give ADVICE
Some Plumbers will give ADVICE
Some (insert profession) will give ADVICE
Others will not and expect to get something everytime they open their mouths and/or minds (which don't always go together).
I also like the point that was made by another poster, many of the folks feeling 'used' are feeling this way by co-workers WHILE AT WORK, so they are getting paid and I agree that if the company does not have a problem with it (and the original poster stated one 'inquisitive' person was a PARTNER, so the company certainly does not have a problem with it) then they really need to examine themselves and their character.
I give advice (and some service) to friends and family all the time, but I considerate it the 'neighborly' (for lack of a better term) thing to do. If it is something that is going to take time to fix/troubleshoot, etc, then we do come to some kind of agreement, and it is NOT always monetary. I frequently trade services, even something as simple as them watching my children while my wife and I go see a movie.
But I am also not into getting money for everything I do, guess that is my CHARACTER.
by r32
by iainbuchanan
by jld2
by lwebb
"No one is calling you at home on YOUR time. No one is dropping by on the weekends! "
Uhh...yes, they are.
And my boss does indeed have a problem with me giving advice on home pc's while at work. He gets the same questions that I do, seeing as he's an IT pro also.
I'm fine with the "you scratch my back, I'll scratch yours" bit, but the original post isn't concerned with this. It's concerned with "IT freeloaders". There's a big difference between renumeration in the form of cash or favors and "Free IT Advice".
For instance, when I share info with other IT pros, I don't consider it "Free IT advice". They owe me and I owe them. It's reciprocal.
I would NEVER even consider having them work on my machine for free. THAT'S the difference. Users don't want just advice. They want more and more until it becomes, not just borders on, Free IT Technical Services.
One such discourse I had with a user I determined he needed his OS reloaded. I was 100% confident in my diagnosis, but I should have kept my mouth shut. It lead to:
"Great! When will you have time?"
My response (not very nice according to the "nice guys" on this forum) was:
"I won't!"
I told him in no uncertain terms that I'd charge $100, would do it when I had spare time and didn't guarantee anything whatsoever after he left with it.
He paid, had his machine a week later and never complained about it. We're good friends now.
"Yet when I need to get something there is a charge for it. I spend a lot of time keeping up to date with the IT field. I spend a lot of time learning what is out there now. So why is it I shouldn't charge for my advice or services?"
Alot of people cannot afford computer repair at $100/HR for a couple hours of time they could just buy a new computer. Yes you spend alot of time keeping up to date but you do that because of your chosen profesion and most of the time you dont even have to pay for it. So why shouldn't you charge for advise of service, one word KARMA and KARMA is a B**CH. I do understand charging if you have to go to someones house for hours and do alot of work but to pop a CD into someones computer and reinstall an OS is no big deal at least for most IT Pros and 99.9% of the time that is what they really need. Do unto others man.
by contact
Obviously you do NOT understand what a problem this subject is for us. Mates, friends, family : we HAVE to setup a strategy on this dayly question : can you (you the guru) fix my computer in two keystroke (which means you won't deserve any kind of greatfulness), do it during offtime, for free and then feel responsible for whatever will happen to my computer the next months on ?
This IS what I hear when asked for free help.
You could ask YOURSELF : why do we take the time to read on this thread that was discussed again and again, over the years.
You seem quite fast to talk about nonsense or the "type of persons we are". Let me do the same with you : if you have no clue what the subject is about and can be quicker at insulting people than trying to understand, I have no doubt with the kind of person YOU are.
by lwebb
At work I know it comes off as arrogance. But it's not.
People don't seem to realize (so I make a point to tell them) how many OTHER people are also asking for free advice. You have to be extremely careful that advice doesn't turn into work.
Example:
Short description of the problem and you think "A hah! Easy! Just install the drivers for your new sound card you ineptly installed yourself because you're a cheapskate! Simple!"
"Ok, how do I do that?"
A 3 min conversation just turned into a 45 min tutorial on driver installation and the risk that said l-user is going to bork it up irregardless and... guess what? It's YOUR fault.
You're a "nice guy" and don't want any harsh feelings so guess what you're doing this weekend? Is your wife p/o'ed? She should be!
by pos_techie
by contact
I am no doctor, but I wouldn't give anythng but common advices: I would'nt try to diagnose, as long as i feel something serious is going on.
I guess the same applies to us : giving common advice is wtg. For anything serious, let's talk serious.
To go further with the doctor comparison, I'd say that I wouldn't considere a doctor who is not feeling this way : helping people first. The fact is that most of those I heard about are not.
But I would DEFINITELY considere an IT that became such WITHOUT any will to help people. Just the same with my butcher or hairdresser.
Let me add that people are much more reluctant to require free worlk from doctors (or butchers, plumbers and hairdressers) than from pro IT's. More reluctant is an understatement, as some of you here might know.
first of all, i am not trying to offend anyone and apologize if this or previous posts were offensive to anyone.
do you ask your butcher for the best technique for preparing a cut of meat? do you ask your plumber the best way to ensure that the drain does not get clogged again in 30 days? do you ask your hairdresser for advice on the best hair care products?
i'd argue that each of those questions amounts to free advice. once the butcher cuts my meat, hands it to me and collects my cash, that job is complete. a follow up question amounts to free advice. or, to look at it with a different spin, it is providing good customer service. or, from another view, it is simply being a "nice person".
if i ask my butcher for preparation advice and he (or she) hands me a business card or tells me to read a cookbook (rtfm) or tells me to surf the web, i will certainly form a negative opinion and possibly not spend my money there in the future. that is very effective way of voicing displeasure.
anyhow, just my 2 cents.
by lwebb
Popping in an OS CD isn't a big deal to me.
But it takes a good 3-4+ hours to do it right. You have to do the settings, download all the freaking patches, install all the drivers etc. etc. make sure they have AV..
THEN they ALWAYS want you to re-install all their software, which can take 10x more time.
And you say I'll have bad Karma for charging $100/hour for that?
Is it worth $100/hour? No. But I charge it because that's how much I value the time I'm NOT going to spend with my family in order to help this schmuck. I charge $100/hour BECAUSE I'M COUNTING ON THEM BEING SET AGHAST! I DON"T WANT the job!
Strangely enough, some people come back with a couple of $50's and insist... I tried to discourage them.
AND If you ever load someone's OS, they WILL be calling you a week later after they bog it down with malware or however they choose to clog it up.
Guess what? It's ALL YOUR FAULT! Karma IS a B!t*h!
NO THANKS. Take your morality and KEEP it.
by stan20
I tell them its $250 an hour. (If I like them.)
If they are jerks, the price goes up. Billed in 15 minute increments.
Anyone who thinks my rates are too high is free to
go elsewhere.
by Thorarinn
I've been following this thread on and off today - during your working hours in the States... How many of those who've posted today are doing so at work, whilst getting paid for doing a job for your employer?
Those of you who are worried about "wasting" working hours on handing out "free advice" to co-workers - are you worried about "wasting" working hours posting to a thread where there obviously is no simple "correct answer"?
Having said that, here's my attempt at the "correct answer" for "outside working hours":
If the gratitude you recieve for helping people out without expecting payment isn't enough for you to feel it's worth it, don't do it. If you're plagued by people expecting something for nothing, there's a good chance they came to you (and not someone else) for a reason. Only you can change that pattern, just try to go about it in a "diplomatic" way (no need to burn bridges) but stick to the truth.
by dr dij
if it crashed when you were working on it, and even if it WAS something you did, it could have life altering (or sever inconvenience) for them. Suppose they had important info on it (that of course wasn't backed up) for the least example.
And not everyone in IT is a PC person, and YES getting that router, etc working so the whole company can run IS more important than answering a person's non-work related questions.
by moralesj01
Tell them RTFM that comes with the hardware/software they need help on.
Use the F1/Help functions.
If that is not enough then tell them to take a course, buy (and read) a book, or look it up on the web.
by lwebb
by lwebb
Giving out free IT expertise gets you lots of new friends.
Too bad you don't have time to do anything but fix their computers. You don't sleep too well either with the wife b****ing that you're never home and you can't pay the bills with beer and pizza...
I used to be a "nice guy". I know how it was. I think I much prefer being the cynical a-hole I am now.
by lwebb
That's definately NOT what to say!
You never want to undermine anyone's confidence in your abilities, especially the abilities you're trying to make a living with.
by sql guy
by tech_guy1
by lwebb
My previous post was just a warning...
I'm not downing the suggested reply, as I use it all the time and it is probably the most gracious way to get out of a jam.
by martimus
this reply leaves an awful lot of latitude for the troubled end user to try to force the situation. End users aren't stupid or ignorant but this reply tends to imply just that.
Let me build a plausible but theoretical framework to help explain my statement. Let us say for a moment that I, an non-computer literate employee of the company come to you, the tech support person at the company, who just yesterday fixed a Windows problem with my PC. I ask if you could assist me with a problem with my home PC. How do you think I would react to a response indicating that you had no experience with my "setup", AND anything you did would be a "shot in the dark"?
In all likelihood I would perceive that response to be a lie. Why? Because most end users see PC's as generic commodities and feel that most computer problems are caused by Windows. And since I already know that you, the tech support person for the company, are very capable with Windows your response is obviously a flimsy excuse to try to avoid assisting me.
So what have we accomplished with this response? Well we've shown the end user a lack of respect reinforced by a statement perceived to be a lie or misrepresentation.
Personally if the question were posed to me, I'd simply tell the individual that I have prior committments that would interfere with my ability to assist them promptly. I would also say that I would be happy to refer them to another more capable resource (like a local computer store).
Simple and honest. I suspect the although the end user may not want to hear the response they'll appreciate the fact that I'm sincere with them and not trying to "Blow smoke up their skirts".
by bad2thebone
I agree with this point! Daily, I have people who come to me for advise...this I don't mind, because they also know I'm a reseller too and will give them good prices on what they need. The ones that really get my goat are those who expect me to spend my entire day piecing their XP Home ed. back together and get them back up AO-Hell and then had the audasity to hym & haw when I charged them added expense to the parts that I ran down the store for (you know gas money!).
I, too, have spent thousands of dollars on my degrees and certifications and feel I have the right to set my boundaries between free advise and free work. Be bold in your stand, but don't burn the bridge! Once you rot one apple, you might as well throw out the basket, because word will spread faster than gossip that you're an ungrateful yahoo for not being willing to "help". Trust me, I've been there!
JDS
by stan20
I just tell them that I can't work on private computers unrelated to my company's business on company time.
But, being a helpful person, I'd be happy to give them the names of some places that would be able to help them.
Or, I'd be happy to help them on my own time, for my usual rates. But, I'm a reasonable person. If they can't afford it, and still want to go ahead, maybe they would trade their less skilled labor for mine, and mow my lawn for the next year or something, lol!
I found that if you help people out for free they expect more than if you had charged the going rate. Years ago, I fixed a disk problem for a friend of a friend, and since I knew he had little money, I didn't charge him a cent for several hours of work. Five years later the disk failed again, and he seemed to think it was my fault, and wanted me to "fix it" again, for free.
by lwebb
Apparently you don't get taken advantage of much. Perhaps you're new to the field. Perhaps you just are a masochist...
The vast majority of us who have been in the field any length of time quickly figure out that giving out free advice more often than not includes basically working for free.
Not trade.
Not barter.
Free.
Information is a valuable commodity. I am more than willing to trade it with my accountant, handyman, electrician, fellow IT pros.
Giving it away may be nice, but the recipient (whether they know it or not) is being rude and thoughtless. At the core, it's also Socialist.
I'm a non-apologetic Capitalist. Dad said "Make a living with your brain, not your back!"
I don't see why I have to give away information to be "nice" when experience tells me I might get roped into spending hours of my valuable free time and risking relationships with the client.
I have had a simple question turn into 48+ hours of free work in another city. How? He was a friend and a "Lodge brother". He took advantage of that and guilted me into being his IT monkey-boy thinking that a half a dozen beers were adequate compensation.
There wasn't any graceful way to get out of it without having to end the relationship entirely.
It's an extreme example, I know. But SO many people I thought were my friends have tried with various success to bend me over like this.
You'll find out your true friends cough up at least a $20 without having to be asked.
by dr dij
I'd driven a ways to help small biz with problem. They knew my consulting rates.
Then they tried to buy me off with a pizza.
I told them no thanks, and got the check.
by thumper1
That's how I feel sometimes. Family, friends and casual acquaintances all depend on me for computer help. I wish I could get buy with simple advice, unfortunately, I screwed up and started working on some of these systems.
The three absolute truths of computer repair:
1) He who touches is last, loses.
2) No good deed goes unpunished
3) The truth, while interesting and amusing, is totally irrelevant. Perception is everything.
For number 1 ? the first time you touch the keyboard, that system becomes YOURS from then on. Every time it burps, you will get a call and be expected to fix it. This is caused by Number 2 and 3.
Recently, I was asked to install a CD rom drive on a relatives system. I said I don?t want to do that. When asked why, I said ?I don?t want to be married to your system. Please understand, if I didn?t have to eat or sleep, I could spend every waking nanosecond of my time working on computers,? Yea, it pissed him off.
by lwebb
For me, my boss has the same problem, so he discourages "wasting company time giving out non-company advice". And I agree with him. It all depends on who's doing the asking.
When I'm NOT at work, well that's MY free time and I don't like to talk shop or work for free. Sorry, I must be a total a-hole with bad karma...
My wife and kids are MUCH more valuable to me than fixing my mothers-hairdresser's-cousin's-roomates' computer, or even my best friend's.
I don't charge $100/hour because I'm greedy.
I charge $100/hour because I don't want to do it.
If they want me to blow time away from family, then they gotta renumerate me how I see fit.
Strangely, people can and do cough up the $100. But most of the time it's the best deterrant I can think of.
by john
If you are not charging for your advice, then it is not worth anything. If you don't think your advice is worth anything, they it probably isn't. If you education and experience are not sufficient enough to bring value to your advice then it's not worth anything either.
I tell my friends that they should seek the services of a competent IT professional and pay for it, because you get what you pay for. People at work need to contact a help desk number so their request can be properly billed to their departments.
If IT is your hobby then I say go ahead and give it away. If IT is your profession then you are foolish to not charge for every bit of work you do. Anyone that can not appreciate that doesn't know what it means to work for a living.
by redline
If I am at work, and am asked for advice about home computers, I tell the person that I am being paid by the company to work on their problems and do not feel comfortable talking about non-company problems. If ai am not at work, I say, "Well, that is my work, what I do for a living. I am not at work, now."
Then, I recommend a friend of mine who does good work for a reasonable price.
There is an exception to this rule, however. When my children call me, I always help. But then, they will usually feed me!
by lwebb
I feel obligated to fix the wife's laptop and the kid's desktop.
The wife feeds me and washes my clothes, but the lazy kid does nothing.
I did build the machines after all...
by lwebb
I've never been sued, but I've been threatened.
It's a long story, but I did some piddly thing for free on an aquaintance's computer, a week later he hosed his entire HDD.
Turned out it was a hardware malfunction caused by a large refridgerator magnet he was using on the side of his case...moron...
But it was MY fault because I touched his mouse a week earlier...you all know the story.
by mr l
I've read a dozen of these "If you are nice...mature...play well...yada yada...you will dispense free advice and free assistance" responses and enough is enough. Because someone chooses not to spend their time dispensing free advice or providing free assistance they are not nice? When did any of you become the arbiters or world authorities on what constitutes "nice"?
I make it very easy for my staff, they are here to take care of company business during working hours. It is expected that that is what they do, not spend time they are being paid by their employer assisting people with personal, non-work related issues. In some very small business, you may be able to deal with the losses in productivity associated with technicians being taken away from their work. When you have 3000+ customers in one facility, and 6 technicians to deal with their needs, I assure you you don't have that luxury...period.
by dr dij
unless your boss wanted you to do this on company time, IT depts, esp. PC dept are usually overloaded.
What other work that is actually for the company will you sacrifice to fix their home PCs? A
nd if something goes wrong with it while you are fixing it, are you willing to be responsible when it was failing unrelated to you, such as a HD going bad or bad MB?
by jeddy
Why is your advice not free? They've come to you because they feel you're the expert. They're not asking you to do the work for nothing (at least you haven't mentioned that).
Consider their questions a compliment to your abilities...and if you don't have time to deal with them at the moment, tell them so, politely.
by dr dij
to fix their home PCs on company time you shouldn't be doing this. If you are willing to do this, be sure is OK with your boss.
Even free advice can cause an unknowledgable worker to do something bad or goof up your suggestion. Free advice for what to buy is 1) freely available on web, you shouldn't be telling them, 2) can get them po'd if they follow your advice and buy something they don't like or doesn't work
by dr dij
We have a finite time on this earth. The one thing they can't repay you is time spent fixing their problem. So you need something in return. If it is someone who already gives you something in return, you're more likely to help them.
The arrogant attitudes of clueless end users amaze me. They want you to fix it, free, immediately if possible, and drive to there place.
And as plenty of others said, you're then responsible if it hiccups a year later.
by contact
I am amazed how so many "almost insulting" posts came up in this thread.
Basically, IT's should be sharing their knowledge -as if they did not do it already either in forums or on their own website- otherwise they get called greedy, mean minded, selfish... whatever. Some might be generous with their time but they are equally fast at disrispecting people. Usually such persons are pretending to be what they are not and don't know what they talk about. Lessons givers they are.
There is no point that knowledge has to be shared, for free. Giving advice is good and everybody here agrees that social skill matters and that greed is bad.
The question is more about being HARASSED :
- How do you manage to refuse doing free work and endure the responsibility for 100's of computers run by noobs in your area?
- How do you get people to making a distinction between advice and free service ?
- How to explain someone that it is not because you put your hand on his keyboard that you HAVE to offer free maintenance for the rest of your life.
- How do you get people to be a bit more specific than "it doesn't work"
- How do you get people to be a bit more honest than : "since you came and installed my printer I have slow internet access"
On one hand, how dramatic it can become in one's life to have to say no, over and over, to peeps he meets daily.
OTOH it is so easy to call us greedies. So easy to point a finger and "your aura's dark" or "you badly minded". Probably, most of those talking this way have an easy work with comfortable wages, 45 hours a week.
I understand they are willing to help whomever will ask from them but I am pretty confident that they are probably not asked on a 100/week basis. Otherwise they would talk differently.
The question was simple : HOW TO SAY NO. Not "Am I allowed to say no".
You advice was not require on that matter. I respect the fact that you give it for free. but it was not required. Nor is it welcome.
Another useful thread could be : should I give any advice, even for free, or should I keep it shut ?
by cogtek
The moral issue aside.
To say No or to not say No will continue to be debated in the other threads.
The only proper way to say No to a request for advice is to politely point out your completely consuming task list.
You don't have time to answer any questions...
On your way to the bathroom
During your lunch hour
While waiting for the PC to finish installing
Because your boss/supervisor/manager/partner/owner pays you good money to work, not socialize.
Yeah, us Techies can be sarcastic too!
Because you can't say No to a request for advice.
When that request requires more than a discussion, you can say No.
Politely.
Blame the boss, blame your schedule, blame whomever/whatever you want.
But NOT UNTIL the discussion becomes actual work.
by dr dij
by contact
I will not agree that "someone hates the life he has chosen".
Sounds more like, on one side, someone who actually TRIED to be helpfull and realized the kind of reward it brings and, on the other side, someone who never tried to help (probably claims so, though) but instead spreads beautiful ideas on what OTHERS should do.
I am confident that you do not* hate the life you have chosen... I probably would but I understand you like it...
This has come up a number of times for me over the years. Especially within the context of our user group, which I've been helping to manage since 1985. BTW, that is an excellent place to refer people to that are looking for free advice. We brief our 'experts' on the ropes of setting limits as they come into the organization. They decide when free advice needs to stop, and payment for a service call is expected.
I'm surprised no one has pointed this out here yet, though some mention has been made of DYI support forums. The only reason our organization still exists is because of the volunteer time donated by so many professionals. They consider that their way of paying their community back.
Of course, there are always those who come in with totally unrealistic expectations. Like the lady that wanted to 'borrow' a complete computer system and printer to print up party invitations. Or those that arrive with faulty systems in tow. Within those meetings is the ONLY location many of us will make an attempt to diagnose a problem for free. Most of the time the advice being that the system should be replaced, or be repaired by a technician of some kind. In the 20 years I've been involved, I think I can count on one hand the number of times the 'problem' has been relatively minor like a bad CMOS battery...
by contact
<>
The problem is that you are ... IT.
Which means you are CONSTANTLY asked, while you barely need anything for yourself.
Surprising how some mates I know who not only seldomly need me for their puter but also do very well at fixing their car, fixing electrical or plumbery problems. These I help whenever I can, plus I know I can count on them when I'm in need.
Let's face it : the old saying was true until pc's got sold in supermarkets : for the average IT, it's become : "you gotta reap just what you saw(saw*saw*saw*2+E^n+7)". N being your number of friends/mates/family.
Sounds more like an evil spell than an old saying, doesn't it ?
by mattk
There is no gracious way to say no, particularly to co-workers and superiors at work. I personally have had to work on co-workers PC's, especially exec's, in every job I have had. The tenor of your message implies that you prefer to be paid for your time and effort. If this is the case, tell them that very thing, and use the example of the surgeon-nobody expects a surgeon to give away his services for free either.
What has been most successful for me was to discuss the situation with my immediate supervisor and take my cue from him. Most of the time the response was along the lines of "do not let it interfere with your primary duties and do not put in any extra hours."
Helping the users never hurt my relationship with fellow employees, my career, or my reputation.
by antuck
Wow you are so far off it's not funny. One I work as an independent contractor for a computer shop. I also have my own computer buss. So NO I do not get paid to talk to people. I only get paid when working on someones computer. Yes people do call me at home on MY time.
Rarly do I get free advise. If I have a problem with a car, A/C, Fridge, or anything else, no one gives free advise. I can't go to the auto dealership and ask how do I replace this part or what ever it maybe.
I can aggree that about the "good deed" and the "reciprocating" as long as it is reciprocated. And not always is that the case. And YES my mother did teach me about do good deeds. The problem comes in when I am expected to give the good deeds all the time simply because I work on computers.
Also, if I did work for an employer, that employer is paying me to work on there computers not everybody elses.
by dawnmms
by antuck
by deesy58
Maybe you should try truck driving. I'll bet not many colleagues would ask your advice about driving.
What an attitude!
by poky_it
by rayjeff
this goes to the posts about "I'm IT. have Dr. Friend...". I have a co-worker I usually get tons of questions about something wrong with her laptop or even her office computer. Now, you would think that I should say "HELL NO!" all the time she comes to me. But, she has been helping me tremdously with her area. She's a college professor with a Ph.D in Psychology and a licensed therpist. So, whenever I have a bad day, I can always go to her and talk about anything. Even a few of the professors/instructors in my own division have asked me for advice/tech support. I'm a sucker for just sharing my knowledge...I admit that. But, they will always do something nice for me like leave a thank you card for at my desk when I come in or something like that.
I don't know. In order for people to not be so afraid of the little box, they have to be educated. Whether it's taking a class or walking them through it by them asking for free tech support, it brings them one step closer to learning to solve "simple and easy" problems themselves.
by samza
I don't think I'm better than anyone else and I'll gladly help someone for free AT WORK, ABOUT WORK. But like many others say here, if I did everything for free that everyone wants, I'd never have a moment to myself. One "friend" of mine only calls or e-mails when he has an IT problem. I never hear or see from him otherwise, but he's a "friend". It's similar to when I lived in New Orleans. Around Mardi Gras I'd hear from "friends" I hadn't seen in years, looking for a free place to stay. Sounds to me like you're a bit jealous of IT with the "IT feels they are above or better than anyone else". If you want to make the money, you've got to do the work. I don't ask my dentist to work for free.
On the other hand, I will do barter. I'll fix this and you do something for me that I'm not good at doing. Remember these are co-workers who don't want advice about work, they want freebies about their home PC's. Have you ever spent hours trying to straighten out a system with a 56K modem and AOL installed, no backups, none of the Microsoft or other OS updates installed and please don't format my drive? Oh, and it's "FREE". It's not like it's work, huh?
by dr dij
to help everyone with problems unrelated to you, and since they are not starving there's no moral obligation to.
we do help people, just people in need. most co-workers / neighbors do not fall in this category
by rlkeady
by dr dij
read resellerratings.com or epinions.com or bizrating.com ratings of dell and you won't recommend them to a friend.
hp and gateway almost as bad
by mail
This works for me. Say yes, but then say that it will take a few days to get back because of pressure of work/priorities. I expect that is true. You'll find that the requests will fall away as they are always urgent and often not really necessary. this way minimum ffence is caused.
Greg
by hank
by dlindley
"if you're already being PAID through a "real job," then you are NOT a consultant for hire technically!"
How do you figure this? Just because I have a "Real job" doesn't mean I don't also have a job as a consultant? I both work for a company and have my own consulting company. I have more work to do between those two than I can keep up with.
You talk about people being selfish for not wanting to work for free. You're saying that since I have a full time job I should just donate all of my free time and the work I do for my own customers?
I will always help people out who really need the help and can't aford it, I have one client who needs the help but doen't have the money, so I trade them my time for worthless equipment they have laying around that I don't want in the first place. But why should I donate my time because someone who has the money is to cheap to pay?
The purpose of charging or bartering is not so much the return you are getting as letting the people know that this is how you make your living and they shouldn't expect you to give up your time to fix their problems for free. There has to be some reciprication.
I just spent 10 hours this last weekend rebuilding a computer for someone who couldn't afford it. That person recipricated by mowing my lawn. That is more than sufficient. Was mowing a lawn equivilent to 10 hours of work @ $75/hour? Of course not! The point is that they paid in a way they could. That's all I ask.
by the admiral
Yes a few times leads to "Awww Come on, you did it before..." then it winds up being an all the time job.
As I have told people that brought in their personal home terminal workstations, "I don't want to ever see the machine again under any circumstances, know it is in your home, or any other information about it after this point." Even with that, they come back and ask information about the PC and I generally give them a bad look and they go away.
The situation is purely an ethical decision when you take all of the good and bad emotions out of the situation. First, it is unethical and generally against company policies for them to ask you about their personal systems or bring them in to be repaired. It ranks along the lines of running a personal business using the company telephone, or selling items on ebay during times that you are supposed to be making a marketing presentation for the company you are getting a bi-weekly paycheck for.
Second, there is a level of ethics that get violated not doing the companies business, but personal business. Technically speaking, personal business is supposed to be done on your break, so asking for personal support during business hours could make you a target for getting fired.
BUT you are human, and you can be human to everyone else, and give them simple answers to the "no duh" questions, but the more advanced questions, such as the one I was asked the other day on how to get the wireless working on their wireless router with encryption and security, I simply told them the fastest and cheapest way to do it is to read the instructions, or if they want it done themselves, that a local PC store that offers home visits. Outside of that, simple every once and a while is OK, but the advanced stuff, I stick by my previous post, refer them to someone who can dedicate the time to it who is a working for food.
by jshtcm213
Exactamundo... We do do not like to talk shop 24 hours a day. Right on, The worst part is, I have never recieved any kind of "real" gratitude from people that Ive fixed their technical problems. A little money would be nice, after all I am saving them money... (cheapskates)
Before, i use to love to fix peoples problems because I wanted to be able to troubleshoot anything. Now, Im not learning anything and its turning out to be hassle more than anything.
From now own, I will only help someone if they truly want to learn or if they are the kind of person that is thankful. Actually you know what, im just sick and tired of this free IT help. Its crap. If you got the internet, then use it. People dont realize how easy it is to learn and look up stuff? know what i mean
by the admiral
by the admiral
Without knowledge of their complete system, you run the risk of loosing the raise anyway. Ever hear of the good samaritan that put the roof on the house to keep the people out of the rain in the poorest part of WVa?
The house fell and killed all 5 who lived there because of the weight of the roof on the house.
So sometimes, giving free advice is the wrong thing to do.
by darrins
by dr dij
then I'd help them and get paid.
I value my time OFF work.
Sounds kind of communist russia years ago, people off work were 'expected' to 'donate' large amounts of their time building the moscow subway.
Do you think that tax guy or car repair guy helps people for free who have done nothing for him?
If you want to help the truly helpless that's great. Some people are simply clueless about computers but have the resources to pay to fix, and of course if anyone can get something for free they want to.
So people helping for free without any barter DOES devalue PC and IT work. Doesn't mean you can't be nice off work and do it for someone special. It's more special if you only do it occasionally.
by dr dij
if you never got anything you might not repeat visit. you might not be able to afford to, it costs you time and money to drive somewhere and help someone.
doesn't have to be money. you help avoid excessive govt by using barter. unfortunately, in cities people don't want to swap anything much of the time, just want it for free.
by dr dij
but co-workers.
they WANT to pay you to fix it sometimes
And I consider it whining to think that everyone else should work for free.
by barkleyc
by barkleyc
I used to be a Physical Therapist. I am also an avid skiier. Nearly every time I told someone what I did for a living they would start in on their list of aches and pains and "what should I do about this?" I cannot tell you how tedious that got over the years!
One fine day I was riding up a 4 person chair lift and the person next to me asked the person on his right what he did for a living. The guy said, "I'm a physician." You can guess what came next; a list of several complaints and a "what should I do about this?" The doctor simply stated, "I'm sorry, I'm not working today." Silence ensued and I could barely keep from bursting out in hilarious laughter. Later I skiied up to the doc and thanked him. Told him what I did and how long I haad meen haveing to cope with the same crap. We skiied together the rest of the day and had a great time!
by jfejsa
I never sad NO to providing FREE advice and never felt any regret for helping others. I am employed as a senior systems analyst/computer programmer for a large health industry organisation which employs over 14,000 people. I also support network administrators/systems administrators in maintaining and supporting the Local Area Network. As a result, most employees see me as a good source of information when it comes to programming/hardware/software problems/tips.
To imprive staff morale the management and IT department made a decision to make the process of assisting staff a formal procedure. I schedule 2 hours per week for public relations dedicated to helping staff sort their problems. Each individual can schedule a 10 minute meeting with IT HELP on Friday between 2-4pm and discuss any IT problems (work or personal) during the meeting. However, staff can only schedule one meeting per month, the meeting NEVER lasts more then 10 minutes and they are not allowed to discuss any personal IT issues with IT staff outside scheduled meetings. This method works great for our IT department. We believe that staff morale has improved, the management is happy with this arrangement and IT staff can work without disruptions during their normal working hours.
On the home front; my partner is always asking for FREE advice and as far as I am concerned she can have as much of it as she wants. I married her; I didn?t just sign a business contract with her. I also provide FREE advice to my friends and neighbours because I get along with my friends and neighbours and the amount of joy and advice I get from them in return is priceless.
PS: I also spend years at university to get a degree, never stopped studying since to keep up with IT technology, worked in the IT industry for over 20 years and never ever felt ripped off for helping my friends and co-workers. The doors we open and close each day decide the lives we live. I choose to leave my door open so others can come in without strings or credit card. Financial reward is not always the best reward.
by presler
Here are some of my experiences with such.
Officemate 1:
n officemete of mine asked me advice for a new computer setup. Then after giving him options, we got out and bought a new PC built from components I chose, then I installed all the software he needs. I did my best to answer all his questions. Then eventually on his own, he learned to install programs, maintain, and upgrade his PC (good for him). I didn't ask or get any pay, but it's ok.
Officemate 2 (bad):
Another officemate of mine asked advice on buying a 2nd hand notebook. The specs are fine and the condition of the unit is still quite good, so I gave him a go to buy it. Then he asked help me on setting it up and installing the necessary software, which again i helped him ( at no charge). But the problem is, everytime something goes wrong with his notebook, he calls me and asks me for what to do (even at past 9PM), and whenever he does something wrong, I fix it. Damn! (my officemate is an ass.... whatever!).
Still Officemate 2 (he's really bad):
Officemate 2 (again) has a business client which had a problem with his PC, a Digital Video Recorder hardware/software setup in particular. The problem was frequent crashes and slow (P4-3.0GHz w/ 512MB RAM... how come?). So my officemate offered service, and then asked me to help him and then we charge his client. I warned him that I may not be able to put back or restore the stored video files. Even though I'm busy, I set aside time in fixing the said PC. Ok, the PC is in optimal condition but the stored video files cannot be played anymore (even the backup). And yes, all the effort, and still no pay (he is really an ass....).
Currently he just asked me to setup his client's PC for background music system, for a fee. I don't want to help him this time. If that breaks up or problems come in the future, I might be again be the "free technical support".
Yes we may give free advice, and yes in some way we can help/support a friend/officemate. But there should really be limits. It may be hard, but we must learn to turn them down. We don't want to put any big effort for nothing.
I am of the opinion that what goes around comes around. If you're seen to be helpful, you will get it back in other ways. Why would you want to be awkward and refuse? Does it not make you feel good being able to help others without expecting financial reward.
As an example, I have had my car fixed for helping someone with their home computer. It's called trading isn't it?
by netwerkss
by bobwinners
I'm assuming you are on company time when this happens. Talk to you boss and let him decide. 'Suggest' that it would be nice to have a company policy on this issue.
OTOH, if you are getting calls at home, feel free to notify the caller of your rates. ;)
by uwe.packer
I 100% agree with you. When I make a "housecall" some people expect my expertice for free as I am "just" sitting at the keyboard and do not hammer in nails and stuff. Yet they would not think twice paying $60 or more for a tradesmen to just show up at their front door. And we are not even talking about any charges to fix a problem.
I have learned my "trade" and expect to get compensated for the time and money I have spend becomming an expert.
If someone needs free advise let them go to backyard experts and get what they pay for.
by the admiral
by the admiral
There is a time when you have to say enough free stuff and actually earn your pay. I do not believe that IT is above everyone else, the fact of the matter is that a high school drop out who put a computer together could answer the question. (HINT: IT is common knowledge, and no one should put more value on it than that since most Idiots guide to.... or Blank for Dummies can get people certified) Don't read more into that than there is.
But if your asked a general question that is not detailed like my printer won't install, the common answer is that if it is a HP you have to run the CD that came with the printer first then plug it in after it reboots.
But the highly technical stuff that will take longer to explain than actually reading War and Peace should be tabled for a person or company that can go to their house and do it.
Sort by Trending