Discussion Locked

Should M$ force security patching?

0 helpful
155 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

155 replies

by techanduser

My concern is when I receive an update from MS which brings down my system. I have had four computers in my family receive an official update from SUS, and after installing the patch the computer would fail to boot. Two of the three required serveral hours online with MS support to back out, one required a total disk wipe (with lots of lost data), and my personal machine had a recent ghost image to restore from. My opinion is that MS should make sure the patch installation is bullet-proof before they force feed us.

by hal 9000

To take the financial responsibility for any flaws in their code we would still have DOS as the only PC operating system and even then not DOS of the Microsoft variety.

Microsoft is not willing to take financial responsibility for their leaking software now what makes you think that they would be willing to accept it if they forced patches to be applied?

Remember every Microsoft product is "Install at your own risk!"

Col

by hal 9000

This would not be an issue as Windows would work as it is claimed with no undocumented features.

Col

by hal 9000

Microsoft had even half way decent code in the first place this just would not be an issue. All these security patches and I'm only talking about the security patches and not the recommended or driver updates plug holes that are in the system that should never have been allowed to be there in the first place.

Maybe if Microsoft had bullet proof code in the first place you would not be spending so much time putting out all those little fires as they just wouldn't happen in the first place because the OS wouldn't allow the end user to mess up the system.

Col

by Former member

We just spent two days reimaging systems that the latest microsft patch broke. Patches will do that, particularly when you have an extremely mixed environment (different applications, hardware drivers, etc...).

A better solution would be to Build a tight, minimalist (ie no integrated browser, media player...) Core OS, with a published, rigid, standardized API, and messaging layer. That takes car of the technical holes.

Certainly I think it is a great idea to have a very noticeable alert that a patch is available, but until "uninstall" works flawlessly. No way I want you pushing it to me without my say-so.

by hal 9000

Than allowing the product to be sold in the first place before at least 2 - 3 Service Packs have been produced.

What Microsoft is effectively doing is having a lot of Beta testers who pay for the privilege and then pay again when they have problems. It is from all of these "reported" problems that Microsoft learn what to make as Service Packs or patches/hot-fixes. When you think of it that way it makes some kind of sense and is no worse than being first off the rank to install new OS's and software just because it has been released.

Remember the lines that formed in front of shops when 98 was released?

Col

by sharding

Let's see, I am a home user with my Quicken files that I, of course, haven't ever backed up and now a forced patch totally screws up my system for whatever reason (I've had it happen before with MS patches, especially ones for hardware). So now, I'm basically SOL and lost X years of financial information. Sounds like a law suit brewing to me.

by hal 9000

Complaining about Symantec auto updates for Virus Definitions here. Recently I've seen these run several times a week and it is considered as a feature.

So what exactly is the big difference for "HOME" users in letting Microsoft auto update than in allowing Symantec do it?

Col

by mgomez2010

On the 7 of April 2004 I was installing Win2k on my system. When I was done I started installing Windows Update patches because I could not load any software that need at least Windows SP2. After that I put Zone Alarm on to protect me right away from the internet. When I was done I kept noticing that a svchost.exe was trying to access the internet so I denied the service a couple of times. Now mind you that these were the only things so far that I have installed. I did not go any were else on the web except Winupdate site. So next I installed Norton AntiVirus 2004 and during the initial scan it discovered Backdoor.Rtkit, W32.Welchia.B.Worm, W32.HLLW.Raleka and Trojan Horse. Now everything I install on this computer was on a cd or from Microsoft. I've been in the computer field since 1998 and I have never encountered this problem. I have read an heard that crackers have started to hack patches and up dates. Could they have penetrated Microsoft and exchanged a good patch for a hacked patch or is this a ploy to keep antivirus software companies employed. This maybe a ridiculous idea but it happened

by farreym

You have never encountered Welchia? Go read up about it.

This particular virus spreads across the network and probably infected your macine before you even reached the windows update site. It attacks machines without a certain set of updates from July 2003 and it has been around since August 2003.

I now keep newly built machines disconnected from the network until the latest service pack and a handful of super critical patches are applied. I have them on CD from easy access.

by pirate?

Let's face it, people like to throw monkey wrenches into the machinery, if only just to see the sparks. So what to do?

Instead of forcing the public to buy buggy software, M$ should be forced instead to quit making users be their beta testers and deliver software that gives the bad guys less to work with in the first place.

With all the money floating around Redmond, maybe some of it should be spent on outside experts who don't have to knuckle under to the sales department and force the fixing of flaws BEFORE shipping.

I know this is likely impossible to enforce unless Bill suddenly gets the religion.

by eri-groe

After rescuing some of my friends who have trusted MS and used automatic updates, my feeling is NO. reasons are already given: untrustworthyness, patches on patches etc. In addition: It is MY system, weither I'm a pro or novice, and it is MY responsibility to know enough about it, not MS.

by hal 9000

The original code was "Bullet Proof" we wouldn't need any patches would we?

But what a lot of people here are getting away from is the "Critical Patches" as apposed to the "Recommended Patches" and the "Driver Patches" all of these have potential problems if installed and if not installed.

If the basic OS actually worked we just would not see the former of these as there would be little to no need.

Col

by black_eyed_pea

I've supported Windows, Netware, VMS, Mac OS, and various flavors of *NIX. Any sysadmin with similar experience can verify that no networked OS is bullet-proof. Somebody name me a viable OS that doesn't need to be patched. Anyone?

If the OS itself has been hardened, you still have to worry about apps/daemons/services. In addition, when you harden any OS, you trade functionality for security. There is always overhead.

It is possible that Microsoft could be knocked off the hill and some other player could shove them aside. It would be nice if the various *NIX factions could polarize forces and become a viable competitor to Microsoft on the desktop. The beginnings of that could be in the works at Novell. If that ever does happen, mark my words, the target will change and exploits will be found.

There is a reason SANS and the FBI release the top ten vulnerabilities for the two most widely used operating systems:

http://www.sans.org/top20/

Comments?

by hal 9000

Being Bullet Proof Microsoft could do a far better job than they currently are as effectively we are all Beta Testers who pay for the privilege to test these products.

Now as far as a viable alternative Xandros looks hopeful it is a Debian derivative that is supposed to be able to run Windows applications, at the moment I've only got it installed on a 200 MMX with a 2.1 GIG HDD so all the features are not active and it is very slow as the recommended minimum is a P11 but it works as a show piece rather than anything else. When I get the time to install it on something bigger I'll report back on just how effective it actually is. Like if it actually does what it says it will or if the people behind this "NIX" version are taking a leaf out of M$ advertising book and making unfounded claims.

Actually you have not said anything that I haven't said previously but then I got howled down by the Linux devotees telling me that it just isn't possible to Hack Linux or write virii for it as easily which of course it isn't but that by no means,means it is impossible either. I took great joy in pointing out that the very first system hacked was in fact a Unix mainframe at Melbourne Univ many years ago.

But what the whole idea of this discussion was originally about home computers and not business units as they are very different kettle of fish. What is useful in a "Home" environment is not necessarily a good thing in the work environment and the same goes the other way around as well.

Now while you are perfectly correct that when you harden any OS you trade off functionality for security but then again what is the point of having a network that is as easy as hell to use if it is a security nightmare for the persons commissioned to administer it? We have to strike an acceptable balance between the two and these are very different for the home and business.

Personally I think most people here are thinking about their work systems and forgetting that the biggest piece of Microsoft's sales are to home users who very rarely do the right thing mainly because they know no better and it is these very unpatched systems which then cause business a lot of troubles. With the Internet being what it is anything can be spread around the world in a few minutes and most of the spreading comes from home users computers as the business computers are on the whole fairly well locked down to prevent this from happening or at the very least they should be.

Now if it meant that the occasional breakdown caused by Microsoft auto applied patches on a home computer meant that things like Slammer or Netsky took far longer to spread even if it was only reduced to several hours and not several minutes I think that would be a good trade off for business. But of course I'm only talking about "Security" updates not the "Recommended r Driver" updates that are available from Microsoft. Also if they where to finally do what they have been telling us for a few years now and set up only one entry point to upgrade every Microsoft product it would make my life a lot easier as all the home computers that are running whichever version of Office would at least have most of the venerabilities sealed.

Col

by deadly ernest

True no system is bullet proof, but does MS have make them holier than Swiss cheese and build in bullet magnets? My biggest gripe is the number of security problems in Win XP that had been identified and patched in Win NT4, Win 200, Win 98, and Win ME that were in Win XP and had to be patched post release. If they did their job properly those holes should have been closed in XP in the original code during the development.

by eri-groe

Due to some horrible experiences with IBM some years ago (early aptiva et.al), I've never even considered going the ThinkPad route. But, as I got into a long time job with one our customers, they wanted me to have one of their laptops - easier to maintain etc. I am impressed. Have used the unit extensivly for 1,3 years now, much travel and working under rather rough conditions. Most of my colleagues have had mayor mishaps with their HP and Compaq units in that period (and they have stressed their equipment much less).

by cyberblatt

Who would by a crap like that.As long as innovation motivated MS they were on a good path with the Windows OS until w98 SE. Since than, their motivation changed towards domination and thus we see more problems.
What is in the patch? Are you sure it is something to improve and protect your OS or is it
just updating the Orwellian digital madcow to pull more money out of your pocket with creating continuous problems. A brand new and freshly downloaded Media Player 7 has a spyware and/or a magnet-hook (doors)for adwares. No wonder Europeans want a version of windows without the Media Player. I have unistalled it after the second test-run showed spyware content again.
I do not patch anything I have stopped that a year or so ago. Even disabled automatic updating.
I do not take any crap from anybody to put on my machine without me wanting it.
Have a good virus scanner, an extra firewall, spyware scanner and cookie controll tool.
Control all start-up and active programs. You will not see any popups or garbage again. Clean cookies after each session when ever possible.
Do not use outlook at all. Use web-based email as your main and the one from your ISP as spare only.

by w2ktechman

First I think that it should be a choice that can be disabled, if nothing else it should prompt for a patch with the ability to say no. Many times I have seen patches run, and then blue screens or other problems follow. I do think that it is not a totally bad idea, but there are literally thousands of system configurations, and 1 patch fits all doesnt work well.
My veiwpoint is that if you want to install it, a prompt is good, but any feature like that should be easily disabled without a novice looking through hundreds of MS docs online.

by lweight

If Microsoft "forced" patches, then my Library District's Groupwise would no longer run (which Microsoft would probably like...) as KB828035 "fixes" a problem with the Microsoft messenger buffer overrun in such a way that GroupWise 6.0.02, which needs MS Messenger to work in the way it was originally designed to, stops working correctly when the patch is installed. I found this out the hard way recently when setting up five new Dell OptiPlexes and a new Dell Latitude notebook. I had set up the first Optiplex and not downloaded that patch (there were 18 "critical" patches and upgrades on the Windows Update site needed according to the site for each of these machines right out of the box-running W2k Professional SP4), and everything worked fine. Then I made the mistake of putting in that patch on the next unit I set up, the Latitude notebook. This was the only difference in my setup routine. GroupWise quit working right after the patch. And the patch would not completely uninstall. I had to reformat the hard drive and reload everything. Put in only the patches that I had on the first machine (no KB828035)and GroupWise worked fine again. I have set the Windows Upgrade on all new machines to have me manually check for upgrades and install as I choose, (after doing a little research on), on an individual basis. Of course I only have 30 machines at two sites to worry about. I hate to think what life would be like if we had a really big network or ran Windows servers. (I have 3 servers running Netware 6.0-have been running Novell since 1995-servers never abend-only time one has been down in over two years was to replace an aging UPS, and when my Novell consultant comes in once a year to do a few ugrades & patches.) BTW-obviously I am not an IT person, just another "accidental systems librarian", and it is only because Netware, Zenworks, BorderManager and GroupWise are such stable, solid products, that I can spend so little time on network administration and desktop support. This lets me do my "real" job, which is all the other library stuff-reference, collection development, etc., Bottom line, as long as computer users, both home and office, are going to have systems that run additional non-MS software on a system with a Windows OS, "forcing" patches (especially when those patches frequently are buggy) and upgrades, while seeming to solve one group of problems, will cause more problems in other areas, and make a lot more people made at Microsoft than already are. Once size just doesn't fit all.
LW

by mxyzyptylk1

...I agree that virus "pushes" are also a bad idea. I still remember the one that flagged Office as a virus and offerred to remove it from 300 machines one morning. One would have thought that Microsoft would know how to find possible examples of buffer overrun in their own code. One would have been wrong several dozen times. Even the firewall vendors are having trouble with their own stuff (and such as they are, they're still our first line of defense). Why the h^ll should we allow ANYONE to do a forced update? Yes- we have an amazing number of polluted machines and zombies out there. One group has a serious business reason for eliminating them: the ISPs.

by maco

We all "automatically patch" already: a message appears saying, "Critical Update!" and we maybe read about the "buffer overflow that could cause an attacker's code to be executed" if we have time, then despite the notice, "This patch cannot be uninstalled," we click "Install".

If only the patch description spoke the truth:

"This patch breaks a legacy app critical to your business, and because it cannot be uninstalled will cost you 8 hours per machine restoring each of them to working order. Do you wish to proceed?"

We don't really know whether a patch is going to break anything or not until after we install it, so "forced patching" is for most of us merely a nod to the inevitable -- we were probably going to do it anyway.

The real issue is the ability to uninstall patches and keep them off until a new patch is released.

by oz_media

I mentioned Ximian Linux for desktops which runs with a Novell server. This is FAR more stable than the other flavours as it is behind Netware for a start. With a well secured GroupWise, AV system and GWAVA, this is a VERY secure, safe and solid system.

by doshelp

For the most part, YES..the simple reason is my site DoShelp.com sees reports of users being infected by exploit/trojans and virii which have long since been patched. It doesn't matter if you don't know how to do it, forget to do it or don't want to do it.....

If you don't patch you are going to become a problem for others on the net! I cannot count how many I have helped who when asked about "did you run windowsupdate" they say HUH?!? YES I think forced updates (including updates for unregistered users should have software updated.

Regardless of a users desire to upgrade, ability to remove by patching should be available to EVERYONE!!

by jaredh

Should MS force updates? NO! Why? Some of their "updates" have caused more problems than they fixed, for one. Also, not all software is created equal and one update for the OS could be a break for an application. SUS is ok because it can be controlled by me. I should be in control of my network, not MS. Finally, if MS would just to a decent job of getting a good quality OS out, there would not be near the need for the patching in the first place.

by holdcraftm

Who owns my computer, me or Microsoft? Answer: I do, therefore I decide what software is loaded on my computer, and I decide when or if I ever upgrade. If Microsoft starts to force upgrades and security patches on me, then I go look for other vendors software.

by hal 9000

It sure as hell isn't you if you have taken the time the actually read the EULA.

The best that can be said is that you have purchased the right to use the software on one computer and that the maker {Microsoft} can demand its return at any time.

Now would you like to insist that you actually own every thing on the HDD on YOUR computer?

Col

by zati16

I pretty much like to choose myself which updates&security patches to download&install, so I don't whant M$ to do these things for me without my knowledge or to force to do so.

by supercub

Greetings to all,

Yes they should force patches AND,I suggest they should have to credit a part of the purchase price for all over a reasonable number of patches.

Everybody is driven by the Almighty Dollar,

My 2c worth, R

by zati16

that's why I recomend McAfee SecurityCenter, it's easy to update (you only need a valid e-mail adress, no questions asked)...
:)

by zati16

I installed a security patch and some stoped to work.I fixed it by uninstalling the sec.patch...
my question is: when I'm paying between 20-50$ for a game and Windows stops it working, would they give the money spent for the product?
The game was just an example.

by jardinier

Pardon my French, but in my experience Norton is an inferior AV.

Commencing 7 years ago, when I first connected to the Internet, I have been using Vet AV (purchase online and download from www.vet.com.au) on all my computers, and recommending it to everyone to whom I sell a refurbished computer.

I have never been infected in all these years. It is also very competitively priced. After the initial purchase, registration renewal currently is about $AU 43 per year.

Vet is part of Computer Associates, a long-established software manufacturer. Currently it updates silently in the background, within about 15 minutes of making an Internet connection. These updates are currently revised almost every day.

I have also used TrendMicro products, which cover everything from AV, anti spam, firewall etc. Their technical support is truly amazing. I was installing it on a Windows 95 computer, but had lost the serial number. Emailed answers to my questions usually arrived less than 48 hours after the request. TrendMicro have a complete range of security products to cover every conceivable setup.

by deadly ernest

Often the patching process can interfere with the operation of applications, thus the decision to pacth or not should be the users. Also to force security patching would require the system to make regular checks of the MS site, not posssible if the PC is NOT connected to the Internet.

MS should force their people to design and write secure software and to properly test it prior to release. Many of the security problems in Win XP had been noticed and notified to MS in previous versions of Windows, as had many security problems with MS applications.

Considering the push that MS has been placing behind the Secure Computing concept, their low concern with security in the basic software design is either a major anomoly or a deliberate fault design to assist their Secure Computing PR program.

by hal 9000

At the Product Release of 2003 Enterprise Server the Microsoft Zombies went to great lengths telling us all about their new "Trusted Computing" and just how secure the new product was. What they didn't say a single word about was the hole that they had known about for over 6 months previously and that took another few months to patch.

Microsoft & Trusted Computing tell me another as it is far more believable that WW11 just did not happen and there are no Atomic Bombs that have ever been made.

Col

by deadly ernest

Home user realities intrude on this issue, I have spent endless hours rebuilding home user client systems after they noticed how stuff their system had become due to loading things like Kazaa, etc; most have dial up connections working at 45 k or less. One client had automatic update operating and said they would hanlde the updates, I left him to it as the last time I had rebuild his system (4 months previously) the auto updates took 3 days to fully process, and that was all the system did whilst online for 3 days.

Many users wont wait around that long; for many I build the system the way they want with their apps etc and the basic operating system disc, then image the system to CD and just leave it at that. When they get hit they just use the CD to reimage and can be up and running again in an hour or so without me; not the several hours or days to do a total rebuild and secure.

by jagostisi

In my business environment I'm using Symantec's Corporate Edition, and I recommend Norton Antivirus to everyone I know with a home computer.

I've been in the IT business for almost thirty years and using/managing PCs from the onset. While viruses have constituted a threat from almost the beginning, the nature and the magnitude of the problem changed radically with the inception of E-Mail. Prior to E-Mail McAffee was my product of choice. Unfortunately, not all vendors have adapted or evolved equally well to meet the challenges and requirements of the real and corporate worlds, nor at the same rates. Symantec has not alway been my product of choice, but it is today.

Why? I have had incredibly bad experiences with Network Associates/McAfee, Trend, and Computer Associates. In the last five years my company has been hit by two virus attacks, one was insignificant, the other was the Nimda virus. When Nimda hit, I was using using Computer Associates' product

Computer Associates - they were the last company to acknowledge the existance of Nimda, the last to provide a scan for it, and the last to provide a fix. Do I need to say more? They were rapidly out the door.

Trend - They were the quickest to identify Nimda and to provide a fix. I applied it. As I discovered later, the fix was to simply delete infected system files on my Windows NT4 server, and it did stop the spread of the virus. Unfortunately, it also crippled the sever, eventually requiring drive reformatng and complete re-installation of all system and application software. The fix caused more damage than the virus.

Network Associates - After Nimda, my goal was to provide more reliable virus protection accross the enterprise and minimize the work and overhead in doing so. At the time Network Associates seemed to be the only vendor that began to approach those objectives. I licensed their flagship product with push/pull technology to effortlessly keep all work stations protected. It may have been the best available, but it was anything other than effortless. The documentation was light on explanation and phone support had to be purchased separately. It worked fairly well but took a lot of effort and manual intervention to keep workstations protected and up to date. There were also multiple instances where the push/pull technology did not work. The real problems though began when I renewed my licence and acquired the latest version. It simply did not work. I was running PSQL7 on my Windows 2000 server but their product only worked with PSQL6(a requirement only found in the documention afterwards). Their downloaded fix for the problem did not work either, and the documentation for it was terrible. When I contacted the company they told me that it was my problem to deal with, but they suggested that I should purchase telephone support. Goodbye, Network Associates. Lastly, I had never found, up to that time, a home user who had successfully downloaded their virus signatures, and I didn't have an easy time of it either.

Symantec - They were slow to address the enterprize, but when they did, they got it right. The corporate edition installed efortlessly and the workstation update is seemless, without any intervention. Updates are fully automatic and the push to the workstations is invisble. How good is the virus protection? There's been no virus penetration in the last two years(since it's been in place); of course, that speaks of some good luck too. I've called them on several occassions with questions, tech suport has been quick and on the money, and free. I've found that Symantec's web site is the easiest from which to obtain imformation on viruses and removal instructions are thorough and complete. Lastly, I had no trouble in training any home user in updating the virus signatures, that includes my 80 year old mother. The latest home versions update themselves automatically. Someone expressed displeasure with their licensing charges. What's the cost of an infestation?

by jardinier

for detailing your experiences with various AV products. I am a home user, and my comments were based on my personal experience.

I do not know if Vet AV (Australia) software is independent of Computer Associates. Vet does, however, in its newsletters, claim to have won awards for its product.

by fluxit

The trick is not to force compliance or write laws or invade alleged privacy. We need creative thought to solve the problems such as design encapsulated systems in which the operating system is burned into a chip or CD and stored internally (sealed inside the case). This offers several significant design advantages.

1. Imposters, trojans, worms, and other viri cannot replace operating system files thus maintaining a high degree of integrity.
2. Malicious software may destroy CPU's, RAM, or hard drives but the operating system will remain in intact.
3. Recovery can be instantaneous. By pressing a button sequence or turning a key the system will clear everything on a harddrive and reboot immediately without a problem.
4. Permanent upgrades, updates and security patches can be mailed from online or purchased in the store. Another approach is if the operating system is burned in a EPROM a direct secure connection can download updates and burn them into the EPROM then lock it.
5. If the price drops low enough on chips and electronics then design the systems completely sealed as disposable appliances. I can see this if several technologies combine into one. For example, a chasis could be purchased that has modular plug ins for a stereo, VCR, TV, computer, and phone. Its a all-in-one box approach. This kind of approach is being thought of in the auto industry too.

Depending on the direction of computing in the future these approaches may be obsolete. Especially, if systems and computing become human centric and distributive (meaning one leases computing power over the internet and does not own the CPU.)

by richard vickery

forget forced anything from M$, what I did was switch to something more reliable, and, I might add, more fun to use: Linux or some other unix variant. Of course, if one wants to continue using a flimsy platform that multiple holes, security, and uptime issues, onne is certainly free to do such.

by hal 9000

It is not a piratical option at the moment in the business environment for desktop use as there are far too many people used to the Microsoft products and those that will only run on a Microsoft Platform like MYOB and its ilk.

Then there are the home users who like my son only want to play games now if I was to insist that I load any form of Linux onto my computer at his place and he suddenly found that he couldn't play his favorite games all hell would break lose. Until a lot of the current applications are available for the "Nix" platforms it just is not going to happen no matter how much better that they are.

Col

by igotspamed

I am in the process of installing os on 4 systems. One of these systems has already gone down. M$ programing has cause p4e's to endlessly loop at full bore on a number of occtions. These systems are for a office enviroment where to ask users to watch things like temperatures and processor activity makes them nervous and afraid to use the computer. Heaven forbid an xp system go down because the hacking a trial and error approach I'd have to take would make me look like a complete fool. I've had to break in to systems so many times I don't think there is a single secure element at the terminal level. Security packs, the upload manger and who knows what else will alter settings at random. Although a system works fine now there are no garentees two hours or two weeks from now. That mean printers failing, lans and wans. I can't ask someone to fool with the network connections wizard to try and get the internet back up. I've got enough problems with routers and modems as is. M$ went to far with sp2. I'm in the process of installing Gentoo Linux on a P3 which will in turn unpack p4 software on a second drive with will go into a p4 system and be installed on the sata drives from there. M$ is no longer welcome on my systems.

by hal 9000

Work Station running XP Pro as I regularly see the CPU's running at 100% for long periods of time and this is after I shut things down.

I also had a Quad Processor Server where the CPU's could not be made to run at anything better than 20% with 2003 Enterprise Server installed. M$ answer was that it was fast enough anyway so why bother but I felt that my customer was not getting what they had paid for with only that amount of workload being available through the CPU's. Once I installed SUSE onto the unit everything worked perfectly and that is how it has stayed running properly and best of all the customer is none the wiser about what they actually have on the new server as they think it is a Microsoft Product but they can not believe just how stable it is.

Col

by hal 9000

Xandros Desktop ver 2 and while it is heavily Debian based it has quite a few differences as well. Currently I haven't had the time to have a good play with it as yet but I do have a new P4 system that I'm going to try it on when I get the time. But just going from the original install it claims to have some interesting features and the copy installed on the 200 MMX works quite nicely on the Windows Network picking up all the Windows machines without any trouble.

I was going to spend Easter playing with it but after making sure that I had nothing on so I could have the time to give it a good workout I've been out working at a business where their whole network has gone down because there where no current AV Definitions on it and no M$ Patches. At least they had a full backup in place so I've only had to reload 100 computers & servers So I'm guessing that the Easter treat just is not going to happen.

Now if only I could find a way to prevent most of what I'm earning over Easter going in Taxes as there will be something like 60% + 10% GST.

So if you want to have a play with it you very well might get to have a look long before I will. It claims to be able to run M$ applications but if this is just "Wine" installed that allows this to happen I'm not as yet sure as I haven't had the time to have a good play with it.

Col

by Former member

Actually, If I remember correctly, it is Codeweavers Crossver Office Plugin that Xandros has licensed for windows Compatibility. It is a little more sophisticated than wine. Works quite nicely, what little bit I have used it.

by hal 9000

I appreciate it as as yet I have not had much of a chance to play with it and even now it is on a sub-standard unit just for initial testing purposes.

When I load it onto some thing far more powerful it should prove interesting.

Col

by oldgoat663

Weighing in as a construction manager / engineer and the local "guru" on the side (and definitly not an IT professional; typical system at a location is 3-5 cpus networked to a router for broadband access) I have the following observations:

1. Most users objective is to do their business, and use the computer to help them do their business. Becoming more knowledgeable than turning the machine on and using their applications does not achieve progress towards their objective (in their short sighted view). They will never learn. Case in point: I rescued an Architect from some virus. (It had him shut down for a week before I happened at a site adjacent to his. Went on the internet and had TrendMicro's Housecall scan it.) Told him flat out -- GO GET AV NOW and install it. 4 weeks later, not installed, he says he hasn't had the $40.

2. Windows vs. *nix and whatever: I am not married to Windows, but I have lots of experience with it. Remember the old saying about "the devil you know rather than the devil you don't?" Also, there are several (expensive, typically vertical) applications that are specific to Windows. Maybe one day someone will come out with an OS similar to how Borland changed me from 123 to Quattro -- key stroke for key stroke compatible, (no learning curve), 1/4th the cost, and look at all of the addtional things Quattro will do. Then I could switch systems at minimal cost to production (remember #1 above?)

3. Yes, I think Windows should ship to automatically update itself with a switch buried deep to allow IT professionals to turn this off so that they can control their systems. This way, the idiots out there at least will have some defenses.

My regularly e-mailed instructions (which I practice) to the folks that I work with (mostly ignored) are simple:

a. Use Windows Update to keep the OS updated.
b. Use Antivirus and keep your subscription up to date (I use NAV)
c. Use a software firewall. (I use ZA plus)
d. Use a spyware buster. (I recommend Spybot)
e. Don't open weird e-mail (I send other users examples of social engineering)

Do the other users get it?? NO. Am I wasting my breath?? Mostly. Has this strategy worked for me?? Yes -- ZERO infections to date.

4. I know, I have heard the various stories about the screwed up patches that MS has put out, but what choice do I have?? I do not have the resources or time to test patches before applying them to the ONE CPU that I use, and my assessment is that the dangers and costs of not patching significantly outweigh the problems of bad patches.

5. The increasing complexity of computing is causing learning resource overload. Moore's law also applies to the body of knowledge needed to keep up. For example, I do not bother trying to fix Win9x problems. (upgrade to Win2K, XP, or call someone else.)I have enough troubles keeping up with Win2k AND XP. Things sure have changed since I learned FORTRAN in 69.

by wpwalsh8

If anything, home users are the worst offenders for updating virus protection. There are enough vulnerabilities with each new release of Windows, due to Microsoft just trying to get the product on the market. They are exploited everyday. Microsooft should take a proactive approach to securing the product that they are ramming down everyone's throat.

by raymond w.

Interesting the range of responses and knee jerks (of all directions and quality) that this brings up.

My own opinion is that it should be left to the user. I know that the majority of the user population is clueless and a siphon for all the bad things that are causing problems on the net, but consider some things for a minute.

This is Microsoft we are talking about. The company that would rather pour money into killing possible competition than fixing known program problems.

Can you imagine what would happen to John and Jane Doe if the forced patching were compromised?

At work, most of us in larger companies are isolated from this issue by the upgrade vetting process and pushed updates. We would probably not see an issue of a compromised updater. But the rest of the world who rely on the normal updating will be at the mercy of anyone smart enough to crack (or be given) the update process. I am assuming that the update will be requested from the user's PC and not pushed by one of Microsoft's databases, that is why this is a mild response.

Now those of us who have our own firewalls and set them to ask before allowing Microsoft processes through may be safe, but if man can make, a kid can break.

Thus my vote would be to say no to the forced updates. For my home computers I prefer to wait until the "Microsoft is God" the "semi-clueless" groups test out the patch and see if there is a problem. There have been a couple that I was glad I waited a few days for.

(kind of rambling, but the small window makes it hard not to)

by black_eyed_pea

Eebywater,

Thanks for the reply. Do you have a list of those vulnerabilities on XP that were fixed in previous Windows releases? Or at least some URLs to direct us to?

by black_eyed_pea

Col,

That was a well thought out reply. If you ever return to this discussion, I would like to know how the eval of Xandros is going.

Also, I completely agree about striking a balance between security and functionality. I wonder what your thoughts about XPSP2 are.

by foringmar

Microsoft should be forced to make a secure product. Microsoft should be forced to make the product secure before they put it on the market. With 50 billion dollars in funds they should be able to do it too. If they want to. But they don't want to, because that way they can make more money out of us users.

I'm currently using Windows 2000. It will probably be the last windows version I'll ever use, because it is the last windows version so far without product activation. I will never use a software product with product activation.
Using a product with product activation is taking the sign of the beast as mentioned in the bible. I refuse to do that.

by rayevanshome

why stick with microsoft and get forced updats when there are free Alternatives like linux out there.

This discussion is closed to new replies.