63 replies
by w2ktechman
They should recommend to use a vpn, and post that their wireless is insecure. With that in mind, they should not be held liable if someone gets their information, as even if they were secured, it can be busted. It is like getting a virus on your PC at home, and you try to sue your ISP.
No network is totally safe, especially a hot spot and wireless. But, I think that these insecured hotspots should inform their users that it is insecure. And WEP is outdated, they should use WPA2 for enhanced security.
Also, maybe they should keep flyers available which explain some things to secure themselves a bit more. This would be a win-win situation
instruct that they are at risk and
give out information to help secure themselves
by old guy
by old guy
but I'm tired of coddling these id10ts. Those who know already have their computers secured and their networks as secure as possible against those who know but are too stupid to care or do anything about it and they deserve to blow up their laptops.
It's just a pet peeve of mine that we cater to these kinds of idiots instead of making them take their own responsibility. That's why the ambulance chasing lawyers have an endless supply.
by w2ktechman
that users need to take responsibility, but I do think that having a sign or pamphlet is a good idea.
Because these are areas hit by identity theives, there should be warnings. Besides, I know people who use a computer rarely. These people are usually guided on how to do things by someone that they trust, just because that person knows a little bit. But, that person may just be ignorant as well, or too young to know better.
I am sure that everyone has heard that 8 year olds at home, seem to be the ones who get the computers on-line for parents, etc. Are these kids really thinking of security, or connecting???
having an informative pamphlet would not be a bad thing, however a sign stating that it is an unsecured network may drive some people away. But the sign would be important if the wireless network was not secured at all.
by tonythetiger
It's perfectly legal to buy a car without having a driver's license. Now if someone who doesn't have a license buys one then chooses to drive it, not knowing how, and kills someone, who is responsible?
Wwll, in this anology, since the highway is the 'network' on which the crime takes place, I suppose the state would be, right? ([sarcasm]I mean, surely the person who committed a crime by driving without a license wouldn't be responsible, would he?[/sarcasm])
Maybe the answer is to require proof of proficiency before allowing someone to operate a computer. That will generate howls of protest, and maybe spur com
by tomac
by whannemann
by tig2
Access to a hotspot for me is no big deal- my firewall will tell me if there is a problem. But I also know to use a firewall and I will be pretty guarded about what I do in a hotspot- checking a web enabled email account? Probably. Surf generally? Likely. Use a credit card? No way!
But then again, I have a good feel for what I am doing. And while I think that others should be as savvy, the fact is that they aren't.
I'm more aware because I have been a victim of ID theft and not because I engaged in risky behaviour. Someone else did.
I don't see an easy answer to this. I would love to see signage and possibly a take away that tells an end user what the risks are. I don't know that a legal liability statement would be enforcable.
by bill_ca
by roger99a
by old guy
Totally agree with you.
Sorry, couldn't resist the little play on words. :)
by gralfus
I was able to successfully do a man-in-the-middle attack on my own network and from my other computer visit "secure" https sites with the padlock icon, and intercepted all logins and passwords. I could even remotely watch the websites being viewed.
The padlock doesn't mean a lot if the network itself is compromised.
by mdhealy
by zlitocook
Would be fine, I agree with what every one has said to a point. ID theft, computers being stolen, wireless is not secure and tons of other stuff has been in news papers, magazines, TV it is every where. People have seen or heard about all of this, if they have not then they should not be using a computer. Because like any device when you buy it you assume reasonability for it.
Like a car, can you sue the company that makes it if it is stolen? How about if you leave it running and the doors are unlocked? That is sort of like a wireless connection; you sit down and turn your computer on. You have no firewall, no encryption, no VPN and maybe no up to date anti virus software. So you started your car in an unprotected area, you leave it unprotected, you leave the doors open and leave your self open to people that can use your ID any way they want.
Sorry rant coming on, almost all computers that you buy have tons of software on them ( I hate that but that?s for another rant) and most of them have a trial version of an antivirus and other things.
With all the media attention on ID theft wouldn?t you thing that every one would buy the software already installed or at least get free programs to protect them?
All they have to do is search, Google or call their ISP and ask. Shoot just walk in to CompUSA or a computer repair shop and ask. But no most people expect the computer they just bought to do every thing and they should not have to do any thing. As for as suing a company for not protecting me, well I could sue the ATM makers if my pin was used by someone other then me, or I could sue Dodge because my mileage is not what they say it should be or maybe Microsoft because I keep getting updates and don?t want to install them.
Ok I wiped the sweat from my forehead and have composed my self now. What do you think?
by tonythetiger
How can you hold one person responsible for the wrongdoings of another?
If you're going to hold hotspot operators responsible for identity theft (if you can even prove that the identity was stolen through that hotspot), then you're also going to have to hold them responsible for other illegal acts that someone who connects through that network might do... like illegally downloading music... or emailing a bomb threat to a school, for a couple of examples. By logical extension, you would then have to hold any ISP responsible for anything illegal their users do.
Sorry, the person who buys the technology is totally responsible for its use or misuse, deliberate or accidental.
by jdclyde
You are still more likely to have a credit card stolen by using it when you go out to eat.
Another threat is someone that sets up their own access point to phish. Had never even heard of it before today. You think it is starbucks access point, but it could really be someone with a wireless card that can switch to work as an access point. The things people will do.
People should still have to be responsible for themselves. There is already too much of people refusing to take responsiblity for their own actins in this sick sue happy world.
by techexec2
I see this as a [i]potential[/i] problem, not a real one. I think it is very likely that there are more people who have become sick from eating tainted spinach in the past few weeks than people who have suffered an actual loss through using unencrypted Wi-Fi hotspots. [no stats, just an illustration for my point]
Providers of unencrypted Wi-Fi hotspots should not be fined. And, I would not be in favor of some law governing how these hotspots are run. I don't think there must be a law for every harm that might befall a member of our society, especialy when the hotspots are run by private companies and the users are private users.
On the other hand, providers of unencrypted Wi-Fi hotspots should be admonished to admonish their users about best security practices and the risks of using the hotspot. This should come from within the industry and from people like us here on TR.
There is a place for government regulation. But, the government does not have to regulate every corner of the landscape.
P.S. Great thread, by the way!
Plenty of people have and use computers without wireless capability, they learn how to use it, then they adda wireless card without knowing the issues. If you feel that someone MUST provide advice on these issues to the general user, then it should be the people making the wireless capability possible. Make the wireless card manufacturers responsible for including a small brochure about the dangers with their products. if a new computer has wireless then it is part of the paperwork shipped witht he computer.
If the purchaser chooses not to read it, then that's their problem.
From a business perspective if you increase the cost of providing a service, and it becomes non-profitable, then I no longer provide it. Then someone provides a blackmarket service.
At present when McDonalds provide a wifi access, they do some checks on the quality of the service and how often it's used. If they suddenly stopped doing that, because you just upped their liability insurance, they will stop checking the area. Someone else can then set up a fake McDonalds access site, and start collecting personal info. In the current environment, they can't do that as the McDonalds staff check the service quality on a regular basis and would detect the fake access.
No law in the world can stop people being lazy or idiotic or criminal.
Just taking one of your examples, Starbucks, there are a few mitigating provisions in place and already some encryption involved. I think you've seemed to have trivialized the mitigations, as in, not mentioned any at all.
First, Starbucks uses T-Mobile. See T-Mobile's security statement:
http://selfcare.hotspot.t-mobile.com/security.htm
Secondly, you have to be a T-Mobile customer to even beging to get on the network in order to snoop around. That's the first mitigation..and the risks begin to fall more after that. The point is that I don't hink the networks are less secure than any public wired LAN network, such as the library, the only difference is that they provide the machine.
Smart people will not put confidential or even personal data onto a public network, period. Usernames and passwords are encrypted and the practice of ensuring smart Internet practices, such as ensuring SSL is on when submitting credentials should apply.
But even though there is mitigation and people should browse intelligently, they should still provide full-time encryption, it can't be that difficult. The average user there should be able to compensate.
by nz_justice
by w2ktechman
ok, I dont think that anything will pass (law) to fine people or institutions if someone does not protect their systems. This would lead to another 80's frivilous lawsuit era, and would not be tolerated, especially because city governance (some cities, more all the time) are providing wireless services for the Internet.
However, I do think that many people are oblivious to security while using these networks.
My suggestions would be to do one or more of these.
1. provide pamphlets with tips and information.
2. when connecting, have an "I Agree" button (often will be disregarded) after an info page.
3. the first 2 can be avoided if a signup is required. Have the information pages and then have a button to "save this page" on the security page, so it can be referenced later, then have the "I Agree" button. to continue.
The security info page should be the first page of the account signup.
Do you expect every free public access provider to issue an SSID and a WEP key to everyone who walks in the door? If they give it to everyone, how is that better than not having it all? How are you going to prove the lost data was due to the hot spot insecurity?
"Yes, users are uneducated about wireless security and should not be expected to know what WEP or 3DES enryption is ..."
NO, users should be expected to know what encryption is! This is another sign of a U.S. culture that refuses to read the damn manual for ANY product. They should be prepared to accept the responisbility of learning what they're doing or they shouldn't be doing it. Why not a law assigning responsibility for the security of data on transmitted over public networks to the data owner, and exempt providers of free services? Put the responisibility back where it belongs. I don't know what your motive is, but it sounds like an attempt to hit on a few deep-pocketed companies.
by jessie
Fences are put up to keep honest people honest, not to keep criminals away... criminals are the reason you get a monitored security alarm.
Pleading ignorance never works in the court of law, unless you've got a LOT of money.
by mgp2
If people are taught that "Ignorance of the law is no excuse", why shouldn't they be taught that "Ignorance of the proper use and also of the dangers is no excuse" as well? I mean, if someone uses an ATM and they let the person behind them see their pin, should the bank be fined?
I have a feeling that the same people who get hijacked at wi-fi hotspots are also the same ones that'll click on any link in an email promising "Instant Wealth/Larger Endowment/Beauty in a Pill", if they haven't already.
Wow, I feel ten pounds lighter already. ;-)
MGP
by now left tr
No Way - they give us all free broadband. Ok you never do anything important on an usecured Wi-Fi spot, but hey - if the are stupid enough to leave the thing open in the public domain!
Not sure how such things stand up in Law however.
by pletizia
by it research
by copisetic
You talk about biting the hand that feeds you? ( not that they are feeding you much )
Just like when you walk outside every day your identity can be stolen, now who should be held accountable til the crook is caught?
These places that provide free WiFi are doing you a favor in addition to the shameles advertising. Your identity can be stolen in your own home so whose accountable then? You own a laptop you know whats out there and whose out there, so protect yourself accordingly.
But if I'm going to be held accountable for something some crook did, guess what... I'll up the security on my WiFi network and charge you lemmings. And Oh yes!! I'm just one place, in a remote little corner of my town.
But when the lawsuits start rolling in, it won't be profitable and places start going out of business. More businesses will follow suit. Then you will see terms like; "Prepaid WiFi cards", Sorry no WiFi here, and at the local McDonald would you like to WiFi your meal at the additional cost of $$$ (you fill that in).
I'm a just a waiting for you lemmings.
sheesh....
WiFi will be free soon. new ways of ensuring security will be found. WiFi will soon replace TVwaves [the frequency is already up for sale since HERTZian TV has moved digital and borrows other channels]. The infrastructure is already out there.
Have you realized how much spam, spy, ads and popups we are already dealing with? Well this is a huge market and no-one will prevent it from growing, even those deep pockets who are trying to steal hotel and cafe customers right now. This is already shifting...
by dr dij
since anyone could put a tap outside your home and you'd not be likely to notice. ISPs have been known to tap and read communications also. famous case of ISP promoting a book site based on comm. they intercepted to subscribers.
Wireless spots are not inherently unsecure based on lack of encryption since any users should be using SSL to secure sites. hacker did setup rogue wireless connect in a starbucks with almost identical name, hoping users would connect to him instead, and they did. he collected passwords, cc#s by passing thru the traffic to the legitimate network.
I think basically you'd have to be doing something wrong to get hacked so not starbies fault.
Still if you hold starbies accountable it will hinder biz, they may be likely to shut down the hotspots.
by gjsterner9
Holding HotSpot providers liable for the stolen identity of a user is moving in the wrong direction.
I recently did an on-site survey of a Food Court where I?m in the process of setting up a HotSpot for the patrons to use.
I asked over 100 people if they knew how to setup WEP security for a wireless connection. In every case, I got a blank stare then they asked what it was. I also showed them my laptop and displayed the list of available wireless networks in the area. When I attempted to connect to a secure link and the ?enter the security key? window opened they were dumbfounded to explain what it meant.
If a Food Court were to implement either WEP or WPA encryption, how would the user be informed of the encryption key to be used? Do you put it on a display card on the table for everyone to see and walk away with.
At present, I don?t know of any way to programmatically and automatically add an encryption key to a wireless connection, on the fly from a introduction web page.
Until such time as technology provides a means to automatically add an encryption key to a user?s laptop or PDA for the appropriate SSID, the HotSpot provider cannot reasonably be held liable.
by thegooch1
by wayne
by pjboyles
Securing the wi-fi connection is not the solution. Web sites that contain sensitive information should be using secure protocols. A bank site should have no insecure content and neither should your e-mail provider. They should use "https" for all of their web traffic.
Securing the Wi-Fi point with encription only provides a failse sense of some security.
by w2ktechman
I say the best thing to do would be to put out pamphlets at hot spots. These pamphlets can make suggestions about 'best practices' for using hot spots. They should also bring up the real threat of Identity Theft.
At minimum I think that hot spots should have a sign up, easily seen, that state that the network is unsecured.
by mtwallet
by kim.kendall
Equally, should the county council be liable for providing the tarmac for lunatic drivers to commit acts of death on?
Of course not, and by the same token it would be idiotic to suggest that free WiFi providers should be held responsible for idiot users.
It's up to us all to protect ourselves against the badies of the internet. Take responsibility for yourself and stop looking to blame others - particularly an easy target rather than the perpetrator.
by w2ktechman
you are supposed to have a drivers license right? Which basically means that you understand that there are rules of the road. Many hot spot users are ignorant of the 'rules' for an unsecure network. Having a pamphlet handy is not a bad idea.
it should help those that do not know, how better to help themselves.
If someone is too stupid to pick up the pamphlet, then that is their choice. But operating an unsecure network, and not doing anything is just as stupid.
Raise awareness, and I think customers may be happier with your efforts, and may just change some of their habits!
by adrian
by tomac
by prime12357
I have never had a lower opinion of any post on this Web site. This type of reaction, thought, lack of understanding freedom, rights and justice truly scares me.
All self-aware beings have the right to Life, Liberty and THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS.
I assume you have some awareness of what Life is, and while you obviously have no idea what Liberty is, I think someone needs to explain the "Pursuit of Happiness" to you.
It means that I or Starbucks or anyone else can do anything that makes us happy so long as we do not interfere with rights of others (other peoples Life, Liberty or Pursuit of Happiness).
You have no right to lobby your state officials to fine anyone for providing a free service and not providing every legal disclaimer humanly possible.
I hope you and your kind rot in a very warm place. Don't bother replying, I'm sure I'll never vist this thread again and I will most likely unsubscribe from this Web site which has changed from good technical data to insane rantings like this.
I can't believe you would have the belief that...
" ...the provider of the unsecure Wi-Fi hotspot be held liable if someone has their identity stolen by using that hotspot?"
But you should be punished for...
"I'm lobbying my state officials for such a bill to hold places like Starbucks and Atlanta Bread Company liable for what I deem as promoting unsafe computing habits."
Good Day Sir
by w2ktechman
so he is 'the problem'?
Just because you do not agree does not mean that you need to trash him...
I didnt agree with him on many items, but he has his ideas. He brought it up to discuss as well, to gather information from others.
If he was 'the problem' he would have only told us what we thought, got a bunch of signatures, and pretty much forced it down the state officials.
I partially agreed with his comments here, but only to the point of having pamphlets and signs.
But I do not think that it should be regulated by the state(s), I think that it should be something for businesses to offer.
But by some of the comments here, it would seem that they do not care to inform their users that they may be at risk. To me this seems more like incompetence on the business side. What a shame. They would better serve their customers by offering pamphlets on how to help avoid ID theft, instead they bash at anyone bringing up the idea....
by thegooch1
Sign on potential Girlfriend: Sex with me may lead to pregnancy.
this is so the guy can not claim in court that he had no idea she might get pregnant when being sued for child support...
Sign on potential Boyfriend: warning, i have no intention of calling you in the morning.
this will aide in the possible "truth in advertising" laws. He said he would call me your honor...
Sign on pack of condoms: you must use product to realize full protection...
this is to avoid potential lawsuit where the guy actually only thought he had to buy it, not actually use it...
Sign on lighter: flame may be hot, do not touch flame... self explanatory...
I could go on with potential signs but the bottom line is this, if you make it available they may come, if you have a lot of money and make it available then they will sue...
by w2ktechman
But looking at my lighter, it does have a sign... WARNING... starts it off.
So what is the problem with putting a sign up specifying that it is not secure?
Do you think that continuing the ignorance is the best thing to do???
I actually like the idea of leaving a pamphlet stating some basic things to HELP protect.
then great. here's how I see it and maybe I'm being a little myopic. As soon as businesses start placing signs then they begin a tacit agreement that they have some sort of responsibility. Once they do this then you start the lawsuits.
But I would rather see them start placing signs instead of the Feds mandating something... but personally, I say if you go to a WiFi hotspot then let the buyer beware...
by w2ktechman
did I say sign a pamphlet or a sign or a pamphlet???
What it is too hard for you to put up a sign that tells people to beware when using your wifi hotspot because it is unsecure???
As a business owner, you should already know about putting out signs for hazards like a mopped floor, etc.. These cause physical damage. Why do you think it is not important to warn people that they should be careful on WiFi???
by big ole jack
Yes i am totaly agreed with the point what you explained here and also what i think is that there must be layer in the client side which provides the proper encryption or decryption. if it does happen than security issues can be improved. So basically we need a architecture in the os which will check that is it working on the wireless network area and if it is then it should on the inbuilt encryption and decryption technology.
Thanks.
by w2ktechman
Even if you add encryption to the wireless net, the computers will see each other, and data travelling between your system can be captured in transit to the AP (access point).
If your wireless card had a highly directional antenne, you would have to sit there playing with it to find the AP, and then you wouldnt be able to move far at all. Your network card and the AP both send signals in all directions (well almost all at least). Using a standard encryption on a public wi-fi network will do little to nothing, because all of the client computers connected have the encryption key.
Best bet woul dbe to use a VPN in this issue, which encrypts further.
Also, if at a hot spot, you should be careful about the sites you visit, dont do banking or purchasing items online from it.
Being careful is the main thing, but having a firewall on your local system is also another big +.
Its not so much that using the Internet at a hot spot will get you, its more the problem of someone near you, capturing your data
by adrianfoot
Businesses providing the public with a free service should be commended and can't be held responsible for its missuse by criminals. Unfortunately the best way to catch these people would be with some kind of "honeypot" arrangements and some do-gooders would want to protect them against "entrapment", and tell us the criminals also have rights.
The use of computers is unlicensed and nature will take its toll of those who don't have care for security first and those who do have a care but their protection is eventually cracked. However we must not lose sight of the fact that it is the criminal who is the only one causing the problem and the detection, identification and prosecution of the criminals is the only real solution. Anything else is tinkering round the edges.
by wwachob
While I generally agree that most users are not as sensative to network security issues as they should be, I believe that fining businesses for providing "free" wireless is absurd.
My business provides free, open, unencrypted wireless to several thousand users each day. It is their responsibility to use that service intelligently. Intelligently means that they are discouraged from using it for Internet commerce, they are regularily cautioned about sharing personal information over the net. This capability has been in place for nearly 8 years (we were an early adopter of wireless) without incident. When we first deployed our service, it became an attraction element for our business.
Now sadly, we are finding it necessary to close off the open service due to misuse of our network tools. The misuse hwever was not from outsiders and I do not believe that we will make a dent in the problem.
by w2ktechman
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Security posts
Sort by Trending