Discussion Locked

Similarities/Differences of UNIX & WinNT

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
What are some of the major differences and similarities of UNIX and WinNT?

12 replies

by russ werner

It is dificult to answer this question, not sure what you are looking for???
To start out Unix runs on a risc processor and NT on an intel processor. Neither OS can be run on the other system.
UNIX is all command line instructions, while windows is graphical user interface.
Unix and Windows are nothing alike. You will find a better comparison with Linux and Unix than windows.

by t bowman

I must respectfully disagree with the previous posters answer. While it is true that USUALLY UNIX runs on risc and NT on Intel processors/systems, several flavors of Unix run on Intel systems (Solaris 8, for example) and at one time I know there were NT versions for risc processors as well because I tested on them, but they may have been dropped by now. Outside of that, there aren't many similarities in the two. They are as different as night and day. Unix is arguably more secure and thus largely void of virus threats. In my humble opinion, WinNT is fine for desktop computing and many applications but Unix is the better server OS for intense applications.

by ustutz

Windows NT/2000/XP has reached the point where it is a respectable work group server. People are also starting to use it in Enterprise applications, but I wouldn't be ready to do that.

I would not implement an office automation system (email, file and print services) on a UNIX server anymore (have done it in the past.

Conversely I alos would not implement an enterprise ORACLE database application on NT.

Windows NT is like your micro pick-up truck: It handles like a car, can do someof the work of a truck. But, if you are going to haul 40 tons of gravel cross country you are going to need a Mack truck. UNIX is that Mack truck: Harder to handle, requires special training, but has the power.

UNIX is still the operating system of choice for high end engineering applications, heavy duty databases, and 24x7 high-availability computing.

That was about a quarter's worth on a $25 question. What are your specific questions? I.e., what are you trying to accomplish?

by bgjkl

Some of the answers are partially true, others are not.

The DEC (now owned by COMPAQ) alpha RISC chip can run N/T, UNIX, and LINUX, as can the new Intel Itanium-64 chip run all 3.
N/T 4, Win 2000, LINUX, and UNIX are 'open' systems, meaning they share a number of common commands across the operating systems. Most enterprise applications available can be had to run on 2000, LINUX, or UNIX. The standard open command set makes it possible. They are all 'C' based code.
The 'more' command is a simple example...used to browse text type files in read only mode, is available on all 3 systems. Try it in Win 2000 command mode, and you will find no difference between a LINUX or UNIX version.

Which is better? UNIX/LINUX was developed by scientists to perform number crunching. Windows was designed to process precise graphics.

Windows makes a better front-end for graphical applications, and UNIX/LINUX is best for number crunching. Which is best is based on what your use for the computer is.

by smithjj

This is probably more than what you want, but I have this DOS to Unix command list I made, so here it is. I think DOS (which underlies NT) is more like Unix than not.

UNIX DOS VMS AEGIS
========= ================== =======
adb debug debug tb
/c c:\ diskc: /c
cat a >> b copy a + b append catf
a >> b
cat | more more type/page pg
cat, tail type type catf
cc cc cc
cd cd set default wd
cdb debug debug tb
cp copy copy cpf
cp -r copy/ copy/??? cpt
csh command dcl csh
CTRL-D CTRL-C,BREAKCTRL-Y CTRL-Q
date time, date sho time date
dd xcopy backup/image
df chkdsk backup/initial lvolfs
diff comp differences cmf,
cmt
/dir/subdir \dir\subdir directory.sub]
/dir/subdired, vi, ved edlin lsedit, eve,
ed dm, fse, ed
exit exit exit exit
fork submit cp
fork command spawn cp
fsck chkdsk backup/initial salvol
fsdb debug debug tb
ftp ftp ftp
grep find search fpat

by smithjj

Here's the rest, which was cut by the 1930 limit:

UNIX            DOS         VMS             AEGIS 
=====           ====        ===             ===== 
kill            CTRL-BREAK  stop            sigp         -q
ksh             command     dcl             ksh
ld                          logicals        crl
ld              assign      assign          crl
ld              assign      define          crl
login                       login   login
lpstat          print       show que        prf -r
ls              dir         directory       ld
ls -d           tree,dir *. dir *.dir       ld -d
mail                        mail            
man                         help help
mkdir           mkdir       create/dir      crd
mv              ren         rename          chn
passwd                      set pass        chpass
pdb             debug       debug           tb
pr, lp          print       print           prf
printenv                    sho sym         lvar
PS1=, PS2=      prompt      set prompt      sh -p
purge                       purge           
rbak            restore     backup/restore  rbak
rm              del, erase  delete          dlfsdb             debug       debug           tb
sh              command     dcl             sh
sort            sort        sort            sort
stty            mode        set term        tctl
telnet                      telnet          telnet
unlink                      deassign        dll
=""        set         symbols       =""
ved, ed, vi     edlin       eve, ed, lse    dm,
                                            fse
vi, ed, ved     edlin       edit, eve, lse  fse,                                         dm
wbak            backup      backup          wbak
xdb             debug       debug           tb

This discussion is closed to new replies.