Discussion Locked

slow down trying to save a buck at WalMart!

0 helpful
292 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The expected mass hysteria of WalMart having a sale, a young guy was killed; that's right, trampled to DEATH by losers trying to save a dollar on low quality chinese import sh1t at Wally World.

Okay, they tore the doors off the store, trampled an overnight stock clerk to death, trmapled another who managed to free himself and even knocked a pregnant women to teh ground causing her to miscarry her unborn child.

SICK f'in freakshow!! What's with people today? and worst of all NOBODY stopped to help!

WHat a great day Thanksgiving will be for the dead young man and pregnant women will be from now on. It is absolutely disgustign taht ANYOEN could act that way in public, showing absolutely NO consideration, manners, or a care in the world for human lives all for a SALE!

It's not like they were giving away freedom, its not like they wer handing out free cars or homes, this is plastic, knock-off sh1t at WalMart for Christ's sake!

I don't know how anyone can stand sharig a country with such losers, that must be the absolute epitomy of the bottom of society, people bumming change on the street have far mroe class and human decency than that.

Just absolutely amazed at how ignorant and useless society can be and, in this case, from what is supposed to be the mightiest nation on Earth?

O.M.G!

http://www.troyrecord.com/articles/2008/11/28/news/doc493037c59f5bd868505197.txt

The part that really blows my mind is this comment:
[i]"The industry?s largest retail group said [b]the incident was rare.[/b]

"We are not aware of any other circumstances [b]where a retail employee has died working on the day after Thanksgiving,"[/b] said Ellen Davis, a spokeswoman at National Retail Federation.[/i]

Okay it's rare, but the best she can do is say its teh first time someone has died this way THE DAY AFTER THANKSGIVING?? How about EVER?

Does she mean to say that its quite expected on Boxinig Day, on Halloween they usually lose 10 but the day after Thanksgiving, now THAT is rare!

What a horrible death, trampled.

I would like ot see them start NAILING people for it, use teh instore camera, FIRST guy to knock him down is charged with life with no parole; sure he was pushed, somebody has to pay. Perhaps they would finally start to get some class and act like human beings, superior to the rest of the animals on Earth.

Sorry, but this makes me sick to death of people in general to think that ANYONE would be so low on the food chain as to participate in something like that is simply an embarassment to mankind as a whole .

In Canada, not to suggest we are better but it is a better solution, Boxing day is now Boxing week (as I know it is in much of the USA too), this stops the mad rush and one day easy theft spree for all shoplifters.

When they do have door crasher sales, they are nowhere NEAR as unruly as that though, people do push and squirm to the front right before the doors open but most just push them back and give them that 'go get some class' look.
It is nowhere near this kind of a circus.

People neeed to learn better manners, have some class and respect for others etc. But if they are simply taught its all for one and one for all then it will never work as society gets denser and denser. Crime, drugs etc. its all a result of people feeling a fight or flight urgency in life.

To make a real stretch, and I know most of you will hate me for it but most of you hate me ayway for not thinking like you; this is probably, if not directly, related to that whole US mindset that makes people not want to help others (welfare etc.) as you are taught to not let someone else have what you earned, to not let others get more than you and to always come out on top; survival of the fittest.

Its great motivational BS but it also instills a mindset of not giving a damn about anyone but yourself.

i still can't get my head around how the US is deemed teh mightiest nation on Earth. Weak economy, reliant on the rest of the world for even the most rudimentary daily functions (yet claiming to be independent), always at war with someone over something, low educational levels, reliant on teh reat of the world to invent everything, etc., etc., etc. the list goes on and on. Its like watching zulu's in Africa....with money and weapons otehr than spears.

the part that really gets me, sorry rant almost through now, is that I doubt ANYONE will learn or change ANYTHYING over this, "Very rare incident.....for the day after Thanksgiving" anyway.

Will WalMart change the way they open stores for such sales? How about like a concert, allow the first 100 people to line up inside a barricade, with third party, professional security containing it. give them wrist bands and only THEY get in for teh first 20 minutes, then more allowed in and so on.

You don't have that wrist band, you can't enter the store, go through the checkout etc.

If you are someone who pushed in front of that first 100 people, you are SOL.

It also opens up opportunity for teh first 100, as we've seen here for Boxing Day sales. The first few get in and buy the door crashers (hey, they WERE there first) they then go to the line poutside and resell what they don't want. People in line get a decent deal, no more lineup and the ones at the front end up keeping the one or two items they really wanted, for free.

man, this is just sick though, how animals behave when uncaged.

292 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is why I hide in the basement on Black Friday.

To quote someone I know: "People are my least favorite species." At least once a year.

edit: The death of Christmas spirit in the public marketplace is mourned by me.

by oz_media

I expected a bit of the 'Oz is US bashing again' type of anti-Oz reply as usual.

This type of mass hysteria happens anywhere, however we usually see it from less developed countires when they hand out bread and water to the weak and needy.

I showed the article to a few other folks that came in the office today and I have to say the sentiment was the same. "What's with 'those' people?"

Its always one step forward and two steps back with such a dense society I suppose.

Best to just stay home, cuddle under the blankets and watch some cheezy daytime crap you don't have to sit through on a normal day of work, kinda like that 34 year old kid and pregnant woman should have done.

Fk WalMart and door crasher sales, it isn't worth it on the best of days.

Cheers,
OM

by tig2

Okay- you used a few generalities. I'm over that. I think
that you were more commenting about the inhumanity of the
situation. I can't say that you were wrong on that score. The
whole thing is tragic.

by keighlar

Oz, while I agree whole-heartedly with your lamentation over the despicable behavior of those people, and while I share in your frustration at the inability of people to comprehend basic human responsibility, I have to take huge issue with you in regard to your assessment of both America and Americans. Truth be told, I am not so happy with my country. I am frustrated with it and its people. I cannot understand the inability other?s have to see truths which appear to be so clear.

I have ?lurked? here long enough to know that you and I are going to fall on the opposite side of every political and social coin. What I take most ire at is your assertion that America and Americans are selfish ? that opposing welfare is selfishness. It proves that (1) you do not understand selfishness, and (2) that you know nothing about the welfare system in this country.

(1) How is it selfish to want to make your own decision on how your money is spent and to whom it is given? Welfare is the government telling me that I am not smart enough, capable enough or compassionate enough to decide how the money I work for is spent. The all-powerful, all-knowing government knows who needs my assistance and is more capable of distributing those ?funds? than I. That belittles and insults me.

Is there no possibility in your thinking that compassion exists by the 1000-folds here in America, but that it is stomped out by the greedy, grasping redistributing hands of the government? By the time they are done, we barely have enough to sustain our own families, let alone sustain others.

And yet, given this environment of ridiculous taxation, America still gives generously of itself.

See one source: http://oldfraser.lexi.net/publications/forum/1999/06/04_charitable_donations.html

Excerpt: (I understand these figures are from 1996, but the pattern remains.)

Charitable contributions: A US-Canada comparison

Canada, in general, maintains higher marginal tax rates than the United States. For instance, in 1996, the top federal marginal tax rate in Canada was 29 percent (plus a 3 and 5 percent surtax)3 and was effective at $59,181.4 The top combined marginal tax rate - provincial income taxes are levied on top of the federal rate - in 1996, for individuals earning $75,000 or more in British Columbia, for example, was 51 percent.5
The United States, on the other hand, maintained a top marginal tax rate of 40 percent in 1996, but at a threshold income of US$271,000. If we assume that the traditional theory of charitable giving holds, we would expect to observe higher levels of charitable giving in Canada than in the US.

Americans contribute in excess of $125 billion annually to charity,6 or roughly US$1,017 on average.7 Canadians, meanwhile, donate roughly $4 billion, or Cdn $738 on average, significantly less than their southern neighbours. This basic comparison casts doubt on the applicability of the traditional theory of charitable giving.

(2) Do you have any idea how inept and riddled with fraud the American welfare system is? Do I believe in welfare? No. Do I believe that there are much more viable alternatives that must be considered? Yes. The second the government (ours and any other country?s) gets involved, money is spent unwisely, committees are formed needlessly, and the entire project is in general botched up!

There are so many other ?points? that you make here that I could take to task one-by-one, but I don?t have the time or desire to engage you in an endless, pointless debate. Besides, Maxwell keeps you on your toes enough for me. It is amazing to me that you are obviously an intelligent and thoughtful person, and yet you so often come to incorrect conclusions. Americans as a whole are generous, compassionate people who do not wish to be subjugated, but to live fully in the hard-fought freedom given our generation.

by tig2

The SO and I went shopping on the day after Thanksgiving
ONE TIME. We were so completely disgusted by the
experience we have vowed to never do it again. I made
our Christmas gifts this year and I feel no need
whatsoever to make any further purchases.

Fortunately, according to the article, the pregnant lady
and her baby are okay. My heart goes out to that man's
family. The horror of such a thing happening is just
beyond belief.

by the scummy one

but I wanted to see. I went past a Wal-Mart on the way to Sears, and the lot was full, traffic was backed up into the street.
Across the street was a Target store, about half the parking lot was full.
Sears was pretty busy as well, but bearable.

As for Wal-Mart, 2 years ago there were a few incidents as well. Last year, those stores had local Police keeping people in line. I wonder what happened today.

by oz_media

form time to time one gets through teh cracks, but hey I haven't been on Bushs butt much lately; then again, I think that playing his Nintendo GameBoy while Obama goes through the files and tries to see how he can sort out the country's problems is okay for him nowdays anyway.

BUUUUUUSH BAAAAAAASH!!!

I'm gonna miss him though, somehow I think that Obama wont be nearly as easy a mark as having a really incompetent idiot at the helm. Like him or not, Obama at least appears to be clever, even if its just a game; he's a lot better at it than Bush was.

by jaqui

welcome to my world view.

people need to be killed off just to improve the gene pool.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

fix it 'til it is."
A bumper sticker I'm particularly fond of. Government attitude in a nutshell.

by road-dog

I just had to read a ways down to get to it.

All that aside, we Americans do need to knock this stuff off. This season has become a monstrosity. I for one am happy I decided years ago to get the hell off the treadmill.

This season is where this "me first" attitude that is all too common in this country comes to a head. And for all the wrong reasons.

I'm sure that TR folks were not in that cattle call. Maybe we need to pass along to loved ones that we'd rather enjoy their stress free company this holiday than see them brave a mosh pit of consumerism... to give us something we could buy on sale after the holiday for a better price than what is available on black Friday.

by maxwell edison

ROSKILDE, Denmark (CNN) -- Grieving fans left candles and flowers at a Danish outdoor music stage Saturday, hours after at least eight people were trampled to death in a surge of concert-goers in a muddy field. Despite the deaths Friday night, organizers elected to go ahead with the massive four-day concert at Roskilde, Denmark, about 40 kilometers (25 miles) west of the capital of Copenhagen.

At least 12 people, including youths and police officers, were trampled to death after police raided a Mexico City nightclub on Friday, according to police. Three officers and nine youths, three of them minors, were killed, Police Chief Joel Ortega said. At least 13 people were injured.

Sometimes the surging crowds, trekking from one station of the pilgrimage to the next, cause a stampede. Panic spreads, pilgrims jostle to avoid being trampled, and hundreds of deaths can result. The Stoning of the Devil ceremony is particularly crowded and dangerous.
? On July 2, 1990, a stampede inside a pedestrian tunnel (Al-Ma'aisim tunnel) leading out from Mecca towards Mina and the Plains of Arafat led to the deaths of 1,426 pilgrims.
? On May 23, 1994, a stampede killed at least 270 pilgrims at the stoning of the Devil ritual.
? On April 9, 1998, at least 118 pilgrims were trampled to death and 180 injured in an incident on Jamarat Bridge.
? On March 5, 2001, 35 pilgrims were trampled to death in a stampede during the stoning of the Devil ritual.
? On February 11, 2003, the stoning of the Devil ritual claimed 14 pilgrims' lives.
? On February 1, 2004, 251 pilgrims were killed and another 244 injured in a stampede during the stoning ritual in Mina.
? On January 12, 2006, a stampede during the ritual ramy al-jamarāt on the last day of the Hajj in Mina killed at least 346 pilgrims and injured at least 289 more.
TUNIS, May 1 (Reuters) - Six people died and a dozen were injured in a stampede during an open air concert in Tunisia, state news agency Tunis Afrique Presse and witnesses reported on Tuesday.

The December 3, 1979 Who concert tragedy in Cincinnati, Ohio, ranks as the most horrific rock concert incident in the United States. Eleven rock fans were crushed to death and scores injured because of gross crowd management failings.

Screaming fans charged the gate of a soccer stadium where the adolescent pop group Menudo was to perform on Sunday, and trampled two women to death, the police said. The women, one 48 years old and another in her 20's, were killed in the stampede toward the Vasco da Gama Stadium gate, which was opened three hours before the teen-age Puerto Rican group's performance, according to Jorge Silveira, a police detective.

Jakarta - At least 10 people were trampled to death in a stampede during a music concert accident in Indonesia's West Java capital of Bandung, local media reports said Sunday. The melee occurred as the crowd jostled its way out the exit doors after an underground concert, state-run Antara news agency reported.

Beijing, Nov. 12 - Chinese cities have ordered checks on supermarkets in the wake of a chaotic cooking oil promotion in a Carrefour store in which three people were trampled to death. The dead were among hundreds of customers who crushed into one of the French retail giant stores in Chongqing, a sprawling southwestern city where giddy growth jostles with grinding hardship. Managers lost control of the hundreds scrambling for discount cooking oil, a powerful lure for Chinese consumers juggling tight budgets and ballooning food prices, including those for the oil essential for home cooking.

Sometimes, the frenzy of a new Ikea store can lead to tragedy. In September 2004, two men were trampled to death and 16 shoppers were injured in a rush by 20,000 people to claim vouchers at the first Ikea in Saudi Arabia.

Meanwhile in February 2005, a riot at the opening of a new Ikea in North London, as shoppers fought over bargains, caused the store to close just 30 minutes after opening.

A sold-out heavy-metal concert in Montreal starring Guns 'n' Roses and Metallica turned into a riot on Saturday after W. Axl Rose, the lead singer of Guns 'n' Roses, called his band off the stage 55 minutes into the show, complaining of voice problems?.. The Montreal police said rioters among the 53,000 audience members smashed stadium windows with an uprooted street lamp, looted a souvenir boutique, burned a sports car and Guns 'n' Roses T-shirts and set dozens of small fires. About 300 club-wielding police officers chased rioters through the streets and fired tear gas to regain control. The police sealed off the area and shut down four nearby subway stations to prevent the riot from spreading to the transit system.

Riots mar Canada Day in Edmonton: The riot began after the bars and clubs closed around midnight, when between 800 and 1500 people spilled out onto Whyte Avenue on the south side of the city. Police say they initially responded to reports of fights. By two a.m., the crowd could not be controlled, and wouldn't disperse. Then people started throwing concrete chunks, rocks and bottles. They also smashed store windows, phone booths, and park benches along a five block stretch of Whyte Avenue.

http://www.mytholog.com/trampling.html

by jaqui

ya gotta remember one thing though about that Canada Day riot.. Edmonton, it's in Alberta, the flatlanders, and I suspect they are all "Flat Earthers" as well.
logical thought doesn't seem to exist in Alberta. ;)

you know, kind of like Canada's version of the hill-billies. :D

by puppybreath

If you had researched further, you would have discovered that all of these incidents were either caused by Americans directly or because of their evil influence on other countries. All of the countries mentioned in the article are loving, peaceful countries when left to themselves. It's only when America starts bullying people and pushing the world around that these things happen.

I'm sure there's also a direct link between these incidents and Bush but I haven't be able to pin it down yet. I'll keep looking but maybe Oz will be able to find it for us.

;-)

by oz_media

There are a couple of similar incidents there, fair enough. The majority are from concerts where large, boistrous crowds fighting it out, is an expected and common thing to occur. When you get general admission to an outdoor festival, especially with underground or industrial metal bands playing, it is par for the course that people get trampled, usually not to death though but many serious injuries.
Stoning rituals? that doesn't fall into the same category as a mother and child seeking bargains at a local discount store.

If your intent is to prove that people have been trampled before, I have to agree.

People being trampled for a sale is a bit extreme though.

I don't even spend much time at the front anymore, mosh pits are out of hand these days, just drunk guys that have no interest in the show and use it for a reason to just start punching and knocking out people randomly. They usually get tossed, but not until after the damage is done.

I'd like to think that shopping in a family department store would not bring about the same brital mentality for most sane people, unless we should expect people to get drunk and slam around, punching each other to get the best deals, not quite the same expectations for the consumer as going to a hard rock show.

One you listed was pretty much started because the Hellls Angels were originally hired as security and then told they weren't allowed to right before the show, good way to upset a few of the wrong people. The same happened when the Stones hired them too.

But that isn't WalMart, or at least one would hope not.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

a couple thousand years, my bets are that Earth has not cornered the idiot market. Betting on lots of extra-terrestrial idiots, myself.

by maxwell edison

4,120 Wal-Mart stores in the United States opened their doors to shoppers on this Friday after Thanksgiving without incident. So far there have been no comments from local authorities or media outlets as to the reason behind this behavior.

by oz_media

That makes it all okay then, no big deal, sorry about that.

That'll make the young guy's mom sleep better at night, perhaps you could mail her your list of liks too so she understands just how normal such an event is all over the world; especially with it happening at concerts and stonings, she should have been prepared for it to happen at WalMart.

by thechas

No incident? Or, no reported incident?

I am sure that at many stores in many towns people going through the doors were pushed, shoved, bruised and battered. Generally, if the injured do not require medical attention, the incident goes unreported.

Over the past few years, the crush of the crowds at the Black Friday sales has been seeing more and more people injured. There has typically been someone injured as they fell in front of the mob. Or, in the fights over who picked up the last of the special sale item.

The American public needs to grow up past the "as long as I get mine, who cares about the rest" mentality.

This mob mentality that has developed over the past decade or so needs to end.

I know it's not everyone, or even a majority of the people who follow the mob mentality. However, everyone is responsible if they don't speak up to their friends and relatives who do participate in the mob mentality.

Chas

by maxwell edison

In your message bashing the general goodwill of Americans, you relied on a per capita assessment. (Although it was no more than a guess).

I was merely looking at this in what might be seen as a per capita assessment. Why don?t you look at it in the same way?

Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting that Americans aren't self-centered and greedy. (Just like most people of the world are self-centered and greedy ? especially Canadians). I just question which ones are self-centered and greedy. After all, how many of them actually feel entitled to be given the fruits of another's labor? How many of them want to shirk what should be their personal responsibility onto others? Is it more self-centered and greedy to want to keep what you earn or to covet what another person earns? What?s more self-centered and greedy? Giving the shirt of your own back, or casting a vote that gives the shirt off another?s?

In this case, one, or two, or three incidents compared to the thousands of non-incidents. It?s the rotten apples that spoils the bunch.

I don?t care what you say. I don?t care what Oz says. Most Americans are decent people. (Although many of those otherwise decent people have been brainwashed to support the political notion that they are not responsible for their own lives, and/or are entitled to have something they did not earn.)

by maxwell edison

Oz, a Canadian, always pointing out what?s wrong with America. Chas, an American, always pointing out what?s wrong with America.

Listening to the two of you, one might think there?s nothing right with America.

Too many people focus on what's wrong instead of focusing on - and encouraging - what's right.

It's said that [i]bad news sells[/i], and you two have bought into it lock, stock, and barrel.

(P.S. Now is the time both of you will criticize me instead of addressing my message. Same ol? same ol?)

by maxwell edison

Unions

And as an extension, everything unions have done. Unions have ruined your state. Unions have bankrupt a once great American industry.

Well done, Michigan. And you espouse more of the same? That's insanity.

by maxwell edison

Unions have lost influence and/or membership in all but one industry. Which industry would that be? Which [i]industry[/i] will be the next one destroyed by unions - leaving the taxpayers holding the empty bag?

by the scummy one

Yes, I went out early this year and few lines until after 10:.
Then I went to Costco -- because I figured everyone was at different stores shopping.
Good call in my opinion, I had fewer lines at Costco than normal :D

then I went home and looked online a little for a few items. Lo and Behold -- All of the items I looked at were cheaper from the manufacturer than from the stores sales :0

I looked at my receipts from these super sales and am thinking about taking them back now...

There are some good deals in the stores, but is it worth the hassle? Looking at a store here, I am finding items that I did not see in the physical store, and at a good price.

I think I am shopping online for the rest of the day

by boxfiddler Hot topic

since I went back to school and work. Get it done in about an hour and a half, no headbutts from lunatics trying to beat me to the last whatever the hell it is.

Sweet.

by tonythetiger

One or more of those people committed a crime and it is being investigated.

By the way, Oz, the woman didn't miscarry.

by oz_media

a later article said [i]she[/i] was ok but didn't mention the baby.

But there are plenty that do.
http://lawfuel.com/show-release.asp?ID=20080

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aMI0subA8R70&refer=home

Another witness told the paper she saw the pregnant woman knocked over nearby the dying man. When paramedics came, she told them she was pregnant but the ambulance crew said she had lost the baby after an examination.
http://www.newsroomamerica.com/usa/story.php?id=439053

by tonythetiger

It's the nature of some humans to amplify a tragedy. No doubt some of those who trampled the poor guy will claim they were injured trying to help him... both to get them out of trouble... and to try to snag a share of the victimhood status they covet.

Hopefully they can get license plate numbers from video of the parking lot and match the owners to the video from inside the store, and proper justice will be done.

by santeewelding

If in the next few days there are scattered reports of goings into rooms, closing the door, and doing the right thing.

Somehow, I doubt it.

by oz_media

The parents can sue teh store for unsuitable security provisions, WalMart's insurance should pay out a tidy sum.

They think have already identified several people (6, I think it said) and are looking at ways to press charges so that the victims can open civil cases for double liability.

by av .

Personally, I don't go anywhere near the stores on Black Friday. Its just absolutely frenzied and sick. I don't see how that gets you into the holiday spirit. Shopping on Black Friday is like vying for red meat in the lion's cage.

I usually do my shopping online or go off-hours to the local outlets and quaint mom and pop type stores that offer a more pleasant holiday shopping experience than a mall or a Walmart.

Whats very sad about the Walmart incident is that Walmart, at least the ones near my home, usually hire people with disabilities to greet shoppers when they enter the store. I don't know if that is true in this case, but its certainly possible.

This time of year people forget the spirit of the season. They are rude, have no manners and will fight you for a parking space or that special item they want if you should happen to pick up the last one. Its just a sad commentary.

Heres what happened to me a couple of years ago at a Michael's craft store in NJ. It wasn't on Black Friday, but maybe a week later. I found a silk Poinsettia plant that I liked. There were plenty left, maybe 20 or 25. As I put one in my cart, a man came up to me and grabbed it out of my cart. He said, "I'm already buying that. I'm buying them all." (what he left out is the BWAHAHAHA). Then he walked away and started putting them all in his cart.

I was speechless that anyone would do that. He was just obsessed or probably buying them to sell on ebay. I just let people like that go. They are sad people and honestly, as a woman, that mentality scares me. Don't even want to go there.

Thankfully, most people behave themselves, but if you have large crowds of people waiting for hours to get into a Walmart, mob mentality starts to take over. It can really happen anywhere.

Alright, you had your rant about us Americans. For some of us, it is rightfully earned. Not all of us are civilized or have manners, unfortunately. I think that happens everywhere though, not just here.

Walmart and other stores that offer doorbuster sales, need to have better security if they have something like that. You can't leave it up to the crowd.

AV

by santeewelding

Snapping an arm at the elbow is easy. Then you walk away with another plant amid the screaming and clamor.

by tig2

That man would have found himself with a cart in the
crotch had it been me. I don't tolerate obscene behavior
well. Something very fundamental in me knows that my
inner b*tch would have had something to say.

And I wouldn't have bothered with the plant either.

The guy would have definitively learned that he was out of
line. Period. We, ourselves, are the best tools for
teaching our "fellow Americans" when they cross the line.

I will concede that your approach is taking a higher road.

by av .

There are some real sickos in our society. Years ago I probably would have confronted that guy, but today, I think twice. You never know when an idiot like that has a gun.

Someone like that is just hell-bent, so now I just get out of the way and let them continue on to that destination.

AV

by oz_media

But is this really what we have come to?

"You can't leave it up to the crowd."

Why not? I have seen people push and shove and, without prejudice, it is common on public transit and in stores for Oriental people to push and shove their way through (getting a lot of wierd looks). However it is simply a result of their overpopulated cities and is usually not too bad and I can understand how they become that way in public crowds.

I have been at Vancouver's largest, most sought out boxing day sales; the crowd is just a long but tidy line of people tucked against the wall outside. The doors open and they let 'X; number of people in at a time and manage it that way, people wait patiently in line for their turn.

That's even at the BIGGEST electronic blowout center in the heart of downtown Vancouver that is famous for its boxing day sales.

I'm not saying we don't get out of hand, but
the Stanley Cup riots and GNR concert riot in Vancouver are not exactly the same thing as holiday shopping at a family oriented discount store, thats just a display of unfathomable ignorance in society.

by oz_media

I know and fully agree that wlefare is an abused and misused system, but they all are.

There's one thing about scammers, they will beat ANY system, ANYWHERE. Always have and always will, that's just what they do.

By taking support form them, you are in turn takign support from others who deserve, have earned and need the help of their fellowman.

DEsERVE, EARN? Yes some people need support, they woked hard and have fallen on hard times, they have both earned and deserve a hand from 'the people' seeing as i have been told many times that THE PEOPLE IS the US government, then the government should have teh ability to act on your behalf in such cases.

If th government didn't dole it out on welfare, you wouldn' tsee a penny more in your pocket anyway, they just alocate it to something else THEY deem worthy.

When you live in a ocuntry, especially one with such great opportunities for citizens, you pay taxes, unaviodable. Where those taxes go, also unavoidable.

So we WILL pay taxes and no matter how much or how little they give to welfare support, which for the MAJORITY of recipients is needed, you will see no additional benefit to yourself. If you think fo rone second that doing away with wlefare puts more money in yoru pocket, less taxes, you are sadly mistaken, governments DON'T give back yoru money, they just spend it somewhere else that most will contest and complain about.

The stats as ot donations are entirely irrelevant, at no tie did I say that Canadians were more generous.
Where you will find we are more generous though would be seeing and understanding the need for medical for every Canadian and welfare for those in need.

We don't make as many personal donations for the benefit of tax write offs? So what?

As for incorrect conclusions, that is relative to who you are speakign to, I could do the same with yoru post too, yet as you noted it's just not worth it nor am I interested in going down that path for a week or two.

"Americans as a whole are generous, compassionate people who do not wish to be subjugated, but to live fully in the hard-fought freedom given our generation."

perhaps you should keep an eye on your freedoms which are removed as soon as teh government decides it needs to remove them. They are merely assumed privileges, not freedoms. ANY American citizen had the same freedoms in 1942 that you have today, yet as it was deemed fit for eth government, they rounded up Chinese AMERICANS many born and raised there, and stuck them in camps. They took their houses, they split up their families and treated them as the enemy.

We did it too in Canada, and I don' tcontest that nbut I at least recognize it. Where were the FREEDOMS then?

Is there a time, in yoru mind, where your freedoms can be simply stripped from you because the government thinks it should remove them?

there are countless such cases in all FREE countries, yeah America's not the only one, sorry bout that.

"Americans as a whole are generous, compassionate people who do not wish to be subjugated, but to live fully in the hard-fought freedom given our generation."

Hard fought freedom taht can be taken away form a hard working American in a whim.

Compassionate people, who don't believe in welfare to support people (no, you don't know everyone and many would go unhelped if it was a personal system) and trample fellow Americans on their way to a store. Compassionate people who think that their allies are either on their side or against them. Compassionate people who rely on teh world for each and every breath they take, and yet spit on other nations that provide them with their lovely lives.

sure, you got me fooled alright. Anyway, time to blow this popsickle stand, talk to you some other time and I do appreciate your approach and honesty with your reply.

by dr dij

it is supposed to be the best off province due to budget surpluses from mining. Shale oil I guess, and they export 1/3 of the worlds chickpeas and alot of lentils.

In my job hunt desparation I was even thinking of moving there to avoid the steaming t*rdpile of crooked brokers that is the US economy. I don't think I qualify as a flatlander tho.

by dr dij

longer than they said I would be needed when they hired me so no regrets.

Just wish I had been CONSTANTLY TRAINING during that time. I was only constantly training instead.

by oz_media

I do a lot of work in Alberta, have done so in all corners of Alberta for years now.

They are some of the nicest and most accomodating people on the west side of the country (nothing like the maritimers, though, that are the best anywhere).

Albertan's are also facing a pretty stuck up younger generation now though, the labourers are the typical yokels jaqi refers to, yup, flatlander but not like Saskatchewan...ers, ese? The TRUE flat landers.

Albertans are like Texans, not always the brightest of the bunch but everything is BIG and RICH, y'all, yeeehaw!! The towns closer to the Rockies are nice, but Edmonton and Calgary are pretty crappy and not much different than other cities, except drenched in crappy music.

Excellent income, you can earn more than $16/hr at A&W drive through, but also a high cost of living, though no provincial tax on purchases (nice). We finally copied their private liquor store idea, thanks for the cheaper booze Alberta!

It is my second favorite spot in Canada, due to the wildlife and mountains, but for 'people' the Maritimes (Nova Scotia/Sydney, PEI, Mew Brunswick, Newfoundland) beat other provinces hands down.

You have NEVER met people like them, but you'd learn real fast when your first interaction with a maritimer(and as a complete stranger)results in an invitation to dinner and to stay at his home so you can save on the hotel.

by dr dij

went there as kids. We'd vacation in Maine up from NY or Pennsylvania in summers and sometimes we'd make it further north.

Even once my dad snuck a lobster up to the summer cottage from the bay, directly into a pot of boiling water. Shudder to think what could have happened if we were discovered poaching.

Learned to swim there, in icy 56o waters. Gives you character, as my parents would say. And then, straight out of a Simpsons episode, we kids were arguing in the back seat, so parents made us get out and run behind the station wagon! (they'd told us frequently before that it would happend but it never had before :)

I'm sure that built character!

Then there was my buddy Jeff who we explored the slippery seaweed covered rocks with, and had an older sister who wanted to play this game.. Well, better not get into that..

by jaqui

Surplus was from the now retired Kline.(sp?)

The socialist Premier of the Province for years actually did a good job, no small thanks to the oil sands.

There are some bleeding edge R&D companies there, in environmentally friendly power generation.

Unfortunately, when things drop in our economy, Alberta will be hit really hard. Since the market drop they have had an increase in unemployment rate already.

by dr dij

home of the 1,500 acre Living Desert zoo and gardens
http://www.livingdesert.org

some d*rka** shot someone else in a Toys'R'Us store friday sale.

Since someone carried their gun into the store, I'm guessing this was not about toys but about gang members or something like that. Not much detail on the news yet.

by oz_media

didn't notice your post when I posted below.

I think police said that it ws a rivalry between two men, but not specifically gang or drug related.

pretty sure the link in my post (below) noted something like that.

by dr dij

was that they both KILLED EACH OTHER!!

Two less stupid people in the world, thinning the herd, etc.

Now if all the bad drivers in the world would just run into each other and not me, and take each other out two at a time...

With my luck there would be an odd number of bad drivers so there'd still be one left.

by oz_media

Max, you can add this one to your list of soothing links to send to the WalMart employees mom.

http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-toystoreshooting29-2008nov29,0,5989270.story

[i]Before police shut down the store, eager shoppers streamed past emergency crews as they worked furiously to save the store clerk's life.

"They were working on him, but you could see he was dead, said Halcyon Alexander, 29. "People were still coming through."

Only a few stopped.

"They're savages," said shopper Kimberly Cribbs, 27. "It's sad. It's terrible."[/i]

by thechas

Many years ago, my wife and I used to get up and shop the early morning Friday sales. We stopped going when the crowds started getting too large.

Also, when you consider that people are now lining up as early as Wednesday evening to get into places like Best Buy, it makes you wonder how little people value their free time.

Back when my wife and I were shopping the morning sales, there were a few decent bargains at each store. The whole idea was to get people into the stores earlier in the day in order to spread out the day after Thanksgiving shopping crowd.

Now that they have established the early morning of the Friday after Thanksgiving as a major bargain hunt, the retailers should take it upon themselves to reduce the size of the markdowns and increase the quantity of each item that is available. That way, there would not be the mad rush to beat everyone else into the store so that you could get yours.

Until the major retailers wise up and reduce the incentives for the mad rush, shop your local stores and give out more unique and thoughtful gifts.

Chas

by the scummy one

that are the problem. If people looked around a bit, they would know that there are good deals all over the place.
Many of the deals to be found in the store are also offered online. As well, many stores have better deals online than in the store.

Furthermore, there are many competing products out there. For instance, the $799 Sears 'big deal' plasma tv, similar deals could be found at Costco, Fry's, Best Buy, Amazon.com, etc., etc., etc...

As for the mob rush, that is plain asinine. In the Wal-Mart instance, they broke the door down to stampede. Then when the announcement was made that the store was closing, these dipsh!ts still tried shopping, filling their carts.

Those at Toys 'R Us was just a sad incident. 2 women get in a fight and their men start shooting at each other. WTF? In a Toy store filled with kids no less, running down the aisles firing guns.
These kinds of things show how society in general is deteriorating.
Hopefully, this kind of cr@p will reduce in the future

by oz_media

I bet you a million dollars that BOTH of those men would sit on TR all day and complain about how THEY are responsible gun owners and that lock up and properly use theor weapons at a range only, unless for emergency protection and that they should have a right to automatic weapons.

There are many reasons I have the opinions I do, this would be example #210B that I don't oppose greater gun purchase control and limitations.

by av .

And Toys-R-Us. If they have a doorbuster sale, they need to control the crowd, especially on Black Friday.

Shoppers need to get a grip. Why is lining up at any store a day or so early even allowed in the first place?

I think big-box retailers like Walmart should continue to have their doorbuster sales, but only if they provide security and crowd control.

I never go shopping on Black Friday either. Too crowded. I like to go to the local stores and outlets. Its a nicer, more leisurely atmosphere. Or, I shop online.

AV

by santeewelding

It's hard being petite in the press of humanity. Maybe niceties are not the way to go, unless you manage having nothing to do with us at all.

by the scummy one

Wal-Mart had provided 'crowd control' at many stores. From what I saw online and driving by one, there was a heavy Police presence outside, and for opening, inside. If I remember correctly, it was due to fights and trampling from 2 years ago due to a cheap notebook

by thechas

Of course from the raw numbers, it looks like the US gives a lot of money to charity when you look at raw dollars given. The US has the highest total personal income of any country.

However, if you look at percentage of wealth versus charitable contributions, or percentage of GNP versus contributions, the US becomes a low end giver.

Even when the people in the US give generously, their gifts have strings attached.

All you need to do is look at how we respond to events like hurricanes to see how stingy we are. While the Red Cross and Salvation Army ask for money to fund the relief efforts, the US people go to their closets and clear out the clothes they don't want anymore. Or, they go down to the local store and buy the supplies they think the charities should hand out to those in need.

Another factor to take into account is that most of the large charitable donations in the US total are from corporate and individual foundations. Foundations set up to distribute money to avoid or reduce taxation.

As to replacing public assistance with local or individual charity, there are many problems with that concept. Not the least of which is that the person who can tell the best story of woe is more apt to get assistance than the one in the most need.

I am sorry, but from where this American sets, the US people are very stingy givers.

Chas

by tonythetiger

[i]As to replacing public assistance with local or individual charity, there are many problems with that concept. Not the least of which is that the person who can tell the best story of woe is more apt to get assistance than the one in the most need.[/i]

Locals are more likely to know if one of theirs is honestly in need or spinning a yarn. They are also more likely to know what kind of, and how much, help someone really needs. One of the dumbest things our government does is to send SSI checks to alcoholics and drug addicts. What do you think they're going to do with the money?

by oz_media

Mroe affluent neighbourhoods, will quickly pick up a fallen neighbour, knowing them and probablhy knowing before the person actually hits rock bottom.

Those is poor neighbourhoods, who supports THEM?

It perpetuates the differences in class and allows those in the most dire situations to go unnoticed an unhelped.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I suspect that the statistics are missing a goodly number of people who give generously of their time and income 'off the books'. I know quite a few of us.

etu

by maxwell edison

And where do you sit? What's your view?

Percentage of income, how much do you, personally, give?

Percentage of time (or hours), how much time do you give?

As a country, can you provide the numbers (in both dollars and percentages), and the source of your information?

As a country, how much time do people give?

What are the reported numbers? How about the unreported numbers?

Moreover, how does all this reconcile with other comments you've made about the average working guy making barely enough to get by? On one hand, you sympathize because he's struggling; on the other hand, you criticize him for not giving enough. What gives?

by thechas

Max,

We have covered this before. I have neither the time or the need to look up and post the sources for my statements. The information all come from articles I have read from a variety of sources.

Unlike you, I do not need to have supporting data from a multitude of sources in order to have an opinion or take a stance.

While I have not seen any data on how much of America's charity giving goes to the local churches, I do wonder what the numbers would look like if you factored out the contributions that solely go to operate and build the churches in this country.

For that matter, how much would charitable contributions drop in the US if they were not tax deductible?

Chas

by the scummy one

they are likely the type to show off their weapon at any chance, and keep it loaded always.
Heck, I doubt they know that the Internet is more than porn and myspace.

by oz_media

It is to ocommon for the normal married family man to do such things, just finally snapping.

"We asked the neighbours if Mr. Smith, a professional and rather mainstream American had shown signs of his instability before"

''He's always been a quiet, neighbour, seemed to be a nice family man and plays with his kids all the time. I just didn't see it coming! To have a man kill his entire family in MY neighbourhood is quite a shock!''

by the scummy one

These were young punks. Get over it already, do you really think that all we Americans ever do is go to toy stores and start shooting people?
These are not common acts at all.

by oz_media

If there were six other similar incidents, where nobody died, the press would simply report the juicy story of a detah and miscarriage.

Max's noted concert violence jst touches on a few reported key events. GNR riot in Vancouver made headlines but I have seen countless numbers of people sent to hospital and losing eyesight after taking a boot in the face while down, broken limbs, head injuries, massive cuts from random stabbings at concerts just to touch the surface, but it isn't news most of the time if there's something more edgy to report.

by tonythetiger

the more widely something is reported. People close to it though still want a piece of the victimhood. There was a tug of war over the last XBOX360 locally. One guy let go, the other fell back and hit a third person. The third person is suing the store???? how stupid!

We wouldn't have ANY of these problems if we'd start holding people personally responsible for their individual actions! All of this "What have 'we' become"?" is a load! "We" didn't do anything. I wasn't there, and neither were you. I don't behave that way, and I don't want to be lumped in with people who do.

by oz_media

everyone can stick their heads in the sand and pretend its all rainbows and lolipops, I'm sure we'd all love ot do it, but it isn't reality.

And I haven't said such incidents don't happen here, in fact with 10% of your population, I am sure that we have probably at least a little less than 10% of the similar incidents that you do. I would think that, logically, the Toys R Us incident would be rarer here too.

But you go get sick and mad, then think of all the positives and block out any evil realities, its easier that way.

by maxwell edison

Give me a break. You know I don't think that, and you know I didn't say that? Therefore, what's the point of conversation.

Okay, as you were - back to your favorite sport - bashing America.

by tonythetiger

never having lived in an "affluent neighborhood".

[i]It perpetuates the differences in class and allows those in the most dire situations to go unnoticed an unhelped. [/i]

So what? There are different classes for a REASON. If you have what it takes to survive, you will. If you have what it takes to thrive, you will. If you have someone [b]willing[/b] to let you tag along, you will. Otherwise, tough noogies! I did not cause you to exist, and your existence creates no obligation on me.

by j-mart

And others have had a bigger impact on auto industry world wide. These companies with superior engineering, build quality and value for money, would have more effect on automibile manufacturers abilty to survive in an incressingly compeditive globalised market.

This leaves your local industry with two options, become better so you can beat the competition, or have the government put up trade bariers to give them a trading advantage.

by j-mart

It will be down to better workers, beter managers better organisation, better technology, benifits gained from investment in tooling and modern factories. Taking the narrow view that its down to unions and /or greedy corporate managers isn't going to fix problems. The industry if it has that atitude had better hope they are next in line behind the bankers with their hands out to the government.

by thechas

Who brought up unions in this thread?

As far as the US auto industry is concerned, sure the wage and benefit package the unions won in contract negotiations are a contributing factor to the impending demise of the industry. However, the US auto industry lost the battle back in the early 70's. They just did not know it.

The US auto industry response to inexpensive well built cars from Japan were the Chevy Vega, the Ford Pinto, the Dodge Omni, and the AMC Gremlin. Detroit got it very wrong. They presumed that people wanted cheap cars. What people wanted was cars that were inexpensive to own and comfortable to ride in. Now, we are getting to the third generation of car buyers who have owned nothing but foreign brand cars.

Farmers in Michigan are buying Toyota pickups not because they cost less, but because they are designed to last.

I have yet to speak with any engineer or designer who works for the big 3 or their suppliers who believes the industry is even trying to get it right.

And, what does the big 3 do when they do have a profits? Do they invest in research or product development? Heck no, they buy other car companies when the price is high and then sell them off when the price is low. Witness the recent sale of Jaguar to TATA motors.

By the way, I don't think the taxpayers should bail out the big 3. They are well on their way to following Leyland into the dust. The US big 3 are going to collapse from there own weight. With or without union wages.

Chas

by thechas

I think a quote from the Tommy Lee Jones character in the first Men In Black movie sums it up.

A person is smart, people are dumb.

I don't disagree that the average person on his or her own has good judgment and can do what is right.

It is when you get a group of people together that things go bad.

Actually, it is pretty amassing that we only had one major trampling happen this year. Based on what I have seen of the crowds the last few times I ventured out on Black Friday, running with the bulls in Pompalo is a much safer and saner thing to do.

Chas

by thechas

Max,

I am sure that part of your problem with Oz and myself is that as hard as you try you have been unable to convince us that your line of thought and way of looking at the world is better than ours.

If anything, you have driven both of us further away from your conclusions and view of what the world could be.

Are there good things that happen every day in the US, of course.

Are there many instances where the very fabric of civil society is at risk and we just happen to make it through the day? That is also true.

To maintain a civil society, EVERYONE has to be willing to put aside what is in their personal best interest in order that society as a whole can function.

Where that line between personal interest and what is needed to keep our civil society functioning smoothly is the real question.

In the case of the WalMart stampede, all it would have taken were a few people to form a blockade around the downed worker to prevent the tragedy. The trampled worker does not bother me as much as the shoppers who got upset when the store was closed to take care of the now dead man.

Society is breaking down all around us. We MUST speak out strongly to reverse the trend.

Chas

by thechas

While I will not argue that the compensation demands of the UAW may be beyond what is reasonable, unions alone are not at the cause of Michigan's or the Auto Industries problems.

In the case of Michigan itself:

Crumbling infrastructure.

Health care and the general health of the population.

Climate. (If you had the option, would you choose a warm state or a cold state?)

Environmental concerns. With the Great Lakes in nearly every communities watershed, there is no low cost option for dealing with waste water or chemical waste.

I could go on. The point is, changing just one factor such as wages would not be enough to correct the overall problem.

Chas

by jamesrl

Ontario.

Ontario has both unionized (CAW equivalent of UAW) sites for GM Ford and Chrysler, and non unionized sites for Honda and Toyota. I don't honestly know if CAMI (GM/Suziki) is union or not. Volvo trucks and Sterling Trucks also manufacture here.

We have the same climate, the same environmental concerns. We have serious pollution, both from our own industry and because we are downwind of the Ohio coal fired power plants.

Our health care costs are one thing that has made us a favoured place to build a car plant.

Its no secret that the big three plants in Canada are struggling while Honda and Toyota thrive(without a unionized workforce). Unions may be a big part of it - also the type of vehicle has an impact. I leave you to draw your own conclusions.

James

by thechas

CAFE standards play a big role in what vehicles all of the automakers build in Canada or Mexico.

Many of GMs larger cars are built in Canada so that they can be counted as imports to offset their low mileage and avoid the CAFE tax.

Chas

by tonythetiger

It would require forcing to the lowest common denominator. But even then you'll have those being forced, and those doing the forcing.

by tonythetiger

The problem is with the government forcing charity, A) we have less left to give, when B) because of the government's "giving", it takes more on our part to make a real difference.

The government is making the problems worse than what they would otherwise be.

by tig2

California has extremely strict laws regarding concealed
carry and carrying publicly. When I lived there, in order to
transport my legal weapon to the range, it had to be
unloaded and locked in a box in the trunk. I had to carry
the locked box and open it in the presence of the range
master who identified the weapon, insured that it was not
loaded and assigned me a lane. I could not change my
lane without the permission of the range master and
could not enter an occupied lane. When finished, the
range master validated that the weapon was unloaded and
I locked it back in the box and locked the box in the
trunk.

It is amazingly difficult to get a permit to carry. You must
either transport large sums of money as a part of your job
or have a minimum of a PI license or be able to prove to
people who don't want people carrying concealed that
you have a REALLY good reason- constant danger to life
and limb may or may not qualify.

The people who post here on gun control wouldn't break
known existing laws. In fact, most of them are more
conversant with their local laws than most. That's WHY we
have gun safes in our homes, and biometric keepers to
lock up any weapon not stored in a safe.

Having read the LA Times story, my guess is that they
were gang bangers.

by puppybreath

that OZ would be critical of the US for a problem with no solution?

I think we can safely assume that he has already come up with the solution, which explains why he is so upset. If he can figure it out, why can't our government?

I want to get his input on the proper way to proceed so that I can forward it on to the proper authorities.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Good one. Just might print a few of those to haul with me to all sorts of places. :D