Discussion Locked

So is getting a degree in Computer Information Systems worth it?

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I keep hearing mixed messages about the IT outlook for future graduates. I am currently looking into getting my CIS degree in the next couple of years, but am getting confused with all this information on these forums. Based on my findings, these forums usually state that IT is in trouble...,but if you do job outlook search, IT is in the top 10 of best and fastest job growth through the year 2010. So who has a good understanding on where the IT market is right now.

Personally, i want to get a great job that pays decent when i first start... not a low paying entry job. Going to college for 5 years isn't my cup of tea if itsn't going to get me anywhere. (BTW, i am looking at jobs like system analyst and computer technician) I just need some advice. Thanks.

12 replies

by amcol

Unless you do it for the right reasons.

There is no one on this board, or anywhere else, who can tell you anything about the way anything is going to be five years from now, or five minutes from now for that matter. If we could do that we wouldn't be here posting, we'd all be playing the stock market or the ponies.

You "want to get a great job that pays decent". Do you want to enjoy what you're doing? Find fulfillment in your work? Contribute to society? You don't say anything about any of that, but it's all equally important and you don't need a degree for it.

What will you be doing in 2010? What company will you be working for? In what industry? Doing what job? I don't know the answers to any of those questions either. The only thing I do now is that between now and then I'll be working as hard and as well as I can at whatever I'm doing, trying to have some fun, and enjoying my life. I'll also be keeping my eyes open for opportunity, something we all should be doing all the time.

Do you want to have a career in IT? Do you love IT? Do you understand that you need great business skills in order to have a great career in IT? Then go for the degree. Life's what happens while you're making other plans (thank you, John). Just do the best you can and don't let it pass you by.

Right now you're reading about the job outlook in 2010. You'll be reading about that next year, too, but what you'll be reading will be different. Which view will be correct? Who knows. We'll just have to wait until we get there to find out. But in the meantime, follow your passion whatever it is.

BTW, you're missing the whole idea about college. Getting prepared for a career is only one reason to go. Don't focus only on that or you'll miss out on a lot.

by dr dij

learn some of the biz side, enuf that you can a) know if an mba is just spouting bs or has the right innovative idea, b) enuf to translate biz processes and requests for data into either a new database layout or changes, or to get data from an erp system correctly.

but not just biz side. that's where your value will be, knowing how to use say the peoplesoft report generator and find data among 20,000 fields.

btw, 'computer technicians' job is often relegated to people who can replace cards so does not pay as well as those working at higher level. complicated network stuff pays more than 'computer tech' as do analysis, security, programming, etc.

and learning productivity tools, & harder to use higher level languages increases pay.

you also need a 'creative streak' in being able to 'see the big picture' of your data, so that you can pull solutions out of thin air. you often feel like you run into a brick wall but usually there is a way thru and you need to find it.

you need the tenacity to KNOW you can 'figure it out' and complete or fix things. and sort of an overview, or to be able to step back and see if you're going about it right.

And know where to look if you don't know something you need. web, specialized reference sites, knowledge bases for product, etc.

by old guy

There is some pretty good insight in the thread, Gartner sees less demand for IT specialists, about listening to all the "doom sayers" and how to broaden you base in the work place. Check those out as well.

by m_a_r_k

The other posts are right on track. I'd like to reiterate several points made so far. One, you can't predict the future. Two, find your interests and skills and pursue a career where you can use your interests and skills. Three, if you chose IT, a CIS or MIS is better than hard-core tech such as Computer Science, Computer Engineering or Electrical Engineering because you will learn some soft skills and will learn about business processes.

Understanding how technology affects the business will likely become increasingly important. I have degrees in CS and MBA, so I have some insight into both technology and business operations. Even though we can't predict the future, two things are certain. Companies' primary objective (at least most companies) is to make a profit. And companies will always need technology. So it would be logical to assume that companies will always need employees who can help them use technology to make the business run efficiently and help increase profits. However, you have to keep in mind that if the supply of these employees is greater than demand, then you could say there isn't much of a future in this type of career. That is the great unknown.

by master3bs

Internet forums, in general, seem to be pretty negative. A lot of people use them to vent. There's a lot of good information here, otherwise I wouldn't stay here. But a lot of it is speculation and opinion as well. Take it with a grain of salt.

by matthew moran

The podcast I posted yesterday - recorded a day before covers this exact topic:

Beware discussion forums and beware your online persona...
http://techcareerconsult.blogspot.com

Or at IT Toolbox - the company hosting my career blog:
http://blogs.ittoolbox.com/pm/career/archives/006719.asp

As far a pursuing your certs - echoing Amcol, certs are as good as the knowledge you acquire while attaining them. Otherwise, there are better, quicker ways to build an IT career.

Matthew Moran
The IT Career Builder's Toolkit
http://www.cbtoolkit.com
Podcast: Technology, Career & Consulting
http://techcareerconsult.blogspot.com

by brentdeback

I mean according to statistics, CIS will employ a lot of people. The unknown part, is how many people are also going into this line of work. Based on your findings and your own experiences with IT, what do you think the outlook is for IT. I would just like a solid answer: Good or Not Good. Thanks.

by joshleahy

If you know what you are doing and you excel at your work you will always be able to find a job period.

by m_a_r_k

Employing "a lot of people" sounds good unless "a whole [u]lot[/u] of people" are wanting to do those jobs. For example, there aren't many jobs available for scooping waste out of sewer systems but there aren't many people applying for those jobs, either. So if you want a job as a sewer cleaner, you can get one easily. Does that mean it's a good career choice? The IT market is pretty good. How's that? It's not nearly as good as it was in the late '90s. In my opinion, it's better than most jobs. Don't go soley by what people here suggest, but if I were 20 and considering a career, I would definitely put IT high on the list (as one of several options to consider). A MIS or CIS degree is a good way to start and go for a MBA or Accounting after working 5 years. How far you go and your career prospects, in any career, have a lot to do with your own motivation and luck as well.

by tony hopkinson

It's flooded with a lot of people who chose IT as a career for financial reasons. An unfortunately high percentage of these don't enjoy it and are quite crap at it. In order to get a return on their investment, they hit the academia and cerification circuses. Because of that now you have to. Like the guys said get some soft/business skills and learn to apply the technology that suits you, (admin, hardware/db,web or programming). I'm sorry to say without a degree or an uncle who's a managing director, your chances of getting a job in the current IT world are very small. I did it but that was 18 years ago, every one I work with in IT now has a degree.

by enrique corona

Hey!
well i love my job but! the pay is getting worse every day, i live in mexico and as you must now the Salary is kind of low... in the past 10 years the payment had got worse, and thats due because theres a lot of competition, to many people for a few jobs.

its not really worth it spending 4 to 5 to end up winning a little les than 1000 dlls or if you are lucky the full 1000 per month. a good payed technician or Engineer is winning arround 1500 per month, in mexico thats a decent salary.

in these days a lot of companys are offering les then 700dll per month and they are asking for a lot of experience and an engineer title. now that sucks!!!

and makin i little thinking people in india are charging less than people in mexico, so they are worst than us. like a friend sayed to me once 'if you want money you have to sell what people always needs' like food for example...

dont get me wrong this computer staff is great i love it, but companies are paying less and less that we have no choice than to turn back and run for the hills!!!...

This discussion is closed to new replies.