Discussion Locked

Software Audits Are A Waste of Time

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We make this bold claim as many organizations worldwide are really wasting large amounts of time, money and effort on a task that really is very simple when you understand what can be done!

Wasting money on software compliance auditing is no way to run your business entity, when the money for the cost of conducting software compliance audits (in the manner they are being conducted at present) could be far better spent on your core business activities, BUT we suspect you already know this!

We know that software compliance is NOT the core business activity of your organization and the money spent on traditional auditing techniques is MOSTLY WASTED and could be better deployed and utilized elsewhere.

"To combat and overcome both illegal and unauthorized software usage in organizations you need a robust technology asset management solution to force a shift in attitude to what is really a PEOPLE based problem!"

You can read the rest of this article here http://www.pcprofile.com/viewpoint.htm along with some other articles at our web site http://www.pcprofile.com

You may contact me direct at robharm@pcprofile.com if you want to know how to force a sea-change in conducting compliance audits across your organization and free up those resources and $ you are wasting!

19 replies

by becker-2004

you can't solve people problems with technical solutions. if you have a people problem, you need to solve it with people solutions.

by jamesrl

Yes, but you see he wants to sell you a technical solution - he can't sell you a people/policy based on.

I really hate people who come here and pretend to start a message thread, but are really trying to sell something.

If they were smart, they would realise the bad impression it makes. I would never buy from a company that acted in that manner.

James

by jasonlove

So what if he is trying to sell you something?

Did you read the rest of his article?

He appears to have come up with an approach that addresses the people/policy problem.

Before you decide to never buy from a company that acts in this manner, maybe you should take a look at what they are offering.

You never know, they might just have an answer for you.

by dilbert-tom

Technical solutions can help identify which people are making problems - once it is clear that compliance WILL be enforced, many people will just quit the problem practices that are leading to non-compliance.
A very few examples can motivate the masses to comply rather than suffer consequences of being caught.
The places where this dosen't work are places where the Top Staff is the biggest problem. Workers tend to adopt the ethics of management, if they haven't got well-established ethics of their own already...
And I do tend to agree that ongoing audit initiatives are more likely to just be a waste of effort, and most non-compliance can be curtailed by encouraging worker vigilance and having someplace to report suspected non-compliance (audit the reported issues to avoid wasting effort).

by tomsal

We established that you need people solutions for people problems, not technology.

BUT what if TECHNICALLY everyone is a moron? ;)

by becker-2004

you can't solve anything without enforcing accountability. unfortunatly, accountability is one of the hardest things to enforce.

by sentrywatch

Yes - we do have a solution that sells accountabilty across the whole organisation, top to bottom. The fact that it uses a very simple technology approach to drive this accountability through the peoople based problem is what makes it unique. The amount of pain suffered by the end user is directly proportional to the lack of accountability they currently have at many sites!

We developed this tool as our clients were tired of wasting money on software compliance audits and wasting 18% to 25% p.a. on annual maintenance fees. It meant they could use the maintenance money on other more important tasks related to their core business.

We make no apologies for stating the obvious. Software audits are a waste of time and its time to make end users accountable.

by thechas

Yes, there are issues with users installing software that is not properly licensed.

Still, the biggest problem in software license compliance is MANAGEMENT!

Managers that refuse to purchase the tools that employees need, who then ignore users who install their own software are the biggest problems.

Next, is the disgruntled employee who knows about illegal software and calls the SBA. Prompting an audit.

Your first line of defense is to keep detailed records on every PC that the company owns.

Chas

by sentrywatch

Agreed, in part.

We focused on the "management issues" ages ago (1998 and 2000) regarding no budget for audit tools and also no budget for standard "everyday use" software licenses at http://www.pcprofile.com/No_Budget_For_Audit_Software.htm and http://www.pcprofile.com/1in3.htm (unfortunately many of the links regarding penalties in those 2 pages have died at external reference sites).

Management (or lack therof) is one key part of the equation that is causing the issue to remain as a hot topic.

Management too MUST be fully accountable for budget setting and allocation, yet many "at the top" still don't realise the significant penalties they personally can face for their lack of action.

There is plenty of anecdotal feedback from press releases that lack of accountbility is the key driving factor both for budget setting/allocation and end user accountability.

Other key parts to the equation are outlined at
Who Is Responsible? http://www.pcprofile.com/who_is_responsible_for_software_piracy_1.htm
Who Else Is Responsible? http://www.pcprofile.com/who_is_responsible_for_software_piracy_2.htm

by pgm554

I was at a training seminar, when the question of unauthorized software on company machines came up (legitimately bought by the end user, but used on a company owned machine).

This, under the auspices of the EULA, could be considered piracy and a compliance issue for the company that owns the machine.

The company would be libel for fines and penalties (even though the software is legit).
The software needs to be purchased by the company and registered in their name.

Don?t you just love lawyers?

by jasonlove

You're right that management often refuse to purchase the tools that users need.

However, my experience (30+ years) has been that management make a decision to provide a suite of office type tools. For example, they choose the Microsoft Office suite.

This makes good sense because then you can have standard templates, styles etc across the company presenting a common image to internal and external customers alike.

Along comes Joe User. He doesn't like Microsoft Word so he installs WordPerfect instead. He doesn't like Excel so he installs Lotus. Illegally because he got them from a friend.

Management provided him with suitable tools but he didn't like the tools he was given so he instaled his own.

Is this management's fault?

Definitely not.

If Joe User is told that company policy requires the use of (eg) Microsoft Word for word processing, and Joe User doesn't like Word - tough. Find another job. Don't try tocost my company mega bucks in fines because he doesn't like Word.

by jasonlove

I should know. I've wasted hundreds of hours on them!

I have lost count of the hours my team has wasted filling up floppy disk after floppy disk with the same old stuff - lists of all the files on a PC. We have enough floppy disks full of old and useless audit records to lift the QE2 out of the water.

I've lost count of the reams of paper we have generated that has then been dumped into an archive and forgotten about.

So why does this happen?

Because the audit software doesn't tell me what has been added since last audit. It tells me what Is on the machine now.

So I have to dig out the old audit records and manually compare the old with the new and hope that I can spot the changes.

I've got better things for my team to be getting on with rather than wate their experise trawling through tons of garbage.

Anyone who challenges this guy's assertion that software audits are a waste of time has obviously never conducted an audit before.

by jasonlove

I have not yet seen a EULA that prevents a purchased piece of software being run on any machine regardless of who owns it.

You can buy some software and install it on a desktop at work. The licence doesn't preclude you from doing that. It merely states that you can't install it at work AND at home.

I can tell you, that my company does not allow privately purchased software on their machines but that is for an entirely different reason.

We don't have control of the licences or media. Hence we don't know whether the purchaser has it installed on their home PC or not.

It therefore makes sense for us to refuse it's installation - we are protecting our interests.

BTW. I hate lawyers too!

by pgm554

Ever open a piece of software that says by opening the software you agree to the EULA,but the EULA is inside the sealed software.

So to read the EULA,you have all ready agreed to it before you read it.

Nice Catch 22 ,eh?

by beothuk

We don't allow staff members to install their own software on our PCs.

Even if they hand the CDs over to us for safe keeping we have no way of ensuring that they haven't got a copy at home and that they haven't installed it there.

No IT Manager in his right mind would allow that sirt of situation to develop.

The risks are too high.

If I caught any of my staff installing such software, they would be out looking for another job!

by jamesrl

I am tired of reading so called white papers which are nothing more than long marketing brouchures, and when someone claims to start a discussion but is really just making a pitch, I find that somewhat dishonest.

If the only answer is to buy his product, then its not an honest answer.

James

by :0)

We are trialing a product called Centennial. It tracks all software versions and any licensing (as well as ALL hardware including roaming laptop users).

So far, it seems ideal!!

Any comments???

by mandrake64

My organisation takes a dim view of breaches of its computer usage policy. This includes the installation of unauthorised software even for evaluation purposes. All software must be approved through the Information Systems Manager before installation and use. Audits of installed software are carried out on every reboot and action taken to remove unauthorised software once found.
Our policy clearly outlined the consequences of breahing the policy including suspension without pay, loss of computer access privileges, demotion and dismissal. I think people have got the message and it appears that the culture of the organisation has changed.
What goes on within people's home might be another story. No-one appears to have any control of their teenagers these days!!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.