Discussion Locked

Soldiers sharing opinions, security or censorship?

0 helpful
58 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is a bit of an odd one really and one I am still pondering myself for a connection but it just doesn't FEEL right.

Snopes listed a false letter/email spam stating how Obama 'blew off'/ignored troops and played basketball on a recent visit to Afghanistan.

the letter was proven wrong (well not really, I'll come back to that) and defied military rules against speaking about politics while in uniform? apparently yoru personal opinion is not allowed when in uniform. But whatever, much of that crap doesn't make sense anyway, it is to be expected.

Firstly, I understand that such visits have to be conducted under a blanket of severe security and in the most covert ways, anyone can appreciate that need, I am sure.

Stories about Democrats ignoring trops or blowing them off as they rush through on PR trips are also not new, and are usually later proven to be BS, it seems that the military like to discount democrats, as do many others, and Dems shoot off about Republicans etc. It's internal, political warfare. whatever.

But the response to the false email states a few things that raised my eyebrows.

First, it was Miltary spokeswoman, Army Lt.Col Rumi Nelson-Green who addressed it by saying " These comments are inappropriate and factually incorrect." okay, so the military actually DOES negate inncorrect/false comments by miltary toward political parties. That's good, right?

BUT she then added.
"Such political commentary is barred from uniformed personnel."

Uh, what? They aren't ALLOWED to say what they see? They aren't ALLOWED to talk about meeting who may be the next US president?

This isn't security, security was how his arrival was obviously kept a secret, and instead of parading in front of troops in a Hummer, they were invited to meet with him ina secured area/building.

He also was said to have met with MANY different troops and divisions and spent time to answer questions and ask a few of the troops himself, an ordinary visit for any leader or potential leader.

So what about this email? Apparently it was not intended to be a mass mailing at all, but as a private email to his (the Captain's)family.

But he had never even met Obama, wasn't near the area Obama visted, the letter said Obama was playing basketball, which was also apprently false and simply taken from a local headline.

The part that bugs me is that this is a Captain in the US military that is filling his family with this BS. It then gets circulated as coming from a legitimate source, 'the troops are saying it and THEY know first hand what is REALLY going on'.

As we now see, while they MAY know what is really going on, there are still those who like to create their own SPIN on the events and slander potential leaders in letters home. So we REALLY don't get the full story from the source either, that is IF and WHEN they are allowed to talk of such matters. How much other information ALLOWED to be aired to the world is actually factual and how much is false?

I find it laughable that in addition to naming his rank, he found a need to add, "American Soldier" and the big closer ("married and father of 6 children"). SFW?

Because you are am American solder AND a father does that make your opinion more valid? Give me a break!

The ability to procreate makes your opinion more worthy? LOL, what a mentality.

When confronted with it, he apologized for it being circulated, NOT because it was full of lies and fabrications but because he CLAIMS it was intended for his family only and not as a blanket statement. So why would he lie to his family? Dad, why did you lie to us when you were at war?

Fair enough on that either wat but he missed one thing, did his WIFE not realize he was an "American solder", that he was married and had 6 kids?

I call bullsh*t; he intended it to be circulated as a piece on condemning commentary from a captain in the field. By not adhering to restrictions on what can be said and WHEN it can be said, he beat the others to the punch. Some others who really DID meet Obama and thought he was a fine example of a future leader of America. I am sure some did not, that's not the point though.

Another letter was written a while after the visit when they were cleared to send letters and discuss it, though only a few were alowed to photograph the event. Other letters say the absolute opposite of what the Captain had said.

They say Obama is a fine man, he apepars to have great leadership qualities, is genuinely interested etc. Even to the point of saying how McCain was playing golf in the US with Bush sr. and wondering why Obama was getting so much press (just a soldier's 'non-uniformed' opinion there though).

I suppose my question is, how much of this actually makes it to Americans?

I know with all the BS surrounding John Kerry, many people were jumping on the bandwagon without investigation (which proved most of teh comments and slagging as pure BS or comments taken out of their original context, any negeative press was eaten up, whether correct or not.

Is it still the same or are people actually a little more open to an alternate solution now?

Have Americans finally seen the light?

Are Americans tired of the constant need to be at war, the deceit, the misinformation, the excuses, the posturing from both left and right?

Are people dead set against Obama because he is a democrat or for McCain just because he is a Republican?

I am sure McCain has many merits, that is not my concern, but are people just following the party and politics without looking at the candidate for who they really are?

Does military censorship, even in such a mild form, cause people to get and BELIEVE the wrong picture just because the source is deemed credible?

The snopes article is here:
http://www.snopes.com/politics/obama/afghanistan.asp

How does a guy get a fair shake in such a media controlled marketplace?

How do YOU find or validate your sources?

58 replies

by jdclyde

We have two candidates that are were they are because the press put them there.

The biased coverage from beginning to end had been a total embarrassment, and has shown us that we now have a fourth branch of government in the US, the media.

I am on mailing lists for both, so hear this going both ways all the time. Nothing new and not news.

They want to the bottom of this? Talk to the man that sent the original email. Anything else is just BS, and shows that Snopes is not the end-all if they accept a blanket "no comment" as denial.

A full speech on youtube of the person in their own words means more than any soft coverage and controlled stories coming out about the election.

by oz_media

You just didn't read it.

Fair enough on that then.

Nobody offered a blanket NO COMMENT and Snopes did quote the original sender's public statement of denial.

by jdclyde

it was damage control, nothing more, nothing less.

As it was never intended as a political or public endorsement, it is unlikely any retraction is more than CYA, or didn't you read that much into it?

I read into what he said and why.

by jmgarvin

Don't Ask, Don't Tell applies to may facets of a soldiers life. You cannot publicly campaign or anti-campaign for a candidate. You can vote, but you can't speak your mind.

The reason for this is two fold:
1) it keeps the military leaders in check as not to influence the troops
2) it keeps the troops in check as not to stage a take over of the nation

That is all

by charliespencer

jmg explained this better than I could have.

For those that don't know, UCMJ is the "Uniform Code of Military Justice". ('Uniform' in this case means it's the same across all branches of the U.S. military; Army, Marines, and those other candy-@ss branches!) (If your civilian a$$ had served with the rest of us, you'd already know that!) The UCMJ is the code of laws governing military life.

Certainly a serviceperson is entitled to his opinions, but he must keep them to himself. Do political issues get discussed between service members? Sure, between good friends quietly over a beer, or at 0230 in a foxhole, or very rarely over a beer at 0230 in a foxhole. But many of the sacrifices a soldier makes are restrictions on those very same rights he's defending for others. Restrictions on speech are required to prevent soldiers from publicly questioning the goals of their civilian leadership. The job of the U.S. military is to carry out civilian policy, not to influence or make policy like the military in some junta-governed banana 'republics' who shall remain nameless. Excuse me, had something caught in my throat.

When I entered the Army this portion of the UCMJ was clearly explained; I have no reason to think that's changed since 1982.

by oz_media

Well I had almost began to think that you were beyond such ridiculous comments, but you prove me wrong on that one at least.

First of all, the military is not some secret society that holds sub rosa meetings under the light of a full moon. Its ont some unique male bonding experience that others can't relate to, its just the military. Soldiers are respected for performing a duty, but that is it, they are not superior, smarter, more valiant, more knowledgable or mroe anything else than ordinary citizens. They simply enlisted to do a job.

If I had served with you, I'd be friggin' American, thank God I dodged that one!

But, I WAS in ATC in teh UK, and would have worked my way through teh RAF if we had stayed. I am not Canadian so I can't help float the Canadian boat, I am luckily not American so I don't have to be sent to die for what I don't believe in.

Your comment was absurd and offers nothing of any value to the discussion. That aside, lets forget abotu your missed comment and move forward through your post.

While you correctly illustrate the duty of a soldier in some circumstances, things seem to have changed since your days of using flintlocks, they WERE allowed to offer opinion but not at the time that this Captain had written an mass email. He CLAIMS it was only for his family, which is crap of course, why would he offer the text "American Soldier" or Married father of 6 children" if it was intended for his family?

These are the words of someone seeking instant credibility and respect for his opinion. He was sending out a mass mailing which was OK once they were ttold they could release info. just as many others later did.

When I entered the Army this portion of the UCMJ was clearly explained; I have no reason to think that's changed since 1982.

Well perhaps you should read it again and pay attention to where they ARE allowed to talk about it, just not at THAT, I assume due to security reasons.

by jamesrl

Therefore, it does not help the president/commander in chief to have the troops talking politics - if they disagree, they look disloyal, if they agree, they appear to be pawns.

Many jurisdictions have similar restrictions on military, civil servants, police etc. You don't publicly comment on your bosses.

James

by oz_media

Hadn't really questioned the ability for a soldie rto speak, in fact I clearly iterated that they cannot in most cases, until an event has passed and they can speak freely about it.

They never mentioned anyuthing about not being able to talk just that they cannot do so in uniform, however they do get clearance to do so and are allowed to offer personal opinion son senators and presidents. They are not restricted form offering such opinions though. In this case, I am sure it was kept quiet simply becase Obama was there under tight security, but I am sure many knew of his visit prior, as they would need to.

but that wasn't questioned, really. It was that these guys DO have a huge influence on the views from the general public. But they clearly can't be taken as valid in all cases as there are many who use that credibilty as a solder in the field to mislead readers and fuel thier own personal agenda.

by charliespencer

"Are people dead set against Obama because he is a democrat or for McCain just because he is a Republican? ... are people just following the party and politics without looking at the candidate for who they really are?"

Unfortunately, yes, there are people who vote based solely on a candidate's party affiliation. In many states it is possible to vote 'straight party ticket'. When you get your ballot, there's an option to vote for all candidates of a party just by checking one box. You don't need to know any of the candidates' names or the office they're seeking. Just mark / punch / click / touch 'Democratic Party' or 'Republican Party' (as if any of the other parties are going to be listed; hah!), and you've voted for all candidates that party has nominated. One-touch voting for those who can't be bothered to research the candidates or issues.

by jdclyde

has been called racist...

Democrats go through the ROOF if you even talk about removing it.

It does make it hard for an independent to get a seat anywhere.

Politically, this state is such an embarrassment for me... :(

by captbilly1eye

The two main reasons I left MI had roots in politics:

1. Out-of-proportion taxation.

2. Off-balanced influence of Detroit (a city mired in cronyism).

...after being run by liberals for so long, shouldn't Detroit be a paradise by now?

I understand that recently several congressmen there were pushing to have the state speed limit lowered to 55. Was that meant as a way to slow down those leaving the state?
:)

Hey.... we haven't pulled up our drawbridge, yet. ;-)

by oz_media

Bush was elected TWICE! Either everyone is deaf, dumb and blind in the USA or they simply vote without knowledge or concience.

by charliespencer

"Either everyone is deaf, dumb and blind in the USA or they simply vote without knowledge or concience."

I could live with either one of these alternatives if 'everyone' was actually involved. The sad fact is that barely half the eligible population votes. I tripped over a graph showing between 48% and 55% of the eligible voters participated since 1976. I was surprise to find even that many voted.

http://www.neded.org/files/research/stathand/lsecc8.pdf

Talk about insulting to service people! In some countries people walk for days in heat or gunfire to vote. Here we won't even get off the sofa if we have to stand in line over 30 minutes.

by jdclyde

it is democraticly controlled regions that primarily push the party ticket.

Makes it easier when they round up the homeless that they pay with smokes to vote for the second name.

by maxwell edison

The two options:

1. Vote for the person, not the party.
2. Vote for the party, not the person.

Option number one, in my opinion, is more idealistic, and less realistic. It?s more romantic, and less effective.

The PARTY controls the agenda, not the person. The PARTY controls the committees, not the person. The PARTY controls the appointments, not the person. The PARTY has veto/filibuster power, not the person.

Anyone who votes for person over party is living a pipe-dream, and he/she doesn?t fully understand the reality and nuances of our political system. Believing otherwise might make a person feel better, but it doesn?t accomplish a dang thing.

by oz_media

But what about how much influence such Bs emails directed at either party has?

Regardless of whether you vote for the party or the person, aren't such letters seen as the final and only real proof? Soldiers don't mislead citizens? news and government say one thing but a solder's word is gospel?

This guy sent out an email that he very well knew would be shared, whether he admits that or not. I am sure its not teh first one he's sent and I am sure his wife has told him how people in such and such forum support him.

How many of them also read the apology or snopes?

by charliespencer

At the national level, maybe. But governors and state legislatures often deviate from the party line. Here in SC both houses of the legislature are Republican-majority, as is the governor, but they can't work together at all. At the city and county level the influence of the national party platform is often given only lip service, if that. Voting straight party ticket when state and local races are on the ballot is strictly a tool for national party domination.

by oz_media

It may have been a personal opinion but here's what leads me to believe otherwise.

If it was for his fmaily only, would he have signed it with rank and the fact that he is an American soldier, married father of 6? Nope, not unless it was a different family.

It was intented to mislead the masses as spam mail, it was intended to show personal knowledge and authority, his signature was used for respect and credibility. He got caught and had to back peddle, but lets be realistic here, it wasn't as he stated, intended for his family only.

by jdclyde

If someone were to hear directly from people on-the-ground, I would believe it.

Having family in the service and recently out, most of that is standard for the auto signiture. Part, added by the person forwarding? I wasn't there, so I refrain from making a statement such as yours.

Until then, I can say that the majority of the military remember how they were treated by the Clinton administration.

by oz_media

Even as a signature, especially a formatted one that is automatically added to all mail, isn't adding that you are a father of six just a plea for attention to your email?

I'd never dream of putting such a signature on mail, whether public, personal, professional etc.

You can't tell me that's teh norm for Americans. I've seen guys here sign with their rank before, which is completely irrelevant to discussions we have here.

I couldn't give a rats for whom and when you fought. I appreciate all the soldiers worldwide who fight for their nation, it is not a nice choice in life but somebody has to stand up and be counted. They hope to fight a valiant battle and do what is right for their country, whether or not that comes true is not in their hands but those of their leaders whom they support without question.

Anyway, I don't have any disrespect for soldiers, but I find it has a place and time to be noted. As for adding that you are married with six children, what bloody relevance does that have with thr price of eggs on a Tuesday?

It makes people think he's just like them, a respectable working, family man with only America's best intentions in mind (which in this case is pure BS of course). So it is used to create a bit of sympathy and understanding which leads to credibility.

We've had many people here post comments from soldiers and state how that is straight from the source. Perhaps it is but it sure isn't credible based simply on that alone.

The key question is how does such information drill into American minds and do people really take such information as credible, or is it taken with a grain of salt and looked into?

As for Clinton having such an effect; does that just not just show complete ignorance of the writer/voter for not properly analyzing the merits and possible benefits of each candidate?

In this case it was even known to be BS by the author before he wrote it and yet he still went out of his way to try and condemn Obama.

Another question (sorry), This email was proven false by Snopes, but it had circulated by then. How many people do you think looked into the validity or checked snopes? Of course, many would be filtered as spam or ignored anyway.

by oz_media

I was on an impromptu date with a waitress on the weekend and we were joking about our bits and pieces when I said, Well Ill have to let you meet CaptBilly1Eye!!

It was funnier for me than her of course, though she said it was anew one, I could barely stop laughing thinking of the link between your alias and my.... Anyway, I have now officially renamed my member. It is no longer a one eyed trouser snake, it is now CaptBilly1Eye. Arrrr, bend over and Ill give you a taste of me fishtick! :)

Sorry, I just really thought it was funny, just one of those stupid things that I couldnt stop giggling like a little girl over.

by captbilly1eye

I've heard that in certain circles, 'Oz' is a slang term used by some boys to refer to their anal orifice. ..."we're off to see the wizard♪♫" So... if someone bent over, it seems to me, you'd kinda be doin' yourself. ;\

by charliespencer

The 'civilian @ss' comment wasn't directed at you individually, but only toward those who don't know what 'UCMJ' stands for because they've never been in the military. It was meant in humor and no offense was intended. I apologize for any misunderstanding this may have caused.

by oz_media

sorry for taking it out of context. As you know, I do get a lot of opposition with such opinions, that is why I was so wordy and careful in my explanation and asked many questions. I hoped it would help show I had a pretty open mind on the subject and that the censorship really isn't the issue but moreso how that effects US opinions.

Obviously the title was poorly thought out, it was a new article I ran into and I now think I was still digesting it as I wrote.

by maxwell edison

As to the appropriateness of the Captain's message, I'd refer to the the section of the UCMJ that covers political activity by active duty military personnel:

________ DOD (Department of Defense) Directive 1344.10, February 19, 2008 ________

4. POLICY

It is DoD policy to encourage members of the Armed Forces (hereafter referred to as ?members?) (including members on active duty, members of the Reserve Components not on active duty, members of the National Guard even when in a non-Federal status, and retired members) to carry out the obligations of citizenship. In keeping with the traditional concept that members on active duty should not engage in partisan political activity, and that members not on active duty should avoid inferences that their political activities imply or appear to imply official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement, the following policy shall apply:

4.1. General

[b]4.1.1. A member of the Armed Forces on active duty may: [/b]

4.1.1.1. Register, vote, and express a personal opinion on political candidates and issues, but not as a representative of the Armed Forces.
4.1.1.2. Promote and encourage others to exercise their voting franchise, if such promotion does not constitute use of their official authority or influence to interfere with the outcome of any election.
4.1.1.3. Join a partisan or nonpartisan political club and attend its meetings when not in uniform, subject to the restrictions of subparagraph 4.1.2.4. (See DoD Instruction 1334.1 (Reference (c).)
4.1.1.4. Serve as an election official, if such service is not as a representative of a partisan political party, does not interfere with the performance of military duties, is performed when not in uniform, and the Secretary concerned has given prior approval. The Secretary concerned may NOT delegate the authority to grant or deny such permission.
4.1.1.5. Sign a petition for a specific legislative action or a petition to place a candidate?s name on an official election ballot, if the signing does not obligate the member to engage in partisan political activity and is done as a private citizen and not as a representative of the Armed Forces.
4.1.1.6. Write a letter to the editor of a newspaper expressing the member?s personal views on public issues or political candidates, if such action is not part of an organized letter-writing campaign or a solicitation of votes for or against a political party or partisan political cause or candidate. If the letter identifies the member as on active duty (or if the member is otherwise reasonably identifiable as a member of the Armed Forces), the letter should clearly
2 DoDD 1344.10, February 19, 2008
state that the views expressed are those of the individual only and not those of the Department of Defense (or Department of Homeland Security for members of the Coast Guard).
4.1.1.7. Make monetary contributions to a political organization, party, or committee favoring a particular candidate or slate of candidates, subject to the limitations under section 441a of title 2, United States Code (U.S.C.) (Reference (d)); section 607 of title 18, U.S.C. (Reference (e)); and other applicable law.
4.1.1.8. Display a political bumper sticker on the member?s private vehicle.
4.1.1.9. Attend partisan and nonpartisan political fundraising activities, meetings, rallies, debates, conventions, or activities as a spectator when not in uniform and when no inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement can reasonably be drawn.
4.1.1.10. Participate fully in the Federal Voting Assistance Program.

[b]4.1.2. A member of the Armed Forces on active duty shall not: [/b]

4.1.2.1. Participate in partisan political fundraising activities (except as permitted in subparagraph 4.1.1.7.), rallies, conventions (including making speeches in the course thereof), management of campaigns, or debates, either on one?s own behalf or on that of another, without respect to uniform or inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement. Participation includes more than mere attendance as a spectator. (See subparagraph 4.1.1.9.)
4.1.2.2. Use official authority or influence to interfere with an election, affect the course or outcome of an election, solicit votes for a particular candidate or issue, or require or solicit political contributions from others.
4.1.2.3. Allow or cause to be published partisan political articles, letters, or endorsements signed or written by the member that solicits votes for or against a partisan political party, candidate, or cause. This is distinguished from a letter to the editor as permitted under the conditions noted in subparagraph 4.1.1.6.
4.1.2.4. Serve in any official capacity with or be listed as a sponsor of a partisan political club.
4.1.2.5. Speak before a partisan political gathering, including any gathering that promotes a partisan political party, candidate, or cause.
4.1.2.6. Participate in any radio, television, or other program or group discussion as an advocate for or against a partisan political party, candidate, or cause.
4.1.2.7. Conduct a political opinion survey under the auspices of a partisan political club or group or distribute partisan political literature.
4.1.2.8. Perform clerical or other duties for a partisan political committee or candidate during a campaign, on an election day, or after an election day during the process of closing out a campaign.
4.1.2.9. Solicit or otherwise engage in fundraising activities in Federal offices or facilities, including military reservations, for any political cause or candidate.
4.1.2.10. March or ride in a partisan political parade.
4.1.2.11. Display a large political sign, banner, or poster (as distinguished from a bumper sticker) on a private vehicle.
4.1.2.12. Display a partisan political sign, poster, banner, or similar device visible to the public at one?s residence on a military installation, even if that residence is part of a privatized housing development.
4.1.2.13. Participate in any organized effort to provide voters with transportation to the polls if the effort is organized by or associated with a partisan political party, cause, or candidate.
4.1.2.14. Sell tickets for or otherwise actively promote partisan political dinners and similar fundraising events.
4.1.2.15. Attend partisan political events as an official representative of the Armed Forces, except as a member of a joint Armed Forces color guard at the opening ceremonies of the national conventions of the Republican, Democratic, or other political parties recognized by the Federal Elections Committee or as otherwise authorized by the Secretary concerned.
4.1.2.16. Make a campaign contribution to, or receive or solicit (on one?s own behalf) a campaign contribution from, any other member of the Armed Forces on active duty. Any contributions not prohibited by this subparagraph remain subject to the gift provisions of sections 2635.301-2635.304 of title 5, Code of Federal Regulations (Reference (f)). See subparagraph 4.1.2.1. for general prohibitions on partisan fundraising activity.
4.1.3. Commissioned officers shall not use contemptuous words as prohibited by section 888 of Reference (b) or participate in activities proscribed by DoD Directives 5200.2 and 1325.6 (References (g) and (h), respectively).
4.1.4. Subject to any other restrictions in law, a member of the Armed Forces not on active duty may take the actions or participate in the activities permitted in subparagraph 4.1.1., and may take the actions and participate in the activities prohibited in subparagraph 4.1.2, provided the member is not in uniform and does not otherwise act in a manner that could reasonably give rise to the inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement.

4.1.5. Activities not expressly prohibited may be contrary to the spirit and intent of this Directive. Any activity that may be reasonably viewed as directly or indirectly associating the Department of Defense or the Department of Homeland Security (in the case of the Coast Guard) or any component of these Departments with a partisan political activity or is otherwise contrary to the spirit and intention of this Directive shall be avoided.
________________________________________________________________________________________________

source: http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/134410p.pdf
________________________________________________________________________________________________

The way I read this (and was trained when I was in the military), the letter was entirely appropriate, albeit factually inaccurate. Heck, there are political office holders (of both parties) currently serving with their Reserve units! To suggest a GI can't have a political opinion is ludicrous.

The Army Captain said he sent the e-mail to his wife and family members; I believe that. However, it was those people who took the liberty to forward it to everyone in their address books, many of whom also took the liberty to forward it to everyone in their address books, many of whom also took the liberty....., and presto, an out-of-control Internet urban legend is born. The Captain, I would guess, did not sign the letter to his own wife and family as a father of six. I believe she already knew that. It was probably added somewhere along the Internet Super Highway by some idiot who though it added something to the false claim, along with the "American Soldier" stuff. I'd also guess (emphasis on guess) that the Captain didn't sign by using his formal name, rank, and unit, this also being added sometime after the original (again, just a guess) by an overly zealous family member.

I think the lesson of the letter shows how two people can view the same event and take something different from it. Sure, there's an obvious political bias dripping from it, but what else is new? I think I can honestly say that I've seldom seen a story or an opinion on something like this that wasn't skewed with some political or personal bias. To those soldiers who sang Obama's praises, but felt compelled to add [i]"..... while McCain was playing golf in the US with Bush Sr....."[/i], their bias is also showing. Your political bias, Oz, is also dripping from your message. My political bias is transparent, although I readily admit it and define what it is and why I have it. We ALL have political bias, whether we admit it or not. It's not possible to be objective. We ALL see the world through the prism of our own experiences and our preferred world-view.

The way I see it, Barrack Obama probably had a great trip over there. He surely scored some political points with soldiers, foreign leaders, etc. To think he would shun soldiers is showing the epitome of ignorance. He went there to win them over, not to shun them. He went there to educate himself on the situations, not to make enemies. Security was tight, as it should have been. That's probably what the Captain was seeing. But other soldiers were on the opposite side of that security, and they saw something different.

I recall John McCain stories criticizing him for being security conscious when he went to the middle-east. John McCain is anything but a coward, and he - as well as Obama - were both prudent to be security conscious. Only a total idiot wouldn't be.

The bottom line is something I've been saying for years - don't believe Internet chain letters. We've seen them for years. We've seen them about GWB, J. Kerry, J. Edwards, John McCain, H. Clinton, Dick Cheney, etc. And just like people who don't read past the headline or hear past the one-liner jokes on late night television, people will believe whatever they want to believe.

[i]"How does a guy get a fair shake in such a media controlled marketplace?"[/i], you ask? That's a damn good question, but my answer is, he won't. And you're spot-on, Oz. It IS a media controlled marketplace - a point of total agreement between us. (By the way, on the same token, how does GWB get a fair shake in such a media controlled marketplace? The answer is, he doesn't.)

[i]How do YOU find or validate your sources"[/i], you go on to ask? I work at it; it takes time; it takes diligence; I go to the source; I verify; and so on. And I'll tell you this, it's frustrating as all get-out to discuss events and issues with those who don't. You'll notice I pretty much gave up trying - at least in these threads.

by oz_media

With respect to the letter's validity, the original letter is posted here in full.
http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/dc/2008/07/obamabashing-gi-retracts-claim.html

The sign-off was as follows.

"If this is blunt and to the point I am sorry but I want you all to know what kind of caliber of person he really is. What you see in the news is all fake.

In service,

[REDACTED BY THE DAILY NEWS] [b]Battle Captain TF Wasatch American Soldier"'[/b]

You are right, his wife was said to have written the married tag line in, and circulate it.

This is a Utah Army National Guard intelligence officer. I assume you agree that it was not his first email correspondence with his wife.

I'll also assume you'll agree that he was quite aware of the support he received from home due to his wife's internet blogs with respect to former comments he had made. She probably told him quite proudly how his stories from the front had been received in the past. Again he's an intelligence officer, what a great source! She was probably just as proud to share this important news online (she was noted to be a blogger) I also think he was playing on that little bit of fame for being the final say for so many avid fans.

We've seen people here with opinions formed solely on correspondence with soldiers and 'private' military blogs before.

This has NOTHING to do with the party the candidate represents, I also stated that and commented that I think McCain has his merits too. It makes no difference WHO did it.

As for your political bias being transparent, LOL, PULL THE OTHER ONE! :D
That's ripe, don't flatter yourself!

You have always seen political bias in others but never in yourself.

You instantly see my post as biased, even though it has nothing to do with either party being compared. You then go on to state how it was no different than the bias shown by those who [i]favoured[/i] Obama; except that one was all lies from someone who wasn't even there and the other was from hose who witnessed teh visit. In saying so you show your defense for the Republican party and thus your bias. Again my entire post has nothing to do with the political affiliation but focuses questions directly at the action.

As for the soldier seeing a different view of the same event, he wasn't even AT the event. He read about the basketball game in the local headlines and many others state how they were greeted quite graciously by Obama as he worked his way through them and took time to stop and talk to everyone.

1) it was contrived, as also recognized by his superiors

2) everyone there including himself has said it was not allowed (as a uniformed soldier) at that time, others said that they eventually were allowed to speak on the matter once it was cleared by authorities. I do see some loose language though, ENCOURAGED and SHOULDN'T etc. instead of can't. Though this issue was supposedly against regulations, perhaps due to his being in intelligence.

I don't see this as a bad thing and as I explained it is completely understandable procedure. Why would he bother to apologize otherwise? he didn't apologize for his comments, he apologized for saying so in uniform.

3)I am confident that he knew VERY well that it would be shared, again as I am sure he had heard about it many times before.

My take, he was playing at being the word of reason and used the faith of others to ahcieve his own objective. An intelligence officer, none the less.

Anyway, later. ZZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

by jdclyde

for sending their spy, Granholm, to INTENTIONALLY destroy the Michigan economy.

It is funny how she likes to state that "ever since Bush took office.....". Hmm, wasn't that the same time she took office? Yeah, it is. And isn't SHE the one running the state, not Bush? Yeah....

There is talk about 55 and the beotch has already said she would support it.

And then there is all the crap with kilpatrick finally getting ready to go to court. Funny how it will take him going to jail to get that crook out of office as mayor of detroit after years of blatant corrupton...

by jamesrl

You praise your country as the greatest place on earth to live, yet you complain when someone from Canada immigrates. Heck shes no commie if she left Canada, shes a redneck right wing Fox watching gal. Gotta be. Why else would she leave the land of universal medical assistance, widely available drugs and friendly people?

Tell you what though, we could work out an exchange. If you take back every whiny deserter (not the Vietnam ones the recent ones), then maybe we will take back Granholm if you can persaud her to cross the border.

Heard an interesting stat the other day. Canada has fewer inmates than Michigan. And you didn't feel safe in Missisauga ROFL.....

Just stop humming showtunes when entering sports bars and you will be fine in Toronto....honest!

James

by jdclyde

There is no way it could be an accident she is doing so horribly.... :D

Here it is, many years later, and I am STILL waiting to be "blown away", as she put it.... :(

That was the ONLY reason I was hoping Hilary would have a chance, because Granholm would have had a place in her cabinet and wouldn't have been our problem anymore.... ;\

Anti-war whiners? I thought you canuks LUVED a good anti-war whiner? Last I heard, you were throwing them back over the border?

by oz_media

She just doesn't fit in here, act like an American, go be an American. No doot aboot it!

by jamesrl

You CAN serve in the US Military or the Canadian military.

You don't have to be a citizen. Many people join the US military to become citizens. Many Americans joined the RAF and RCAF before Pearl Harbour. Some Canadians, including many natives, joined the US Military to fight in Vietnam.

You do have to swear an oath.

My Father in law was born in the Republic of Ireland, lived in a British Colony for a time, joined the British Army, left them for the Canadian Army, where he became a Canadian citizen.

Your age would be a factor at this point howeve.

James

by oz_media

Firstly, of course, I am a broken solder now and was disgnosed with a spinal disease as a teenager.

But even so, I am British, I hold a british citizenship and would rightly only fight for England. Plus you have to ask the question, would you rather fight for the RAF or the USAF, LOL. Actually Canada wouldn't be so bad, fighting for Canada is the same as fighting for the UK and vice versa; we pretty much stand side by side on most issues and have done all along.

But if I fought for the USAF I would never be able to show my face at home again.

As for all the foreign troops fighting for the RAF in WWII, I have always recognized it and tip my hat to those who had to endure it. My parents recall the bomb shelters and their parents racing home after work to rush them off to get into the best shelters to avoid winding up in the underground. The Battle of Britain was won against massive odds, by many allied forces (Poland, New Zealand, Canada, Czechoslovakia, Belgium, Australia, South Africa, France, Ireland, United States of America, Jamaica, Palestine, and Southern Rhodesia) who were all flying insane numbers of hours over and over again.

by nicknielsen

Political speech and activity is permitted, with limitations. Any such activity while in uniform or while identifying yourself as a member of the military is prohibited. JMG caught part or the reasoning. Another part is that your speech while in uniform can be construed by some as an official statement about a candidate or political issue. Violations are prosecuted under Article 92, Failure to obey order or regulation. http://tinyurl.com/6gttdd

And I wouldn't be a bit surprised to find that the parts about "father of six" and "American soldier" were added by somebody else after the email was forwarded.

Further information about the UCMJ: http://tinyurl.com/fgvn9
Link to the UCMJ itself: http://tinyurl.com/57of2l

Edit: BTW, Oz, Article 92 hasn't changed since my first exposure to it in 1974. The regulations, of course, have changed, but those concerning political speech have not changed significantly.

by oz_media

As I said to Palmetto, I think the title is misleading. But I went on to ask som especific questions and said that it really didn't matter if they were not allowed to share such info, as a security measure, until it is safe to release.

After reading other sources, it appears that you are right in saying the married part was added by his wife before she sent it out to others and poste dit in blogs.

I think the only thing that changed his mind was gettign caught though. I am sure he was well aware that his family shared his 'news' on blogs and a groups of friends, it is very common.

But my questions were with regards to how such news is accepted as true by many Americans without further invetsingation. not so much with what they are allowed to share but that this was intentionally sent to mislead groups who believe whatever a soldier says from the front lines.

He said he wasn't a political person, but the letter was intentionally politically misleading. Sounds like BS to me.

by nicknielsen

Combined with almost complete ignorance of the rest of the world and absolute laziness. Throw in the argument from authority and there it is. "Why should I check it out? It's gotta be true! This guy is a captain in Afghanistan. He was there."

As for the Captain, the tone of the email makes it appear his opinion of Obama was fully developed before he drafted the email, so of course there would be nothing good in it.

Like you, I believe the apology comes as a result of being "caught." The standing joke when I was active was that military Intelligence is a specialty, not a state of mind. It doesn't much look like anything has changed.

by nicknielsen

The military doesn't have 100% participation in elections, and it's the one form of speech that is not limited in any way. For many years, I was a Voting Assistance NCO, responsible for helping people connect with their local or state Board of Elections. After one presidential election, I conducted an informal survey ("Did you vote in this election?"); only about 65% actually voted. Sad.

by nicknielsen

About 55% of civilians voted and, in my little world, 65% of military. I don't have access to numbers (I don't even know if they exist) on military voters, but I've been told that in the days of the draft, a much higher percentage of the military voted.

IMO, if you're in the military and don't vote, you're not much smarter than a cow pat.

by oz_media

The original post was completel;y without bias and was just a question as to how many people actually buy into such emails. It ha no bearing on any specific party, it just happens to be it was a slam on a democratic candidate. Whether it was about Obama or McCain makes no difference, I have already said that and stated that I am sure both have their merits and shortcomings.

The issue I saw was that, as demonstrated here before, some people actually use that kind of commentary as definitive proof of what is really happening. How many other people are glued to such lies as the ultimate proof? I have said a few times now that it was mistitled because I was still forming thoughts on teh subject as I wrote it and asked many questions to show my objectives.

by oz_media

Unfortunately I think that happens mroe than I would like to believe. And I am nto saying just in America, I've seen Canadians with similar takes on Canadian politics and even WORSE understanding of US politics.

CNN can be a really bad thing! Some people actually see it as NEWS that supercedes local news. It's pretty scary really, especially when they sau, "you know, I think I am going to vote this year." or "I better watch teh news and get my facts stright." I am actually quoting people (Canadians with respect to Canadian politics) that I have heard, and yes it is ridiculous. I have even defended Bush against slaggign from Canadians, sometimes they have the right idea or conclusion but it is based on complete BS. They have a conclusion but they can't tell you how they reched it or why.

Yes, it is pretty scary.

by jdclyde

I get them all the time, from both political extremes.

After a quick google search, it is shown to be false, I reply to the sender to correct them.

If it APPEARS to be valid, then you spam out all your associates that you know would be interested to hear the information.

Most people don't stop to question.

What people don't understand is when gotchas are proven wrong, they HELP the "victim" because they can point to the lies people have to say about them.

There are plenty of bad points that show Obama is going to be a disaster for this country, that there is no need or call to lie about it. Same to be said about McCain.

If we would have had the Dems put up a solid candidate last time, Bush never would have gotten a second term. Now both partys have put up losers, so it doesn't matter which wins, we still lose.

by jamesrl

One was deported last week. We do allow all kinds of appeals to refugee claimaints, be they from the third world or US, they all get their second and third chances.

I get why we let Vietnam deserters stay - they were drafted. Its isn't the same - these people voluntarily joined the army, and are now suprised they have to go to war.

The US government has helped by not prosecuting desterters who have, it pokes holes in the cases of those here arguing they will face persecution if they return.

James

by oz_media

I can't count the number of times I was told that as a kid. There was no whining around my dad, it was 'suck it up and get on with it'.

Tough bunch that's for sure, a hell of a lot mroe resilient than most people these days that's for sure. We have so many creature conforts now that the though of even the slightest inconvenience is appalling.

by jdclyde

more people like that.

The mental state of people globally is dismal and going down.

by jdclyde

If someone signs up for the military, they don't get a lot of sympathy if they are expected to serve somewhere.

Dishonorable discharge and a full reimbursement of any and all signing bonuses would be a start for such.

by nicknielsen

[i]If we would have had the Dems put up a solid candidate last time, Bush never would have gotten a second term. Now both partys have put up losers, so it doesn't matter which wins, we still lose. [/i]

Who would be a solid candidate?

In today's political climate, I can't imagine a "solid candidate" even being nominated. Every time a "solid candidate" tells the truth to the American people, he or she is disposed of by the radicals (left OR right) that vote in the primaries.

edit: runaway [i]formatting[/i]

by jdclyde

Any of those three had some sound ideas, while McCain has usually always been someone I disagreed with. He is wrong on to many issues for me. That is why They were either attacked or ignored while McCain got nothing but praise for being "A Maverick". Haven't heard that in a while, huh? Notice as well how Obama is making the media cream in their pants, while McCain is now ignored.

Notice how Romney was hounded about his religion, but Hucklebee wasn't (a former pastor) by the main stream press. Notice how that same press stays away from the word muslum.

As for last time, Kerry found you can't win an election by being "Not bush". If Edwards had been the front runner last time around, I would have taken Bush because Kerry is unlikeable and especially for Democrats, it is a beauty contest.

Obama, the great speaker? They called Bush stupid for less than this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxBX8sz3tO8

How many states?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpGH02DtIws

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ae-Ak9WuUio&feature=related

by nicknielsen

My problem is I will look at the projected policies in the speeches and releases, and even if I agree with most of them, if the candidate hasn't shown me the ability to think, I'm not interested.

by nicknielsen

None of the major candidates, anyway. Even Bob Barr isn't much more than a parrot this time out.

This discussion is closed to new replies.