21 replies
by aaron v
I think in terms of stability, I would choose Solaris. The only issue I have seen is a memory leak of similar products on Solaris. This only required stopping and restarting the app.
If initial cost is your primary concern, NT 4 is probably going to be less expensive.
In the long run?? Depends on the hardware requirements, staffing and experience...
by philip.royes
by mightyduk
Here are the issues in choosing a platform for web apps:
security
stability
performance
scalability
price??? perhaps
I doubt that anyone would argue that nt 4.0 will beat out Solaris 7 or 8, on any of these except possibly price. I'm both WebLogic and Oracle are well supported on Solaris. Perhaps Windows 2000 will close the gap on these issues.
The only time I would recommend NT for a web server/application server is when it is a small application that needs to be managed by a novice.... if that's your circumstance, I would highly recommend a 3rd party hosting service. They can offer far better support than a small internal IT shop. Judging by the Oracle and WebLogic choices, i would guess you are talking about arelatively large e-commerce site.
Good Luck.
by philip.royes
by insatiable
I highly recommend the Solaris for your Webserver for security and stability.
I've run both and Solaris is definately less work and much more secure. Just make sure it's kept up-to-date with patches and installed as a secure server.
You can find more information about it at this site, as well as many, many others:
http://www.sunworld.com/common/security-faq.html
This is really intended to build a firewall, but there are some links to pdf documents for minimizing solaris that I found helpful.
http://www.enteract.com/~lspitz/armoring.html
As for the application server, I haven't run one from Solaris or NT. My better judgement would say to stick with Solaris, but if you already have NT servers up and running, go ahead and build a secure NT App server.
Good luck!!
Melissa
by philip.royes
by drahbany
I would chose Sun's Solaris (especially if you're running on a SPARC instead of an Intel box) for the application server. WebLogic IS a JAVA app server, and I'd trust Sun's Java support over Microsoft's any day! In terms of performance, reliability, and support, Sun is the clear leader. My company has had two Sun app servers supporting our e-comerce site, neither or which has been even warm-booted since they went "live" in November 1999! Can anyone say that about a Microsoft NT implementation?
If you can afford it, I'd separate the application server from the http server. That way you can tune each machine for its specific purpose. If that's a possibility for you, check out Linux/Apache as a http platform. You can get a lot morebang for the buck with that combination over a Wintel or a Sun/Netscape solution.
Best of luck!
by philip.royes
by cpfman
Neither. Ask yourself, What's more stable, secure, and scaleable?
Stable ? How about 99.97% uptime(this is real life), Rebooting a couple of times a year only if you want to.
Secure?, Never a reported virus ever. Object based security. (BTW, the World Court in the Hague, 100% of the casinos in Atlantic City, and over 60% of the casinos in Vegas use them)
Scalability? Who holds the Benchmark records for Java?
Volano Benchmark? How about the only platform to break a six digit number(108,283 messages per second) Or how about 23,942 messages per second with 20,000 concurrent connections on a 12 way with 8GB memory? Sun Solaris's best was 4847 messages per second with 9000 concurrent connections on a 22way with 30 GB of memory(http://www.sun.com/software/solaris/java/benchmarks.html). It's the record holder in both categories.
Specjbb2000 benchmark? How about 80,348 transaction per second? The record holder for this benchmark too(http://www.spec.org/osg/jbb2000/results/res2000q2
by philip.royes
by cpfman
The answer to the above post is continued;
Its the only JVM that can do Java Garbage Collection while processes are active and running, Every other JVM (Sun's included) have to halt all threads while garbage is picked up. Oh, and it isn't architecturally limited to a 2GB heap size for Java, it can have 10, or 50 GB heap size.
(IBTW, It's the most scaleable Lotus Notes platform also with 75,000 mail users. )
And the only platform with Copper Chips with SOI technology.
You should really check out an AS/400 instead.
(http://www.as400.ibm.com/news/05jun2000.htm)
On the other hand, we're talking about computers, so why be logical about the decision? Go with what you know and ignore the above facts.
by philip.royes
by especkma
I am going to play devils advocate here.
Performance: Java application servers like weblogic are generally memory and CPU bound. You will have a hard time beating intel for price/performance in the CPU arena. Sparc chips are great and all that, but their integer performance isn't that stellar. As for memory, sure Sun systems can address more memory than Intel systems, but Sun systems that can support large amounts of physical memory carry a large premium + how good is a JVM going to be at managing >2GB heap sizes?
Reliability: I have had heavily used Intel NT systems up for long periods without reboots. Certainly long enough to provide excellent service in a clustered environment.
JVM Maturity: Right now, the JDKs BEA lists as supported on Solaris is a sorry lot--they reccomend Java 1.2 over Java 1.1.7, but they don't reccomend using the JIT with any of the supported 1.2 JVMs. In contrast, their certification of NT JVMs has led Solaris JVMs for months and they currenly list JDK 1.3 + hotspot. Note, because there are more people deploying weblogic on solaris, there are more opportunities to find and report bugs, so this sample effect could skew the results somewhat.
Security: Much of the chest beating about the security of solaris vs NT is, unfortunately, born out of ignorance. NT has supported ACL based file access (well beyond 'ugo'), role based system policy and detailed security auditing for years. Solaris supports some of these features, but theiradoption is limited, and widepread support for them in operating system and utilities is sparse, making them more difficult to implement. In addition, Solaris's network security features are weak compaired to NTs, which is pretty sad. Most servicesbind to network adapters indescriminately, NT affords you some level of controll, and there aren't even limited packet-filtering capabilites built in to help secure apps.
by philip.royes
by james_randy
by philip.royes
by james_randy
by philip.royes
by grumbler
Definetly Solaris.Its a lot more stable,
you can setup a real cluster on it (and not
only a failover cluster like the one in
MSCS), and besides its cheaper (you can get
Solaris 8 just for the price of the media)
by philip.royes
by philip.royes
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Linux posts
Sort by Trending