Discussion Locked

Symantec's Firewall?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We're looking at getting Symantec's new Firewall/VPN server for our Church network. Has anyone gotten any experience or seen any reviews on it?

8 replies

by gmn17

Forget Symantec,. get Black Ice Defender and go to Dutch teenager websites to learn cutting edge and low cost security info. No joke.

by james r linn

Not everyone drives the same car, not everyone needs the same firewall.

Black Ice is great for someone who wants to tweak and twiddle, but if you don't know the basics, you can get a lot of annoying traffic, false positives etc.

On the other hand, if you are a Church, i.e. IT is not your business, you have limited time to spend on firewalls, I know the Symantec products are both effective and easy to set up.

James

by robotech

I just installed a VPN/Router/Firewall for a customer who suffered hacks while using black Ice. Any firewall solution that runs on windows is vulnerable, except Tiny personal firewall www.tinysoftware.com which integrates itself into Windows key bootup files.

by madmark

Are you talking about the Velociraptor (Models 1100, 1200, & 1300), or the new Firewall/VPN Appliance (Models 100, 200, 200R)??

Both are EXCELLENT products. The "Appliance 200R" is rated for only up to 30 users. The VR 1300 can handle 4000 nodes.

Both are solid products.

For feature comparisons, www.zdnet.com or www. cnet.com are usually good. I don't think I've seen a 'head-to-head' comparison, but they have reviews of just about everything there. You could put one together from their research. If you have the coin, you could always check out Forrester Research or Gartner Group.

by inkster

I know from experience that some government agencies have used the old Raptor Firewall, recently bought by Symantec, with success.

by Member 23080015

I started a few months ago on my home computer with the free version, but quickly realized I wanted the PRO version. I bought it for $49 as a download with update protection. The firewall loaded flawlessly and worked, essentially, right-out-of-the-box. The signature files are regularly updated and while not pretty, the program allows for DLL authentication, stealth browsing (works great except in MSN applications, and an intrusion detection system, among other several other features. You can overide the program's defaults and produce "advanced access rules," to include the time of day specific ports or IP address (for instance) can be or will be allowed access to your computer. The program also has a feature to block offending IP addresses for a period of time after a port scan has been detected. Sygate also has a great on-line forum with moderators to assist you with the program, or bugs that you might encounter at . Both Symantec and Sygate security check programs indicate that my computer is fully stealthed (ports) and trojan protected. I highly recommend you try it; it's free for 30 days - you have nothing to lose! If you try it, make sure you immediately upgrade to Build 1120, as there was a bug in the signature upgrade on Build 1117.

by Member 23080015

Wow, I must have not had enough coffee when I posted on this thread. My glowing endorsement was for SYGATE PERSONAL FIREWALL, not Symantec. I'm sorry for the misplaced post.

This discussion is closed to new replies.