Considering you mention, "connect to our central office, at all time", the answer is a point to point solution. Whether it is acceptable in the budget is another story.
VPN tunnel links using the public internet is just that, the public internet. If the internet has problems or one the ISP's is having problems so will your network between the locations.
I work with a company that uses roughly 13 different VPN tunnels, but they transfer Point of Sales information (low traffic) in short periods of time and occasional Exhange email.
Let me put it simple, they have problems. Much, much more than a computer network using t1's.
On the subject of speed; DSL upload's can be restricted to 300/400k. So two DSL links will talk at 300/400K depending on Internet/ISP traffic, opposed to a Factional T (512K consistent).
Edited:
Use the DSL analogy for the T1 internet example as well, but the speed will be 512/frac or 1.5/full