Discussion Locked

Tears as campaign tactic, new definition of 'pathetic'

0 helpful
50 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20071219/ap_po/who_s_crying_now

If a candidate makes a Strong Enough effort to resist, I will not count crying against Her, very much. It will never count in His favor.

Get their hands out of our pockets, and quit crying about it.

50 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"If a candidate makes a Strong Enough effort to resist, I will not count crying against Her, very much. It will never count in His favor."

So it's ok for Her to cry but not Him. Why? Isn't that rather sexist? :D

by absolutely

... gives equal representation, on average, of both, while maximizing verbal economy, in contrast to the verbose 'he or she.'

Any substantive comments?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

while I believe the White House (the political cimate in general is pretty lacking) needs an inhabitant with heart, IMO emotional excess is not likely to be a good thing in a President, or any other elected official. Public tears, with little regard to context, are more likely to turn me off a candidate than attract me to one. Death of an immediate family member or dear friend aside, I consider public displays of [too much] emotion on the part of our elected officials to be displays of weakness. I don't need to know what makes you cry, I need to know what makes you act correctly and with the strength and integrity to guide us through the next few years.

"Get their hands out of our pockets, and quit crying about it."
As long as massive government programs, funded by taxpayer dollars pass for charitable deeds on the part of government their hands will stay in our pockets. No use crying about it - no one is listening.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Interesting...
(if related)

Merriam-Webster's Medical Dictionary - Cite This Source - Share This

Main Entry: path?e?tism
Pronunciation: 'path-&-"tiz-&m
Function: noun
: HYPNOTISM 1

Ok, I'm bored, I admit it.

by absolutely

[i]...I consider public displays of [too much] emotion on the part of our elected officials to be displays of weakness. I don't need to know what makes you cry, I need to know what makes you act correctly and with the strength and integrity to guide us through the next few years.[/i]

I couldn't have said it better myself.

[i]As long as massive government programs, funded by taxpayer dollars pass for charitable deeds on the part of government their hands will stay in our pockets. No use crying about it - no one is listening.[/i]

They will. They might have to lose their jobs, or homes, in even larger numbers, but they will eventually notice that to be distributed, wealth must first be created, and that re-assigning the choice of wealth distribution from its creator to those not competent enough to create it, is responsible for the lacks in wealth they personally experience due to diminishing ratios of total wealth to would-be recipients.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

or I am remarkably pessimistic. I'm loathe to allow myself to believe that anything is likely to change until the greed kings are removed from corporate board rooms and public office. Somehow I don't think that's going to happen in my lifetime.

"They will. They might have to lose their jobs, or homes, in even larger numbers, but they will eventually notice that to be distributed, wealth must first be created, and that re-assigning the choice of wealth distribution from its creator to those not competent enough to create it, is responsible for the lacks in wealth they personally experience due to diminishing ratios of total wealth to would-be recipients."

AAGH! edit yet another typo

by absolutely

Hint: The scenario you described and the one you quoted from me in that post, to me are the same scenario.

by tonythetiger

There would be a whole lot less [b]to[/b] distribute.

You can either have a little bit of something, or a whole lot of nothing. That's the concept people need to grasp.

by drowningnotwaving

Crying as an emotion - I've certainly done it. Never actually faked it, I can honestly say that.

But I've 'faked' being the Hard Man when I felt it necessary, to acheive an end. It's nt my normal personality whatsoever.

I guess the difference is that a politician on the trail always runs the risk of being perceived as 'putting it on' to meet the desired or supposed need of their audience at the time.

But I'd be interested to know if you have the same attitude to the entire range of emotion from a politician on the trail?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

not excesses of emotion. In a presidential candidate I expect to see someone in control of themselves when in public. A candidate who cries too easily (yes a matter of how I define too easily) in public can just as easily lose his/her cool too easily and start a fight on the floor of the UN (or wherever critical).

Public control of my emotions is key to my success in my work and my life. My political representatives (and I use that term loosely) had better be able to exercise control of their emotions as the health of a nation rests on their daily public behavior in addition to their decision making process. Emotion does not belong there.

by drowningnotwaving

for anyone I felt was a machine.

I want to see emotion. I want to see enthusiasm. I want to see unbridled anticipation of a future. When they see injustice, I want them mad as hell. And when they see disaster (like 5,000 homes burning down in California and walking through the ruins with the folks), damn if they don't cry I'd be wonddering what actually makes them care.

If I wanted a spreadsheet and an accountant, I'd hire EY.

If I wanted a General to take me to the war, I'd join the army.

I'm very happy that my politicians, for the most part, are neither.

But that's just ME of course !!! :)

edit a fat-finger spellink erra

by absolutely

[i] I wouldn't vote for anyone I felt was a machine.[/i]

I've never met a machine-man, other than in fiction. I think your concern projects fiction onto fact, with the result of favoring the weak -- excessively emotional, specifically -- over the efficacious -- maximally in command of emotional reactions. That's a virtue, full stop.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is that I don't think it will ever happen, even if they lose their jobs, etc... I think they will destroy us first. It appears to me (and I may well be wrong as in fact I have not until that post perceived you as optimistic) that you think that given certain extreme circumstances things will change.

I think the world will end without things ever changing.

by absolutely

Believing that the evidence is that we all evolved from monkeys, I consider it self-evident that the remaining cavemen will also, eventually, catch up.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"I guess it is a little bit optimistic - Believing that the evidence is that we all evolved from monkeys, I consider it self-evident that the remaining cavemen will also, eventually, catch up."

I think that probably all the cavemen ever cared about was eating, sleeping and sex. The greed kings and power mongers probably don't even think about that. They crave money and power. While this appears to give them an advantage in the evolutionary scheme at the moment, it more than likely makes them the weakest in evolutionary terms. They will breed the next weak generation that will breed the next weak generation and that line should at some point become extinct due to an inability to survive without the trappings of money and power. And those trappings do tend to fail on occasion.

I figure that all that greed and power mongering is going to doom the planet in some fashion and we'll all bite it in the process.

Providing of course that evolutionary theory pans out.

edit freaking d*mn typos wish I could get some sleep

by jdclyde

Politicians are willing to do just about anything these days to get the power that they crave, regardless of the letter behind their name.

If we were to see Hilary break down, it would be a big negative for her because it would be so out of character that everyone would see how fake it was ( like her changing accents ).

The Romney deal might be a little more believable, but not being there it is hard to say.

I think most people would still see this as being a wuss and a negative rather than a plus for anyone that would try to use tears.

by av .

I missed Mitt's emotional displays, oh well. I think what most politicians say and do is pretty much scripted. Crying comes off as just another ploy to make people think they actually care, to me. Yawn. Crying on demand. Wonder if they have a coach?

If someone like John McCain cried though, I would believe him. The difference is that I think McCain is a true patriot and has integrity. I may not vote for him, but I think he is a real person with honest emotions.

Here is a real crackup. Mike Huckabee's Christmas card. He actually sat on TV and said he didn't notice the cleverly photographed bookcase that looks like a cross behind him. Really? It stands out to me. But this is the kind of BS that just cheapens him. Check it out if you didn't see it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xn7uSHtkuA

AV

by absolutely

[i]Here is a real crackup. Mike Huckabee's Christmas card. He actually sat on TV and said he didn't notice the cleverly photographed bookcase that looks like a cross behind him. Really? It stands out to me. But this is the kind of BS that just cheapens him.[/i]

I hadn't seen it. The + shape really does stand out, and it hardly seems likely that the coincidence with his words was entirely accidental, although that doesn't mean it was [i]his[/i] design. What stood out even more, to me, was how hard he seemed to be trying to seem sincere, to talk to the camera like all the viewers are his pals, and how little he got right about impersonating somebody who I'd want as a friend.

by jdclyde

it is controlled and scriped.

While it is POSSIBLE it was accidental, I did notice the "cross" was not a part of the whole message, and was replaced by the Christmas tree.

by av .

I agree that he's trying really hard to be your friend. The good guy. Your local minister.

Personally, I'm afraid of someone that portrays himself as a "real person" but uses a floating cross in his holiday card to subliminally tell everyone that he is a man of God.

He denies the cross was intentional, of course. Oh, sure, I believe that (NOT!). Its not what you do sometimes, its how you do it. He's being dishonest.

AV

by nicknielsen

...Dr. Neil Clark Warren of eHarmony fame. No, I wouldn't buy a used car from this man.

Edit: tyop

by deepsand

I've a hard time reconciling his record as Governor with his words of the past and present.

This is not to say that he did not have the courage to take unpopular stands as Governor, but rather that he lacks consistency, both in word and in deed.

by deepsand

It is obviously intended as a subliminal message to the evangelical right, who he's desperately hoping to successfully court.

If one compares his present stance in this regards with his track record as the accidental Governor of Arkansas, one will notice a significant lack of consistency between his words, his acts, and the desires of his present target audience.

This is yet but another example of a politician pandering for votes, by way of telling the crowd of the moment what they want to hear.

by nicknielsen

I don't have any direct recall. ;) I have, of course, seen and read the speech in history classes and know the background and immediate results.

I'm not sure a Checkers-style speech would salvage a political career today; we are much more cynical and much less accepting of politicians' faults and foibles. Over the past 40 years or so, almost any public display of emotion by a presidential candidate has pretty much been the kiss of death for that campaign. Displays of emotion under personal stress have inevitably caused the media to call into question the "emotional stability" of the candidate. Gotta sell air time somehow, I guess.

by deepsand

Was the panning from the "cross" to the tree accidental?

Did the editors and producer(s) accidently miss seeing the connotation?

In both instances, I think not.

He's clearly pandering to the evangelical right.

by jdclyde

[i]"He's clearly pandering to the evangelical right."[/i]

who is it he should be pandering to then? You?

by deepsand

Several days ago he held a press conference, for the purpose of stating that he had decided to take the "high road," and not run any further negative ads re. Romney. As part of that conference, he played the very ad that he said he would not be running; which was of course filmed and re-broadcast.

When asked why he had done so, he responded that had he not shown it, he may of been accused of fabricating his decision to not show it, and that showing it was therefore the "right thing to do."

Kind of like saying "I was going to accuse my (female) opponent of being a slut, but now I'm not going to."

by absolutely

... the ad was, with or without the cross, symptomatic of an approach to campaigning that just doesn't have the potential to impress me, however carefully it's done. I know everybody puts on their pants one leg at a time, that many of these dudes have families and they all have lives outside of their work. I'm not voting for their home life, I'm voting for their voting record. I don't expect 'Seasons Greetings' from politicians who aren't also personal acquaintances, I expect them to uphold the Constitution and the rights that it guarantees.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"I'm not voting for their home life, I'm voting for their voting record."
"I expect them to uphold the Constitution and the rights that it guarantees."

Unfortunately, it appears that far too many Americans pay little to no attention to the voting record of their politicians. The remainder appear to have a very short attention span in addition to severe, short-term memory loss.

by av .

Its just too bad that most people don't bother looking at the voting record. They go by the campaign speeches and never look any deeper. Thats why Mike Huckabee's Christmas card is so effective.

Evangelicals are looking for a religious man in the Whitehouse that will overturn Roe vs. Wade and appoint conservative judges. It pretty much doesn't matter what else he does or doesn't do. He must have the wife and kids, though, and be of a mainstream religion. No Mormons need apply or dysfunctional families.

I think the "Seasons Greetings" cards are appropriate for this time of year, but I wouldn't base my vote on them either. I sure don't like subliminal messages, like the cross in Mike Huckabee's card though, but lots of people are swayed by them.

I don't know who our next President will be, its too close to call, but I hope we choose more wisely this time.

AV

by absolutely

Being in an IT forum, I can't resist:

Maybe what "most Americans" are lacking is a comprehensive database of candidates' voting records. One easily-foreseeable side effect of such a thing, once widely used, would be a new level of vigilance on the part of the elected to oppose "riders," which would have the effect of putting each representative on a publicly-viewed record, voting for each issue represented in every bill, whether they bother to read the entire bill, or not.

by absolutely

[i]For him to claim ignorance of the matter lacks any shred of credibility.[/i]

It's fishy, definitely. However, I'm sure his voting record is far worse.

by deepsand

you still can't make it float on its back and blow bubbles.

My life experiences tell me that providing voters with more information will have little effect outside those very few who are already willing and able to both properly understand and act accordingly.

by absolutely

[i]My life experiences tell me that providing voters with more information will have little effect outside those very few who are already willing and able to both properly understand and act accordingly.[/i]

But not applicable to humans; the difference between information in higher quantities and a higher ratio of useful information is missing from your analysis.

by deepsand

A quick review of the tenure of the "accidental Governor" of Arkansas yields what appears to be a study in contradictions, a portrait of a man prone to giving too much attention to his own little inner voice of the moment, and not enough to the voices of others.

This is not one to whom I would entrust the bully-pulpit of the White House.

by deepsand

process as quickly as possible.

Witness the great number who blindly accept religious dogma.

Witness the great difficulty to be had in making reasonable decisions on matters that directly affect their own personal lives in the short and near terms.

Witness here alone the propensity to not merely disregard, but actively avoid knowledge of facts that serve to rebut deeply held beliefs.

by absolutely

[i]A quick review of the tenure of the "accidental Governor" of Arkansas yields what appears to be a study in contradictions...[/i]

Yes, I could Google it, but if you have already filtered out the shallow & obvious, I'd be grateful to go straight to the highlights, or in this case indicative lowlights, and skip the irrelevant.

by absolutely

... to make the desired information available more [u]conveniently[/u]. If it is not convenient, it will appear impossible to many to find information that can be compiled, stored, and made available by a relatively small team.

by deepsand

act accordingly [b]even if personally delivered to them.[/b]

This is a lesson that I began to learn at a very early age, the earliest remembered case involving a wage increase won by steelworkers, the following increase in the price of steel, and the eventual rise in the costs of automobiles, refrigerators, and all those other products built of steel.

When the steelworkers succeeded in winning their wage hike, the working class cheered; and, when the prices of said mentioned goods, they were most unhappy.

When I asked if they understood that those price increase were the result of steelworkers wages having been substantially increased, they responded that "Well, yes; but, the steel companies were not "forced" to raise the price of steel. When I tried to explain to my elders that there is a distinction between that which one can/cannot do, may/may not do, and will/will not do, I was brushed of with "You're too young to understand. Just you wait; you'll see."

These are people for whom there can be no reasonable expectation that an increase in data will lead to a proportional increase in knowledge and understanding, let alone a rational active response to such.

by absolutely

It reminded me of his backtracking from some comment equating to Mormonism to Satanism [my ignorance of Mormon and of Huckabee's dipwitticisms are running neck-and-neck], which he explained, he [u]intended[/u] to mean that he would not talk about Mormon. For a fraction of a second, I thought that's a classy position to take on an opponent's religion, then I realized that if that was really his [u]entire[/u] intent, he should have just said "I will not talk about Mormon," and not talked about Mormon.

Do you know what is the only thing that is [u]not[/u] easier said than done?

by absolutely

of issues, or analyze long-term costs of short-term advantages to various collectives to an economic ideal. However, I think a lot of "riders" are worthless, and easily recognizable as such on cursory inspection, and if Pareto's Law applies -- and it always does! -- 80% improvement can be had for 20% effort, by identifying the most pertinent information in any complex system.

by deepsand

However, being the cynic that I've come to be, I would point out that such strictures are already in place in several legislatures, to little or no beneficial effect.

PA has such a provision in its Constitution, reading "[i]No bill shall be passed containing more than one subject, which shall be clearly expressed in its title, except a general appropriation bill or a bill codifying or compiling the law or a part thereof.[/i]", but our Supreme Court has given exceedingly great latitude to the definition of "related." A recent case in point is that of legalizing Slot parlors here.

What began a a 2 paragraph bill relating to the background checks required for harness racing employees saw a 145 page slots amendment added, which was then passed in the dead of night, before a holiday adjournment, without public comment.

Furthermore, it contained a unique provision that only the state Supreme Court had "[i]exclusive jurisdiction to hear any challenge.[/i]"

In speaking for said court, the Chief Justice stated "[i]Since the Complaint is based on challenges to the constitutionality of the statute, we must begin by considering the standard by which we resolve constitutional challenges to legislative actions. First, our case law makes clear that there is a strong presumption in the law that legislative enactments do not violate our Constitution. ... This includes the manner by which legislation is enacted. [b]All doubts are to be resolved in favor of finding that the legislative enactment passes constitutional muster.[/b] Thus, there is a very heavy burden of persuasion upon one who challenges the constitutionality of a statute.[/i]"

He continued with "[i]there is a single unifying subject - the regulation of gaming[/i]," this despite another Constitution provisions which reads "[i]No law shall be passed except by bill, and no bill shall be so altered or amended, on its passage through either House, as to change its original purpose.[/i]"

In that regard, the Court turned the case on its head, by stating that they ruled the slots law was constitutional "[i][b]not by comparing[/b] the [b]original purpose to the purpose at final passage[/b], but by considering only the bill at final passage.[/i]"

And, to add insult to injury, said Justice concluded with "[i]Furthermore, our Court is loathe to substitute our judgment for that of the legislative branch under the pretense of determining whether an unconstitutional change in purpose of a piece of legislation has occurred during the course of its enactment.[/i]"

And, to think that along I believed that such was precisely the Court's intended function!

As for the voters, those who don't gamble, and whose neighborhoods are unaffected, don't care; those who do, and for whom Slots is their passions, love it because they no longer have to trek to Atlantic City or further.

by absolutely

I might have hoped a judge would have a bit more backbone, but I can't say I'm surprised. If anybody would be expert at circumventing legislation, don't you think it would be a legislator? But, as certain activities, particularly in New Hampshire and Iowa are now demonstrating, legislators do have an Achilles' Heel; whether they're campaigning for office in the Executive Branch or for re-election in the Legislative, they are at the mercy of public opinion at all times. That is why I think it wise to make a concise summary of their voting records, which includes not just the title of bills and their tiresome complete text, but something more like an Abstract, to include separate summaries of each section which [i]should[/i] be a separate bill, and summarizing each representative's voting record per thus-identified issue, not just on the nominal topic of the eventual bill.

by deepsand

Still, it's a very sad commentary indeed when a majority of the Judges of the oldest Appellate Court in the land cannot not only fail to reason well, but are unable to more effectively disguise such failure by way of a plausible argument.

BTW, the U.S. House Rules do in fact prohibit non-germane amendments, under Rule XVI, Clause 7, with several additional references to such elsewhere in said Rules. See http://www.rules.house.gov/ruleprec/110th.pdf

However, as said Rules do not carry the full weight of Statutory Law, they are easily and frequently bent to the point of breaking.

The U.S. Senate Rules do allow of non-germane amendments in all but a very few instances.

This discussion is closed to new replies.