Question Locked

the Yankees are coming to town vs. the Yankees is coming to town

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Let's say that the Yankees baseball team is coming to town. I know that it sounds better to say that the Yankees are coming to town. However, why couldn't you say that the Yankees is coming to town since the Yankees is one team. If you are talking about individual Yankees, then yes use "are" coming, but as a single team why can you not use "is" coming?

7 replies

by thumbsup2

Because, when you say "The Yankees", it is understood that you're speaking of all of the players (plural). When you say "The Yankees baseball team", you're speaking of one single thing... the team which happens to be named Yankees.

by artie

Your point is that of "understanding" or assumed. I'm talking about technicalities. So technically speaking saying the Yankees is coming to town should be just as correct as the Yankees are coming to town. It doesn't sound right but technically it should be correct.

by tig2

The "Yankees" implies the entirety of the team which is plural.

Therefore, "The Yankees ARE coming to town" conveys the meaning that all of the team are coming.

The "Yankee" is coming to town is singular. It implies that only one will come to town.

Therefore, "The Yankee IS coming to town" would be correct.

Then, based on your geographical location, you may need to eludicate- the Yankee could refer to a member of a specific baseball team or might refer to a person who is from the North.

You just gotta love American!

P.S. I are one!

by older mycroft

Erm... Don't you mean 'English'?

'American' as in the spelling of written words usually only applies to the words that have suffered bastardization at the hands of the American populace; words like 'Aluminum', 'Color', 'Honor', 'Nucular'.

'Are' and 'Is' still retain their English spelling.

by santeewelding

You may start a thousand-post discussion about language consumers/controllers fraught with subterfuge and ethics, paradigms, dinosaurs, and God knows what else.

by rfink

Collective nouns i.e. "state", "company", "team", "everyone", "everybody". are singular. How many times do we when refer to the government as "they" instead of "it"? All the time. The answer to the poster's question should be "is". The Yankees is coming to town.

Bear in mind due to political correctness nouns refering to people are being referred as "they, them, theirs,etc" even in the singular because "he" and "she" are considered sexist.

I see it alot. Classical English grammer requires that a group of people of mixed or unknown sex be referred to as "he".
Example: Everyone should order his supplies today."

This discussion is closed to new replies.