Discussion Locked

This is about I get managed

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a manager who has the philosophy that "I don't thank people for doing their jobs - that's what we pay them for" The consequence, I think, is that when she does speak of something, it's something that's gone wrong or tht could have been done better. This has had an effect on my morale and that of the people I manage.

I will say that neither me nor my folks are perfect, but some of the things I've wanted to try have been rejected in favor of how she thinks the department ought to run. For example, when I first signed on and was not responsible for anyone, I saw that calls or problems needed to be assigned to someone who'd be responsible for it (there was no HD software in place) Boss didn't like that. She thinks the calls should be recieved and just 'taken' by whoever could do it. Nothing central, no escalation procedures. Another example - when she asked what could be done so that people remembered what was said at weekly meetings, I suggested a rotating minute-taker.No dice.

I've been really frustrated about this because I know we can do better, but I don't know where to start to convince her to try something different - which by the way, is something she lectures us on - think outside the box - prove thatsomething won't work.

Any clues, ideas, pills?

9 replies

by kelly_aitch

How much autonomy does she give you in managing your own people? If you are responsible for people, I would think you would be able to run your group as you see fit. However, the reality may be that you are being micromanaged to death. Do what you can.

If your group is responsible for support, can you assign jobs to people? Can you give them responsibility for solving and closing the call?

As for weekly meetings, what if you took your own notes and made them freely available to other attendees? Even set up your own mailing list of those interested and publish your private minutes. This could be a valuable CYA initiative.

How are your management skills? Your most challenging management task may be running interference for your staff to keep this person off their backs and let them get the job done.

Good luck

by g'nat

There's autonomy and there's autonomy. I can assign jobs, but what she wants everyone to do is somehow assign jobs to themselves. So, there is no one person to triage - if you can solve a problem, take the call. If you can't, or you don't know you can, then you're supposed to ask - which to me is a back a**ward way of assigning things anyway.

I like your idea of my own notes. I have taken some but not of every little thing - and I have the feeling if I did she might ask why, but at this point I'm willing to do anything.

When I started my management skills were pretty poor. I took some classes, read some books, and there has been improvement in my performance as well as the technician's - of course not enough if you beleive my boss. And yes, being in the middle has been the greatest challenge, because if I try to run interference, she feels cut off from them. If I don't, they feel put upon.

I used to bcc her on my scoldings to them. She didn't notice, so she'd start adding her own comments, which just made everything worse.

btw, there are only two choices on ratings, so I'm only marking this "unacceptable" because I'd like to hear from others. I just want to say that I appreciated your clarity.

by wayne m.

Apparently you and your manager disagree on how well things are working. Try documenting how well the current process is working. Look at things such as how long it takes to resolve calls and how well the calls are resolved (i.e. no call backs fora single problem).

Once you have the data, you have a starting point for a discussion with your manager. You can high light problem areas and you have an established yardstick for comparison to determine if a proposed improvement actually helps.

You and your manager have different styles. To resolve this, you will have to go beyond subjective evaluations and get to some objective evaluations you both can agree upon.

by g'nat

"You and your manager have different styles. To resolve this, you will have to go beyond subjective evaluations and get to some objective evaluations you both can agree upon. "

That's very true. I'm working on that now. Thanks.

by ckilday

First off, I like what kelly_aitch said about taking your own notes. Not only is it good CYA, but it does fill a need in your organization. Until you can get your boss to see your side of things, you may just have to extend yourself to fill the gaps you see. I also like what Wayne M. had to say about compiling statistics to prove your case objectively. The difficulty you may encounter is how to track those things if she hasn't provided you with any automated tools. Consider obtaining some HD eval software and see if you and your staff can put it to good use.

As for my original contribution, I'd suggest you sit down with your boss and find out what makes her successful to her bosses. Be blunt. Ask her what she's being held accountable for and what it takes for her to meet those objectives. Once you know what she needs, you can begin to craft your arguments for the changes you want to implement in light of her objectives. If you can show her how your changes will make her successful, I expect you will find less resistance to the change...even if it means spending money! It sounds like you have a good grasp on what your organization and your subordinates need to be successful. Help your boss to succeed and all of you will prosper. Best wishes,
- ck

by g'nat

"As for my original contribution, I'd suggest you sit down with your boss and find out what makes her successful to her bosses"

Actually, we (she) has talked about this. What she gets are vague instructions, and impatience when she asks questions. What makes her successful is not aggrivating her near-retirement boss and not bothering him with too many details.

by realgem

Well, I think that the first thing to do is start agreeing with her. But, I don't mean sucking up. As weird as it may sound, she may have a good reason (as she perceives it) for doing things that way.

I suggest that you try to improve her process. If she wants people to manage their own assignments, then maybe you could develop or find a process that will let people manage their requests (including prioritization and reporting). But, make sure you find one that will let people pass the requests on to others. I think that you'll get part of what you want.

As for the meetings, and I know this sucks, if it's important to remember what happens at the meetings, then maybe you could bite the bullet and keep abbreviated notes. See if it improves things.

There is no magic bullet or pill. But, you can sneak in the back way. Come up with suggestions that will actually SUPPORT your manager, while meeting your agenda at the same time. After some successes, and especially those that make your manager look good, she should start to listen more closely to your suggestions. She just has to realize that it's in her best interests.

Good luck.

by g'nat

"As for the meetings, and I know this sucks, if it's important to remember what happens at the meetings, then maybe you could bite the bullet and keep abbreviated notes. See if it improves things. "

I have started doing that. I've given up on what she thinks is right in some situations and just doing what I think (and what other service experts think) is my job. If that means staying extra hours to get other things done, then that's it. If she questions the time I'm spending doing stuff, well, then she's got all the more reason to ask for another position.

Thanks to everyone for your responses!

This discussion is closed to new replies.