Time for a gas tax
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
I said China/India.
All I said about the environmentalists is they are using that demand to lie to the world about why the price has gone up so far and what we should be doing about it.
environmentalists are using this to push their agenda, and are willing to say anything to anyone to get their goal.
As people start to wise up, the world will see the econuts for the deceitful bunch they are.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]So did ... the Chicago fire and the San Francisco earthquake.[/i]
Funny. But I don't know of anybody claiming that an income tax is necessary, in order to cause disasters. The argument is generally that income taxes are necessary in order to have large enough budgets to pay for large projects, like the transcontinental railroad, and forgetting that useful large projects are feasible on the available budget, by definition of the word [u]useful[/u].
by delbertpgh
If human contributions to atmospheric CO2 are causing the earth to warm, then it's all humanity... not just the Indians and Chinese. In other words, it's us, too.
You're right, that the that the Asians who are becoming rich will use more and more energy, so if we take expesive measures to cut back on carbon production, they will be exactly nullified by the Chinese and all ramping up their economies on the cheapest available fuel. None the less, I don't see how we all can go on drilling holes in the bottom of our boat, and blame the Chinese, saying "If I stop first, I lose to them."
It will take 20 years at the very minimum to move into a different kind of energy economy. We've got to do so for security and financial reasons, in addition to any tree-hugging logic. (Or Hilton Head loving... if the waters go up, that place goes away.) Which, by the way, brings us back to what we can do in that direction, and the simplest, easiest, and most effective thing is to shift more of our tax burden onto gasoline.
by jdclyde
we do it because we need oil until alternatives come out and get the infrasturure they need in place.
You don't stop breathing today to save oxygen for next week.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]an increase in barrel price of $10/barrel would equate to a few cents more at the pump (after refining).[/i]
My cost at the pump now is about $4/Gal and barrels are trading around $130
IIRC, when I was paying about $2/Gal the cost of a barrel was $60-$70
Do you have records showing pump price vs. barrel price?
by delbertpgh
There are 42 gallons in a "barrel" of crude. I don't know where they got this barrel size, but that's the standard.
At $135 a barrel, that's $3.21 for the raw material alone, forget about transport, refining, distribution, and retail charges.
by delbertpgh
The first time I heard this term, I thought about my draft physical. "Doctorgonnacheckyourbuttforhemmorhoids. Turnfacethewallbendovergrabyourbuttandcrackyourcheeks. Now, maggot!"
The crack spread is the difference between the price of a barrel of crude on the spot (immediate purchase) market, and the price of one-month futures for a barrel of refined product. (Refining is the process of catlytic cracking of hydrocarbon chains; financial spread is the difference between prices in different markets or different times. Thus, crack... spread.) You can buy futures and accurately simulate the economics of refining petroleum. In fact, oil companies do this a lot, as a hedge against the unexpected.
Some times, the crack spread is negative, meaning refiners are losing money on their business. However, if the refinery is owned by an oil producing company, it's making so damn much on crude that it doesn't care.
by oz_media
Crack spread, invented/produced in East L.A. and packaged/distributed by Kraft.
That little teddy bear on the peanut butter jars has gone bad. Twitchy Bear!
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]The lie environmentalists want us to believe
...Is that this is caused because of America and their big bad SUV's, and if we all switch to hybrids and sing qumbiya, all will be well in the world.[/i]
Who exactly says that?
All I said about the environmentalists is they are using that demand to lie to the world about why the price has gone up so far and what we should be doing about it.
And I posted a link to a perspective from the mainstream media expressing a very different analysis, without any overt "environmentalist" agenda. Rather than being caused by supply being tight compared to the new demand from China/India, which is the standard line from the non-OPEC petroleum corporations, much of the recent spike in price is caused by speculation. No, you may not have your scapegoat back.
by delbertpgh
I've seen a lot in the financial press about the rise in oil prices. The cause is a mystery to most analysts, who figure that Asian demand plus spot shortages plus the Bush factor accounts for only part of what's going on now. In other words, psychological factors (greed and bubble mentality) are driving it. Don't be too surprised by a crash some day.
India and China will keep pushing world demand higher for a long time, and pressure will always be there to move the price up. The world has got to figure out a non-carbon-energy way to industrialize, because there are another five billion guys out there who will all get to be rich some day, and in the long term, we will choke on the gasses we produce.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
by delbertpgh
by oz_media
"In 2008, taxes in Canada represented on average 35% of the pump price versus 20% in the U.S. Taxes include a Federal Excise Tax of 10.0? for Regular, 4.0? for Diesel and Provincial Tax. "
http://www.bcgasprices.com/can_tax_info.aspx
So actually, at $1.40 per litre, there is over 50 cents per litre in taxes, that's roughly $2 US dollars per gallon.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
[i]YOu can't expect me to believe that it costs as much to get oil to my gas station as it does to get to Arkansas or even Vancouver Island for that matter.[/i]
But I don't expect bread to cost more the farther away the store is from the bakery either.
You have a million of something... it's going to cost x to deliver it to everywhere it's going. You divide x by a million and build that into the cost of each thing.
[i]The largest western refinery and HO for Canada's largest oil company is about 15 minutes from my front door![/i]
Did your gas station's fuel come from that refinery?
[i]I want cheap gas damnit![/i]
I haven't used my truck in almost a year. I paid $2.7(something) for the gas that's in the tank right now. I wonder if I should siphon it out and sell it for a profit.
by oz_media
Yes, Petro Canada AND Chevron are within walking distance.
As for teh cost of bread, much of the grain being shipped to the US to make bread is coming from Canada too. But bread is over $2 a loaf at most places.
Income taxes are all bad -- however the govt. seems to be gouging us and the rate is way too high. And for what?
So that I can pay for things that I dont care about in many cases.
So that the government can fund more and more projects which may infringe on my freedoms.
I have no problem paying some taxes, however I would like to decide which projects that I would pay for.
by tonythetiger
yields roughly 20 gallons of gasoline, a $10 jump should raise prices 50 cents a gallon.
Then since we've had a roughly $60 per barrel increase in the last two years, one would think that the price of gas should have went up $3.00 in that time. Since it hasn't, I must assume that someone is absorbing some of the increase. I strongly suspect that that someone is us, in the form of tax breaks to the oil industry.
That's nice of us :)
by $$$$$$$$$$
"I have no problem paying some taxes, however I would like to decide which projects that I would pay for."
You want to vote directly for a referendum, not on a representative who claims to take some kind of blend of my interests and my neighbors' interests to DC, then votes for the lobbyists.
by oz_media
I suppose, by some people's terms, that makes it a 'standard' but only the US uses that unit of measure so it is a US standard if anything.
"The 42 US gallon size of barrel as a unit of measure is largely confined to the American oil industry, since other sizes of barrel were used by other industries in the United States, and nearly all other countries use the metric system."
by delbertpgh
by oz_media
In the UK it is not considered a 42 (US) gallon barrel, they see a 34.9723 (Imperial)gal barrel, Canada sells in 158.9873 (Metric litre)barrels.
"[b]The standard oil barrel is used in the United States as a measure of crude oil[/b] and other petroleum products.
[b]Elsewhere, oil is more commonly measured in cubic metres (m3) or in tonnes (t)[/b], with tonnes often being used by companies that ship most of their oil by sea."
Is the USA's 42 gallon barrel actually a standard then? As I said, in America yes, around the world the volume changes.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
From Wiki: "The current standard volume for barrels for chemicals and food is 55 US gallons (46 imp gal/208 L)."
From me: farm grade gasoline or oil is marked and is for industrial/farm use only. This is probably a reason for the different sizing, as with other chemicals.
by delbertpgh
It says that in 2008, about 35% of the pump price was tax. In Vancouver, you have:
$0.10 federal
.21 province
.06 transit
.07 GST
or 44 cents total. At 3.78 liters/gallon, that comes out to $1.66 tax per gallon.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
As illustrated by the Petro Canada bio, the cost of crude bears little on the refined price of oil. In my rant I was running on about how the pipelines are visible and run to a refinery a few minutes from my house. Why is MY gas so expensive?
Because we chose to become a part of global oil pricing, we are stuck following the lead of clowns who set high prices. The cost of extracting crude doesn't rise that much at all, in fact once the pipeline in built and pumps are installed, it is merely a maintenance cost. They haven't built any new pipes or pumps out here to justify a 'cost' increase, the cost of refining is immense in comparison though.
A refining cost is the variable not the drilling and pumping cost. BUT, the cost of refining is offset into the drilling/pumping cost and hidden into the price per barrel.
Either way, they are scamming us and unlike other corporations here, they are not forced to offer any retail price protection. That would really change things!
Canadian law offers consumer price protection, regardless of what the retailer states, if you find a lower advertised price from the same company within 14 days, they must honor the lower price and rebate the difference.
Yesterday, gas was 146.9L on he way to work, and 138.6L at the same station on the way home. If they were held to retail price protection laws, they would not be able to quickly play the pricing game, or they would end up spending all day refunding overcharges.
It's a scam, not a crisis. If there was lower demand, prices would drop in the long-term, but not instantly. We need to reduce our dependance on oil for a good year before we see any financial benefit.
Now if everyone stopped bitching and arguing about whether climate change was a real issue or not and instead focused on conserving energy anyway, we would see a benefit.
Look at it this way, if climate change is REALLY a political game, then could it not be a game simply to create enough doubt that people don't start conserving energy? This would keep oil prices high, which in turn makes Arabs rich, which in turn increases Middle Eastern investment in the USA. It is in the government's best interests to keep oil prices high, not low. Rich Arabs make rich investors and you NEED those rich investors in the USA.
As long as people play the disbelief game and waste resources in spite of better judgement, then we are stuck with the high prices due to demand.
by tonythetiger
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]... even WITH conservation efforts, there will still be pressure on usage to increase, simply because the population is increasing.[/i]
Is that based on scientific projections of population growth and feasible conservation measures, or more mystical revelation?
by oz_media
all we need to do, according to other posters on TR, is to allow gay marriage.
Now, as to why I wouldn't vote for one - does no one else understand that their behaviour is counter-survival to our species? How can I expect someone to represent my best interests when he has already demonstrated that he is not interested in preserving humanity?
That would cull the herd, fa@s don't reproduce and apprently we don't have any other form of impregnating women other than through male/female contact.
Once all the world is gay, we will die off. LOL :D
Oh gawd, some of thee loons crack me up. I didn't realize they still had such deep woods, backward mentalities still.
by $$$$$$$$$$
We only need to return to the Gold Standard.
[i]Rich Arabs make rich investors and you NEED those rich investors in the USA.[/i]
Only because irresponsible printing of more promissory notes steals value from all dollars already earned, in favor of those not yet earned.
by oz_media
Just because there is a reason that their investments are so important, doesn't mean that it isn't so.
America and most others rely heavily on foreign investment to support their ecomony.
With the trillions of dollars invested in teh USA from Mumbai alone, losing that investment would kill your economy.
This is also exactly why the big push for friends is on in the Middle East. If they ALL start to trade in PetroEuros instead of Petrodollars, as some do already, then they will have no reason to invest in the USA and will start getting their money back and selling off investments in order to reinvest in Euros elsewhere. That'll go down well in America, at least Starbucks would lose thier main competition.
by jck
you would keep smoking crack too because you'd think it's great you have it and you feel like there's nothing wrong with using as much as you want...
but when it comes down to it, you'd end up broke from using too much, you get a dependence on it, if your supplier goes away you won't be able to cope or keep your life together without it, and it's the big contributor to harming things around you.
just food for thought :)
Have a nice weekend.
by jdclyde
and I am concerned about a supplier CAN go away, I replace them as the supplier BEFORE they can go away. Businesses do it all the time if a vendor is not able to keep up with their demand.
Why is it perfectly acceptable for Canada to drill their own oil, but not the US? Isn't that very hypocritical? Shouldn't the econuts be protesting to get ALL drilling shut down? Or is it really just the American economy that is in the sights here?
Watch out for next wednesday. The house is trying to pass a measure so we will also be able to drill our oil off-shore instead of [b]stupidly[/b] sitting back while the Chinese and Mexicans drill it all. The sub vote went right along party lines, but the full committee will vote to bring it to the floor or not on Wednesday. Has Pelosi given the marching orders to keep from doing anything to improve our energy crisis?
I think we need to outlaw air conditioning, because it uses up to much energy AND the motors generate a lot of heat. Willing to give up your air conditioning for a cause you pretend to care about?
by jck
If the earth's supply of oil or clean air goes away, you're not going to find another supplier...are you? Good luck with that search.
As for Canada drilling, I've never said anything against it. I've never said anything against us drilling for oil...now have I?
My concern is when it comes to the track record of oil companies being responsible to create technologies that would prevent contamination of the ecosystem, they have been very lackadaisical in doing so and often [b]forced[/b] by national, state, and provincial government to do what is right in running their business.
I am concerned whenever an oil company is drilling somewhere like off-shore or in a pristine habitat, because the amount of damage that can be done is astonishing. You should go down to the Gulf of Mexico sometime after a platform or tanker leaks some oil.
As for "econuts", there are the radicals who would rather no one use any natural resource. I like the idea of eliminating the need for dependence on fossil fuels totally, but it won't happen (and I don't expect it to) until business gets off their arse and their wallet and really puts forth an effort to develop alternative technology without government welfare footing the bill for it.
As for outlawing air conditioning: that's fine with me. But, it takes more heating oil to heat a home in the winter than it does oil or coal to power AC for a home in the summer. Heat pumps are much more efficient systems than oil heating systems.
As for giving up air conditioning: I live without it for about 8-9 months of the year, so sure. I'd do that. I've lived without AC before growing up where it was regularly over 100 in July and August. So living in 90-94 temps is no biggie.
Question is, if I give up my AC...will you give up your heat?
From the 'official' sites that I have been reading from they are trying to mislead everyone.
When they are talking about 42 gallon barrels to make 20 gallons of gas (even you say the #'s dont add up) this is only because a percentage of the barrel us used for gas.
On these same sites it states that 1.5 gallons of crude makes 1 gallon of gas -- however they leave out several items.
First, they are measuring from the total barrel amount -- which a large portion is used for other things than gas.
Second -- this is before refining, so they should say something like 'gasoline grade crude'.
Now lets add some common sense to it. After refining, gasoline is very 'thin' while crude is much thicker. In refining they need to thin it out, this uses additives.
While you may be told that 44 gallons crude = 20 gallons of gas, this is only accurate before processing and is only meant to mislead the facts.
While I dont have the exact #'s avail (I will look a bit this weekend) I have read that refining 1 gallon of crude provides 1.5 - 2 gallons of refined gasoline.
And, going by these #'s (do the math) it coincides with the huge bankroll that gas companies are reporting
apparently the energy used to refine gasoline eats over 40% of what it creates.
However, what I have read states that this still depends on additives. Also to note that there is very little lost (mass) from beginning to end, that each part is used for something. As it is treated and refined, it is separated into different oils and gasses. the end result is almost nothing lost from start to finish.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Those big refining tanks are actually pretty cool. The sludge for grease and farm tractors is at the bottom of the tank, cooking oil from the top of the tank and diesel and gasoline close to hte top but not quite fully refined.
I've visited a couple and have seen/studied the process in trade school; its actually pretty simple and very straight forward. As for additives, they constitute such a minuscule portion of the finished product that they don't merit having a size of value applied to them, most of it it simply detergents with a few little combustion enhancers to make up for skimming too low in the refining tank.
by nicknielsen
by tonythetiger
[i]My concern is when it comes to the track record of oil companies being responsible to create technologies that would prevent contamination of the ecosystem,[/i]
Uh... They're [b]OIL[/b] companies...
Would you expect or demand that Hostess and McDonalds come out with a line of exercise equipment?
by jdclyde
for most of last winter... admittedly not by choice though...
AC is a luxury, keeping from freezing is not. (but of course you already know that)
We are talking the same as an SUV vs Hybrid, it is descressionairy on how much you use and what you use it for.
Anwar is not a "pristine habitat", it is a wasteland. Drilling off-shore is going to be done anyways, so it is assinine to say everyone but us will do it. Clearly another intentional effort by our government (Democrats) to (as Bill Clintion advised) "slow down our economy" for the sake of the environment.
Unlike Democrats, I am not willing to turn the US into a third world country just because they have self loathing for having a better life than many in the world do.
by jck
by jck
[i]for most of last winter... admittedly not by choice though...[/i]
sorry you went without.
[i]AC is a luxury, keeping from freezing is not. (but of course you already know that) [/i]
you can die from heat exposure just as easily as from cold. did you know that?
[i]We are talking the same as an SUV vs Hybrid, it is descressionairy on how much you use and what you use it for.[/i]
thing is, most people use little (if any) discretion in regards to what kind of car they buy and how much they use it. personal responsibility and humility both seem to be a thing of the past.
[i]Anwar is not a "pristine habitat", it is a wasteland. [/i]
wasteland? haha. i guess all the lakes and forests in Michigan are too. maybe they should drill for oil there?
[i]Drilling off-shore is going to be done anyways, so it is assinine to say everyone but us will do it. [/i]
huh?
[i]Clearly another intentional effort by our government (Democrats) to (as Bill Clintion advised) "slow down our economy" for the sake of the environment. [/i]
and you pick on me about being down on Bush?
[i]Unlike Democrats, I am not willing to turn the US into a third world country just because they have self loathing for having a better life than many in the world do.[/i]
But at this point, the administration of your government is turning America into a third world country. Why not go and fix the problems of the present, rather than dwell on the past?
BTW...ever been to a third world country? I went to Mexico in the late 1980s, and believe me. We are a far cry from being 3rd world. But, our economy is turning toward it. Impoverished middle class, high unemployment, etc.
And lastly: having a better life...is not exclusively dependent on gluttony and vanity. Because you can do something doesn't mean you should do it out of an exercise in self-indulgence.
And wanting to strive to make the world a cleaner, healthier place by being conscientious about your habits and practices is not "self-loathing"...it's called "responsibility".
by wayoutinva
by wayoutinva
by jdclyde
just pleasure driving?
Any and all other fuel increases raise the costs of doing business, which gets passed on to the consumer.
Simple minds will think increasing the gas taxes will be good for us.
by wayoutinva
"Simple minds will think increasing the gas taxes will be good for us."
I have yet to really see anybody who is advocating higher gas taxes also come out and point out that "oh by the way pretty much everything else will go up in price as well when we raise the fuel tax". That part seems to be forgotten or simply not said..
by tonythetiger
[i]you can die from heat exposure just as easily as from cold. did you know that?[/i]
Wearing multiple layers of clothing can help prevent both.
[i]And lastly: having a better life...is not exclusively dependent on gluttony and vanity
[/i]
But do you have the right to define that for someone else?
by tonythetiger
[i]But, I'd expect them to come up with the equipment so that the Twinkie goes in the wrapper, and not vice versa.[/i]
oil companies should do this... how?
by notsochiguy
I would actually argue that somehow reigning in the speculative aspect of trading oil commodities would do more for the price, than any tax, and would have lasting benefits.
From what I've read and gleamed in hallway conversation (I work for a firm that deals with financial markets), up to a third of the price of oil is purely speculative.
So, you're paying a high price for a lot of 'What If'.
What if it is a bad hurricane season?? (but what if it isn't)
What if war breaks out against Iran?? (but what if it doesn't)
What if America never increases capacity?? (what if we do)
Seems like too many unknown variables going into something that is a fixed need. Heck, even Saudi Arabia has admitted as much.
Oil gets traded, from what it seems, on a 'worst case scenario' basis. Perhaps using a formula similar to project management (you factor best case, worst case, and most likely delivery times to come up with your project time estimate) would help reduce oil prices??
Long term, though, I am in full agreement that moving away from the foreign oil dependence is priority #1, and then finding an alternative should be priority #1b.
by wayoutinva
by notsochiguy
Read about how China is essentially drilling for oil in US waters...pretty frustrating to realize how much of a quagmire political bickering has really put the citizenry into.
If the US were to utilize the reserves on which it sits (hence, reduce dependence on foreign oil), while proactively planning a move away from oil (saw that new Honda Hydro car on the news yesterday...intriguing), we'd be in a much better spot.
As is, we're pretty much funding everyone in the world that would like to nothing more than to see the US crumble. Bad position to be in, if you ask me!
by jdclyde
He MEANT find an alternate source for our oil for now.
THEN find a product to use instead of oil at plan 1b.
so, either you misunderstood, or just thought you were funny?
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
teach people to hate anyone who has "made it" because they MUST have cheated to get to where they are.
And of course, people short on thought throw the "greed" word around a lot. Making a profit is a good thing, and any company that doesn't goes out of business.
by jdclyde
we hear about how it is to the evil share holders all the money goes.
As soon as a share holder can make more of a return on their investment in a savings account, the company is toast. people that don't see that are dumb.
by notsochiguy
...is how much $$$ the envy mongers make by facilitating this garbage.
I grew up poor (about as poor as you can be and still have a roof over your head). A lot of my circle of influence when I was younger had a less than favorable view of those with more. Greed was about the most euphemistic term they'd use.
Well, now, here I am, 25+ years later, and I am doing pretty well for myself. Did I start back-stabbing, lying, cheating and stealing to get to where I'm at?
NO!!!
I actually paid attention in school, self-funded my college education, and worked my way up from the very bottom (temp pushing paper work) to establish a good employment track record.
In retrospect, if the people I had in my life when I was younger would have spent half the time working even the most menial of jobs as they did whining and moaning, they'd have a two comma amount in the bank by now.
Ask not what your country can do for you...get off your @ss and do it for yourself!!
by jck
Making a profit is the defining quality of any business which is going to be successful. Yes.
However, where do you draw the line between "selling at what the market calls for" and "exploiting the market"?
Gas prices have risen by about 50-60% in less than a year. In some areas, even more.
Neither OPEC nor any other body of petroleum resources has cut back their drilling or pumping. So, the supply has remained stable.
To me it seems, the oil producers and refiners are exploiting a market and taking advantage of speculative rumour and innuendo to drive prices up artificially.
Lots of people say that it is China and India driving up the price, but China is looking to get all their own oil. Their own government website even said they were exporting oil (i think it was over 3M barrels on the report i saw). If they had a shortage, why would they do that?
Plus, the new power plants they are putting online coal-fired. So, they are not using oil to make power like we do.
So why isn't it greed on part of the oil companies? Why do you see it as such a bad tag to put on them as "greedy", when most of the indicators point to manipulation of the market to raise prices based on "what if" speculation?
Don't you see an ethical issue with that? With driving the market up as high as you can to cause maximum profit with no valid supply reason?
Would you not think it was wrong if your grocery store said "all food is going up by 80%, because we think there's going to be real food shortages next year." and you had to pay $8-9 for a gallon of milk, or $10 for a 6 pack of beer?
Or, are you saying that anything in business that does not break the law is okay for a company to do to make profits??
As for me, I don't think people cheat to "make it" in this world. But, the vast majority do pull shady deals and the like.
You don't see many business people anymore in leadership roles who got there through 30 years of service to a company. Most of the time, you see the guys who get promoted through "cowboy politics" and what not.
But, I guess anything in business is fair...as long as you make all the money ya can...eh?
Guess I'll start charging $150 an hour for consulting and tell people "Well, the morticians of America have predicted higher death rates this year. That means there are going to be fewer programmers available. Plus, I need to afford gas. So, I'm just charging what is fair for the market."
by jdclyde
and Dems in charge start talking about "minimum wage" as if it is a crime that someone can't make a living working at fast food.
The only thing minimum wage does is lower the quality of living for those that are making between 10 and 15 an hour, because THEY will not see a raise, but their cost of living will go up.
I wish people would THINK more and FEEL less. Good intentions does not make for good legislation.
by tonythetiger
claiming that it's a fact!
[i]Dems in charge start talking about "minimum wage" as if it is a crime that someone can't make a living working at fast food.[/i]
as I know couples who are doing it.
by jdclyde
by delbertpgh
You can see that the idea is more unpopular than not.
Here's a question for you: how should the United States pay for the cost of government? By taxes, of course. But, what and how to tax? Income? Import duties? Sales tax? Vice (smokes & drinks)? Anything you tax will crimp business or consumption, and will shift economic activity to alternative that aren't taxed.
It makes sense to me to load up the tax on petroleum fuel, and ease up on something else. Hell, maybe you could even rebate most of the fuel tax at the end of the year. It would still encourage fuel economy and the pursuit of alternatives. And keep in mind, pouring money out of this country into Arabia is just paying for mischief from Bin Laden and others of his kind.
by jdclyde
because fuel raises the costs of everything else because of raised shipping costs.
Or is trying to hide the tax your intention?
I do not have problems with the idea of a "use tax", as long as they are done reasonably and the "revenue" is spent on covering that use.
A gas tax should not be used for anything other than road upkeep and development.
As for pouring money into Arabia, that is entirely the blame of the buttmunches that won't ALLOW us to use our OWN oil. It is the Democrats that are FORCING us to send our money overseas because they won't ALLOW us to produce our own.
Keep the blame where it belongs on WHY our oil is coming from where it does.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by jck
A) I have as much right to tell someone not to be a selfish, wasteful person...as they do determining for me or anyone else how much pollution is coming out of their car that we have to breath into our lungs or pollute the environment we all share.
I guess if I have the money to buy cigarettes, I should have the right to smoke and blow it in your face since there is no direct correlation to smoking being a definitive cause of cancer?
I should sue the State of Florida and start smoking again.
And yes, the amount of emissions is proportionate to the size of the engine. More fuel = more carbon-derivatives expelled in the combustion process.
B) How do I expect them to make anything? The same way I'd expect them to do it normally: design and engineer it. Just like they do their rigs, drillbits, platforms, refineries.
Or are you saying that an oil company can't engineer devices, structures and apparatus that will prevent or minimize environmentally damaging accidents?
by jck
In reality?
The majority shareholders in almost every publically-traded corporation in this country are the corporate executives, who are usually given the greatest part of the shares they hold by the corporation's board of directors as part of their "compensation package".
There are exceptions, but that's usually how the corporate works. The good ole boy system of backscratching at the cost to the common investor.
That's the truth.
by tonythetiger
70.5% of oil company stock is held by retirement plans (including IRAs) and mutual funds, providing income to nearly half of the households in this country. Only 1.5% is owned by oil company executives.
by jdclyde
The question, will anyone buy it?
I think it is overly simplistic and childish to throw words like "greed" around like that.
I was NOT arguing that prices are not being fixed, for a variety of reasons. I AM arguing the stupidity that Democrats in the public eye show when they continue to promote class envy as a way to endear themselves to the mindless masses that are sitting around waiting for government to "do something about it".
See a bit of a difference?
It is about posturing for stupid people about something they have no control over.
Remember the pledge in the 06 elections when Dems took over Congress, they were going to lower gas prices and get us out of Iraq. Gas prices are 60% HIGHER now that we have a Democrat controlled congress. Is it THEIR fault? Or does "the government" NOT really have any control over such things?
As for "exploit the market", I think a lot of this all has to do directly with Democrats. Before the prices FIRST shot up, they were discussing dumping punitive taxes on gas to artificially raise the prices, like they do in the UK. The ONLY thing that is upsetting the Dems is that THEY are not the ones getting all the money. Other than that, they are getting EXACTLY what they wanted, higher prices to force people to use less. This is what Dems and econuts wanted all along.
It is also the reason insane Dems and econuts alike go the obstructionist route EVERYTIME there is an effort to build a new plant, coal/gas/hydroelectric/wind/nuke, because they don't WANT a solution that will give us affordable energy. They want us to stop using energy and slow the economy.
That clinton quote was a RECENT speach that he gave, not from back when he was in the office. It is on youtube and I have linked to it before.
You post the usual simplistic arguments to avoid having to change anything about your lifestyles. What is proposed is a GAS tax, not a fuel tax.
If you put the tax on gas and not diesel then the majority of your transport industry is no more affected than it is by simple rising prices. In fact, put the tax DOWN on diesel - paid for by the larger gasoline tax - and the cost of trucking goes down.
Usual suspects jumping on the bandwagon, I see... :D
You guys really, really don't like social engineering, do you. Yet, do you like paying for the Sheiks and Chavez so much that you'll sit there and pay and pay and pay?
Yeah, build more refineries, drill the White House lawn for oil but both of those take years to kick in properly. A gas tax would change your driving habits NOW.
by tonythetiger
that get less than 20 miles per gallon are owned by those who cannot afford newer vehicles. Raising the "gas" tax would hurt the very people the liberals "claim" they want to help.
Using taxes to "herd the citizens" into a particular behavior by the government is evil. The people are supposed to run the government, not the other way around!
by jdclyde
because "the people" are to stupid to know what is good for them, and need "The Government" to fix and run everything.
Edit to add: We should not be using gas taxes for anything but infrastructure upkeep and development.
"The Government" currently gives a tax cut on truckers that have a permit, giving them a break. If you use diesel in non-road vehicles, you don't pay ANY of the road taxes. (construction and farm equipment)
until it all comes and bites them on the arse! Which is now exactly where you are now - snapping teeth time.
The fact that things ARE happening in the US with gas at $4 per gallon so simply makes THAT point that I don't think I need to say anything else.
Neil :D
"Raising the 'gas' tax would hurt the very people the liberals 'claim' they want to help."
I can't argue with you over your demographics because I have no sources so I think that I'll insist that YOU provide some evidence for your statement before I believe you.
by jdclyde
lets not bother doing anything about it for the future, right?
Why not look at solutions for NOW, soon, and in the future instead of saying "it will only help a little" or "it will take years".
Isn't that the same approach greenies are taking, help a little, and over the years? Why is it good for greenies, but not for something important?
by tonythetiger
[i]Gas prices have risen by about 50-60% in less than a year.[/i]
They've risen everywhere in the world! But do U.S oil companies control the whole world's oil?
Why demonize them? They're not making any more profit, percentage-wise, than they ever have. The reason profits are up is that we are buying more oil. We're gaining population. More people are turning 16 and starting to drive than are older and giving up driving. Absent some miracle breakthrough like (for real) cold fusion, energy cost is going to continue to climb as population does.
If you REALLY want to curb energy costs, curb births!
by jamesrl
If you want to look at the worst polluters, look at those crappy cheapo 2 cycle gas lawn mowers and boat engines. The pollution they spew versus a well tuned car is much higher.
Its not as simple as small engines=good, big engines=bad. I can assure you that an Super Ultra Low Emissions Vehicle (SULEV) whether it be a Honda Accord or a Mercedes CLK, will produce fewer emmissions than say a Hyundai Accent. But of course, engineering for lower emissions costs money.
James
by tonythetiger
by delbertpgh
That's the essence of the free market. There is no morality to it, and in times of shortages or bubbles, price is not tied to cost. Like it or not, that's the way it is; and like it or not, it works best if you leave the market alone. Keep your morals out of it; morality just screws up a market.
Except, that is, if you've got people colluding to drive up the price, rigging the game. We don't call that a "free market", so we should stop it when it happens. It's worth investigating.
However, JD, the connection between skyrocketing oil prices and government action should not be the Democratic Congress. The connection is George W. Bush and his war in the Persian Gulf. It's not the only source of price pressure in the markets, but the insecurity that the war causes about supplies drives up the cost. There's no evidence and no case to be made that Democrats have affected the price of oil, except the coincidence of their thin majority starting 18 months ago.
by tonythetiger
[i]I have as much right to tell someone not to be a selfish, wasteful person[/i]
But I would submit that it is not reasonable to make one person pay for what another person does.
[i]And yes, the amount of emissions is proportionate to the size of the engine. More fuel = more carbon-derivatives expelled in the combustion process.[/i]
Yes, but a Honda that's driven 50,000 miles will create more pollution than a Navigator that's driven 5,000. So why should that Navigator owner be punished and that Honda owner not?
'Miles per gallon' is not the end-all/be-all! I can drive to work through town and get 20 mpg driving 5 miles and use 1/4 gallon, or I can go the long way, 12 miles at 36 mpg and use 1/3 gallon. Or say I want to take a trip with 6 people. I can haul all 6 of us in a Navigator, or I can make two trips in the Honda. Can I really say in either case that I'm doing better by the environment because my gas mileage is better?
You are not going to produce any amount of fairness until you start looking at individual situations and holding people individually responsible for what they individually do. Banning certain kinds of vehicles is simplistic and assinine. This is why you are meeting with so much resistance.
by jdclyde
Iraq is more stable today than it was two years ago, so how is THAT to blame for the price going up an additional 60%? Please explain what has happened in "his war" that has made things WORSE in the last two years other than you don't like him?
More talk about his "oil buddies"?
More talk about Haliburton [i]( the same company Clinton used with no-bid contracts, so it isn't like Cheney brought in his buds and shows stupidity when accusing of such. )[/i]
Did or did not the Dems run the last election with the promise to lower gas prices and get out of Iraq? [b]How is that working out for us?[/b]
Dems have done nothing to help with that price, despite their promise to do otherwise, because the US Government does NOT control gas production other than the extreme limits that they have put on over the last few decades.
Maybe we can sue the evil oil company like we did evil tobacco? We would get a huge settlement that can go "for the children" and mindlessly wonder why the cost of a pack of smokes has tripled?
by notsochiguy
I use proactive in the sense that, to a degree, there is still some control over what happens. Project what you'll need over X time frame, project what you can pump yourself and what you'll need to import, and get to work on a solution. The situation is going down in a swirl, but it isn't fully unmanageable quite yet (though, it is coming soon, admittedly).
Now, if you mean that the numnuts in charge have had about 30+ years worth of warning, and done nothing to date; and that for many in charge, there is no real benefit financially to them to make the move....well, in that case, I'd join you in the laugh, but I'm too busy crying! :)
by tonythetiger
[i]A) I have as much right to tell someone not to be a selfish, wasteful person...as they do determining for me or anyone else how much pollution is coming out of their car that we have to breath into our lungs or pollute the environment we all share.[/i]
Do I then have the right to say that you cannot reproduce, since that requires you to buy more groceries, which takes more trucks to haul, which pollutes the air more?
by notsochiguy
Realistically, there is no jump off to an alternative right now. Even if that Honda Hydro design was the silver bullet, the needed infrastructure would take the better part of a decade to be put into place (that is probably extremely optimistic, to boot).
Ween off of enemy oil to the greatest extent possible (more domestic drilling, refining), and get to work on the solution.
I mean, the Chinese apparently recognize the value in getting oil from off of the Florida coast. I don't see why the US can't, either.
by jdclyde
Democrats don't WANT us to be independent with our oil supply.
Why would they INTENTIONALLY make us dependent on the Middle East?
by notsochiguy
Maybe we should all just get dressed up like The Cure, and start picketing the BP and Shell stations?
Think it would make a difference??? :)
by jck
[i]Iraq is more stable today than it was two years ago, so how is THAT to blame for the price going up an additional 60%? Please explain what has happened in "his war" that has made things WORSE in the last two years other than you don't like him? [/i]
Actually, it was reported the other day that attacks in Iraq are now at a higher level than they have been in the past 6 months. So, it isn't working that well. Sorry to tell you. It's not that stable. And, it will never be considered "stable" so long as we occupy it because the goof-ass ultra-conservative (yes...they are religious fanatics, so they are CONSERVATIVES) nut-so terrorists will keep attacking it...it's a perpetual cycle. We need to get Islamics in power and leave. That's the only way to stabilize it.
[i]More talk about his "oil buddies"? [/i]
Well...it's true. Cheney and Bush are the two highest ranking officials in this country, as well as two of the most heavily-tied officials to the oil industry. So, those guys in oil are literally their "buddies".
[i]More talk about Haliburton ( the same company Clinton used with no-bid contracts, so it isn't like Cheney brought in his buds and shows stupidity when accusing of such. )[/i]
Clinton used other companies for the major no-bid contracts as well.
Halliburton has been deemed by the Bush administration as the only supplier with proper assets in the region.
Now ask yourself...how does...an American company...that even during Desert Storm had no base of operations in the middle east. Yet, all of a sudden...they just happen to put facilities in the region.
Doesn't it seem a bit odd to you?
[i]Did or did not the Dems run the last election with the promise to lower gas prices and get out of Iraq? How is that working out for us?[/i]
Republicans also offered the same thing. Lower gas prices, lower taxes on the working class, yadda yadda yadda. Both sides do it. it's called "Politics".
[i]Dems have done nothing to help with that price, despite their promise to do otherwise, because the US Government does NOT control gas production other than the extreme limits that they have put on over the last few decades.[/i]
And...the Republicans have done any better in 7.5 years of controlling the White House and years of controlling the Congress?
Best I remember, in December 2004, I was paying about $1.55 or so a gallon for unleaded. That's when the Republicans were in control. By summer 2006 (before Dems won over Congress), gas was almost $3 a gallon.
So, who was it again that did nothing about big price spikes?
[i]Maybe we can sue the evil oil company like we did evil tobacco? We would get a huge settlement that can go "for the children" and mindlessly wonder why the cost of a pack of smokes has tripled? [/i]
Well, gas has quadrupled here in FL in the past 8 years. Maybe a lawsuit isn't a bad idea if it means that money will go to fund the building of cars that don't burn gas and give people real incentives to buy those cars?
BTW...did you just complain about the price of a pack of smokes being so high?
I think I'm going to encourage all Hummer, Navigator, Escalade, Yukon, Blazer, and other gas guzzling vehicle drivers...to SMOKE YOUR LUNGS AWAY! I'll buy the first carton for ya. :)
by jdclyde
it is the "poor poor" that will always get hurt the most when prices for EVERYTHING go up, because they have less income to begin with.
A greater portion of their total income then is spent on fuel and everything that rising fuel costs effected (buying ANYTHING) leaving less left over.
Not a difficult concept.
Your government - and mine and everyone else's - is charged with a lot of high-level duties, such as defence, that you don't seem to object to.
They are also charged with prudent fiscal management and any examination suggests that the US is spending far, far too much on buying in oil and that, if demand is not capped, this will only get worse. Do they not have a duty to manage this haemorrhage of money? If they have then what other mechanism do they have other than tax? (OK,OK drill the White House lawn but that takes TIME and that is something that you don't have at $135 US and rising.)
I guarantee that large sections of the current US administration are absolutely delighted with the current price of oil because, for the first time since the LAST oil crisis, demand is slowing and they haven't had to apply any taxes and the oil lobby and chums are still raking it in!
Neil :)
I don't know what you're upset about. It's so obvious that your politicians don't have the nuts to actually DO anything.
"The majority of non-commercial vehicles that get less than 20 miles per gallon are owned by those who cannot afford newer vehicles." was TonyTT's statement and it's such a flat "fact" that I want references. I'm getting fed up of anecdotal evidence and I may just morph into Absolutely on a bad day if I don't get some facts!
As for your comments about the "poor", well, yes but why does the richest country in the world HAVE so many poor that you can parade them up and try to make me feel guilty?
Neil :)
by jdclyde
Yeah, there isn't any poor in the UK or the other great socialist nations that DO SO MUCH for "the poor"?
Why do we have so much? Lots of reasons.
We have learned dependence after more than half a century of welfare programs and telling people it isn't their fault they are not rich.
We have a marketing movement that gets stupid people to live beyond their means because they HAVE to have multiple cars/tvs/cell phones, or whatever widget you like.
We have people that are lazy and do not put forward the effort to ever do more than get rent and beer money.
Can we really count all the reasons there are poor? Are they really any different here than in the UK or Canada or France? No. Clearly is shows that Socialism is not the great savior for eliminating poverty.
The "war on poverty" has only served to give unethical politicians a way to gain power for themselves, and does nothing to actually get people OUT of poverty.
But you already know all this.....
Edit to add: we also have had generations paid to breed at the states expense and our politicians refuse to enforce our immigration laws, unlike ANY other country out there. Both feed directly into the number of poor poor.
by jck
[i]But I would submit that it is not reasonable to make one person pay for what another person does.[/i]
If you're contributing to greater pollutants to the environment because of vanity and self-indulgence...then you are making me pay more than i should...along with the entirety of the planet.
[i]Yes, but a Honda that's driven 50,000 miles will create more pollution than a Navigator that's driven 5,000. So why should that Navigator owner be punished and that Honda owner not? [/i]
If you're gonna compare mileage to mileage...do it fairly.
[i]'Miles per gallon' is not the end-all/be-all! I can drive to work through town and get 20 mpg driving 5 miles and use 1/4 gallon, or I can go the long way, 12 miles at 36 mpg and use 1/3 gallon. Or say I want to take a trip with 6 people. I can haul all 6 of us in a Navigator, or I can make two trips in the Honda. Can I really say in either case that I'm doing better by the environment because my gas mileage is better?[/i]
What Honda are you driving that only takes 2 or 3 people?
Lincoln Navigators average (according to official stats) about 14mpg mixed driving and total seat capacity of 7.
The Honda Pilots average (according to official stats) about 18mpg mixed driving and total seating capacity of 8.
Now you tell me. How is it better to own a Navigator again if you need to haul 6 people and want to get better gas mileage?
[i]You are not going to produce any amount of fairness until you start looking at individual situations and holding people individually responsible for what they individually do. Banning certain kinds of vehicles is simplistic and assinine. This is why you are meeting with so much resistance. [/i]
I never said to ban them. I might have suggested rules to force them out of the market, or I said to make them increase their efficiency long ago. But, most people seem to think it's their God-given right to do whatever the hell they want as long as it doesn't break the law, even though it might be bad for their neighbor and/or the world.
And the fact is if anything is ascinine, it's the attitude of "I'll do what I want because I've got the money and I can spend it how I wish".
As I said somewhere else, i guess humility has gone out the window nowadays...as well as good manners and courtesy.
But what do you need those for, right? As long as you're making a lot more money and driving you and your lady around in your big chromed-out Hummer, everything is right with the world.
Bah humbug.
by tonythetiger
by jck
:)
Someone wants to drive that 9mpg Hummer...let em think of it...while they're paying $350 a tank for gas
:)
Spot on. Nice call, dad!! :D
by jck
[i][b]API is the only national trade association that represents all aspects of America's oil and natural gas industry. Our 400 corporate members, from the largest major oil company to the smallest of independents, come from all segments of the industry. They are producers, refiners, suppliers, pipeline operators and marine transporters, as well as service and supply companies that support all segments of the industry[/b][/i]
Nothing like asking the fox if he thinks he'll steal eggs from your hen house.
BTW, "all stocks"...that can also include subcorps and other non-related subsidiaries. I don't think for a second that only 1.5% is owned by all execs, when I have personally seen an energy company hand out 500,000 shares to a new CEO as a "sign-on bonus". And, that was in 2004 and about 2% of the total held shares in the corp at that time. It's standard operations to give execs large blocks of unexercisable shares as compensation, especially in oil and energy corps.
I think the number is padded. I'll do research later. Right now, I'm going to lunch.
Sort by Trending