Discussion Locked

to report or not to report

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Recently i left a company which does not have the proper licensing for software. I am also an MCSE. I informed my boss of the issue, and was ignored. The company has 200 employees and will gross 23 million this year. The network is over 350 PCs. It is also a 5 person IT department...this past year 4 people have left from the IT Department. I was the last one to leave after almost 6 years. I am wondering that if i was to report them...if i would be jeopardising my career? I need your advice as what to do next.

11 replies

by jamesrl

It might be a little suspcious if you did it immediately after you leave.

It might be even better if you waited until you had another job.

James

by jdclyde

Users will ask for you to do it because it is only software.....

While I don't respect MS or the way they do business, I respect that if someone doesn't want to pay for their product, don't USE their product.

I just tell the user that I don't ask them to go up to the corner store and steal a 50 cent candy bar for me, so don't ask me to steal a $300 package.

Waiting is a good idea to drop the dime.

by jamesrl

I always say no.

Its easier for me as my company produces software. If we don't respect other people's intellectual property, why should I expect someone else will respect ours.

We have a representative in each region that acts as the software licensing contact. If we embed other people's software in our products or preload others software on our server, his responsibility is to make sure its legal. If we find our customers are doing something illegal, we issue a written warning with an end date - if they don't make it right within that time, we tell the vendor. If we don't some vendors would stop doing business with us. That licensing expert works for me.

Waiting is good for both sides. It means that the person will be a little more "detached" and unemotional about the situation. It also means it is less likely that they trace it back to the person dropping the dime - especially if the turnover is high.

James

by dspeacock

You should definitely report them. As for waiting, that is up to you. I did it once, right after I resigned, and right in front of my, now, ex boss. Had a new job 2 days later, never used them for a reference though.

by daveo2000

One thing is certain. If you do report them you will not keep your own secret. The topic will come up again in other companies that you work for and you will almost certainly "spill the beans" about reporting the other company.

Make sure that your goal is altruistic and consistant with your behavior. If you happily helped install improperly licensed software and only got touchy about it when you stopped liking the job then your goal is really revenge.

If your goal is revenge then that aspect will very likely come back to bite you big time. If your goal is protecting the company from undue operational risk then stand up and be counted.

by halonsx

Upon starting at the company I brought the subject with my supervisor and he became a little touchy about the subject...so i left it alone for fear of losing my job. I am no longer with the company. The part that gets me is that they can afford to purchase the licenses yet refuse to do so. The company grossed 23 million last year. Being that software is intellectual property.....i am sure if intellectual property that belonged to the company that if company B was using Company A's intellectual property - Company A would not be too happy that Company B was using intellectual property illegally. I have been thinking this for the past 3 months. I prefer not to report them because of the opportunity they gave me to learn and the number of relationships I have developed at the previous company, but at the same time according to the agreement with Microsoft I am supposed to report them.

by daveo2000

Not having worked there and being a pragmatic "don't burn bridges unless you have to" type, I will offer the following idea. As you know, I don't know all the ins-and-outs of the situation.

I would suggest sending a letter to the CEO and the company's legal department (which may just be their lawyer). Make sure it is certified and request a return-receipt.

The letter should outline the problem that you had with your former supervisor and how it made it uncomfortable that you were being pushed to install software illegally. Go on to say that you doubt if the supervisor made it known to his upper management that he was indulging in this illegal activity and you don't know his motives but you felt it important, now that you are no longer in fear of losing your job, to report his activities to upper management.

This does a couple of things:
* Makes you look like a good guy, not a whistle-blower;
* Makes the supervisor look like a bad guy;
* Puts the lawyer and CEO in the uncomfortable position of being officially informed of illegal activity in their company.

Be very careful not to say that the supervisor "forced" you to do this. Find words that say you felt your job was in danger and you didn't know what else to do since you had to pay the bills (or whatever).

Keep a copy of the letter with the return receipts, mail them to yourself and don't open the envelope. This will document the date that you sent it.

If the supervisor is the problem, you may get him fired. Would that feel better?

If the company is a problem then you have documentation that they were, in fact, notified. If you have friends that still work there, let them know that they can report the company and you have prior documentation that the company was notified "at an earlier date".

Giving the benefit of the doubt is almost always the best path. That is, unless the benefitter is going to eat you for breakfast.

Always remember:
Revenge doesn't have to be immediate and it is better if it doesn't look like revenge.

by tig2

And it sounds like you have integrity. I applaud you.

You can anonymously report the software violation. As James suggests, I would allow some breathing room.

Dave is correct that you must know your motives. But it sounds to me as if you do. No one wants to be put in a place where they can't look at themselves in the mirror because they are violating their own ethical and moral code.

I wish you the very best of luck. This is a tough decision but I know that you will make good choices.

by cactus pete

you have to report it. I think you agreed to report any such thing when you became an MCSE. I remember that in the paperwork somewhere...

by hayward.johnson

...jeapordize your career by whistle-blowing. But only with those you wouldn't WANT to work with, anyway. 'Snagging' software for personal examination -- to 'raise the hood' and see how it works, and to determine whether it has a place in your affairs -- is one thing. Using it day-to-day in an ongoing business is another. Report it. (Hell. You might even get a reward!)

by halonsx

to my knowledge the company does not have legal department, but i do know they have lawyers (just not at the location). In other words I do not know whom their lawyers are. I do know the CEO and HR Director of the company. The CEO and the IT Director are college buddies and the CEO and HR Director grew up together. By informing them with a letter it gives me away as the one whom would report them. I guess I could write the CEO an anonymous letter and have it mailed to the CEO by someone from another state. Taking your advise into account I should wait one to two years perhaps....to not appear as revengeful.

This discussion is closed to new replies.