Discussion Locked

To shut down or not to shut down PC

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
The IT folks here at the office recommend leaving our computers up and running 24/7 so that they can update software at any time. I've always been in favor of shutting down my desktop PC when I'm not in the office with the philosphy that when it's shut down no one can hack it, plus it saves energy. If an update does come about the IT folks have the computers set to automatically update when they're turned on and/or reconnected to the network if the PC is a laptop. What are the Pro's and Con'sof leaving a PC up for automatic updates versus shutting it down? (besides just the updates potentially taking a while to load in the morning)

5 replies

by vince9978

I belive on shuting down when not in use.
Why leave it on when not in use. Updates can be set automatically and install while you work. The tecnical aspect about the electronics going off and on four times a day will damage the equipment is a bunch of ##**.. Will you leave your lights on when not in use?? or your car in winter season--running or ??? (cars do have electronics too)..SI vince(A++.)

by smckay1128

True, turning your PC on and off will eventually take its toll on the HD and the PS. That does not preclude turning it off at night and back on at the start of your workday.
As for updates, they occur during boot up.
From a security issue, I can say with confidence and personal experience, it is a lot easier to penetrate a system that has idle PC?s at night than it is to try it during the day while operators might notice the activity.
By the way, my specialty is Penetration Auditing, and thereport is slim if all the non-essential PC?s are turned off when I do an ?audit?. However, if unattended PC?s are available, I usually find volumes of ?interesting? ports and vulnerabilities to exploit.
The last reason to turn off a PC is that mostare not connected to UPS services (not Brown) and therefore can be subjected to damaging power interruptions which can destroy OS and information, along with hardware.
If you admin types want to do downloads and updates during the off hours, activate ?Power on LAN? and remotely power up the systems, upgrade the OS and apps and then power them down. That is how I handle all my clients, ?Lights out administration and deployment?

by lordinfidel

While I tell my users to shutdown their systems on the weekend. It's more for the "If I need to kick them off their system they won't lose work" mentality.

As far as shutting down a system and turning it back on several times, that *DOES* cause stress to the components.

It is not a old wives tale, it is not BS. It is a simple law of modern physics.

When you heat something it exands, when it cools it retracts. That is called stress.

As with your car, stress over time will kill theengine. Every time you turn your car on and off, it's just one step closer to it's grave.

Same thing with a computer.

Lights are a bad analogy as they will burn out.

As far as updating, most systems that require an update will need an admin log in. If they have their users set up as admins on their local machines then they need to be shot. There is no reason why you should have to keep it up and running over the weekend.

But in the end and overall: Systems like to be stayed on atone constant tempeature.

by thechas

One old Windows 95 bug is that without an update, the PC could hang if left on for more than 49 1/2 days.

Of course, since Windows 95 tended to lock up for other reasons, it took a while to discover the bug.

Lord Infidel is correct, that a PC will wear out faster if you shut it off, and start it up often.

Where I work, we have a few 286 machines that have been running 24/7 for over 10 years.
What goes out? Monitors and fans, followed by hard drives. (long past MTBF)

Just like a carengine, the most wear on a PC happens in the first minute after you turn it on.

When a PC is setting idle, the main source of heat and power usage is the monitor.

I would consider shutting the monitor off, and leaving the PC itself on.

Chas

by gonzalo.raffo

The sudden temperature change in the cpu may damage it after some years of use and a computer doesnt consume that much electricity,why shutting it down?

This discussion is closed to new replies.