Discussion Locked

Took a job far away, now maybe one in to

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What a dilemma, a few months ago I learned I was going to be laid off. Couldn't find a job for 2 months. I finally got an offer from a company several states away and took it. They are very accomodating and even let me stay in my current state for amonth to sell my house (bought 6 months ago), and get everything straightened out. I know I'll be a good fit there, but my family is devastated about the move and loss of friends.

Today, I get a call from an agent for a position about 5 miles from home. I've got experience in everything they are looking for, all the same software and even within the same industry. The salary is right and I'm pretty sure I could get it if interviewed. How much of a jerk would I be if I took the local job over the interstate move?
I want to be fair to the far away company after they suspended their job search for me, but I think I need to look out for me and the family too.
Any opinions? Thanks ahead for your thoughts.

10 replies

by jellimonsta

In the very least you should inquire further into this position that is close by. You will only kick yourself later if you do not (or maybe the rest of the family will kick you :)
In all seriousness though, I would probably take the position close to home if the other factors are all relative. If you feel it would be a better opportunity out of state great. But if the credentials for both positions are comparable, I would not put your family through a move they obviously do not want to endure.
Remember that this is business so the out of state company has to realise this. I imagine they would have taken a local applicant over yourself if experience and other factors were comparable. So why can you not do the same?

by mallardtooxx

I must say that this is a position that YOU will have to rectify. I do not think the out of state company is going to get pissy and poison the water in your home town if you do not go. However you do owe them an explanation. If you were not getting a relocation package or anything like that then you certainly should stay where you are. If the job close to you is the same then I would look at only one aspect, security. Are you going to need to find another job in a year? Is the company at home as stable as the out of state company? What about cost of living? IS it comparable to where you are now? Those are the questions I would ask before I made a final decision.
-duck

by coloradoguy

Thanks for the opinion, here's a little more info.

The cost of living in the new state is less, but it is more likely to be stable. Its kind of a family business with less than 8 members of management.

I'm curently in a town that has a high ratio of high tech people and companies. Many of them have had recent layoffs and are in trouble. We have larger companies like HP and LSI Logic that have been reducing staff so many of their folks are out looking for work and making it easy for companies to find employees with skills. I don't think I'll be looking for work in a year, and the local company appears stable from what I can tell. They are privately owned so I can't get much financial info via Internet, but they do have some favorable & recent articles within the industry.

I know this is my decision to make, but I wanted to get some confirmation of my feelings... (boy, that sounds wishy washy)

by jmottl

Hi Coloradoguy,
I'm interested in writing an article on your dilemma and how you ultimately make your decision, the decision and why -- could you email me at judy.mottl@techrepublic.com so we can communicate on this,
Thanks,
Judy Mottl
Senior Editor

by jkaras

I experienced "the move" many times due to an ambitious father changing jobs for a better future for our family. Yes, I went kicking and screaming that the world was over having to start all over. I have to tell you that I pondered who I could of been if I stayed where we were and can tell you I became a more rounded person as a result with my horizons broaded. I actually started my freshman year in high school in a new state. (got off plane,dropped luggage went to school jetlagged and all) Yes, it was hard but I got over it. Your decision effects your family and the only factor concerned should be the financial stability to provide the best future for the family. Apply to the other job and see what falls from the tree, which have the bestbenefits, pay, and most important job security with advancement possibilities. What good is a job that lays off due to our struggling economy. Either way your family could be enriched from a different environment or appeased through staying. As for the current job, if quit blame it on family not being prepared for the change, most companies that hire out of state know of this situation and roll the dice, "family comes first" is never disputed and understood whether they like it or not. I know you are struggling with loyalty issues to the company that's providing for your family during this time, but I'm sure you will make the best choice that benefits everyone. Let me know if you want more of my "move" experience to relate to kids. Luck

by prefbid ii

I just saw your note and am intrigued by your choices. I have moved many times myself, both because of the Army and afterward. For some reason, I have never had a problem with the move. I guess I'm just not tied to any one part of the world. I have seen each move as part of the adventure.

Some advise:
1. Only worry about how a move will impact your spouse. You know you can handle it. If your spouse has reservations, then pay attention.

2. Include your kids in the discussion, but don't take their objections too strongly. Your kids have very little idea as to how something like this will impact them. On my last move (less than 2 years ago) my kids protested loudly that the world would end if we moved to NC. After just 3 months in the new location, they were calm about the experience. After 6 months all my kids (all 4 of them) began wondering why they thought NC was going to be a drag. After a year, they can't imagine living anywhere else.

3. Realize that bowing out of the other job is tantamount to "burning a bridge" with both the company that had hired you and the headhunter that helped hook you up. Of course that might not be a big deal, but it is something to remember.

4. Realize that you may be contractually obligated to pay back some direct costs. That will depend on the contract you signed with the out of state employer.

5. It never hurts to ask. No one would think twice about a new Marketing VP who suddenly got an offer to be the CEO of another company. Companies understand $ decisions. They can understand quality of life decisions too.

If it were me, though, I would be taking the out of state job.

by coloradoguy

I too moved a lot when I was younger as my Dad was in the military. I agree that it provides a richer experience. Family is definately first on my list, job security is a tough one in this market, and my position is usually comprised of a staff ofone, me, so advancement is limited. I'm going for the interview, I have found, since my last posting, that the local company is only interviewing a few candidastes and will be making a decision soon. (My move to the new state is scheduled for mid next week.)

by mrafrohead

I changed everything I wrote here at the last second, so hopefully it still makes a tad of sense.

I would have a family discussion about it and get your family's input. Since this move concerns all aboard. And I mean your immediate family. Those that would be moving with you if you left. The others, should not be included in this discussion as they can cloud the honesty of it.

But sit down with your family. Present to them the pros and cons of both sides of each move. Let them make the decision or at least help. This move will definately impact each person within your household and they should all have a fair say in the matter. Regardless of age.

I am an Army brat, and this was how my parents helped us when it was time to move. We would all sit down and have a talk about where we could be going, what we think and all of the like. We were included in every aspect of it. Down to the home we lived in when we got where we were going.

I can tell you this much about it. Either way sounds like pay will be fine. So there's apparently no worries there. The only other thing to worry about is your family's happiness. And if you include them in the decision it will not only work smoother for yourself, but it will bring your family even closer than it already is. I know your kids will certainly appreciate it. Especially when they hit a point in their life that they can reflect on it and truly understand the value of what their parents taught them while hopefully trying to help someone else with a decision of the like.

Mrafrohead

by coloradoguy

Thanks for the support everyone. It turns out that I probably won't meet the time frame of the new position in the current town. I had a great interview and I'm second in line for the position. But, the employer wants to review more candidates and then bring back the best for a second interview. With my existing commitment due 1/30/03 I am going ahead with the move.

Thanks again

by jellimonsta

Good luck with the move but more importantly congratulations on the new position. I hope you and your family settle nicely into your new neighborhood and your new work place.

This discussion is closed to new replies.