43 replies
by jdgretz
In a past life my clearances began where most people think they stop. Didn't give me any delta over those without clearances working for other companies, all it allowed me to do was get and keep the job I wanted.
Of course working on non-existant projects for customers that didn't exist in buildings that didn't belong to the folks I didn't work for was fun.
jdg
by jamesrl
My clearance was a condition of employment. Similarly when I was promoted and my clearance level was increased, it was a condition of promotion.
I never worked in the super secret lab, but I did know where the nuclear materials were, and we had a conveniently located military base nearby, which provided helicopter surveillance and additional security when needed. Our security guards had gun envy.....:)
James
by illilli
Don't listen to those posters comparing apples to oranges! There is a huge difference between a cleared job at Secret or Top Secret and when you get your Lifestyle Poly. Right now, I estimate you can get 10-15 thousand more a year with the Lifestyle Poly. That's in the Washington, D.C. area however where the demand for this is extremely high. That number might be less in other places that require this type of clearance.
Just do two Monster Searches; one for your job skills and one for your job skills with lifestyle poly after it. There are enough employers that list salary on their sites that you can clearly see the difference. So, don't take my word for it, go look for yourself.
by mp3spy
by amcol
The other posters are correct.
I work for a Federal agency and have a top secret clearance, as does everyone in my agency. There is no comp delta associated with that clearance...it's a condition of employment, that's all.
I employ contractors from several private sector firms. We require they all have top secret clearances as well, and that's also a condition of employment. None of those firms provides a comp delta for the clearance...they won't hire you if you don't have one, or if you have some unique skill they want they'll take you on and then sponsor your clearance. Either way, they don't pay any more money.
I recently attended a meeting of fellow Federal CIO's in which this issue came up, and what I'm describing is an across-the-board policy not specific to any one agency.
by illilli
Yeah, and you should see what 23 years of experience get you! I have interviewed with many large companies that contract out jobs requiring TS/SI w/Lifestyle Polys, some multiple times. They really offer some great salarys. Unfortunately, I didn't receive my clearance, so I had to look for jobs that didn't require such a high clearance. That's how I know so much about the difference; I've been down in the trenches beating the pavement. (I also know how to ADD, SUBTRACT, and calculate AVERAGES, but employees really DON'T give you more for those basic skills.)
Anyway, don't listen to those who have posted here telling you there is no difference, it's about 10-15% better for clearance you have. Here are a couple of links that you might find good reading also:
http://www.intelligencecareers.com/careerseekers/index_cs_candidate_marketplace_value.cfm
The second one is awesome because it addresses the reason the salaries are higher in the first place. It's a report to the Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs from the Information Technology Association of America. It's over a year old, but from everything I see, it is still relevant.
Good luck to you!
by m_a_r_k
by illilli
TS with SBI is not the same as TS with SBI with LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH. When you get a job that requires that level of security, the job always requires that level of security. If your employer doesn't need you on one particular job requiring that level of security, he will move you to another one that does because your clearance has value to him. If he doesn't have another job with that level of clearance, look for a convenient layoff in your near future.
Now if you are a governement employee, then that is different. The clearance is a prerequisite for employment.
I guess I assumed that people who understand how security clearances work would be the ones to post here, but I shouldn't be surprised, because I have talked to several Security Officers who didn't understand the entire United States Security Clearance process either.
I don't fully understand physics. So, I wouldn't begin to try and tell Einstein he was wrong about his theory of relativity just because it "seemed" contrary to what I know about physics. Afterall, everyone knows the Sun revolves around the Earth!
Hey Mark, Wassup?
IM(egocentric)O, Full Scope Background Investigation is COMMONPLACE compared to Lifestyle Poly... The fact that TS/SBI is the minimum requirement now for all Air Force Network Comm/Ops people will tell you how common that is. And remember, we're talking about walking into the job with the polygraph already in your pocket... The starting pay, it really is ***MORE***.
by illilli
Hey, neither of us are technically wrong. What you say is technically correct I suppose. However, we are talking about a Top Secret Clearance WITH LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH which is different than Top Secret Clearance alone. I am ignorant about what you mean by "comp delta", but if it's an official compensation amount, then I'm pretty sure there isn't one for Top Secret WITH LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH either.
I thought we were talking about the actual dollar value difference that employers offer people with Top Secret clearances WITH LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH. Employers pay people more money for complimentary skills when they have the LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH. This fact is verifiable like I mentioned above through Monster.
Man, I know so many circumstances where people including myself think they know the ENTIRE environment based on what their own experience tells them, yet they are mislead. I find it amazing in others and REALLY amazing when I do it. I guess it is possible that this condition only exists here in the Washington, DC Metro area, but I assure you it exists here. If your Federal CIO's don't know about it then that's probably why they are Federal CIO's. I know the Federal CIO that we have to work with has trouble with spelling IT sometimes. I never believed that was representative of all Federal CIO's, but I wonder. My experience tells me it must be true based on 1 out of 1 experience.
by jamesrl
And its in Canada, but we have similar rules.
We did compensation studies, and we had a target rate for comp of the 50th percentile. We made no adjustments for the level of clearance required for the job - some employees needed the basic, som Secret, some Top Secret. When someone moved from one role to another and it was a lateral move, and they required higher clearance, we didn't give them any extra pay.
I think the difference between that scenario and yours is market forces. Obviously the rarer the clearance and the more demand, the more someone would have a delta in pay. We don't have the longish waits for clearance in Canada, and thats probably a factor.
James
by illilli
Our original poster put the words LIFESTYLE POLYGRAPH in the title of his post for a reason. It is a special kind of clearance that only a few United States agencies require. I happen to know that Canada has a similar caveated clearance and I bet if you did a compensation study on just that one aspect, you might find that it did indeed have a "delta" in pay. If you ignore a dimension of the domain, that doesn't mean it doesn't affect your bottom line.
No offense to you from Canada, but thank GOD a lot of us IT people didn't decide to become Rocket Scientists!
by amcol
Speaking as a Federal CIO who does, in fact, know how to spell IT, and being the kind of person who likes to get my facts straight, I did some additional checking just to be sure.
Since there are exceptions to every rule there may in fact be employers who offer a premium for people with top secret clearances AND lifestyle polygraphs. (Do you now understand, BTW, that "comp delta" means additional compensation?) However, I am told by representatives of two major recruiting agencies in the DC area that a job requiring a top secret clearance does not typically have any additional compensation benefit when the requirement for a lifestyle polygraph is added. In fact, both agencies told me they actively discourage their clients from requiring lifestyle polygraphs because it chases away a lot of otherwise fully qualified candidates, and the top secret clearance by itself is typically enough.
You may be trying to draw a comparison between two different job at two different companies that sound like they're the same but one requires a lifestyle polygraph and the other doesn't, and the compensation is different. This is an invalid comparison, as there are many other factors that explain the delta (that's Greek for change, BTW...in addition to being able to spell IT I also know the Greek alphabet, among one or two other things I can do with reasonable competence).
by illilli
Our facts do not agree.
Mine are based on personal experience.
by jdgretz
It may well be the physical area you are in, or some particular aspect of the job, or the day of the week, or whatever.
I've had my tickets punched, jumped through all the hoops (some that have not been identified here and probably will not unless the poster has no interest in remaining in free society) and I've never seen much of a difference in salary based on the clearance requirements. What I have seen from time to time is companies (civilian) willing to pay either a sign-on bonus or slightly higher pay for not having to pay the cost of acquiring your clearance. Also, a clearance transfer is sooo much quicker than an initial investigation.
Who knows, if you can get more money, good for you.
YMMV
jdg
by jamesrl
You know when someone says "no offense" its just an excuse to say something offensive.
I was offering a datapoint, no more, no less. Because that datapoint happens to contradict your theorem, you not only reject it but insult the poster.
As someone who did some work with IT security in a nuclear firm, I do have some exposure to the Government security models in Canada. Because we had US partner firms, I know about similar clearances in the US.
I was not trying to argue your point, I was providing data. Try and not be so touchy.
James
by m_a_r_k
by illilli
by m_a_r_k
by m_a_r_k
by maecuff
by m_a_r_k
Yeah I hate those questions. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Do you stay true to yourself, tell the truth and hurt the other person's feelings? Or do you be dishonest to yourself and the other person and lie? How DO you say "you're an ugly toad" without upsetting the other person.
No offense to women ;) but here's another example...
When a guy's wife asks him, "Do you like my new dress/haircut/"? No offense to women who wear $800 dresses, blondes, brunettes, long-haired women or spike-haired women, but how does a guy answer that if he hate the $800 dress she bought or she went from long-haired blonde to spike-haired brunette??
by maecuff
Tact and diplomacy should ALWAYS trump cruel honesty. Or at best, if you really feel you MUST stay true to yourself (another expression I LOATHE) then say nothing at all, or subtly change the subject.
Being true to oneself..my ex husband used that excuse to call every person the two of us knew (including my grandmother) to tell them every secret we had ever shared as husband and wife. He was being true to himself. Personally, I saw that as his license to be a sh*thead.
by jamesrl
For apologising. It shows a level of maturity and the ability to understand the perspective of another.
I am usually pretty even tempered, but I will readily admit to loosing it from time to time. I should not have called you an @ss, though my intent was to focus the criticise the sentiments you expressed and not generalize about you as a whole person.
I had some pretty interesting experience in trying to design systems that would work to meet top secret requirements, while at the time I only had secret clearance. I knew what the information was about, I knew the methods we wanted to use to isolate the data and the user, but at the fine detail stage I had to step off even though I helped design it.
jAMES
In this case, you're coming to the table without the clearance so you can't negotiate based on something you don't have. If you're being sponsored for a TS/SCI w/ lifestyle poly, consider it a gift and do your salary negotiations off the strength of your skillset and experience. They think enough of you to invest the time and money into getting you sponsored. Not a lot of companies are willing to do that unless they're a massive operation (ie. Lockheed-Martin, Raytheon, etc.).
Now, once you get the clearance, it's another ball game. I see that you're in the DC/MD area so you're in a hot bed of opportunity. There IS a big difference between Secret and Top Secret (wrt salary and opportunities). There is also a difference between a Lifestyle Poly and a CI Poly. The "Top Secret" world is a secret society and once you're in it, you're going to see alot of opportunities come your way simply because you have the TS. The reason that you won't find any "numbers" comparing cleared to un-cleared work (and even Secret work) is because you can't really compare the two. A candidate can't even sit at the table unless he has that clearance. So you can't compare. I will say that you should be able to see about a 10-15 percent increase in pay because of your TS (if not more based on the opportunity). It's a simple case of supply and demand. In the geographical area you are in, there are more opportunities than there are Top Secret Cleared professionals to fill them. Couple that with the fact that there are not alot of skilled tech professionals out there with a Top Secret Clearance, then you have a recipe for negotiating a great salary. Because you have the clearance, you're going to be in demand in that area. If you have hot skills, then you're going to be in higher demand. Also, remember that the TS clearance only benefits you if you're in an area where the work is (like DC/MD/VA area). Good luck.
by mp3spy
Well noted.
Thanks for your input!
by danc1957
by darkfriend
Text from ClearanceJobs.com:
Candidates with active or current security clearances continue to be valued more than their equivalent non-cleared counterparts. Based on our 2005 Salary Survey results of registered ClearanceJobs.com job seekers, cleared candidates earn an average of $11,500.00 (or 16%) more per year than non-cleared candidates. (Non-cleared salary source results from Salary.com). On the high end, some industries are paying as much as 29% more in salary for cleared candidates. Higher paying jobs come from industries where cleared candidate supply is traditionally low, including skilled Administrative Assistants, Senior Software Developers, and Contract Administrators with Federal contracting experience.
The U.S. Department of Labor published a nationwide average yearly salary of $49,650.00 for white collar, non-sales positions in 2004. The average yearly nationwide salary of security-cleared candidates on ClearanceJobs.com is $67,462.06, a difference of $17,812 over the uncleared national average.
Your expertise - the demand for someone in your field and your experience.
Honestly - there is a salary difference. Getting the TS with a poly just opens you up to the government job market. Now - the only way you can really slam the market to work for you is if you have a million people beating down your door due to your qualifications and clearance. THEN you can shop. But don't think that just because you have a TS with a full boat that your salary is going to jump up 20k or even 10k. There has to be a need for your skill set or you end up at Lockheed Martin or some other large firm working for the same price that Joe Smith is working in the non-cleared market.
Granted I'm just speaking for the D.C. market - I know very little about other cities.
by mp3spy
I agree, MP3... My pay prospects jumped CONSIDERABLY when I got my lifestyle, as opposed to my TS/SCI (DCID 6/4)... From what I've gathered at the job fairs around DC, it's about a $13,000 difference... But since the companies either take you or dump you, it's hard to compare the salary [per employee]... (Also, to those who have a "GS" in front or behind their name, contract wages are WAY different! (But the compensation, and inability to easily be fired can be a good trade-off for "problem children!" How's that for a compensation delta, james?) We contract employees see a significant jump in starting pay if we have "w/lifestyle poly" in our clearance info!
(PS... Hey MP3... I've probably seen you in the hall! But I've renamed all my illegally downloaded songs .XPX and zipped them with password, so good luck tracking me down! (j/k)
by joecleared
There is a clear need for skilled tech workers who hold a TS with full lifestyle poly. If you look at the number of opening reqs versus the number of qualified canidates... it looks really good for the cleared canidate.
While people are saying that 10-15K raise with a clearance seems to be the norm. I would say that with a full lifestyle poly and some decent skill set, you could look at as much 40-50K more in the current market. There is clearly a market where there are many more open positions than there are qualified canidates (clearance and skills).
I don't anticipate that this market will last forever as the government catches up with clearing more people... but for the time being it's great to have a clearance.
by mp3spy
"Langley?, we used to DREAM of working at Langley..." (In my best Monty Python voice)
Good luck! BTW what's to do at Langley? Clearance for what?
by mp3spy
by tturow
For Secret & Top Secret salaries the best I have found is:
They cover just about everything, and the numbers seem very accurate... plus they compute their results by specific location.
by alex
by ben_ziskind
One of my clients in MD has several contract engineering positions open for various IT and SW Developers/Sys Admins that all require a TS level of clearance or higher. Shoot me an email if you would like to be set up-
Ben
Ben_Ziskind@oxfordcorp.com
978 717 7649
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending