Discussion Locked

Two years in the pokey for writing virii

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just heard on the news that a 22 year old man was given a two year jail sentence today for distributing a mass-mailing virus that hit 27000 computers in 47 countries in December 2001.

The person concerned was from Llandudno in North Wales, UK and his tracking and arrest was facilitated by Scotland Yard's Computer Crime Unit with assistance from the FBI in the USA.

Now...he boasted about three virii he had written in various chat rooms on the internet and this was what started the trail that finally identified him and helped his arrest.

This brings up several points for discussion!

Is two years in jail enough or is it too much?

If 27000 computers got infected and possibly put out of commission, where was the security, virus checking and preventative measures?

If you were going to commit a cybercrime...would you advertise the fact in internet chat rooms?!

30 replies

by madroxxx

The punishment should be castration so we can start thining these idiots from the gene pool. ..............I'm only sort of kidding.

by oldefar

Having looked back into the family tree, I am glad that castration is not a common punishment.

I am not familiar with the facts in the case. From the age, I suspect he was guilty of the cyber equivelent of graffiti.

In general, incarceration should meet two key objectives. First, to remove a threat from society for however long the threat remains. Second, to rehabilitate. This can shorten the duration of the first objective.

As for punishment, I would prefer to see restitution. Ifrestitution is not feasible, then a flat time to value approach is appropriate. Example, 4 days for every machine day lost.

by jkaras

Castration? Wow I'm imagining the pain as we speak. I think a virus is an inconvience, not that big a deal, but hacking into your or anyones computer and extracting banking info etc... should be delt with a heavy hand.(chopping?) This individual wanted to be caught for attention. As he enjoys his known stunt he will think what was I thinking as he realizes their is nothing cool about jail and no one will trust him when he gets out. Regardless of the time served this mistake will cost him far more than any inconvience he created world wide. If I was to do something illegal it better have a huge payoff and world wide acclaim being the most notorious person of the century, but I doubt I would do it if I could.

by madroxxx

Well I was kidding, but think about it. Most likely you would only have to hand down that punishment once. While pople that write viruses might not fear jail I bet castration might be a pretty good deterent.

by oldefar

People are by nature social creatures. They want acceptance and respect from others. This is what leads individuals like your example to talk about their exploits in chat rooms.

It is probably the same reason we participate in forums.

So thecyber criminal can overcome the technology barriers, bypass defences, social engineer cracks in security, but can't keep his mouth shut. Lucky for us.

by mallardtooxx

There are two types of people in this world, cheese buyers and cynics. This guy is clearly a cheese buyer. If you were going to write a viral code for any real purpose you would not talk about it in a chat room (Well if you were a cynic that is) But this guy was clearly longing for someone to notice him.
What a shame it is, there are literally millions of people that can write code, but the ones that can actually use it use it for petty pranks and worthless Viruses. I think castration,followed by a five day immersion from wast to toes in salt water and a 2 month scab ripping regimine would fix his problem. maybe as a soprano he will make a better coder.
-duck

by pesk, mbcs, mcse, mcitp, sts

If you are going to spend a long time writing malicious code or defacing others' hard-worked works of art (Webpages, etc...), knowing full well the destruction it may cause, then I think it's only fair that the sentence befits the crime. I have infoon my PC that actually helps me live life better daily, as many of us IT types do and I would be extremely upset if someone tampered with it. So, let him/her who writes malicious code/commits cyber-graff and has the audacity to shout out about it, sit in prison for those two years, and more and maybe after their time in the pen, they will have learnt to write some useful code. Or grown up, whichever is the sooner...My 10 cents.

by admin

>>Is two years in jail enough or is it too much?

I doubt he'll stay the whole 2 years unless he further does stupid things while in there. 2 years on probation\parole seems like enough. I don't know what priors he has, but I think the point wouldbe to have him learn, not to just punish for punishments sake. Of course, if he was a "hardened" repeat offender he may need to be locked up for our protection.

>>If 27000 computers got infected and possibly >>put out of commission, where was the security, >>virus checking and preventative measures?

Well, most users are idiots and don't fathom this and deserve what they get. Still, the fact is, you can still write all the virii you want and share the knowledge of it, get credit, and NEVER distribute it. This guy distributed it. He didn't run to the software company or even BugTraq and say: "see what I found!", he released it. Some people shouldn't drive cars either IMO.

>>If you were going to commit a >>cybercrime...would you advertise the fact in >>internet chat rooms?!
Most of the smart criminals never get caught.

This whole thing, to me boils down to the distributor. The gun maker shouldn't be liable for a stolen gun sold by a blackmarket dealer. The blackmarket dealer is the right target in my view. Same thing here. If he was merely the "writer" then this would be horrible, but it sounds like he went down for the distribution, which I don't know the details of, but most likely he was not putting it in thehands the right people.

by oldefar

I hope we don't reach the point where failure to wear a chasity built makes rape the victim's fault, or failure to wear Kevlar clothing puts a shooting victim automatically at blame, or not putting security bars and alarms on the home makes it toughluck if it gets cleaned out.

by mrafrohead

But considering that we have so many different methods of backup. There are so many different types of companies that supply AV software. Not to mention sites that report on the virii themselves. It's getting to a point where it's HARD to get a virus. If you stay on the ball and pay attention to what you're doing, you should be fine. It's when you get sloppy and lazy that you catch one. Unfortunately that's how it is. And with the resources we have nowadays, no one should really be getting virii any more. Unless it's a nice shiny new one that no one has seen before that works in a way never before seen.

And this is coming from a person who is mailed at least five freakin bugs a day...

by jackofalltech

There is a vast differance between stupid computer users and other crime victims. Other people are going about their daily lives under normal circumstances. If you drive into a high-crime area, do you leave your doors unlocked? After working withraw meat do you not wash your hands? While removing asbestos, do you not wear an air filter/respirator?

These days, computer use (especially on the internet) is a high-risk activity and proper care must be taken.

Ralph

by tomsal

I see your point...its a sad fact of life that more and more, at least this is how it seems when I watch the news each day, victims are being put to blame for crimes against them.

The one thing that drives me crazy is when some gets killed in a public by some nut case and people the media interview says "Well he was just in the wrong place at the wrong time..."

Wrong place at the wrong time? So if I'm hungry and I'm eating my dinner at a restaurant and I get shot and killed - I was at the wrong place at the wrong time....what about the nut case with the firearm -- last time I checked restaurants are a place to eat at, not a firing range.

;)

As for the hackers who get caught..zero sympathy I utterly don't care if they are locked up for life, sent to solitary confinement, subjected to endless hours of insurance seminars or have to actually publically announce to the world that Microsoft is the greatest company on earth and Windows is the best OS ever!!!

They get what they deserve...

;)

by admin

McDonalds should be put out of business for all the coffee people dumped on their laps.

Motorcycle companies should go away because people kill themselves on them frequently.

The United States government should personally not only return the entire country to the original owners, but continue to tax themselves and make reparations forever to all that were forced here and suffered. I would personally also like the British to return me to Scotland, fix what they did to my family name which forced us out and restore my homeland to all my family worldwide in direct one to one proportion to each individual in regards to land mass, so they better start enlarging Scotland now. Oh yeah, and return it to how it was in it's pure un-polluted state.

Victims are not treated equally or fairly, they can't be. You can't ever restore all the Jewish community lost in ww2, you can't restore the lifestyle of the original tribes, you can't ever recover the items stolen as they were or regain your peaceful naive sleep or take away the rape and subsequent disease, nightmares, or relationship challenges in the aftermath and you can't take a virus back if you distribute it stupidly.

Everyone I know is a victim in some way and money or killing someone else in retribution doesn't fix it because being a survivor doesn't come from the outside- it comes from within. The strength is within. IMO we victimize them all over again when we keep them in the victim role fostering dependance insteadof the life affirming damn hard pull up by the bootstraps that actually builds character and self-esteem. So, although I wish the original answer I posted wasn't reduced to what was almost a sidebar of the intent, I am glad to see on my return that it has provoked discussion :)

by generalist

I've noticed that a number of people seem to be focusing on the 'most users are idiots ... and deserve what they get' comment to the exclusion of the fact that the guy distributed the virus as opposed to contacting the 'good guys'.

Personally, ifyou are dealing with a criminal act like virus distribution, it doesn't matter what the victims are like. Heck, all 27,000 victims could be doing all the right things and still be the victim of a well planned attack.

Imagine, for example, a verylow profile attack that spans several months and then destroys everything you have on your system. If it is very well planned, even the backups may be affected.

by mrafrohead

Is two years in jail enough or too much???

Well, considering I could break into y'alls houses and rape your wives and get less of a sentence, yeah, I think that this guy got too much. I find it hard to believe that a little computer virus like this entails so much freakin punishment, when there are REAL criminals out there committing REAL crimes that actually HURT people.

27K pc's getting infected. If you seriously think of how many computers are in the world. That's not that many. They probably got infected because they are illinformed users that open up any file sent to them. Or else they don't know how to surf the net intelligently, and well. Now they know better than to do what they did to get infected. Consider it a learning experience.

If you were going to commit a cybercrime...would you advertise the fact in internet chat rooms?!

Personally, I think it's best to not have any partners/witness's when commiting a crime. And if you go into a room and advertise it, you're opening yourself up to a whole bunch of partners or witness's. Bad idea. The less people that know, the better. And if no one else knows but yourself, then you're in gold.

Mrafrohead

by madroxxx

Here is dictionary.com's definition.

To remove the testicles of (a male); geld or emasculate.
To remove the ovaries of (a female); spay.
To deprive of virility or spirit; emasculate.

by mrafrohead

Yeah, that sounds like a not so bad idear...

I had something sinilar to that done last week, and I can tell you it's punishment enough;)

Mrafrohead

by guruofdos

A guy doing 3 years for a similar crime in the US has just been released from prison.

Allegedly, he's NOT going back to his old ways, but teaching major companies how to prevent virus attacks!

by admin

Black Hat while those of us that chose to stay always on the white path often get our reward in the great blue sky....or so I'm told.

:)

by oldefar

"Well, most users are idiots and don't fathom this and deserve what they get."

I disagree. No one deserves to be victim of any crime. Independent of whatever precautionary steps they could take, the fault remains 100 percent that of the criminal. It is the criminal's action that creates the victim.

by admin

How about we castrate all the stupid users who keep them circulating? ...I'm not really serious about this, but couldn't resist the thought.

by prefbid ii

I figure he got 10 days for the virii, 20 days for releasing it, and the rest of the time for being so stupid as to brag about it.

Is is the right punishment? I think you could argue both ways. I think 5000 hours of community service would have been better, but I don't think jail time is out of line.

by generalist

The problem with security and preventative measures is that they lag behind the state of the art. When somebody comes up with new ways of breaking things, it takes some time to come up with ways of countering them.

If you planned things 'right' and had something completely different, you could infect hundreds of thousands of computers despite what would be reasonable security measures. It would take a lot of prep work and would require an unused approach, but it could be done.

by admin

It seems when a new encryption scheme or new firewall strategy etc. comes out it takes a while to break.
"If you planned things 'right' and had something completely different,...a lot of prep work and ... an unused approach" in a system originally it would take a longer time (I think) to compromise.

On review of the opening statement: "The problem with security and preventative measures is that they lag behind the state of the art."

(And at the risk of sounding like "The Sphinx" in the movie Mystery Men....)

The problem becomes the solution when the solution is the problem.

hehehe :)

by jkaras

I wonder the origin of the term "pokey".... hmmmm...... on second thought it's too scary a thought to ponder.

by maxwell edison

Depending where you're from, there are many slang terms for jail, aka the hoosegow, aka the clink, aka the can, aka the big house, aka the pokey.

"The pokey" (from "pogy," a 19th century term for a workhouse, from "poke," meaning "to confine"). Along with "the clink" (the name of a famous London jail), we have "the can," "the tank," "the slammer, "the cooler," "the joint," "lockup" and "the big house," among others. And yet another Spanish word, "calabozo" ("dungeon") lives on today as "calaboose." Hoosegow" comes from the Mexican Spanish word "juzgado," meaning "tribunal" or "judge." Originally the "juzgado" was the local courthouse in the Old West, but, frontier justice being what it was, "jail" was a functional synonym and the English version "Hoosegow" never meant anything but "the clink."

----- Back to the topic at hand -----

Nevertheless, in my opinion, if someone defaces your property, that person should be forced to pay restitution AND spend some time in jail OR somekind of community service. Restitution AND some sort of punishment to act as a future deterrent. Therefore, whether a person damages your house, your automobile or your computer, the same theory should apply. Pay for the damages and be subjected to the "incentive for deterrent".

(Wow - 27,000 computers damaged at a cost of $50 per equals 1.35 Million dollars in damage.)

by dbgirl

Your command of American slang is rather impressive. Even assuming you had to look all that up doesn't detract in the least, considering the initiative and effort.

This explains your generally well thought out responses.

Returning to the topic...
I do think financial restitution is a good idea. The idea of community service does appeal to me over confinement, though. I would like to see the offenders be put to work for volunteer organizations, in some but not all situations. The others, go ahead and lock 'em up.

That of course brings up another question.
If opting for community service, how are they going to be supervised?

by curtisinterruptus

but what would you do if the offender was female? Everyone jumps to the conclusion that all hackers/crackers/virii writers are male. Ain't so!

This discussion is closed to new replies.