Discussion Locked

Unsatisfactory warranty treatment

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I purchased ext. warranty for my compaq presario laptop. I spilt coffee all over the keyboard causing it to gradually stop working completely...no problem I just used a ext. keyboard since I called compaq and learned it would not be covered. My problem is this..several months latter the monitor quit on me so I sent decided to send in it for repair making it clear I would pay for any expenses concerning the keyboard only to have them send it back, missing screws, keys, and implying I spilt something on the monitor...this is bullhockey and I will not stand for it....monitor rubns near $1000 but its more a matter or princible.....THe monitor retired all on its own and is compaq's duty to replace it...any recommendations??I went to compaq and they put me on the phone with (ge their service dept giving me this line of crap...I could not reach compaq's manager at the time and got mad and steamed out...

6 replies

by jkaras

I used to work for Gateway comp. in a call center that they outsourced to. In any situation of abuse/cust error we wouldn't do much of anything. At times depending on the worker who doesnt care would replace without telling the supervisor full details of failure. Your situation falls in they have to inspect/repair. If they realize that you opened any part of that laptop warrantee is void. I know it sucks that a technicality is stopping them from honoring the warrantee so they increase their profits. Only advice I can offer is keep complaining till you get as high as you can to a top dog and demand documentitive proof on what failed/caused failure that prohibits coverage as breach of contract. Point out that could the tech forgotten screws,proof? Mistakes happen, we are all human. Is this a local repair authorized shop? If so call local media to run a story about shoddy workmanship/warrantee scam that could damage future business, believe it or not they always fold vs. the negitive press.

by phone6911

thanks much, I've worked tech support myself and always have relied on my technical abilities to address situations. I'm not much of a people person and don't like to be told no......thanks for all the good info and recommendations.....I think I canremain calm now while I keep hounding them, heck I'm not desperate to have it repaired immediately, maybe we'll make a game out of it, a saga to be continued

by timwalsh

What you may be missing here is that on a laptop, EVERYTHING electrical (to include the LCD connections to the motherboard) is located under the keyboard. Therefore, unless you can somehow prove that the screen dying was not somehow related to yourcoffee spill, Compaq is well within their right to refuse warranty service. They are not going to spend their dime trying to determine if the problem relates to the screen itself or its connection to the motherboard. They see user-caused damage, which isn't covered under warrenty, and they stop work there.

I don' think you would get any different treatment from any other vendor. Sorry.

by mrafrohead

I think that Tim is right. It may have caused the display to go out through time. Which is more than possible.

Liquid and electronics don't mix.

Although, I would try this if I was you. Considering the fact that they returned a substandard piece of equipment to you, I think that you now have grounds to fight.

SOOOoooo... Call the press as recommended above. Report them to the Better Business Bureau. Call the Attorney Generals office for your state and file a complaint.

Kick them in the nuts harder than you have ever kicked anyone else. And remember this when you do it. You are not only standing up for yourself against a conglomerate corporate machine, but also standing up for the rest of us small guys.

They need to be shown that they can not treat us like crap. Make an example of them. That's what I always try to do and it works.

Just keep this in mind. Change your focus from the broken monitor to the POS that they sent back to you with missing keys and screws. Tell them that you want it replaced. Push hard enough and they will do it.

Mrafrohead

by oldefar

Duane E. Zitzner, Executive Vice President, Personal Systems Group Hewlett-Packard Company.

Michael J. Winkler, Executive Vice President, Chief Marketing Officer Hewlett-Packard Company

Carleton S. (Carly) Fiorina, Chairman and Chief ExecutiveOfficer Hewlett-Packard Company

Carly has an email link at http://tinyurl.com/7j8d and the link shows the other senior management members.

Consider an email, and then a move to press with copies of correspondence and pictures.

This discussion is closed to new replies.