Discussion Locked

Upgrade from Win98SE to ME, 2000, or XP?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
System is a 500 MHz AMDk6-2 with 512 MB RAM, abundant hard drive space, and an older motherboard with 3 PCI and 3ISA slots, running on Windows 98SE operating system. Recent device additions now confront IRQ limitations, and "fatal errors" are becoming more inconvenient. Should operating system be upgraded to either ME, 2000, or XP for better resource management? Or, would overhead requirements of ME, 2000, or XP excessively slow down this system to negate any advantages of upgrading? Which upgrade path, if any, would be best?

9 replies

by hereinoz

I would tend to stay away from ME - there is no significant gain to be had, and ME did have some stability issues.

XP would probably carry too much overhead to give you satisfactory performance, so the best bet would be Win2000.

Bear in mind that if you do upgrade from Win98, you will carry most of the problems with you, and because you are going 98 to 2000, it is a different OS in effect, so some of your programs may not work, and may need to be re-installed. If you can manage it, a clean install would be better.

Before you upgrade, or re-format and install, try to get an old hard drive if you can, and a copy of Norton Ghost, and Ghost the original system to the other drive, so that, if you find that for any reason your motherboard doesn't like 2000, you can ghost back the old system and think again.

Whatever you decide, export your address book, your browser favourites (or bookmarks), and your email accounts to your data folder(s), back up the data folders, then go forit - at least then if events turn to straw, you can re-build the 98 system from scratch and put back your data, address book and mail accounts.

Good luck

by paulo.sedrez

Depending on your add-on hardware, you may not be able to upgrade to win2k - it has basically tha same limitations then WinNT, specially on multimidia devices. ME does better work on IRQ sharing, but stability issues are a killer.

Your best try would be XP, which is a memory hog - but since you have more then enough, it is a matter of fine tunning to improve the performance - that said, a LOT of fine tunning to get rid all kind of CPU hungry processes.

But don't forget: BACKUP YOUR DATA, and make it VERY WELL BACKED UP. Things can go very wrong ono upgrading.

--Sedrez

by ann777

Forget WinME.

For a 500 MHz computer even with 512 MB RAM, if you have a 60 GB or less hdd, I'd format the drive and put a fresh copy of Win98SE on it; depending of course, on what you plan to do with it.

The IRQ errors could be the result of the addition and incomplete removal of devices. What you might want to do before doing anything, is boot to Safe Mode and make sure that device manager does not have any duplicates of any devices it should not have. I've seen many a computer withtwo/three or more extra instances of NIC adapters that were not really supposed to be there (and indeed did not appear when running in Normal Mode).

If the computer is mostly used for office applications... then upgrade to Win2000 if you must upgrade.

If the computer is mostly used for games or other resource intensive programs (graphics, animation, etc), then I'd recommend either sticking with Win98SE or upgrading to WinXP.

WinXP if configured properly (unused services = disabled), will operate reasonably well on a 500 MHz computer with 512MB RAM... and WinXP has the added advantage of larger hdd management and System Restore points.

But if the IRQ limitations are because of external devices, you will also need to make sure you have WinXP specific drivers for all of these external devices. Be forewarned, that some devices (like parallel port scanners) have problems with WinXP. MS recommends USB for most (if not all) external devices.

by deadly ernest

I agree with the rest the best Microsoft operating system avialbale for a PC is Win XP Pro, then Win 98SE. Forget Win ME and Win XP Home.

Get Win XP Pro, disable the services that you are not using, use the inbuilt firewall. Your system should bemore than capable of running it and you should not an improvement, best to go with a clean install on a newly formatted drive or partition. I got a big improvement when I did this with a P III 500 and 256 MB RAM and a Celeron 500 with 256 MB RAM.I would recommend that you use a third party memory management program like MemTurbo or the like with any Microsoft operating system, all the MS o/s suffer from memory leakage to some degree.

This discussion is closed to new replies.