Discussion Locked

US Senators goad India to act on the Nuclear Deal.

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

2 Democrats - John Kerry & Joseph Biden and 1 Republican - Chuck Hagel stopped over at New Delhi on their way back from Pakistan.
Regarding the Nuclear Deal between USA and India Joseph Biden says the following:
[i]He warned that if the deal did not reach the US Congress in time, "it is highly unlikely the next president will be able to present the same deal.[/i]

Link: http://tinyurl.com/ytbfle

Why does he feel this way? Does he think Bush offered too much to India, and that a Democrat President will not offer the similar benefits? If yes, then is he not acting against his own party's interest? Or does Chuck Hagel feel the next Republican President will not offer the same benefits? In that case does he think Bush offered too much? If yes, why are they pushing for the deal?

So why are Kerry and Biden pushing Bush's deal? Are all the politicians from both the parties in all this together?

Is this deal just a way of getting India to oblige NPT via some kind of back door?

The deal seems to be very fishy.

8 replies

by dawgit

And intreging as well. First, I don't believe those 3 senators would be pushing any deal from Bush, especialy now. (He is a dead duck Pres.) The problem here is that I don't know that any-one knows exactly what Bush promised. He has had a bad habit of making promisses to get support for what ever he was up too. And very few were followed through, or even could be. (The money just ain't there folks) It does seem clear now that there were strings attached, (with-out a doubt, IMO) that bother the Indian Government. (The political party references seem a bit propaganda like here.) I could imagine this was a "Deal" for show-boating again, never meant to be implemented in the first place. As if the Indians needed incentive to stand against Pakistan. (Problem here is that those in Washington, have no clue as to what is really going on in the world, if it isn't what they want to believe. Sad, but... They haven't read History, if they can even read at all.) But there does need to be an answer, and everyone knows that. (The Indians might be trying to be polite by not insulting the US Gov. with the truth at this time.) Those Senators would love to show the present administration as bumbling idiots at this point. (It could get even worse if the Indian Gov. were to push it) Interesting. -d

by onbliss

I think folks do know much more about the deal. After the 123 Agreement between the countries, the Hyde Act was passed in USA.

The present Indian Government does not come out as it cares much about the strings or the country. The major party in the coalition government is the Congress, and it is pushing for the agreement. The Leftist parties that are part of the coalition are opposing the deal. So is the major opposition party - BJP, which is considered to be a nationalistic party.

by dawgit

Political play that is. (work, actually, for those inclined) Makes one wonder just what the what is. -d

by dawgit

take a look at this: [ http://www.bharat-rakshak.com/SRR/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=34&Itemid=1 ] it is a very long read, but an indepth, well prepared and written piece concerning this topic. Did I happen to mention it was long, printed out it is 5? pages long all type, very little white space. Really enjoyable actually.

I also foun this: (on your favorite site) [ http://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/viewtopic.php?t=3814 ]

India to tap uranium-rich Africa for fuel
By RAMESH RAMACHANDRAN

New Delhi, Feb. 4: New Delhi?s belated attempts at tapping the African continent for sourcing uranium to fuel its ambitious civil nuclear programme is beginning to show results. Gabon has conveyed that it will not be averse to supplying uranium to India. An Indian company recently bagged exclusive rights for exploration and mining of uranium in Niger.

Niger, Namibia and certain other African countries produce sizeable quantities of uranium and, importantly for India, are not members of the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG).

Sources tracking India?s engagement of Africa told this newspaper that Gabon is willing to enter into a commercial transaction with India. New Delhi is studying the possibility of reciprocating by enhancing its civil and military cooperation with Gabon, a source said, adding that the Mumbai-based Taurian Resources has made a foray into Niger?s uranium mining industry. The sources maintained that India needs to refocus attention on the non-NSG countries also because of the reluctance of Australia, Can Canada and Kazakhstan to supply uranium to non-NPT signatories like India. This newspaper has reported that Canada and Kazakhstan have joined Australia in suggesting to India that there is no change in their policies of exporting uranium only to those countries that have signed the NPT.

The Summit of the India-Africa Forum, to be held here in April, can be expected to lend an impetus to New Delhi?s desire to court the African continent for uranium. The sources said that secretary (economic relations) K.C. Singh in the ministry of external affairs has been mandated to explore all the options and to give direction to the newly created division of energy security.

According to Prof. Bharat Karnad of the New Delhi-based Centre for Policy Research, exploring the non-NSG African states for uranium is "eminently realisable" and a better option than tying India to the proposed India-US civil nuclear cooperation agreement.

"We don?t need this deal (for uranium). The government is living in a fool?s paradise and waiting for things to happen when we should have done our home work and first approached the non-NSG countries before exploring the India-US nuclear deal," Prof. Karnad told this newspaper.

He said that some African countries, like Niger, have "absolutely enormous" deposits of natural uranium and are not members of the NSG. He blamed New Delhi?s "slow-moving, viscous" foreign policy for India not tapping the African continent for sourcing uranium to fuel her nuclear energy programme.

"They (non-NSG African countries) are happy to provide. These will be commercial deals. The question is how can we incentivise them," Prof. Karnad added. Namibia, Niger, Nigeria, Uganda and Angola, which are outside the NSG, can be approached for procuring natural uranium. Namibia is among the largest producers of uranium. Similarly, uranium is among the largest export items for Niger. Triangular cooperation among India, Portugal and Angola, a former Portuguese colony, has also been proposed.

A source familiar with the negotiations for the proposed India-US civil nuclear cooperation agreement said New Delhi could consider a two-pronged approach to meet its appetite for energy. The first prong would require sourcing of nuclear fuel from the non-NSG countries. New Delhi could either make direct investments in uranium mines abroad or collaborate with Indian companies operating in certain African countries.

The second prong would be to augment domestic production of uranium. The sources cited Atomic Energy Commission chairman Anil Kakodkar as saying that domestic uranium production would be augmented and exploration will be stepped up in Meghalaya and Karnataka. Dr Kakodkar also said that a uranium mine and processing mill would soon be commissioned at Tummalapalli, in Andhra Pradesh.

I add here, and where was Pres. Bush this week? Africa. China is considered by many to be the new "Threat" in Africa. (They might 'steal' all the good stuff.-before we do.) It all fits, in a very perverted way, but it fits. -d

by onbliss

....it is so amusing to me for you to cite me that forums. Are you a regular lurker there?

I am glad you seem to like that website. Anyone having any kind of association with armed forces will find that site interesting.

Try the discussion forums too....

by dawgit

I try to stay up with it at least once a week. Just to keep up to date. I check out the forums, but I don't think I'll be posting there. (I would only embarase my self there.) I also follow a couple of good blogs form India. It helps to give me a feel as to what the rest of the world is thinking. To me that is important. -d

edited to add: there is a lot of good articles on History there as well, and as I was a History major... well it kind of grows on you. -d

by onbliss

...you won't embarrass yourselves. Every now and then Americans do come and post. Like anywhere else, there is both pro & anti US crowd out there. So you might get some tough time from the anti-US folks :-)

There are some Israeli and Pakistani defense forums out there too :-)

by dawgit

Isreali one. (I have a friend, former IDF, now in Foreign Ministry, and had the pleasure of working in the area of some of the other bunch as well.) As for the Pakistani's, I leave them alone. It's just too hot going that direction at the moment. (hint-hint) -d

This discussion is closed to new replies.