10 replies
by epepke
It's sad to me that so little effort is given toward user-interface design in general. The common belief seems to me to be that if you just slap a few forms together, that's good enough. I believe that there are many reasons for this, and I'm in the process of putting together an essay, tentatively to be published by the ACM Ubiquity on-line newsletter, to describe some of these factors.
One thing about your message, though, gives me pause: the combination UI/Graphic Designers. Graphic Designers are not necessarily good as user interface design. Although they can be good at it, too many graphic designers are interested more in making something look "kewl" than in making it usable.
Furthermore, there are some lamentable web designpractices that seem to be standard, such as having the main menu options on the left side, as far away from the vertical scroll bar as possible. (Even websitesthatsuck.com uses this convention.)
by vota idiota
grouping together of the GD/UI is another reflection of the lack of investment/serious belief in this side of development. Typical situation I have encounter is 8 programmers on a project, one UI developer/site builder (me) who ends up scripting/programming anyway, and one GD who is geninuely too busy to to have permanent/positive input and who, unsurprisely, becomes a little disgruntled upon the realisation that his/her designs haven't been implemented..(due to lack of resources placed on thisside of things).
Maybe this whole thing is symptomatic of an industry that cares more about deadlines (i.e: just get the damn site working and stable) than investment in human computer interaction and user interface. Of course..long term, thislack of investment will be detrimental to the site, just because the programming staff (and the management) can't see any immediate, tangible benefit from UI research/work.
by shiny_topadm
by epepke
The best UI designers are, I think, people who have at least some experience in anthropology and psychology.
For an entertaining commentary on the relationship of art to web sites, go to http://www.satirewire.com/news/0011/cubist_site.shtml
Atleast in software, I am sad to say that I think that it is not merely that too little attention is given to user interface design. I think that the marketplace actually selects for bad user interfaces.
This should be less true of the web, for reasons that a lot of people have suggested. However, as I look at websitesthatsuck.com, I see that a substantial number of the sucky websites are some of the most successful.
by shanghai sam
I think companies are slowly learning that they MUST place the user and the user's needs first in their product development process.
I think much of the dotcom fallout can be attributed to companies that overlooked the user by creating products for which there was no user need.
Personally, I think it a great time to be in the Information architecture / User interface design field. Many of the companies that don't "get it" are gone. And the companies that do "get it" are starting to invest more in user-centered design processes and usability research and testing.
I strongly believe that the Information architect / User interface designer that can balance both business goals AND user needs is invaluable to any company that depends on the internet to interface with customers.
So I think that you should focus on the companies that "get it." Ask them questions about their processes and methodologies upfront (like "at what stage do you perform usability tests?" or "explain your methods for performing task analysis"), before you get into a bad situation. I know that being picky about your clients can be difficult in a slow economy; but, in the long run, it will be worth it.
Having worked for both types of companies, Iknow that there is nothing worse than pouring all of your effort into a project that you know will ultimately fail to meet user needs.
Hope this helps.
sm
by epepke
As a passionate proponent of usability for a quarter of a century, after seeing products with good usability consistently get beaten in the marketplace by inferior products, I am quite depressed about the state of usability. I'm writing a book about it, which will probably never be published, as it contradicts the naive optimism of the usability guru set.
When you make a smooth, unobtrusive interface, be prepared to hear the following:
* It's a toy.
* It must have been easy to write, so it isn't worth much.
* Build a system that even a fool can use, and only a fool will want to use it.
* It isn't impressive enough. There aren't enough buttons. I want to see lots and lots of little icons.
* You're insulting my intelligence.
and so on and so on.
I still like to make usable interfaces, but I no longer believe naively that they are what the marketplace selects for.
by admin
That's funny, in a sad sort of way. People still think if you don't sweat and toil enough it's no good.
Interestingly enough, most commonly used "labor-saving" devices consume more time and energy than ever before.
It's too bad that the people whoknow how to enjoy their spare time never win any wars....
by smorty71
I don't think that I was being naive when I suggested that working for a company that adheres to user-centered design principles in their product development process is better than working for one that doesn't.
And from the sound of your "quotes"above, it sounds like you haven't worked for the companies that "get it."
I prefer to concentrate on what the users of the product have to say. That's the opinion that really counts. And if you have your customers behind your design, it is much more difficult for anyone in your company to complain (although someone always does).
I have developed a lot of user interfaces, some that other people in the company didn't like (and some that I didn't even like); but in the end, the designs weren't for me or my co-workers, they were for our customers.
And because I kept the needs of both the company and the customer in mind while creating the interface, I have yet to hear any comments like the ones you mentioned.
So while I will accept "optimistic," I won't accept "naive."
sm
by epepke
during the 1980's and early 1990's I did research in user interfaces and presented a couple of times at SIGGRAPH. So you aren't really in a position to know what I haven't done.
As far as working for a company that thinks it's OK or even good tomake usable products, well, sure, that's great. However, as for the orthodox view that the problem with usability is the supply, that's not true. If you don't think you are naive, that's fine, but when I believed in the orthodoxy proposed by people like Donald Norman, I was being naive, which is what I said. If that bothers you, well, whatever.
I can't think of any response to your claim that you have truly never heard any of the comments that I mentioned. I will believe that you may never have heard them about your software; people don't say things like that to my face, either. However, I can't imagine any way, other than staying away from all publications, that you haven't heard them at all.
In any event, it is unquestionably true that the most popular suite of operating systems and software is a second-rate copy of a copy yet again. It is also true that a lot of the very good, usable products are not around any more and have been replaced by mediocre products. The companies that built them are either out of the picture or struggling.
I was once at a panel of people who were talking about usability. One guy gave an amusing talk about the scythe as a mature technology where form afforded function. That sounds great until you ask how many people heavily invest in scythe works.
by smorty71
It is clear that you have an agenda that you want to cover regardless of the topic.
I believe the original discussion concerned whether or not there were any good places left for a dedicated IA/UI person to work.
I tried to address that by suggesting to VOTA IDIOTA that he seek out companies that share his beliefs. That's all. No big revelations.
I did share some positive experiences that I've had in the UI field as support for my suggestion. Call that whatever you like.
I was simply trying to address the issue that VOTA IDIOTA raised. Maybe you could try sticking to that.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending