Discussion Locked

Users of XP should just Dump it

0 helpful
33 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Windows XP was and still is the most pirated software out there in terms of OS. This reason is because well Frankly, the people think the same way I do. XP isn't worth the money to buy it. Okay Vista OG was a flop, but even Windows VIsta Owns XP when installed with SP1 installed from the Get Go.

However I do agree with MS pushing Windows 7. Why? Well becuase in teh 3 years or so I have been using, I myself and all my customers who took the plung, never ounce had anything happen that got in the way. The only ones that did were people who didn't have hardware with Vista drivers available. With this said. MS is doing the right thing, finally in teh what 25 years they have been around. The end users need to wake up and figure out that better technology of course always has a learnign curve, but really 7 is and will always be easier to learn the XP ever was.

Sure Bill Gates Prized OS XP did turn out to be a decent OS, and finally spending 10 bux as I did to get my legit copy was actualyl worth it, but Windows 7 is worth every penny. Stop laggin Wake up and get off XP, IT iS DEAD!

33 replies

by slayer_

...sets of speakers using two sound cards.... You can't. But XP can. This is difficult to accomplish in Linux as well, but Win XP + GOM player or Classic media player, works perfect.

So if I want to (And I do almost constantly) catch up on my TV shows and watch the downloaded ones, while playing a game, my TV outputs the TV show sound, and my computer outputs the game sound.

by av .

We plan to move to Windows 7 within the next 2 years at work, but our critical legacy apps have to be upgraded first. So does the hardware.

If I could, I'd move right now to Windows 7, but it's not that easy.

AV

by seanferd

I just felt no need to repeat what Ron had so clearly articulated.

I also noticed the contradiction you have pointed out.

v/ & v/

by hal 9000

One customer who runs XP does so because they have to. Their Mission Critical Software isn't written to run on anything newer and as it's a small scale application it's not only incredibly expensive, doesn't have anything to compare with it there are currently no plans to rewrite it for either Vista or 7.

But also take into account a Network Printer that they have in place that they had to build a new building to house, it costs well over 55K and it doesn't have any Vista or 7 Drivers. The person from M$ just said buy a new printer which if it was a $100.00 unit would be acceptable but as they can buy about 20 High End NB's for the cost of this printer you work out what they want to do here. :D

To me it's an easy decision look at a 2K Computer that will work very well with 7 but not be able to print anything on the existing hardware or stick with what they already have which works and be happy with it. Not much brain Power required as to what they wan to do here buy all new hardware including a network printer or stick with what they have which works doesn't cost any money. Sure they may want new NB's at some point but they are not going to consider using 7 till after their Network Printer comes out of it's Service Contract which is still 3 years away so it's a [b]No Brainier[/b] as to what they want when you consider the costs of what you call Upgrading.

Not to mention that they will be unable to actually do their work as their main application doesn't work on 7 and it's a No Win Situation for M$ Representatives who constantly tell them to upgrade as the M$ Product is the most expensive thing that they will ever use and the computers and associated equipment are cheap to replace. :D

Col

by dr dij

We have mission critical medical apps that run on XP.

The horror of this debate is not which OS is better, it is that this debate even comes up. It is an Obamanation [sic] that m$ screws around with the OS so much and so frequently that the operating system version even has to be considered.

While they have gotten over the horrors of updating .DLLs versions so that older apps would not run till you re--registered an older version

(their excuse was that 'it will enable the programs to use new functionality without being upgraded, instead it would tend to break apps)

Sadly, m$ is in the biz to shovel out copies of new and improved (wait there's more!!) OSes like late night 'seen on TV' jockey Billy Mays.

In reality they should be concerned with providing a stable environment that apps dating back to the beginning of time could run on (in computer terms that is about 20 years since the beginning of windoze)

And DON'T TELL ME THEY COULDN"T DO THIS! what with virtual environments and virtual this and virtual OS versions on a PC, they certainly could. As part of a class I downloaded a version of high end reporting tool that was put by instructor in a virtual environment so that it would run without question. I've lost use of some great programs I wish I could run due to this OS thing and the makers not updating software. Why should they be forced to put in the effort when the OS maker was the one who caused the problem?

I also have a student version of a high end math prog that only runs on XP / 2000. I was searching for a new computer and have to therefore get refurbs with XP pro.

to paraphrase a TV person, 'STOP THE OS MADNESS!!!!

by oreamnos_americanus

So what stops these folks from running the critical apps in an XP Virtual Machine? I have scanner I am to cheap to replace and a couple of pieces of software that don't run in Win 7 either. So when I bought my newest machine I spent the few extra beans for Pro instead of Home Premium (which I do run on my laptop). A business should be running Pro anyway. XP Mode in Windows 7 is not even the only way to run XP in a virtual environment, there are several more.

by danerd

just because its new it doesnt mean its better, i always say---if your computer is doing what you want it to do then there is no need for an upgrade.

by seanferd

Won't happen. XP → 7, if I'm going to continue modernizing with windows at all.

A lot of people, and particularly enterprises, have a lot of money invested in software that won't run without kludges, if at all, on 7. Never mind the perfectly good hardware which might not run with 7.

I'd have to say that 7 has got to be the best Windows OS RTM of all time, but it still has some issues, and many enterprises will not deploy until some number of months after RTM (it's called "testing") or until after the first SP.

And if you can't do on 7 what you want to do, and you can do it with XP, why change? I mean, MS put the XP VM capability into the pricer version of 7 for a reason, although it isn't always a good solution.

by nexs

Let's all talk dogmatic!
Actually, I agree, but also disagree.
XP is/was good. It works, is easy enough to troubleshoot(for the most part) and because it's been around for a while, there's plenty of other support and drivers for different hardware types.

I disagree because Vista sucked the proverbial testes. I'm sorry for any offense taken in my language, but in my experience, it's ran terribly slow and just guzzled resources.
Windows 7, on the other hand, is also good. Lots of auto-go-magic bits and pieces. Though the only problem i have is the change of location and how you do administrative tasks, but that's all part of M$'s plan to make money off training etc.

All in all, it's all good.

by deadly ernest

for the Home Premium version, which is the main one that will be used by the retail user. Also, from a business perspective, you are talking about dumping many thousands of dollars worth of software and replacing (if you can, as much of it does NOT have Win 7 versions available).

If Microsoft hadn't done the 'screw the user, let's change the command code sets again' bit, then they may have had business ready to move on over as they could continue to use their existing specialist business software, but that is NOT the case.

Win 7 is a total screw up in the big business environment, and a worse mess in the Home environment, UNLESS you like have a system that's sitting there and screaming out 'make me a bot.'

by takuya_101

Well reading what you have said is what I see a little pig headed and closed minded, what would you say to a person still using Windows 2000?

While Microsoft had failed for some time to not releasing an operation system within a good time frame, that has nothing to do with needed to upgrade. Just think for a moment you have say five thousand more or less computer systems, an unknown number of servers, all with scripts and applications written all for special reasons and tasks, and your saying everyone should upgrade?

Just think of the time it would take all the Hospitals, Doctors, School's and the Governments to test, trial, deploy and replace there systems, not to think of the time and money needed. (And replacing all the special applications and scripts written for the 2003 and 2000 servers)

Also have you noticed how much Windows 7 talks to the internet, in my four months of playing with Windows 7 I see it as a security risk, yes all the processor might be talking to Microsoft own IP addressed, but the question is what is being sent?

Unless I can access documentation which fully discloses what information is sent to those IP addresses and how to fully disable this function, I don't believe accessing switching to the new shiny thing as the best move.

by ron k.

You're certainly consistent. That's a good thing.
I appreciate the information about Windows 7. That's the first I've heard of it.
Adobe has something similar, if you have one of their CS4 packages.

by charliespencer

This subject seems to be his obsession. He's too radical and offensive to be a paid MS shill. Apparently he's just obsessed with XP, the way some sports fans spend all their time discussing a player they hate.

Poor guy could obviously use some 'professional help', if you know what I mean.

by ansugisalas

Drugs are bad, get help.
Win7 might be worth considering in three years, or not. End of message.

by ron k.

Overuse and abuse can be harmful. Some drugs can also make you sit around with such a big grin that your upper lip becomes dried to above your teeth and gets stuck in that position until you get an orange soda. Or so I've heard.

by ansugisalas

A new life awaits you in the offline rehab-colonies! A chance to begin again in a golden land of opportunity and offline adventure! :p
Drugs are bad. Unless, like me, you have a prescription :D

by ron k.

One with a prescription. Cool! :D I hope the underlying cause isn't too difficult.
Nothing for me, thanks. I may have to drive.

by seanferd

Good question, great answer. I see that everything is under control here.

Have you added this to the Urban Dictionary?

by peconet tietokoneet

If you are at home and want to have a new Windows operating system to look cool, then yes go for it.
In a working environment, such as big corporations, they tend to hold on to their money because to a big company it costs more because of the licensing of many computers, not just the one (computer) or two (computers) but could be quite a few hundred.
PLUS on top of all that, different applications made (or coded) for the companies operating systems are (sometimes) running soundly, so why change all of that to go backwards and start all over again, test upon test with each bit of hardware and software. Home use yes, work place (depending on your size) no.

by seanferd

Why spend the system resources to run an OS you don't want and a VM on top of that to run the OS you do want? Assuming it all behaves as expected.

Why not just keep XP boxes for applications or hardware that won't run in 7 or Vista?

by hal 9000

Not everything works in XP Mode.

By the time you add the Virtual Machine inside the running OS it's so painfully slow as to be not so great compared to the old box that runs XP anyway. ;)

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.