Discussion Locked

Vote Ralph Nader for president

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Naturally he can't win and with your dumb electoral system your vote is wasted, but if enough people voted for him the major parties might actually get the message that you are dissatisfied with both of them.

In this interview with Amy Goodman (yes raging, liberal loony) I cannot fault anything Nader says.

The crux of his argument is that as long as you stick with your two party system the quality of your presidents will continue to decline as election after election, people will vote for the lesser of two weevils.

http://www.democracynow.org/2008/6/18/ralph_nader_on_barack_obama_it

As usual, petty personal insults against myself will be ignored. After all, seagulls must serve some purpose in the grander scheme of things. :)

5 replies

by maxwell edison

People who admonish our electoral system simply don't understand (or forget) that the form of government we have is a Republic. We do not hold national elections in the United States - we never have, and we never will. We have separate State elections. To hold national elections would further infringe on the sovereignty and rights of individual States.

We've also always had a two-party system - and again, we always have, and we always will. Generally speaking, things get done by majority rule. If there were several different parties vying for seats, forming a majority would take-on a different form. What differentiates our two-party system from other Parliamentary forms of governments might be seen in the formation of those coalitions between different factions within the party. The Green Movement, for example, has found a home within the Democratic Party, forming the coalition before an election. In other Parliamentary systems, even though that same Green Party might win some seats, similar coalitions are formed after elections. Both methods result in establishing an eventual majority, but the means is reversed.

As far as initiating drastic change, it's always been done within the party, or by a split within a major party, not by the emergence of a strong third party. As one who has strong libertarian leanings, I see making change within the Republican Party a more viable option than holding onto hope that the Libertarian Party might become a major player. The latter simply won't happen. Standing firm on one's principle is one thing (and a good thing, I might add), but finding balance with reality is the only thing that will make change possible.

Voting for a third-party candidate is like spitting into the wind. On the other hand, by associating yourself with one of the two major parties, you at least have a better chance of getting your hand on the rudder so as to better navigate into that wind - thereby having a better chance of shifting the direction one way or the other.

by notsochiguy

In principle, I have no problem voting for a third party choice; assuming I felt that third party choice actually represented an improvement over what the two main parties provided, or was much more closely aligned with my personal views.

When a guy running for president has 'dudes' (and yes, I mean dudes as in 'hey, dude, that's not cool, man') running around looking like they were just paroled from prison and looking for a way back, and smelling as if they bathed in bum urine, asking people to sign a petition to get his name on the ballot, I'm thinking that's not a candidate for me.

But you know what, I'd vigorously defend his right to be on the ballot, all the same.

by charliespencer

"... with your dumb electoral system your vote is wasted,...people will vote for the lesser of two weevils."

Why should I respect election advice from someone who clearly expresses his contempt for our system? Why should I respect election advice from someone who isn't going to be governed by the winner?

by jdclyde

you shouldn't....

Which is dumb, the system that runs the last super power in the world, or the person that doesn't understand why it works they way it does?

Funny how we always hear about "majority" until it comes to things like courts legislating from the bench like in CA.

This discussion is closed to new replies.