Discussion Locked

Was this the correct thing to do?

0 helpful
56 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Give this little story someone posted, a read.

http://tinyurl.com/jk9yy

I think what the IT guys did was good, in light of what was about to happen to them had the CFO succeeded in his plans.

What do you guys think?

]:)

Edited to fix a typo

56 replies

by jamesrl

The IT guys may have had all the best intentions. But BCCing the whole office was the wrong thing to do. People need to trust that their mails are not being read unless there is cause. They violated that trust for the whole company, not just the three.

Now if in the course of the investigation, the person discovered emails which may indicate malfeasance, then disclosing them to the board is the correct thing to do. If the porn sites were illegal (underage) or were against corporate policy they should go to the police in the former case and the board in the latter.

James

by stargazerr

You cant go around trying to sell the company and kick out the employees.

Forwarding all emails (including the porn ones) was wrong I admit. but the employees of the company have a right to know what the CFO is about to do.

]:)

by jamesrl

You can go around trying to sell the company and kick out the employees. The employees do not have the right to know what the CFO is doing. The Board of Directors and the CEO do however have to know exactly what the CFO is doing, and clearly that isn't the case.

I think that transperency is good - one of my employers was quite open about the fact they were going to have layoffs.

But there is a time and place for that, and companies have the right to make changes that may negatively impact employees. Thats life. I've been laid off from a company where I had a great track record, lots of raises and great reviews. In the end, its their call.

James

by dmambo

James is, as usual, a moral compass. Our mothers told us all that two wrongs don't make a right. As he said, since this potentially illegal activity came to light out of the normal course of business, the admins had the right to go to the board of directors, but not to include every employee, especially non-equity employees.

I'm sure it was quite satisfying for them, though.

by faradhi

First, I do not believe the story. The Board would have to approve the sell of the company. As far as I know, at some point the exec would have had to present the plan to the board.

For the sake of this discussion lets say the story was true. James and DMambo was correct that the proper thing to do in that situation was for the Admins to contact the board. Of course that means that the Admins have to accept the consequences of doing the correct thing. The Admins took the cowards way out. They did not want to accept the consequences of their noble actions. As such, they showed a lack of integrity.

If I were on the board, I would have been asking them questions on how the emails were sent to all employees. They are lucky they were not fired. At the very least, I would have reprimanded them.

That may be harsh. But integrity and responsibility is very important for an IT admin.

by too old for it

I wonder why the C-Level execs didn't just tell everyone upfront that they were going to get screwed. Oh yeah, they teach that in MBA school to not let on while you are lining your own pockets.

No wonder techs feel they have a target on their back and therefore have a "1st Air Cav" approach to CxO shenangins.

by mp3.aac.mp4

The story seems to fairy-tale'ish "happily ever-after" kind. Evil CFO terrorizes poor-innocent non-managers; poor-innocent non-managers make a plan to overthrow evil-CFO. Evil-CFO is bannished from the land, and replaced by good-CFO. poor-innocent non-managers lived happily ever after!

Well, fact IS stranger than fiction, but there are obvious flaws in the story...
Why would the CFO use his official email to send a mail to a porn site? He could not have been that stupid to not have a seperate, free web-based ID for such things.

by rob mekel

Legally spoken. In Europe it is not allowed to look into some-ones email, neither private or nor company email. On company email there are exceptions, that is if by an employee a law is broken or there is reason to believe he/she has or if company rules(writen out and not in conflict with any law) are broken, then it is allowed.

Humanly however I do understand him/her for doing so. And there was a reason for doing so, as the email-server failed and they had to find out what caused the problem. But if it is a legal reason? It can be questioned.

Rob

by cq_west

Here in America, many corporations (mine included) require end-users to sign a document delegating the appropriate use of company resources including email, internet and files and the penalties for violating this use. Many times, this includes termination. Many times, this outlines the fact that any resource created, modified or sent to third-parties is the property of the organization or company, not the individual.

In the process of a day, most IT personnel need to access end-user resources for the purposes of troubleshooting, configuration and/or training. In the process of doing this, I have worked with other IT Staff that have discovered inappropriate web-sites or illicit/illegal emails. Because of the usage policy signed by the end-user and the corporate policy of enforcement, this has lead to the termination of the questioned employees.

I do agree that the methodology was incorrect. The board should have been notified of the activity and presented the evidence. However, by sending all email to all employees, both of the techs involved should have been terminated as many IT staff have to sign confidentiality agreements.

Our organization has this type of policy. If anything is discovered to be illegal or out of line with corporate policy, then the evidence is presented to the IT manager or directors. From there it moves through the various chains of command. We do not probe for activity unless we observe patterns and/or discover this type of data during the normal course of a support call.

by too old for it

(a) In what locale is it legal to create pr0n with 17 year olds, (b) is it a country with which we have a free-trade treaty, and (c) if it is legal to create and possess there, isn't there a free-trade argument to be made that it should not be restricted here (as long as you keep the age 18 for locally-produced pr0n).

Given your individual countries trade laws, your mileage may vary.

by jaqui

not very practicle though.

easy to set up postifx to send all emails to one address, for the legally required archiving purposes. ]:)

guess what, the Tech person appointed to maintain the servers and archives of data is legally allowed to read every message.

hmm, corporate email policy says no personal emails? if they are creating the archives required, then you are caught.

Most company owned fax machines I've worked with are also configured to print a duplicate copy of all faxes overnight, so that the company has a copy for the records.

by ontheropes

I have some low-priced commercial property for sale that is currently used to sell top-of-the-line yet inexpensive laptops on Ebay.

You?re sure to profit from this deal because we?re located right next door to a nice 300-employee self-sustaining company that?s looking at our building for expansion. Illness forces sale. Please hurry. Use your credit card.

by ontheropes

I just thought that it should be SO obvious to people that the link that started this thread has all of the earmarks of an Urban Legend, not even a really good one.

I retract my "offer" to "sell" the building next door to "their" now thriving "self-sustaining" company that was saved by the heroic efforts of IT people with no integrity.

by eblank

Hummm.. Interesting, I have some Seashore property for sale in Nevada. Inhereited from my maternal grandfathers great uncles' neices boyfriend who recently died from a strange illnes in Gunnie. I have to get rid of the Seashore property due to tax liability, so I am willing to part with it for only $100.00US/acre, but I have to sell it in 100 acre lots (part of the will).
If you are not willing to take this in trade forthe property beside the new 300 person employee tech firm, perhaps someone else out there migth be interested... Any takers?

by oneamazingwriter

I can tell you that I don't believe we will be interested in trading at this time, but that we would be willing to list your property if your present ad finds no buyers.

I will consult with my partner and get back to you. We might be able to work something out that will be agreeable to all parties.

As an aside, though, from me personally, would you consider a used Kayack with a few small holes and some rusty paint cans as trade?

by ontheropes

we offer (2) unlimited mileage air travel tickets on the RailRoad of your choice.

Ticket offer valid only in limited areas of the US and Canada. Black-out dates may apply. Small activation fee required. No refund after 30 seconds. Taxes and maintenance fees not included.

by oneamazingwriter

For ONCE, I understood something! I actually got what you intended. Don't get used to this, though. I'm only noted for occassional clarity. If I wind up with Alzeimers, I doubt if anyone will notice any difference.

by ontheropes

I'm glad you got it but maybe you should be concerned about understanding the ramblings of my alleged mind.

by oneamazingwriter

The thing struck me as an excellent work of fiction, and I applauded the author...then you replied and I giggled and was glad someone said something. The whole thing, though, was a great exercise in sorting one's values, and that appears to be what most people did with it where it was posted and here. I got a kick out of your "rambling".
Robin Hood and his band of Merry Men is overdone. Me? I like Peter Pan!

by oneamazingwriter

when Jaqui laughed, I thought, "OK, maybe someone sees what I see. Then neverbusted did his wonderful sale, and I was ready for it.

I realy think there ought to be some kind of celebration. This surely isn't going to be happening too often here. I generally sit here watching things go right over my head and say, "Looks like a pretty bird. I wonder what kind it is."

by jaqui

My favorite was the interest in "Ocean view property just off the coast of Florida"

I couldn't beleive how many people wanted to buy.

by the admiral

Well, first we have to take a look at who was not being ethical in the first place. Was it the executive or the geeks?

I say the executive, since he was perving out on a kiddie porn site and attempting to use enron mathematics to set up himself and other executives with parachutes that they were not entitled to.

Secondly, while I find copying all emails from the executive to all non-management personnel concerning, I do find that some times you have to cross the line in order to get the appropriate action taken.

You have to look at it like the desperate parent and a kidnapped child. The parent would do anything to get the child back, even that which could be considered unethical.

by daniel.muzrall

Well, I'd say that the geeks had the right idea at heart, but strayed a little on their execution.

I'm assuming that all employees at this company signed an acceptable use policy, and that the policy included language stating that all communications made on company equipment (i.e. phones, e-mail, fax, cell phone, etc.) are the property of the company, and that the company can monitor those communications. I would also assume that the policy prohibits viewing/downloading porn on company computers or using the company data circuits.

That being said, the CFO has no reasonable expectation of privacy when sending e-mails, and would be in clear violation of the acceptable use policy on the porn bit. The CFO also made a very bad and dangerous decision in sending detailed personal financial information via an unsecure e-mail. On those two counts, the CFO gets what he deserves.

The CFO's e-mails regarding the selling of the company and its assets could have been done in a legitimate fashion, but since he would be profitting in an underhanded method, and on the backs of investors and employees alike, this is something that should be reported immediately to the board.

I agree with the geeks notifying the board, but believe that they should not have set up the BCC to all employees. I feel that this is an abuse of their powers, and is a reckless, irresponsible tactic. That being said, the final outcome of the process was right on, but the road to get there wasn't the best.

by too old for it

tho maybe I would have taken it a step further: Round up the CxO crew, kill 'em all, let god sort 'em out.

(You should see what I want to do to virus and malware authors ... ]:) )

by oldbag

Virus and malware authors deserve it. Since I grew up with 5 brothers, I have very clear ideas of what needs to be done.

by mickster269

Well, that one sailed WAY over my head.

I'm going to go stand in the "Clueless Corner" for a bit.

by ontheropes

I?ll just hang on to that property and put it up for sale again later, someplace else.
I might have to make improvements to bring up the market value as I didn?t even get a single decent offer.

If you read this Jaqui, thanks for the suggestion.

by oneamazingwriter

I was a Realtor and have done remodeling, papering, painting and decorating...just in case you want a business partner.

I don't need to show you my card, do I? :D

edit: if you don't put the ing on paper and you don't add the comma after papering, what you get is "paper painting" and that's one of the things I am NOT good at! LOL

by jmgarvin

This happens everywhere with every bean counter.

What CFOs, or any financial only person, don't get is the fact that human facts DO have an impact on the bottom line.

If you increase hours and cut pay, plan on poor moral (which usually means poor output). While a happy worker doesn't mean a productive worker, an unhappy worked DOES mean an unproductive worker.

by faradhi

In the context of this fictional story, The C-level exec's behavior is irrelevant when discussing the ethics of the situation. It does not matter what activity the C-Level exec's were doing. If it was a determent to the company then the IT Admins had the ethical responsibility to bring it to the board. No one else but the board should have gotten the information. It is true that the IT exec's might have experienced negative consequences. That is the risk you take when you stand on principals. It was unethical and cowardly to broadcast the issue to all employees.

by too old for it

... after all, no company's CxOs would set out to screw hard working employees ...

Where DO boards of directors find these people?

by avid

i don't care how he was found out. the guy was looking at little girls naked. he is a freakin sicko. ever hear of the phrase "you have to break a few eggs to make an omelette"? the portion about screwing his employees takes a back seat to his illegal kiddy porn. why does it seem that everyone is concentrating on the money issue. And this opinion is coming from a business owner.

by faradhi

Aside from that, lets for the sake of argument it did actually occur.

Then the IT admins had the responsibility to bring the evidence to the authorities. They are still cowards for forwarding the CxO's emails to all employees and letting someone else do the whistle blowing.

Understand, they would not have been wrong if they reported the wrong doing. However this is not what the story portrayed. In this story the IT Admins were absolutely wrong in their actions.

by sleepin'dawg

It was a cute little story right up until they mentioned screwing the investors. Let me assure you that the first people to get paid off in any corporate sale or IPO are the investors and the venture capitalists. In fact if the CFO was flogging the company around it would proabably been in total agreement with the board and all the investors. Understand that. The investors and venture capitalists are there to build a financial entity. They owe nothing to the employees other than a days pay for a days work; unless they have made other contractual promises to the employees; such as vacation time; severance pay; profit sharing; medical and dental coverage; etc. ad infinitum.

Any employee who violated confidentiality in such a manner would be black listed. I would never hire an individual like that because I would never be able to rely on his discretion to maintain confidentiality and I would fire anyone who violated our corporate confidence. I would black list them. In fact breaches of trust in this manner, in certain industries, could lay the employee open to criminal charges.

As I said an Urban Legend, never happened and isn't likely to either. As for the porn thing c'mon, get real, how would any one know if the girls were 17 or 16 or 15 or 14 or 13 or even younger. The point is once you dip below 15 the laws on child pornography kick in and your CFO is looking at some real serious jail time; for child pornography but not for financial skulduggery unless it was a public company, which it obviously wasn't.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by ontheropes

Of course you don?t need to show me your card. If you said it on the Internet it must be true. I appreciate your offer and will keep it in mind should the occasion arise.

by eblank

While the rusty paint cans may be of interest in the future, I must warn you that any Kayak with small holes in it may be a sign of impending sale of your corporation. For your own job security, I urge you to make sure that your partner is not currently negotiating a sale behind your back. Just to make sure, I would advise getting some knowledgable hacker to spy on all aspects of your partners incoming Chineese take out orders. Purchasing of Mushu-Gaipan is often seen in direct correlation to backstabbing sell outs in CxO's.

BTW, What kind of paint?

by oneamazingwriter

We sell only the best. Guaranteed full coverage of tall sky scrapers, and leaves no marks on any windows.

But my partner has made a different offer and I NEVER cross my partner, so if you want the Kayak and the rusty paint cans, you'll have to speak to him and add to what you are offering in trade.

I happen to know that Mushy Guy Pan left the business years ago and cleaned up her act, so I'm on to your tricks! Several men named John proposed but I heard she married some guy named Ralph.

by oneamazingwriter

Watch out for this dude. I think he has something up his sleeve besides an arm! He's into voodoo Kayaks! Make certain you limit those tickets to the the west, and keep him off the east coast.

by eblank

While the original offer of Kayaks with holes was interesting as a trade for the Seashore Property in Nevada, This mention of VOODOO Kayaks may be the deal maker. Tell me, is it possible to use said Kayaks in Network monitoring while going down the river? While I am very interested in learning to WhiteWater kayak, I am concerned that if I take up this sport that I would no longer be able to monitor my co-workers activities in an effort to prevent future fiscal Malfesance by the Janitors (who we all know actually run the companies).
Please get back to me withthe TCP/IP specs of the VooDoo Kayaks. I promise that if I should use them in conjunction with the Airway railroad tickets that I shall only be traveling south.

Anyone have a paddle for this creek?

by stargazerr

500 timeout error revlarry? If that is the case, the link should work now. Sometimes there are time lapses when you cannot access a web server. But they fix themselves after a time.

]:)

by stargazerr

I checked when Rob peer mailed me. Its working for me. Someone mentioned getting a 500 timeout error. That happens when the website's server doesnt respond for some reason or there are too many hops when a request is sent.

But if a few people are getting continual errors, I am supremely curious.

]:)

by ican2

Otherwise we would not have "Everyone" mail lists. In this case (and it's remarkable that this thread is going on and on like it is, even worse, I am replying to it.)
Corporate mail belongs to the corporation. Meaning: No separate individual
The reaction of the IT folks bordered on unethical, maybe. Yet in these times of V.P.'S bad behavior being overlooked or ignored, acceptable use policies, and 401k's that can tank in less time than one can qualify for employee benefits. The work force must look out for themselves. Was it unethical? Why do the rules only apply to regular salaried employees? I liked the story although it was fiction. But when it is time to fish or cut bait and you have to survive, you might change your morals. Sounds to me like the characters were standing on their moral principals.

This discussion is closed to new replies.