Discussion Locked

What Anti-Virus for Linux in Enterprise do you recommend?

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Running Linux for some time now and have been real happy with the performance and stability.

The question I have, What is a good Anti-Virus to run on an Enterprise deployment of Linux?

What have you been using and for how long?

Dependabiltiy is more important than "free".

24 replies

by jaqui

with 6 years running linux, just using cron jobs to keep system patched, and firewalling I have never had a virus.

never used any antivirus software in linux.

by jdclyde

I am concerned about protecting the corporate servers, for that "just in case" issue.

If this was a home system it wouldn't even be a concideration.

Do you run Corporate Linux servers or are they home boxes?

I do understand the basis of why linux viruses don't spread, because of not having root access to the system but I would hate to bet my job on there not being a way around this.

by apotheon

Keeping your system(s) regularly patched basically [b]is[/b] anti-virus for Unix and Linux. On the other hand, there are anti-virus software solutions that exist.

I've been using ClamAV for some time now, not because I feel any need to protect my Linux systems with it, but because I want to ensure that anything coming out of my Linux systems is clean so that no Windows viruses will be spread from here. Despite the fact that Linux systems are pretty nearly immune to virus activity, it's my opinion that all Linux systems should have anti-virus software protecting them for the purpose of protecting the Windows systems with which they may communicate.

The ClamAV website is at http://www.clamav.com and you can get a list of available ClamAV software on a Debian system by entering "apt-cache search clamav" (without the quotes) at the shell.

There's also the aegis virus scanner, which I haven't used (because it is optimized for use from the GNOME desktop, which I don't use), which you could try out. In debian, the package name for it is aegis-virus-scanner (and I'm afraid I don't know where the website for it is).

All other Linux-compatible anti-virus software with which I'm familiar is specifically for email only. You seem interested in more than email, so I'd recommend either ClamAV or aegis for your purposes. Aegis is probably much easier to learn at first, because ClamAV doesn't have a graphical front-end as far as I'm aware, but ClamAV is what I've been using and it seems to be quite effective at detecting Windows viruses.

by jaqui

I'm independant, so my network is in my home office.
not a large enterprise, but still has business requirements.

by praetorpal

"in the wild" as far as my research has found. The point about protecting windows machines sharing the network is worthwhile though.

by joedcook

I haven't used any antivirus with my linux systems but I understand that Watchguard has selected CLAMAV for one of their new security appliances.

by husp1

never having seen or used linux or uniux I have very little info that might be of help, bur I did read somewhere that kapensky has an AV released for linux.

by praetorpal

What if you are still running a version of a distro that is no longer supported (say RH7.3) Do you go to a 3rd party provider like Progeny, or upgrade?

by apotheon

I run Debian almost exclusively, and upgrading is as simple as typing a single command at the CLI, so it's not really an issue for me.

by praetorpal

What if you are still running a version of a distro that is no longer supported (say RH7.3) Do you go to a 3rd party provider like Progeny, or upgrade?

by the dobc

Have a look at MailScanner, www.mailscanner.info

It is a great front-end for a corporate server, and it is not only free, but well supported. Viruses are most likely to move through Enterprise linux through e-mail first, then through Samba file shares.

I have Clam-AV, Bitdefender, and a site license for McAfee, and Clam-AV seems to be ahead of the rest most of the time. There is also a patch for Samba to have on-access scanning of file shares.

by garnerl

Like the other posters here, I have no experience with this product on Linux, but I've had great success with the "NeatSuite" for Windows & Netware (and yes, I know that there are also no NetWare viruses, but I ran AV on the servers anyway).

by apotheon

In my experience, Trend Micro kinda sucks. Granted, I've never used the network version of Trend Micro's AV solution, but the single-system version sucks rocks. I'd probably recommend Norton before Trend Micro, because even though Norton is horrible hostageware, spyware, and six or seven other kinds of evil, at least it will find virus infections a sizable percentage of the time, whereas Trend Micro (in my experience) misses a LOT of stuff.

Luckily, there's much better AV out there, including AGV from Grisoft and ClamAV for Windows (called ClamWin). Then, of course, there's the Unix version, ClamAV, which runs on Linux. Much, much better.

by thrash cardiom

Haven't tried the single system version but I recently moved one of the networks I work on from Norton's Corporate to TrendMicro's Neatsuite and find it a far better product. Haven't had a virus infection under either product but I find I have far more information and control using NeatSuite. The TrendMicro ScanMail component stops a quite a bit of stuff that gets through to our Exchange server (after passing through the first defensive layer - MailMarshal) that Norton's simply ignored - mainly phishing items and the like rather than viruses though.

by frozenjim

Who wants to bet that the day Symantec creates a commercial "Anti-Virus" product for Linux, there will instantly be 40,000 "in-the-wild" viruses for Linux as well?

I am still waiting for the Microsoft-generated viruses to come along just to make Linux look bad.

by jaqui

there are some viruses for unix, unix like systems. about 250 a year as a matter of fact.
it isn't an issue as the security hole gets plugged very quickly.

and there are commercial anti virus solutions for linux.
until there are more than 250 a year the big names in anti virus aren't going to port to unix like systems.

by apotheon

The fact of the matter is that effective Unix viruses are difficult enough to write that there's unlikely to ever be a very substantial number of them per year. Furthermore, the 250 per year are largely only capable of doing any damage because they exploit holes in what amounts to third-party software in the Unix world. This all leads to the state of affairs as it currently exists: viruses for Unix systems are rendered obsolete the day they're noticed because the vulnerability that they exploit gets fixed within hours, thus making Unix AV software irrelevant for protection of Unix systems.

Commercial Unix-based AV software isn't designed to be used as an AV "client" the way Norton, PC Cillin, and others of that ilk, are. They're server AV, which means they exist to protect other systems in a network from viruses that pass through the servers without actually having an effect on the servers. The most common use of AV software on Unix systems is in cleaning up email that passes through a Unix mail server so that it won't trash a Windows system where the email account is accessed.

Just for general purposes, I run AV software on Linux systems. The reason I do so isn't out of fear of the 250 viruses a year: it's just general principle, in case someone comes up with a virus that will actually have persistent threat capability so that it might eventually be a problem to me. It hasn't really happened yet, but it might some day. Anything is possible.

Basically, it's more a matter of "I'd rather have it and not need it than need it and not have it" paranoia than of actual practical protection.

Keep in mind that, technically, viruses aren't even usually much of a problem in Windows. The major problems are, usually, actually worms and "macro viruses". Because worms are just malicious programs that must be "installed" and run on the system, and because Unix systems don't allow that sort of thing to happen unless you intentionally run everything with administrator permissions (and I do mean pretty much [b]everything[/b], which takes a lot of configuration tweaking), worms are mostly confined to the Windows platform. Macro viruses run within applications that use macros, and they cannot do anything outside the application without having system administrator equivalent permissions. In Unix systems, that requires the user to actually (again) do something stupid and deliberate to let them run rampant within the system. In Windows systems, stuff is run with administrator permissions all the damned time just because that's the way Windows software works. Furthermore, the most macro-vulnerable applications for Windows (IE and, by way of IE, Office and Microsoft's various email clients) are actually hooked into the operating system itself, bypassing permissions entirely. As far as a macro virus acting within the application, this pretty much means that macro viruses can only do stuff like send themselves to other people if they are written for your mail client. Most mail clients aren't macro-vulnerable like that, though: the big exploitable clients are Outlook and Outlook Express.

by apotheon

You may have to wait a while. They've probably been trying for a decade or so. Notice how well it's working?

by apotheon

I'll defer to your expertise in the matter. I haven't touched Trend Micro in several years (since the most recent of my bad experiences with it), and have found far better virus protection than I'd found anywhere else in AVG and ClamAV.

by saphil9

BitDefender has a Linux version. I have not tested it, but I have used their windows version av/firewall.

This discussion is closed to new replies.