Discussion Locked

What are the important characteristics of a Project Manager?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Some say project management is a science, other say it is more of an art form. I say quite frankly its a royal pain in the, Anyway, regardless of what it is and is not, it is extremely important. A good project manager is worth their weight in platinum.

A buddy of mine says to me the other day "Jon, I have three types of project managers in my shop. One I can trust with my Life, one that does okay but occasionally comes through in the clutch, and one that just fails miserably at everything they do." Often times you'll find that organizations groom their own project managers. In an attempt to avoid my buddy's mistake, I'd be curious to spark a discussion about this group's opinions on the fundamental characteristics that make a good project manager?

9 replies

by rapace

A good PM is:
- Familiar with the application of standards but able to adapt them to the project and environment as appropriate
- Disciplined and organized but flexible
- Familiar with the project details without getting mired in them
- Willing to accept the expertise of others
- Has a good understanding of the organizational politics but does not play political games
- Always holding themselves as accountable as they hold others
- Credible and honest

In the end, the largest challenge in choosing a good project manager is defining what works within your environment.

If the PM is working in an environment that is fairly disciplined, uses a development life cycle with some maturity, then the PM needs to be most adept and understanding business needs, communicating cross-functionally, managing the schedule and changes as necessary, and general leadership.

OTOH - If the environment is less disciplined, with many different projects, interdependencies or with little or no process then the PM needs to be a good negotiator, process improvement champion, relentless with follow-up and a good meeting manager.

I could probably go on for week but don't want any of you to fall asleep on your key boards ;)

by jeremymaynard

The one characteristic of a good Project Manager is the ability to 'think outside of the box' and to encourage those off the wall ideas which most of the time appear over the top, but which occasionally display a streak of brilliance.
A succesful project team has to have a mix of different personalities which will occasionally clash strongly, but the succesful Project Manager will have the ability to bring such a team back together to concentrate on the goal objectives.
Project Management is stressful, time consuming, challenging, and down right frustrating, but an awful lot of fun.

by jkadinger

I believe project management is both a science and an art form. The science is in the "Forming and performing" phase of a project - managing, strucutre, process, metrics etc. for keeping projects on track.
The art form is in the "Storming and Norming" phase of a project. Pulling the team together, getting everyone going in the direction you need them to go.
I also believe different personality types do better at one part of it than the other.
Recognizing that there are various roles (negotiator, facilitator, etc..) a PM must take on and understanding your weaknesses is key to being succesful. In my ideal world there would be two PMs, one to kick it off and get things going, and one to wrap it up and make sure the paper work gets done.

by stephen.burns

Project management is hard work with lots of trials, setbacks, dissapointments. The ability to see a project to completion despite setbacks is more valuable than all the other skills put together.

If a project manager can't or won't finish a project (for whatever reason) then they aren't much good to you.

Skills can be trained into people, personality can't. Find the people who will stick with the job, to find the ones who succeed.

by issue_solver

Let us keep in mind one important element in this discussion-the word "manager." Whether it is applied to a project or any other endeavor, the fundamental managerial skill set is at the heart of this issue.

A "project" manager must have a technical background, but more germane is the ability to lead people who are IT professionals. This is the primary criterion above any other set of measurements.

by josb

My little experience as Program Manager tells me that it's about setting and meeting expectations.
So you should know if the project can be done in time and budget.
You should know or be able to determine what the risks that could cause not meeting time and budget are. And you should be able to handle those.
You should be able to determine the requirements for the project and make sure the customer meets those requirements or knows the consequences of not meeting them.
You should be able to handle some difficulties on more personal level (like project members that do not work together).
You should be able to set and meet a timeline for deliverables.

I've only handled a few large projects so far, but those with clear risk assesment, project dependencies and clear timelines finished better than the one with shifting timelines and constant business interruption because of 'going concern'.

by george.tsafandakis

1) The person has fire in their pants i.e. they are tenatious and have the desire to get things done.
2) Well connected in the client organisation i.e. they know who to get what from where.

by pm hut

In my opinion, a PM has to have the following in order to be successful (in order of importance):

- Excellent Communicator
- Leader
- Problem Solver

Since the important characteristics that a PM should have are the same characteristics that anyone needs to be a PM, then this article can be an excellent comprehensive answer:
http://www.pmhut.com/how-to-become-a-project-manager

This discussion is closed to new replies.