Discussion Locked

What happened to a college degree?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Now days having certifications and enough experience can be as or even more weighty than having a college degree. Do you have any experiences that are on either side of this issue?

7 replies

by wayne

I do have a degree.. (it is totally unrelated to MIS/IT/IS in anyway)... in Criminal Justice. I was fortunate enough to get entry level work, during college, in an IT dept. almost 8 years ago. One thing led to another and I now run a large IT department for a major corporation. (I have only gone back to school for certifiations since then, no degree as of yet)

I have in the past 5 years though, fired more people with collage degrees/certs than I have kept. I find my most valuable employees tend to be mostly self taught,over acheivers with only "some" college time (if any) but a boat-load of hands on experience. (That's not to say I don't have any college grads here though.)

Books are great and education is very necessary in this field, but you don't become a master woodcarver without spending the bulk of your time with your hands ON the chisel!

I have to say that I prefer a highly motivated, self starter with "real-world" knowledge to a newly printed piece of paper almost everytime.

by brianharris

if you're an employer and you just want people who can get stuff done. Degrees or certifications don't mean much in that case.

However, if you're an employee looking to be in any field for any length of time, you need something more substantial.

What so many people fail to realize is that a degree doesn't make you instantly capable of performing in your field. It provides you only with the background to be able to LEARN your field. Law students don't get their JD and then off to court they go. They have to put in time and then take the Bar. The same for Doctors and Architects and Accountants. The degree is only preperation not the end.

Plus, a degree isn't just about classes in your field. Its about all the "other" classes. I hated soc and most of the history classes but I'm a more well rounded person because of that. I have something in common with the CEO who doesn't know a router from a .dll.

That's probably why so many people with degrees outside of IT aredoing so well in IT. Pure IT fosters the idea that just "putting in the time" is enough. Yes, if all you want to do is config servers or write GUI apps, but where does your career go in 15-20 years? Do you have the ability to deal with people outside of IT?

Experience can show if a person can do the job "right now" but how will they grow beyond that? Can they help extend the value of the IT department? Can they see past the server room?

Just an opinion.

by jdmercha

The main problem here is that there is no college program that really prepares you to work in an IT department. Yes they may teach you how to plan projeccts, write programs or manage people, but there is very little being taught on how to support desktop applications, how to configure a srever or program a router. These topics are learned in certification classes or on the job.

by brianharris

However, as you said, "...they may teach you how to plan projeccts, write programs or manage people..." That's what college is for. Tech schools are for "...support desktop applications, how to configure a srever or program a router."

My point was that if you want your career to extend beyond support, programming or networking then you NEED to go to college. If you want to do that kind of stuff for the rest of your career, go to a tech school and get a couple of certs. Not everyone wantsto be a manager or move into a hybrid tech-business role. Those who do should go to college, those who don't should get certs.

Some of us crazy people(wink, wink) want to do both. And everyone should get the best hands-on experience you can get.

by al macintyre

There are areas of human know-how for which colleges do an excellent job of packaging everything we need to know & communicating it clearly. However, given the rate at which technology evolves, it is real hard for Academia to remain current. They really need a partnership with computer industry so as to constantly update the curriculum. Many such programs are available, such as IBM Partners in Education, but for every one institution that is teaching current state of art through such an arrangement, there are tens of thousands teaching stuff that is no longer relevant to current computer business world.

Look at what passes for the text books in computer science at many Universities. They illustrate systems from the 1950's & 1960's that predate both the micro computer revolution & the mini computers before it.

by al macintyre

There are both college level and high school level curriculums that teach the WHOLE job.

Communicating with the end users to determine their precise needs.
Testing software as it is developed.
Packaging in appropriate help tailored to people who are at different levels of capability ... the recent political mess in Florida taught us that for all the ideas on on-line voting, there are people who cannot cope with the instructions as now written - there is a spectrum there that needs to be serviced.

IBM Partners in Education arranges for colleges & universities & high schools to have the latest technology at prices so low that you would think it was stolen except that they are buying direct from the suppliers, they throw in upgrades &tech support for free, so that the insitution will get the latest versions upgraded without being blocked by not know how or not want to spend the money.

IBM PIE schools can send their staff to a 2 week class that IBM runs every summer in Rochester Minnesota that I think 500 teachers were in last year. This brings the teachers up to speed on latest technology & teaching latest curriculum.

As I have stated elsewhere, for MOST of academia, what they have to offer is pitiful by comparison.

by blitzer

This is how I view these issues;

College/University: Great eye opener, gives you a broad range of skills to develop, technical, personal, etc. I would no hire anyone straight out of College or University, as they lack what I consider the mostimportant aspect of IT, experience. But, those that have the minds and the patience, should experience College/University, because if successful, it will give you a ladder extension for the future, specially when roaming into management pastures. Certification: Fantastic skill honing exercise, it takes an are which you want to become competent at, and explores it further. Again, I would not hire anyone just waving a fist full of certs. But take something like a CCNA, it takes an interest, explores the technical details, it lack real world exposure, but gives enough to play and fix.

EXPERIENCE: Nothing beats experience, I've worked with system administrators/developers with no tech education or certification, yet they are at the top of their field, those people will always have my respect. Myself, I did not have a good education, nor did I endevour in collecting a pile of certifications, I have relied on challenging factors to learning, if it doesn't work, keep at it until its fixed, using whatever resources I could.

BUT: Mix these three previously mentioned factors, and you have a great combination. A good tech education, some certification, and a load of experience, and its a formula which 9/10 will work.

D.

This discussion is closed to new replies.