Discussion Locked

What is the big deal with using netbios

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have several clients that refuse to use netbios. My company's product requires a network share to be configured to access certain files. There seems to be a panic about using netbios growing in IT departments across the country.

I have not seen a good reason for Netbios not to be configured on a network.

I also have not heard of an alternative to netbios when accessing shared folders on a network.

Does your company "ban" Netbios? If so, why?

How do you access shared folders without netbios?

20 replies

by ebob

For starters, anyway.

1 - not secure
2 - too darn chatty
3 - not secure

I don't consider "accessing shares" a core competency of a network, so I don't worry about it. If I want to access a file system, I prefer to setup tools using real TCP/IP services like FTP, TFTP, etc.

(These viewpoints do not necessarily reflect those of my employer.)

by chuckmentz

Thank you for your response, I appreciate the time you took to reply.

I hear what your saying, but I have yet to see documentation of lack of security for NetBios. I have seen examples of the protocol being chatty like you mentioned.

Most applications that I have seen do not actually provide integrated ftp or tftp features.

We are taking this concern of our customers into consideration for our next generation product, but I am curious about a solution for the current generation also.

by bobg

NetBIOS has a number of limitations, most going back to its origins many years ago.

First and foremost, it is entirely dependent on using broadcasts to find hosts. This means that in order to communicate, two stations must either:

1. Be located on the same LAN segment so they can communicate via broadcast, or

2. The network must be set up to propogate NetBIOS broadcast traffic between each location. If a company has a large corporate network, and potentially users on any of their network segments, the overhead of propogating broadcasts to each segment just so they can use your application is enormous, not to mention expensive in terms of bandwidth required.

NetBIOS is also not routable by nature, so to use it, the ONLY CHOICE is this inefficient spewing of traffic, in effect making the network into one huge broadcast domain.

You are SERIOUSLY LIMITING your potential market by insisting on NetBIOS, particularly now that TCP/IP is pretty much the norm in internetworking.
Just a few thoughts.

by ebob

"IF" I was devoping an application that needed to talk across a network, I would work exclusively in TCP/IP. I could be happier with a much larger market potential, scalability and constinued support. I would also find fewer customers putting up anyresistance.

Well, that's just my $0.02 (which is only US$0.016).

by epepke

Do a search for netbios. You will see plenty of documentation of lack of security.

by ntoz

Actualy Netbios over TCP/IP would use WINS or if it had a #PRE statement in lmhosts before it broadcasts. I think your confusing NETBIOS with NETBEUI. NetBeui is an enhancement extention to Netbios but in its self it can be encapsulated in TCP/IP and using the 16th byte determines the type of resouce and queries wins for name to ip mapping. I would agree it has some additional over head as its an upper layer protocol but then again so is socket api's. No dis-respect intended please help me if Im incorrect.

Pete

by donalda-m

You offered to e-mail me some info on NTbackup, and asked me to e-mail you a request - except you did not include your e-mail address, and I could not find it in your peer listing. Please return to that issue (Use of W2k Ntbackup... and leave me your e-mail. Thank you.

by valkos2

Whats the big deal with netbios? that's one of the easiest and most abused configuration.
Any hacker, or dare I say it, script kiddie will scan to see if there are open shares to see if netbios is active. If it is, viola... they are in your system. And browsing your computer or your network computer as one would browse thier files in windows explorer.
It's not as easy as turn the key and your in, but a few passwords tried, (if there are passwords) and they are in. Most companies don't like Netbios, due to the fact that if you have been accessed and your on the internal web, then so are the hackers.

by admin

No, we don't use it.
Extra uneeded traffic.
Insecure. (yes, it is.)
tcp/ip is available and necessary for other reasons, so why have it running too.

by chuckmentz

I apologize because I was called away, and I have several comments/questions?
First, Thank you for the time spent in answering. I value each of your comments.

NTOz - I agree, the intent was to discuss netbios not NetBeui. Some of the cases inthe past were easily resolved by using netbios over IP.

eBob - I agree, and we have this in the development queue for our next gen software. Unfortunately, I have to resolve an issue with a released product.

epepke@acm.org - I spent severalhours searching but really did not find anything. Do you have a site or link that you could reference. It would be greatly appreciated.

valkos2@hotmail - Could the same be said for any non encrypted protocol? How does one perform simple file sharing functions that will allow easy access to open and edit files on a remote computer without netbios?

admin@133central.com - Are you using netbios over IP?

Thanks again to all who replied.

Inreference to the confusion over Netbeui/Netbios, this happens alot whenever this subject comes up.

Netbios requires another protocol like NetBeui or TCP/IP to get past the Network card.

When using TCP/IP, netbios is enabled by default unless turned off by the Network Admin (or some facsimile thereof).

In win2K the setting is a checkmark on TCP/IP properties>advanced settings>Wins tab>disable netbios over tcp/ip

In NT4 the setting is under network>Bindings>Netbios interface>Wins Client(TCP/IP). If netbios is turned off there will be an international No symbol (circle with slash).

I am wondering for those who said they have netbios turned off, what solution do you use?

by epepke

Let's try it again.

http://www.cert.org

Go to that site. At the upper right, there is a search box. Enter netbios into the search box and press GO. A bunch of hits will appear.

CERT is the Computer Emergency Response Team. They conglomerated due to the Internet worm about a decade ago. They used to communicate via email, but now they have a web site.

by admin

for some reason I read it as NetBeui originally. I apologize and retract the above.

by chuckmentz

Sorry, I must have skipped over the subject line when I read your previous message. I ran the search and found several as you stated. It will take me awhile to read through all of them.

Good site, thank you for the info.

by chuckmentz

Thank you for confirming that. I was wondering if I missed something with regard to TCP/IP.

Chuck

by mike-r

There seems to be some confusion... NetBIOS is used by *all* MS operating systems (including WinNT and Win2k)...it is an *internal* transport! This *transport*, when passed over a suitable protocol allows machines to discover what resources are available. NetBEUI (NetBIOS Extended User Interface) is non-routable, chatty, small packet size, etc. *protocol* and considered unsecure. NetBIOS over TCP/IP is called NBT. It has the same security problem as TCP/IP (its protocol transport). Win9x platforms use NBT. NBT use is an option in WinNT and Win2k.

Installing NetBEUI decreases network performance (and may be what your clients refuse to use). However, if NBT is not installed then all resources must be manually mapped (UNC mapping).This could be a daunting task within a large network. :-)

by trebligb

Netbios over IP is required for file sharing in all MS operating systems except Windows 2000. Windows 2000 can use Netbios either as a broadcast method or via a WINS server to support down-level clients (9x, 3.11, NT). If you will be supporting a mixed environment then netbios in some fashion is necessary. If you will have a pure Windows 2000/XP network however then it is advisable to set up a 2000 server box as a DNS server and run Dynamic DNS exclusively.

Hope this helps

by lordxeen37

I also recommend a Windows 2000 Native Mode invironment, and using a router/router, switch/switches...good security, fast performance, and you can set up an ip helper address on the router to forward your dns broadcasts to the right dns server for each LAN/WAN segment.

by lordxeen37

If you use a cisco router, for example, you can set up integrated routing and bridging and route Netbios by tunneling it into an ip packet. A router with vlans set up with switches will limit your broadcase and collision domains and reduce that overhead by using access lists. This may seem like an expensive solution, but in the long run sharing files, distributed applications, and bandwidth issues will justify it. I you choose to use IGRP or OSPF as your routing protocols you will be able toimplement load sharing on your links which will also improve reliability and performance.

by geno

My boss went to a site that checks for vulnerabilities on his system and it came back with a warning about having Netbios active on his system. Since in win9X NetBIOS over tcp/ip is automatic, as long as he doesn't have file and printer sharing active he shouldn't have any worries. Should he?

This discussion is closed to new replies.