Question Locked

What is the reason for setting a "number of remembered passwords"?

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
What security principle is advanced or what threat is minimized by setting this number higher?

11 replies

by ic-it

is to prevent users from recycling passwords too often. If set at 5 then they must use a sixth password as the new one. At the next change then they could go back to number one.

As far as security or threats; that has been debated to death. The two arguments are between -users get frustrated and start writing down passwords and - Frequent strong passwords better insure less opportunities for hackers to obtain access.

by tonythetiger

It's the number remembered I don't get.

[i] The only reason for setting it is to prevent users from recycling passwords too often.[/i]

That's kinda like "because I said so", unless it's accompanied by an explanation of why recycling passwords is undesirable and how we define "too often".

Users are asking. I'm trying to find an official explanation (but I'd settle for an official-SOUNDING one) :)

by ic-it

IMHO there isn't a valid reason for setting this.
You may change the setting (or disable it) or try to convince the demi-gods to do so. ;-)

by jdclyde

The last place I saw that used this ended up with users having a password, and then just put the number of the current month at the end.

01
02

How does this help make things secure?

And of course I have seen the password list taped to the bottom of the keyboard AND have even seen it as a "post-it" on the monitor.

Some security ideas just are not thought out very well, and rapidly changing passwords is one such poor idea.

by tonythetiger

I just don't see why changing between two strong passwords is any less secure than changing among 12 or 24.

It's causing a lot of frustration... When a user is prompted to change their password, they essentially have to remember the last 12 passwords or else they'll get an error when they type it in. After a couple of these, they quit trying and just call and say they forgot their password. It accounts for about 10% of every work week.

by jdclyde

The "experts" are assuming that someone is using a brute force attack that will take X number of days to break (which is WHY they say 180 days for a password). Everytime the password is changed, the attack would have to start over, and they are ASSuming that the attackers will know the schedule of the change that they can pick back up where they left off.

Dumb is as dumb does.

by jellimonsta

It is basically another drop of water in the bucket for security via obscurity. I think 'number of pwd remembered' and 'minimum pwd age' are in place to deter users from changing passwords temporarily and reverting to a 'preferred' pwd.
JD pretty much summed it up. Two factor OTP is the way to go though (until the users keep losing their keyfob). Also, you run the risk of a user pasting their PIN to their keyfob too. :D
Damned if you do, damned if you don't really.

by tonythetiger

Setting number remembered to 1 and minimum age to 1 day would be adequate, IMO, and given human nature, would garner more cooperation.

It boils down to why we're here... Give the customers what they need with the least amount of inconvenience possible.

by tonythetiger

[i]Everytime the password is changed, the attack would have to start over, and they are ASSuming that the attackers will know the schedule of the change that they can pick back up where they left off.[/i]

That in a brute force attack, changing it back to what it was last month is no worse than changing it to one you've never used before.

I am going to approach those at the top of the food chain with this.

Thanks

by tonythetiger

that all it's accomplishing is giving us 4 hours of extra work to do a week.

I hate "make-work"!

This discussion is closed to new replies.