Discussion Locked

What personal info can a Company ask for during the interview process?

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I recently lost my job of 12 years in the IT field due to contract cuts. Now that I'm back on the market, I recently experienced something that I thought to be strange & possibly illegal. "Before" a first interview with a prospective company, I was asked for my SS#, Drivers License#, & date-of-birth. This position did not require any driving. My question is: Is asking for this info illegal & if you refuse to give this info, would this hurt your chances of getting the job? Also, are companies "open" to you giving this info at the end of the interview process or just before an offer is presented? I am very concerned due to age discrimination which I believe exists & also the problem of "identity theft".

26 replies

by jamesrl

In many places, there is no harm in asking, but no requirement to answer. It would be difficult however to prove you were screened out because of these questions.

I went to an interview where I was asked to fill out a form which had this kind of questions and worse - criminal convictions(ok i can see that if you are in a role if you need to be bonded), car accidents(job did not require car) and credit information(hold on there). I don't believe there was any attempt to steal my personal information, but I wasn't comfortable giving them that detail, so I left. I would suggest if they ask unethical questions, do you really want to work for them?

I believe in Canada, you are only obligated to give SS#s for tax purposes, IE when they have hired you.

James

by jaqui

in Canada asking for social Insurance Number is illegal, until after you have accepted an offer.

d.o.b. is not legal at all.
and dl# only if you will be driving company owned vehicle. ( for insurance purposes )

they cannot do any background checks other than a work history through revenue canada ( C.C.R.A. ) without explicit agreement, requiring your signature before doing the checks.

by dc guy

It seems to be permissible everywhere in the USA for a prospective employer to run a credit check on a prospective employee. Responsible people are responsible throughout all facets of their lives, or so goes the reasoning.

As a hiring manager I would be VERY interested in criminal history. If you have one we'll talk about it and you get to say your piece, but I need to know. Of course I run it through my own filters, the laws on victimless crimes are blatantly unconstitutional. But I would have a problem with someone with a history of violence, failure to respect others, or inability to consider the consequences of his own deeds.

by countrytechie

What that company asked for is pretty standard considering all the information security acts out there HIPPA,Sarbanes-Oxley etc. A quick national agency check is most likely prudent.

What is bad is the habit some companies have of googling your name. Recently read were a woman's ex husband had decided he was transgender. Since her name was linked with his on many sites potential employers found out about this. (the ex is very vocal in the transgender community) Well at 2 interviews the subject was brought up in the interview. She didn't get the job in either case. Fun part this was in San Francisco. Imagine what her chances are else where.

I guess we all should google our names regularly and see what we have been associated with.

by librarygeek

Even more important, if you find listings of personal information that you do not want listed, you can often have that removed (e.g., yahoo white pages); sometimes you will need to go the source's source,but it can be done.

As far as having your name associated with other items it is important to be pro-active. Be active, have a blog or website (not that I can talk here...), make public posts that *show* the kind of person and thinker you are. Rather than ignoring the fact that her ex is TG--knowing that he is vocal and active--the woman could have posted her own opinions about the situation. That way *her* view is also represented. It seems that she would have been in the right to request her ex to not use her name or any legally identifying information; the ex was really in the wrong for "outing" the ex wife :(

But, yes googling is going to happen. I don't think it is a bad habit. When conducting my last job hunt, you can bet that I googled! I also dug into the potential employer's website to try to get a picture of the who's who/how do they run things. I did have one interviewer that was disconcerted by the fact I recognised her. That showed a lack of current awareness in my opinion. The woman was one of the principles listed on the company website along with her photo!

To sum up my meandering, be proactive -- use the Internet to provide the information you want to be out there.

by highlander718

I find that pretty common lately. And I think it make sense for the company to know if you had convictions or credit issues.
I don't mind them doing the check, as long as I have nothing to hide.

by librarygeek

They recieve facts without any context.
For example, a catastrophic illness or serious emergency (house burns down, parents both die) can force people into bankruptcy. In the case of catastrophic illness, money management skills have nothing to do the issues --loss of the ability to work makes you poor! Are these the most common causes of bankruptcy? I doubt it, I rather think that poor decisions and management are the cause of MOST bankruptcies. People who think that the way to pay off a card is to open another card are prime steak to the bankruptcy hawk. However, the exceptions are at risk of being unfairly tarnished and blocked from getting their lives back up and running.
In addition, I've heard and read numerous nightmares about ID thefts that have ruined people's credit, rendered them unable to obtain loans -- even after filling out all required reports etc. This is another growing segment that is unfairly affected by this management assumption.

by macghee

LibraryGeek,
You're off target on what leads most people to bankruptcy. The three biggest causes are loss of employment, divorce, and medical expenses.

by antuck

The SS# and DL# I'm not sure of but the DOB I do belive is illegal. I would be surprised with the age discrimination laws they would even ask that. It seems as soon as you ask that you are setting up a discrimination law suit. I remember briefly I did some hiring for a company and had asked about why was there no DOB on the aplication. I was told they did not want age discrimination to come into play. But it didn't take much to figure out a general age based on other information provided.

by jdmercha

It seems to me that SSN (or its equivalent) is needed to prove you are authorized to work in the US. I wouldn't think DL# is needed uless driving is part of the job or a security clearance is needed.

by amcol

Nor unusual, with one exception.

It's becoming more and more typical for companies to run credit and background checks, for which they need your SSNO and driver's license number. The background check is obvious...if you have a criminal record, your prospective employer would certainly find that a pertinent fact. The credit check is done because companies believe people who can't manage their own money can't be trusted to manage the company's. DOB shouldn't be solicited because it opens a company up to a possible age discrimination charge, but that's so hard to prove no one really worries about it and most people don't supply it anyway.

What's unusual about your sitation is that you were asked to supply all this information prior to the first interview. Most companies will only solicit this either just prior to or immediately after making an offer. There's no point in checking on every candidate who walks in the door, and if they're using all these checks as screening criteria it says a lot about their corporate culture and you probably don't want to be working there.

I'd decline to give them the information as well as the opportunity to interview.

by jaqui

they check every person that gets an interview.
full criminal records check. ( for security clearance reasons )
they ask you to supply a recent drivers abstract if you will be driving company vehicle.

but they do not touch credit. it is not allowed for employer to check credit, not even for financial industry.

by amcol

These checks are not cheap, and can be time consuming. Why bother checking every single person who walks in the door? That's paranoia at least, and invasive of privacy.

by jpaullanier

Credit, background and age inquiries are all "potentially discriminatory" according to page 364 of the text, Management: Meeting and Exceeding Customer Expectations, 8th ed. (2005: WR Plunkett, RF Attner and GS Allen).

According to the authors:
* age/DOB = discriminatory, but it is OK to ask if the applicant is under 18 or over 70.
* credit check = potentially discriminatory unless personal credit is required for the job. The reason is that it could discriminate against minorities or women, who on the average have lower credit ratings.
* background check = potentially discriminatory against minorities, who on the average have a higher rate of arrests and convictions. Inquiries on arrests are prohibited by the Illinois Department of Human Rights. However certain jobs may legitimately require candidates who have not been convicted of a felony or a violent crime (security, handling large amounts of cash).

The three rules for employment application questions are:
1. Make sure you are eliciting information required for the job;
2. Don't ask questions which might discriminate against a protected clas of persons, unless it is clearly and absolutely necessary; and
3. When in doubt - don't ask!

regards, Paul

by amcol

This is a pretty superficial treatment, which would have more value if there were some meat on the bones.

"Potentially discriminatory" is in the eye of the beholder. Hardly a basis for a lawsuit, and I wouldn't want to bet my family farm on it.

I could make a compelling case that personal credit is required for most professional jobs. There's ample legal precedent for companies doing credit checks on applicants by virtue of the logic that anyone who can't manage their own money can't be trusted to be the steward of the company's funds. You may be called upon to hire an employee, engage a consultant, approve an invoice, analyze a contract. How does the company know you can effectively do any of that if you're consistently overdrawn in your checking account?

Pretty much the same comment for background checks. You may be privy to company confidential information, or work with data supplied and owned by a third party, or perform some service on behalf of the company's customers. If you're not of demonstrable good character as evidenced by a clean police record, how does the company know you won't walk off with corporate assets given the opportunity?

Academic treatments are all well and good, but they all too rarely reflect the way the real world works. This information is marginally interesting, but ultimately useless.

by abitcrazy

What frosts me about all this is those in upper management and the ruling class government types all can't manage their OWN or OUR money, yet they will put the ropes and the screws to common workers. It is getting disgusting how much corporations have dictatorship powers over us, and how little ACTUAL rights we have, regardless of the laws, which really don't amount to much.

by chibibarako

* Most job applications have the SSN and DOB on them. The interviewer should have no business asking for that because HR already has the info.
* I thought asking age questions was illegal?
* As to the DL, I agree with the post above which points out that they should only be asking that of people further into the hiring process -- maybe after the first interview. (Besides, with the SSN why would they need the DL?)

by worm22

Some of that is required for tax info and background checks if they're seriously considering giving you a job. If you haven't met with them, then I'd be very careful about it.

As a rule I don't give that info out, except in person (ie at an a interview), where I can see that the company seems to be a legit business. I have once or twice, but the only time I didn't know the person personally (or through friends), I did a lot of checking to make sure that the name I had corresponded with an actual employee. That wasn't too hard since it was a university, but if you don't know the company is legit, and/or can't validate that who you're talking to is an actual employee ... I'd say refuse to give it until the interview.

by mnunno

Most of that information is very easy to get and I cant imagine a busy IT manager asking some of those questions unless there is an interest in hiring you. But lets dig a little deeper can he ask any questions about your medical history or family medical history?

by worm22

In most cases, no. That information is private and cannot be required as a condition of employment. There are exceptions to that, but not many.

by psinger1

I recently had an interview with a company in the HR field (so they should know a thing or too). During the final stage, they asked for similar information.

The reason was what has already been discussed at length: If they decided to hire me, they wanted to first request a 3rd party background check.

Some points which have not yet been mentioned:
1) This was done as a last resort, not a first step. As such it is reasonable. As a first step, it is not (and you should refuse it). Because...

2) Too many of these background checks will hurt your credit rating, which will hurt you chances of getting hired, which will further hurt your credit rating which..........

3) It was explained to me to be very careful in filling out the formal application, as that info was what the 3rd party was going to attempt to verify. If I were known by my first name at one job, but my middle name at a second, this info needed to be available at the start, to avoid potential conflicts. Explainable, but they take time.

4) This was being done in lieu of the traditional calling of references.

5) My question is, how was the interview set up?

-If you applied directly with the company, and their first step was to try to set up a search, then something is wrong.

-On the other hand, if this is part of their standard app, they may just try to get it all in one place. Enter "to be supplied at interview" in the boxes and see what happens.

-Or, you may be going through a independent body shop. Part of their services may be to qualify you for prospective clients (but you technically are their employee). If this is the case, question what is going to be done with the information, and hold off until something is really happening.

by klfarrell

Well, having experienced this once or twice myself. If you are applying for a position that requires a government security clearance that is higher then what you have now (if you have one at all) then the employer has a vested interest in running a background and credit check to determine whether or not your background can present a problem to getting your cleanance.

Some employers are just not interested in spending the time and or money to get you cleared if you have a problem when another candidate with a better background history is available.

But just a thought....

by cyclical01

As many have pointed out, Employers have several valid vested interests in making sure they do not hire the "wrong" candidates. This is balanced by the fact that all of us have a right to basic privacy.

What is very scary is the proliferation of companies out there willing to sell "background" information on all of us. This information is rarely validated, cross checked or screened in any fashion. In short, it ends up being little better than "googling".

It is an industry over-ripe for regulation.

Regardless of whether the information is valid, objective or correct, the crux of the matter is in how it is used.

For example, the fact that (as cited) a spouse's transgender viewpoints were even brought up in an interview probably violates several local and federal anti-discrimination statutes and could likely be the basis of a rather profitable lawsuit.

If you are interested in more information on this topic, the International Assn. for Human Resource Information Systems Management (IHRIM) has an excellent site devoted to Privacy and Security issues (http://www.privacy-security-sig.org/). I encourage you all to check it out.

by abitcrazy

I recently read, "Conspiracy of Fools" - a book about the rise and fall of the Enron empire. These people were swindlers, liars, and committing money laundering and fraud. Could they handle their money? I read several years back how congressmen and senators were all seriously in debt, and so the credit card lobbyists got legislators debts "paid off" in exchange for tougher laws on credit card use! these poeple are blatant in their hypocracy and blatant in their own abuses...read the book. YOu will be shocked.

The texts of HR always like to talk about how the laws have to be watched, how they must be so careful, blah blah blah, but companies today know there is little, if any, agencies really overseeing any of these things, and the courts are getting more and more hostile to workers. We are getting the shaft (ever since Reagan, actually) and the shaft growing...

by jpaullanier

I suggest if you can make a solid case for a credit or background check as being necessary for a specific job, you're probably on safe ground. It is true that much IT work requires the highest character to protect assets.

However a blanket policy that credit and background checks are in general required will place you in the position of hiring fewer women and minorities. That could end up in a class action suit which puts a black mark on your record and your company's reputation - even if you eventually prevail in court.

If credit or background checks are used to screen applicants or candidates for specific jobs where the need for that is obvious, you should be okay. But you might want to save yourself some trouble down the road by checking with HR for situations in which the need for such checks would probably be questioned.

regards, Paul

by bytlan

Prior to an interview really seems to be too much! I would really question what that company is into and would not feel any comfort with them. I would need to know from them specifically what the need and intentions are from them to have that prior to an interview, maybe even have it in writing. I just see a no comfort zone happening with those requests. And me knowing me, I would walk out or hang up or ?Just say No that won?t happen?. I would even begin to question what could be the wages for that type of a position as for raises. I worked for a Casino and yes I understand the whole FBI back ground check, credit check and all that. This was not an issue for me as it was stated prior to the first interview. That informing set the stage for me to say yes or no to even going out on that interview with them. To me, this company is playing games psychologically, to much for power and control and submission. Working for a Hitler type just does not sound like a winning company to work for... They have other issues going on with in the company that just are not favorable. They are controllers. Not a friendly place at all to work for?

This discussion is closed to new replies.