Question Locked

What should I do with an idiot committee?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was recently asked to produce an online questionnaire in order to determine the IT skill levels of the IT Support Staff, with a web front end, a back end SQL database and an MS Access admin area. So far, no problem.

Now I'm good at what I do, having a LOT of experience and so I was able to create a questionnaire that allowed users to log in, choose which sets of questions (Hardware, OS, Programming, Applications etc) to be asked according to their expertise. In addition, it allowed users to part fill the questionnaire and come back later to complete it.

The data it generated (skill-level ratings from None to Expert) was perfectly suited to queries allowing people to identify skill gaps for training, pick out teams of people for upcoming projects etc etc etc.

Then it went to committee. I have now been given sets of questions put together by this committee. After removing the repetitions (the ambiguous 'Do you have hardware skills?' was in there FOUR times!!) and the outright nonsense ("I don't know about MS Office" - that's a question??), I am left with something that is ineffective, almost peurile and under no circumstances useful. To gain anything out of it, the analysis has to be qualitative rather than quantitative and any question asked of the data will need to be carefully crafted by an Access expert (of which there are few here).

What do I do? Do I say 'No' and withdraw from the project (not a good idea)? Do I do it but refuse to put my name to it (that's feasible, but those in the know will know it's my work)? Do I just grin and bear it?

What would you do?

4 replies

by bizzo

Companies do like their questionnaires don't they. I do think there is a problem when non-technical people produce technical questions.

Could you not just send it back to them and explain just what you have here? Rephrasing, obviously.

Hang on, Nottingham, UK? If you stand up will I see you?

by snak

.....cos if so, one fine sunny morning you might find this questionnableaire in your in-box :o)

by 1bn0

I have taken this kind of testing at a contract employment agency. It was a commercial package but I do not remeber the name of it.

Maybe you could find something you could recommend instead of the in-house solution.

It would get you off the hook for being responsible for the content as well as someone you can send them to with their idiotic questions. Having to ask an outsider would cut down on that right away.

"Explain" to them how an industry standardised database from qualified vendor would be so much better. (Mostly for you but they don't need to know that part)

This discussion is closed to new replies.