Discussion Locked

What should I do with my career?

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I currently have a government job as a Systems Administrator. The pay is decent and I can go for days and weeks without doing any real work. The dilemma is that I am getting a lot of job offers from private firms that are offering more money and with better positions (IT Manager, Hardware Engineer, Software Engineer). I have been weighing the pro and cons and don't know what to do. I can make decent money and do next to nothing. Or I can make more money and have more stress and be overworked. The government job seems very secure and I won't have to worry about losing my job. On the other hand the job with the private firms offer more money and better title, but who knows if the job will be around in a year or two. But with the government job I feel like I will not be able to move up because they do not promote based on performance. I am still relatively young (25) and I feel that I need to be challenged. I feel like I can move up fast with a private firm, but I feel like I would be gambling job security. I have a B.S. in Computer Engineering and the government job is spending a lot of money for training towards Certifications. Right now they are training me for A+, Network+ and Macintosh certifications. And with the next fiscal year they will probably pay for my training for the Microsoft Track...with the Cisco track the following year.

I have no idea what I should do. My goal is to become IT Manager and eventually become vice president, IT. Right now my decision is to stay for five years (when my pension becomes vested) and let them pay for my training to get my MCSE and CCNA. And maybe get my MBA along the way since my work isn't too stressful. What do you guys think I should do?

51 replies

by amcol

Go look at yourself in the mirror, take your head in both your hands, give it a good solid shake, and say out loud "I'M KIDDING MYSELF!".

You're 25, you're obviously perfectly content doing little to nothing on the job all day long, you clearly need an inordinately high degree of job security, you actively avoid stress, you believe government promotions are not based on performance (cue laugh track), you claim to need a challenge (cue second laugh track), you're gleefully and borderline unethically taking a wide variety of government perks (training, early vested pension) without giving much of anything back, and with all that as context your career goal is to eventually make vice president presumably in a private sector firm.

I'm not sure how things are done on your planet, but here on Earth rewards are performance based, hard work is the key to success, and career goal achievement is the result of long years of paying dues. Stress and risk come with the territory.

Your version of reality is about as unreal as it gets. Before you try to figure out what to do with your career, understand how things work in the real world.

Sorry if this sounds brutal or disrespectful...not my intention. I have a son your age and it worries me when young folks think like this.

by why me worry?

I used to work for a public sector state goverment agency and believe me, it was a very unsatisfying and mundane experience. The people in IT I worked with didn't know anything, they had crackheads working the helpdesk who could not put two words together to make a sentence and slurred their speech, people were promoted on how long they sat on their fat lazy asses and not on performance or merit, and the whole IT equipment procurement and bidding process was an absolute joke. By the time we got the equipment, it was three or four generations behind current technology and was considered obsolete. Another big problem I had working as a Novell Admin in public sector was that whenever others in IT didn't have an explanation for a problem, they blamed me for the cause. Eventually, I got sick and tired of this bullcrap and took a good paying job as a senior systems engineer in a prestigious law firm. After seeing the bullcrap, laziness, incompetence, and arrogance of people in the public sector who come to work to sit on their fat lazy asses and collect a paycheck, I was convinced to never go back to the public sector. Anyone who needs to suck off the government teet needs to take a good look at themselves and question as to why they have no desire to advance and better themselves. Public sector is a starting point, but it should not be a lifelong crutch. Find a good private sector company, do your job well, and you won't have to worry about job security.

by itstech

Amcol,

I understand things can be taken out of context through posts, so I am not taking your response as brutal or disrespectful...but I do not understand how my perspective is unreal. I only bring up the topic of Job Security and Stress because the reality is that there is a lot of unemployed people out there and a lot of them are good at what they do.

And how am I unethical? It is not my idea to do minimal work...I am usually the type to take the initiative and do more than expected...but the job limits why I am allowed to do because I work in a union shop. I have even asked for more responsibilities, but my supervisor told me I couldn't due to union issues. If it was up to me I would do more than I do now. I worked for a private firm beforehand and there is definitely a difference. And how am I unethical for taking all these government perks such as training when the bottomline is that my supervisor set aside budget for training and insists that I become certified? Any person in their right mind would jump on training paid for by their employer.

What I was hoping from this post was for some direction? I admit I am still young and have a lot to learn, so I was looking for advice from those that have much more knowledge and have been in IT for years. I really do what to be challenged and I really do want to do what is best.

by why me worry?

No IT professional I know of needs a union to enforce or protect their job security. Personally, I think unions are for incompetent morons with barely a HS education who need some form of protection against their own stupidity and incompetence. I've seen unionized plumbers, electricians, and people in other trades, but those who are really good frown upon unions because they take responsibility for their own actions. True, in private sector, you would end up getting fired for being incompetent, but anyone with half a brain should take the heat for their own actions. Unions remind me of a bunch of spoiled bratty kids who hide behind mommy when they misbehave because mommy will protect them from the scolding of other parents and adults.

by amcol

From your original post:

"The pay is decent and I can go for days and weeks without doing any real work"

"I can make decent money and do next to nothing"

"The government job seems very secure and I won't have to worry about losing my job"

"they do not promote based on performance"

The context here is the information you've provided. These are not the statements of someone who shows a strong work ethic or who understands the workplace.

To the ethical question...irrespective of the constraints placed on you in a union environment, which you have more control over than you think, you're not providing value commensurate with your rewards. To me that's an issue of ethics, you may see it differently. You say to-MAY-to, I say to-MAH-to.

You ask for direction. My advice is to first make sure you know yourself. Your comments are inconsistent...you like security but crave a challenge, you're comfortable going long periods of time without doing much work but aspire to a high management level. Who are you?

Next piece of advice...run, do not walk, away from this job. If you really want a challenge, if you really have a good work ethic, if you really want to achieve career advancement, you are just wasting your time where you are. To echo another poster's comment, it's not about the amount of time you put in, it's about the value you add while there.

by jpitt2298

I would love to have a position like that. (The free training anyway)You really shouldn't question where you should go. Stay put,learn, and use your brain. Work may be slow but take that SLOW time and put it to good use.

by jkowolf

The 'young folks' didn't create the government job system. I was a teacher and can guarantee you I would have moved up the pay scale with minimal effort. I considered myself young and truly ambitious which is why I quit, got into the IT field with no direct degree or certification and prove that I can get the job done on a daily basis. As long as I didn't send too many kids to the principal's office and turned in my grades on time, I would have continually received my raise every year.

by jamesrl

is not time served. If you want a management job, you'd better be able to display not only competence but accomplishments. What did you do to improve processes, save money, improve security, develop staff and so on. The government seems to be investing in you - how are you paying them back?

If you job is to collect pay and not do anything, don't expect automatic promotions to management.

You wanna be VP of IT - you have to earn it.

You have a decision to make, either committ to making a name for yourself where you are, or finding some other place where you can achieve and shine.

James

by jck

Corporate world sucks. I've worked for 2 multibillion dollar corps. If you're not "one of the boys" or a schemer, you'll get screwed.

by j.lupo

I have to agree with you jck. Corp world does not give you anything no matter how hard or smart you work for them. You have to know how to play the game and play it their way. Competence is irrelevant, skills are irrelevant, personality is irrelevant, etc.

by jdmercha

"...I am getting a lot of job offers from private firms that are offering more money and with better positions (IT Manager..."

"My goal is to become IT Manager..."

by itstech

Jdmercha,

Sorry...I should have been much clearer about this. The jobs that are offering more money are hardware and software engineer positions, but I am not more interested in IT as oppose to Engineering. The IT Manager position offers were actually for less than I make now. True, it would be great for my resume if I were to take that the IT Manager position...but is it worth it to take lesser pay and probably more hours work? Or should I wait for an IT Manager position with pretty good compensation? The pro of taking an IT Manager position for less pay now is that I would gain valuable Management experience.

by why me worry?

You can always do engineering work and some minor project management, but engineering is a more rewarding and fullfilling job than telling others what to do and how to do it

by itstech

I agree that unions do protect those that are incompetent, but when I bring up Union and job security it is to protect me from future Outsourcing...Our organization is not allowed to outsource our jobs to a private firm...it is not because I am incompetent for the job. I am very qualified to do IT work, unlike some of the people I know here...

by tconard

Where's the problem?
If you truly want to advance, get out of the government job.
What are your accomplishments in the government job? That is what people are expecting in the private sector. How important is job security to you? You are too young to be worrying about job security at this stage.
I've been unemployed several times in my career when a consulting company folded that I worked for and once when a company moved out of state and I didn't want to go.
Your reputation and integity will help you get another position. The networking of IT professionals is amazing. You must use that network by doing an outstanding job and impressing people with your abilities.
Currently, I have been bouncing around different departments in this company. As soon as one contract ends, another department wants me to start for them based on the work I've done in other areas.

by namco

I was in almost exactly the same situation, i'm the same age (23) and was working as an IT asst in a local Uni, like you I could go days or weeks withoud doing much. I made the most of the experience and learned as much as I could, but it was ultimately boring. I made the change to work in industry as an IT mng for not much more pay - doesn't cover the extra commuting costs. But I made the concious descision to give up the easy life and go for a tougher but more rewarding job that will give me the IT and business skills to progress.

The descision was made even harder when I was offered a position in the health service - permanent, better pay but very mundane, 1 server and 15 users compared to about 150 users, 15 servers and multinational. health service would have been easy life but I went for experience.

In short go for experience and personal development jobs now and worry about job security and convenience of the job later.

by itstech

Especially how I will accomplish more with a private firm. But for the long run would it be better to leave the public sector now and work hard in the private firm and be able to say I improve these processes and earned the company more revenue by doing so and so...or would it be better for me to gain my certifications and earn my MBA while working for the government then leave for the private sector?

by namco

The fact that they are offering training makes it slightly more appealing to stay. I would say that moving from a Uni (I was a student for 4 years before then worked at neighbouring uni for 18 months) environment to manufacturing has been a major change for me. Edu/health/public is such a different atmosphere. I knew what I wanted to achieve but I was also aware that if I got used to the uni atmosphere I might never change, so I went whilst I was young and not completely settled. This meant leaving money, nice people, good work/life balance behind and taking on a new challenge.

Your training aside, this is really about the work/life balance and your long term goals.

by tconard

Companies want to know what you have accomplished in the past. You may be book smart but business dumb. You will have all this training but how have you used in in your job?
Yes, it's nice to have the training paid for but that shouldn't be the only reason to stay there. Most companies will help for training.

by itstech

"The pay is decent and I can go for days and weeks without doing any real work"
---I am just stating the facts that these job pays me good money for less work than a private firm. My job beforehand was with a private firm where I was severely underpaid for the work I put in, so I know what value means. But I rather get paid more money for less work than work more for less money.

"I can make decent money and do next to nothing"
---Again this is just facts. This is not my attitude to not work hard. I am a hard worker, but the fact is...is that my job gives me good pay for not much work.

"The government job seems very secure and I won't have to worry about losing my job"
---With security with this job I mean the work is not going to be outsource nor are they going to consolidate positions.

"they do not promote based on performance"
---They do not promote here based on performance...I can work hard here and my performance can go unnotice unlike private firms where they reward those that do more than expected. There is a lot of politics with government jobs, and the best qualified do not get the promotion. There are a lot of people above me that do not deserve their positions.

by tony hopkinson

The fella is trying to point out that without a total re-assessment of your requirements you may make the wrong decision.
You already know you are secure and unstressed and comfortable financially. In order to get more satisfaction from your job and potentially accelerate your rise through the hierarchy by moving into the private sector, you'll have no security, a lot of stress and never be comfortable financially because you can make no long range plans based on continuous employment.

We can certainly advise of that and even of ways of improving yourself and ameliorating some of the effects.
We can't advise you of what you want though, just what you need.

This is not a dig but the mere fact that you are comfortable with the way things are going now suggests a step into the private sector is going to be a massive culture shock for you. From the sound of it your skills and education aren't a problem but they aren't enough, you need the drive as well. You can't buy it or learn it, your circumstances either give you it or they don't.

Do you want it enough is the only question that needs to be asked. It your answer is yes then private sector will be your examiner, daily.

I won't criticise you for playing it safe, if you take the risk and fail I will try to be constructive so you can address the problem.

by amcol

At least you understood what I was saying. I stopped responding to the original poster because he/she was clearly not receptive to the message, proving my point...there's a large denial of reality going on there.

I see this way too often in young people that age. There can't be two different views of reality...reality the way you'd like it to be and actual reality. There's only actual reality.

You can look at a chair and perceive it as apple pie, and maybe that makes you feel better about life. No matter how hard you try you'll still find it a little tough to bite into.

by itstech

Tony,

You hit it right on...on what is going through my mind. Part of me says go take a chance and the other side says to play if safe. I never had a problem with taking risks...but when I graduated from college and stepped into the real world(around the time of the dot com crash) it took me awhile to find any job. I was just lucky to even get a phone interview. Then when I did find a job...the compensation was way below what I was putting into the company. I guess the real world has changed my mind about a lot of things. Now I find myself with a decent paying job...but I am not finding much reward because I am not being challenged enough. I know I should try to make the job challenging for myself but the fact that this is a government job limits that. Is the risk of finding more challenge worth losing a good paying secure job? Maybe I should look into other avenues to challenge myself. Maybe start a business of my own on the side...

I'm sorry if I sound confused, but I still have a lot to learn about the real world

by gralfus

So far it is the best job I've had. The challenge level is minimal, so I'm finding ways to challenge myself. I'm training myself in computer security, and getting funding for training where I can. I may break off and work for myself eventually, or if they open up a forensics job I'd apply for that to keep the health benefits.

Since your stated goal is to be an IT manager, does that mean in the private sector or in gov't? I think you'll find that the public sector has WAY better benefits than the private sector. Private companies are cutting IT back to the bone, and even cutting bones now, all in the name of staying afloat. Never mind that they give multimillion dollar bonuses to the CEO, they can't afford decent IT support. That kind of behavior has killed my desire to be employed by a private firm. I will work for gov't or for myself, unless I can do nothing else.

Ask yourself why you want to become an IT manager, and what you think that will be like both for benefits to you (pay, healthcare, bonuses [ha!]) and what it will require of you (managing people, firing people, making things work that are outdated and broken, dealing with management fury over IT problems caused by underfunding, stress, stress, long hours at the office, and stress).

by itstech

Gralfus,

I definitely think government job pay per work is the best. I used to work for a private company and I worked hard but my performance was never appreciated...plus my compensation was not that great. I have a lot of time to learn on my own. I'm often testing new things on my test environment I developed here at work. And I get free CBT here on top of training I want to take.

One of the major reasons I want to become an IT manager is definitely the challenge and the pay. I am very goal oriented. Although my pay is decent and consider good pay...it is not enough to afford a house in the area I live.

What do you think about an IT manager position in the public sector? Is it hard to obtain with all the politics? The people above me here are so incompetent...I would do a great job if I were in there position.

I am not so sure about the job security with private firms. I always here talks in the news about layoffs and outsourcing. That is one of my cons for leaving for a private firm.

I know IT managers get more pay...but the other factors I see is that I would definitely have to put in more hours...at my current position I could spend a lot of quality time with my family (if and when I do start a family). In private firms you are expected to be on call 24/7 and put in more hours than the slated 40 hours per week. Here if they need me to work outside of regular working hours they compensate me time and a half.

by gralfus

You certainly can become a manager in the public sector, but usually only when someone retires. It is definitely a seniority based system. I have lots of training in networking, but can't get into that section because there are no openings.

I understand the desire to get more money. Just make sure that whatever direct pay you get doesn't get eaten by healthcare "insurance" in the private sector. It really is a dramatic difference.

My wife is with a large private firm and they are once again cutting back. I advise you to learn all you can where you are and try to get as much management experience as you can, then apply for other gov't jobs.

by itstech

I am the youngest IT staff member by at least 20 years and some of the other IT staff members have talked about retirement soon.

What is the promotion process at your place? Is the process the same at all government jobs? Is there a lot of politics?

by gralfus

I work with many who have worked up a few levels, so it does happen. I've only been here a little over a year. However, there may be opportunities in other agencies and locations, but still within local gov't.

I tried for a few federal positions, but they invariably came back with a terse "Didn't show experience" line, despite clearly showing experience. So feds may require some special wording or something.

by tony hopkinson

you've got to stop knowing. One thing I have learnt and do know is the longer you leave it the harder it will be. Just imagine the responsibility of having a family to support and this descision. The more you walk in a rut the deeper it gets.
You don't have to make an irrevokable decision now, but you've got to find ways of exercising as much of your skillset as possible, otherwise when you feel you should make a decision later, the opportunity will be gone.

by tony hopkinson

I progressed through five jobs over 19 years for one company. I could have probably stayed 'til retirement (just finishing a contract with them next week). When I was making the decision to cut loose from my nice 'comfortable' environment, a lot of people told me I was making a mistake giving up an 'easy' job and the security in return for relocation, different business etc.
I did it and have little to regret, but it was a damn big step to take. This one can only be an internal decision, no amount of advice can give you the courage to leave a warm comfortable nest.
It's jump out or pray you don't get pushed out.

by tony hopkinson

when I had an accident at work, they funded the lwayers and all the legal requirements, got meycompensation and made my employers make the place safer.
They also spent a lot of time talking out of their collective arse as well I must admit.

But unions were invented to protect the workforce from exploitation, I know why 'management' don't like that but I wouldn't like to see them go completely.

by j.lupo

I don't want them to go either, just get back to the original reason they formed. To protect workers and make a negotiating body that created collaboration and fairness between employer and employee.

by tony hopkinson

You get the bosses at one extreme using your kids as rags to wipe down the machinery. Labour fights back, starts winning, gets drunk on power and closes down their place of work arguing about which brand of tea management should provide at meetings. New businesses get set up, management with lots of clout ...
"Where's that kid of yours I need to clean a white board."
It's called progress.

by itstech

Thanks for all your advice. A lot of people think pay and moving up the corporate ladder is the main thing to think about...but work is just part of one's life...it's not the main focus...There are other things in my life besides work that I want to accomplish...And another job with more pay and more potential growth may prevent me from having the life I want.

by tconard

your heart really isn't matching what you said in your original posting. Challenging positions sometimes require taking risks. I went into consulting 10 years ago and I gave up the security of steady work for the possible lulls between contracts.
I think the job security is a huge importance to you. Sit down and create a list of what is important to you and give them a 1-10 scale with 10 being the most improtant.
Good luck with your decision.

by jdmercha

It sounds like there is a lot more to it than a career choice. What you are looking for is a "Quality of Life" issue. You need to sit down and prioritize what is important to you. What is it that drives you? Family? Health? Religon? Free time? Accomplishemnts? Money? Retirement? Respect? Location?

If money and growth are not a priority, then what is? Write down your goals in life. Then what career choice will best assist you in achieving your higher goals.

by itstech

Yeah...I guess I'm at the point of my life where I need to decide what I want to do with my life. Do I want to further my career? Or do I work on other aspects of my life? It's an interesting decision that I bet a lot of you have made...

A couple of you have made a point to write down my goals and prioritize them...I wrote down some of my goals and it seems like I may have to give up some goals in order to accomplish other goals.

by oneshoe

I have had eight different jobs in my 15 years in IT. I left for better positions twice. Once to become Manager of Information Systems, the rest were due to corporate buyouts or outsourcing. The manager job sucked. All I did was go to meetings and do paperwork. Not much of a challenge at all.

My advice to you is stay where you are, work hard, learn what you can, live within your means and save your money. Other positions will no doubt open up where you are. Enjoy what you have. Job security is invaluable, especially when you have a family. You will be able to retire with a pension after 20 years, right? Look for a challenge then.

by n.salooja

I currently work for Local govt and before that i worked for State Govt. and in my opinion state job is much better than a local job and if you have enough education and work experience you can work for Federal and thats what i wanna do eventually. I am moving back to state govt starting next week with a pay cut but i know i will get more experience there and i have more opportunities to move up. I am also young (26) and i will have 5 years with state and local govt so i will be vested also. I thought about going to private where i had many offers but after thinink it throughly i have decided to stick with govt and then move with Federal. So in my opinion stay with govt.

by jdmercha

If money is what you are after than stick with engineering. I am currently an IT manager. I used to be a nuclear engineer. It took me 10 years in IT to get back to the salary level I was at as an engineer. My son is graduating this year with a BS in Computer Engineering. He has no offers yet, but he has 4 interviews set up for engineering jobs that will pay him as much or more than I'm getting now.

by craig herberg

If you want to have any hope of taking pride in your work and career, you need to get a job that pays you to work. If you keep on your current path, you will probably become unemployable.

Craig Herberg

by why me worry?

If you ask me, it's complete bullsh*t. It is some cert that some companies require PC techs to take so they have bragging rights that they can format a hard drive or replace a motherboard. I've seen 10 year old who can build band repair custom PCs' better than anyone with an A+ certification. At one point I believe, both Novell and Microsoft required their CNE and MCSE candidates to have A+ certification so that they had a solid understanding of PC architecture, but in today's day and age, it is expected for you to know the internal workings of a PC before you jump into IT or networking. If all you know is how to manage a network and nothing about replacing bad RAM or swapping out a bad hard drive in a server, then you are in the wrong career. A+ is no subsitute for real knowledge and believe me, I've seen A+ certs who still didn't know how to fornat a hard drive or connect a CDROM to the IDE connector on a motherboard.

by kfchan

I am not going to tell you what you should do, just to remind you what factors you should consider before making a decision.

From your description, it is clear that if you choose to stay, you gain job security and a comfortable environment. Otherwise, you get some more money and job satisfaction. However, I think money is not the main concern in our consideration because either decision offer you enough money. And job security is not a big issue because you are still young. So that job satisfaction and a comfortable environment are the weighs in the balance. You know which one is heavier.

by absolutely

First, that job security means the same boring job forever. So the focus of the computer industry moves around, so what? So you look for several jobs in the course of a successful career, so what?

Also, the government is not the only employer that will help with certs. My private employer pays for whatever tests I pass.

I think you should test your ability. It's the most rewarding and enjoyable, and you waste less time relaxing.

by hydrodog90

Don't forget, there's an active movement in government to outsource all functions that aren't part of the core mission of your agency. I believe it is being done under the Fair Act (not sure of correct name), assuming you are in the federal government. IT functions are among the first being evaluated for outsourcing, and I suspect that a relatively junior position like yours will end up in the private sector anyway.

Take some control over your life! Decide what you want to do, and go for it. You'll find that the rewards for achieving something difficult go deeper than the paycheck.

And, IMHO, not all government IT workers/jobs are so lazy/simple/undemanding. Although I work in the private sector, I know a lot of government IT people and they work hard, long hours giving good service to their users & managers. It's too bad you perpetuate the stereotype.

by doug m.

What about keeping the job you have, getting the training or education you desire, and starting your own IT biz on the side? This is what I am considering doing. I work for a school district and the pay is not great and the BS of going thru a bid process and budget cuts really limits our purchasing, but the job is actually rewarding to me in that I help a lot of people here each day. Maybe starting your own side-biz could lead to being fully self-employed someday which would be a real challenge and you would no longer rely on someone else for a paycheck. Speaking only for myself, I'm not looking to get rich, just need enough to pay the bills and feel satisfied with my job. Ask yourself one question: Do I feel like going to work today? If the answer is yes most of the time, I would say keep the job. If not it's time for a change.

by dwdino

As a Network Admin for a local government agency, I really enjoyed the none work side of it; plenty of time off, flex hours, training, toys(always getting new hardware/software), time to dream up and work on projects, etc. While a government employee my family life was excellent.

But it got to me; Little to no challenge, par was good enough, flippant deadlines, etc.

So, I had to go. Had to find that next hill to climb, I went private.

Wow what a change, that hour or two extra I put in is no longer extraordinary, rather almost expected. "Close of business" ... what's that. On-call oh yeah.

Outside of the time I have lost from my family (biggest negative), the move has been worth it. I am surrounded by compitent, motivated, people who never settle for good enough. Already I have been able to grab responsibilities outside of my hired scope.

So, yes. The move can be worth it, but think hard and long. There are days when I have been working 18+ hour days and running on mostly caffiene and I think, man it would be nice to be back in government. But, at the end of the day, I have accomplished something, made something work, or in some way climbed another hill; so I will try again tomorrow.

by tony hopkinson

If you are in position where you can afford the risk and the poster seems to be since he didn't mention whompin' great mortgage and a family. Then that's the most important question you can ask. Spending 40+ years doing something you don't enjoy for a few quid is just mad.
Be a lot easier in the UK though as you could get a 50% payrise for the less responsibility by going public to private, the salary itself is pathetic.

This discussion is closed to new replies.