Discussion Locked

What to do if you ace a technical interview but they lowball the offer?

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I was at an interview not long ago for an IT Consulting firm in which I aced their interview process and they made me an offer. I did state on the application and verbally to the interviewer what my desired salary was. She was a bit dissapointed in my figure and asked if I was flexible, so I said I am depending on the entire package that they're offering. About a few days after the interview, I get an email with a formal offer letter and I was shocked at what I saw. They're offering me about $25,000 less than my desired salary. Now I can understand if they can't offer what I want, but to lowball me with a salary that I made 10 years ago in my career is not only insulting, it's very unprofessional on their part for what they call a "Senior level" position, which also involves managing field techs and engaging customers on a pre-sales and post-sales basis, as well as project management work. Do they expect me to haggle with them until I accept their peasly and pathetic offer, or should I just outright decline and move on? I'm still waiting on other offers, but I don't want to take a job in which I'll hate myself and be miserable because I shortchanged myself.

21 replies

by tony hopkinson

In fact it must be, given you are even considering it.

I'm taking a wild stab in the dark here, but their personel turnover must be horrendous.

by maniacman

I'm not considering it if they can't do better than that pathetic excuse for an offer. I told them I don't need medical coverage because I'm covered under my wife's plan through her employer, and the 401k comes out of my paycheck anyway, so what are they really contributing to here? I have an uncanny feeling that this place is a revolving door or an H1-B body shop if they lowball with such insulting offers. I've disclosed my salary history, and I told them that I was an independent 1099 contractor on my last gig and grossed about $125,000 for the year. They offered me $90,000 base, which is what I made about 7 years ago, and they call this a senior level position which also expects me to respond to emergency calls on a 24/7/365 basis? I'd like to know what they're smoking because I want some of it too...LOL :^0

by tony hopkinson

blow jobs?

May be time to find a tactful way to say f**k off.

Tactful isn't one of my strong points though, with me they'd get the straight anglo saxon...

by jaqui

make a counter offer to them for the same amount over your last rate as they went under it.

cut back on the availability to a 40 hour week as well.

if they don't respond with a counter offer, then they aren't worth working with.

by maniacman

If they expect me to work over 40 hours a week, then they had better pay me OT at time and a half. I've worked as an exempt salaried employee before and all I can say about it is that it's a fancy term for a sweatshop employee. I personally think that 40 hours is more than enough on salary and anything over that should be compensated accordingly.

by jaqui

but you have to cover the subject in the contract, or you screw yourself over on it.
which is why you need to specify that the base salary only covers 40 hours in a week. anything above is overtime and is paid for according to local labour laws.
[ here, an employer must give you 38 consecutive hours off in any given 7 day period or it is overtime until such a period of off time occurs. nice for the overtime pay, bad for the taxes ]

by maniacman

But I agree with you on the 40 hours a week stuff. If they expect extended support on an OT exempt basis, then they can kiss their offer goodbye and stick it where the sun don't shine. This isn't an offer then, it's a sweatshop invitation if they expect anyone to work non-stop without proper compensation.

by cg it

make a counter offer if you really want to work for them if not I would politely decline the offer.

by maniacman

I'll make a counteroffer and see how much I can squeeze out of them. If they balk at giving me more, then I guess it wasn't meant to be.

by cg it

if they really want your expertice they will consider the counter offer..

if they want a college grad who doesn't know anything but has a college degree, they won't.

by maniacman

And they know this because they saw it on my resume and know I have over a decade's worth of experience in this industry. I'm just personally appaled that they would go so low with their offer after I specifically stated what I want as a salary. I can understand them going $10K lower, but not $25K, which I see as an insult to my intelligence.

by tig2

Other benefits in the package that will make up for the shortfall, I'd simply walk away. I don't know that I would even bother with a counter but to say- if asked- that while you were wiling to come to the table with a certain flexibility, the offer doesn't meet your minimum requirements.

If you accept an offer that you are clearly offended by, you will be miserable at the post. And that will show in a myriad of ways.

Much better to decide that you aren't willing to be THAT flexible and move along.

I have taken significantly less money to work with a particular team or on a particular project. Each of those times, the decision was mine and mine alone. If this role isn't offering you something compelling, you will indeed be unhappy in it.

You have to do the right thing for you. Figure out what your low number is. If they can't meet or exceed it, the best answer may just be to walk away.

You know the answer to this. It was all over your post. It isn't a bad or wrong answer.

by maniacman

with no guarantee that the contract work will encompass a full 40 hour work week. I asked them to give me a week to consider it, but I think I'll end up declining in the end, as I'll be miserable and hate myself for taking such drastic paycut.

by rt735

Well being only 22 making 50 a year (which i guess isnt bad) i think i need to get into consulting? yea 25k paycut is not resonable at all, but boy would i love 90k ;) Hope everything works out right for you.

by tig2

Don't do that which will make you miserable. It just isn't worth it and life is certainly too short.

You had the answer when you posted. You just needed to hear from your peers that you had the right answer. You will never regret choosing to pass on this.

Hang in! You're doing the right thing!

Edit: Missed a couple of essential letters!

by maniacman

As a salaried employee, they can't offer more because they have to pay all of their "techs" equally. So much for calling this a "senior level" position. They are willing to work with me on a 1099 hourly basis and can offer me a higher rate, but they can't guarantee that I'll be working at least 40 hours a week. I've got a second pending interview with another firm and I'll see where that takes me, as they're in the financial services sector and can pay me the salary I seek. Decision, decision!

by maniacman

You'd fit in just well as a New York resident because you're not afraid to flip somebody off if you're not satisfied with the conditions. For what it's worth, we need more people like this in IT who can tell it like it is to these lowballing companies. Perhaps when enough people start squeezing for more money, the firms will start listening and we'll be paid accordingly.

by maniacman

to pay for, so $90K just doesn't cut it for me, even though my wife works as well, but her paycheck is barely enough to support us. I don't want to work in such a manner that I'm still living paycheck to paycheck, but rather be able to save and invest some extra money into my IRA and money market account. You're young, so I'll tell you how it is...Don't think that consulting is all that great because when you're on contract, there will be times where you are out of work for weeks, if not months on end as you find new work. When you gain experience, it will be easier to find work quicker because recruiters will be hunting you down, but will little experience in IT, stick with salaried position until you gain enough skills to call yourself senior level. If you live by yourself or have a family to support, consulting can actually hurt you in the long run if you don't have steady income. I'd accept a permanent salaried position, but not for the kind of pennies this place was offering. Always know that any paycuts will only hurt you later on when you are interviewing and have to disclose your salary history. It's very awkward to have to explain why you took a $25K cut in salary, and HR will use it against you to lowball you even more.

by geekdoe

There might be a few reasons why they do that:

- They do not have enough budget;
- They do not know how to appreciate skill and knowledge

You can make your observation towards the company, and decide which one they fit in.

If they fall to the first, I will write them back, stating that it's better for them to find someone else who would take the job for the offered salary.

But if they fall to the latter, I will write them back with the naked truth: I refuse. I will tell them that the salary they offered is the one I have like 10 years ago, and how the offer really insults me.

--
geekdoe

by maniacman

I politely stated to them that I do not wish to lie to them and myself by taking an offer than will not make me happy, resulting in my leaving them after a month or so. They truly want to hire me, but I'm not convinced that their offer shows any appreciation for my skills or past salary history. I will just respectfully decline instead of wasting any further time on this.

by ron.delaware

If they can't give you defined cash salary, then work it this way:
1. Request that they up their counter by 6K and give you one additional week of paid vacation
2. if stock options are available, get them to offer you options, may not help immediately, but comes in handy in the future.

This discussion is closed to new replies.