Discussion Locked

What would you choose? All Windows or mixed Windows/Linux

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I ask because I'm being pressured by my manager to agree that we should revise our network infrastructure to completely eliminate any Linux servers. this would then leave only Windows machines which would then be 'easier to manage' and be more 'cost effective' in IT Support terms.

My colleague and I have brought up the the fact that any system where security can be compromised across the board in minutes is a bad idea.

I guess the corollary to this is the question of whether it's worth sticking it out in a job with a stubborn manager.

37 replies

by robroynj

I'm not a Linux zealot and there are many place where I would and have choosen Windows servers over other choices but to go with one platform simply based on an "ease of management" is in my opinion very dangerous and if I were to do this I would lean towards Linux and not windows in server environments.

by ian lewis

My boss has been speaking to lots of consultants who spend most of their time immersed in the MS view of the world. The telling comment was that of referring to Linux as having 'no future'. I certainly wouldn't agree there.

I enjoy the challenge presented by IT security but migrating from a stable mixed platform network to a monoculture needs careful thought and planning. Our charity will now be spending more money in the name of standards when in fact it isn't necessary.

Thanks for your comments.

by stress junkie

You would do well to maintain your position on the subject. Eventually your manager will override this and make the policy in spite of your objection. When problems from this decision arise you can at least say that you never thought that the change was good. If you agree to the change then your manager will blame you when problems surface.

I've worked with a lot of managers by way of working in contract employment for many years. (Not now, but previously.) In all of those jobs I only met one manager that was an asset to the business. ALL of the rest were liabilities to the business. Therefore you will probably gain nothing by moving to a new employer. Just accept the change without agreeing to it.

by neil higgins

Just take a look at this article,The Windows to Linux Migration Guide,from 2004.The answer to your question,is in the opening few lines of the article:

http://enterprise.linux.com/article.pl?sid=04/07/23/2219257

Why change to Windows en-mass? Altimately,the final decision may/will be taken out of your hands.Whatever happens,dont quit,sit this one out after reflective debate,and if the outcome is not what you intended,just watch the chaos unfold."Told you so" comes to mind :)

Also see this about the city of Munchen,Germany:

http://news.com.com/Munichs+Linux+migration+slips+to+2006/2100-7344_3-5850633.html?tag=nefd.top

by rhoninpowers

First as an employee the last thing I would recommend you do is go the "I told you so route"...professoinally document the risks as clinically and unemotionally as you can and let the process, whatever its direction takes its course and attempt to support your manager in a professoinal manner.

A lot of whitepapers and marketing buffs push the "one vendor one platform" reduced TCO button, if your environment is one where costs are tightly managed and every task is tracked, then arguments could be made that preserving your existing investment is more wise then going and spending money to deploy more of whatever the platform.

In short the answers to this problem lie with how/if metrics exist in your environment that truly track the cost of managing the systems down to vendor support, internal support, help desk issues, etc. Once these numbers are known it won't be a technical decision also a business decision.
Don't get caught up in the evangelical wars of Windows vs. Linux, as upper management I want my folks with their eyes on the business issues more than platform vs. platfrom discussions.

Also if you have any systems that "can be compromised in minutes"...then I would say no one in your shop has a clue about security. Change is difficult especially for IT folks and beyond looking at my manager I would have to look at myself and what role will I play in the equation.

by choppit

Stress Junkie is right. If your manager insists then do as they ask, but make it clear that you're doing so because you've been asked, not because you agree.

by ljgizinski

Don't just tell him. Email him. Make it written so you have it documented for posterity.

by cactus pete

You mean that your argument rests completely on "any system where security can be compromised across the board in minutes is a bad idea."?!

If you can't secure a Windows box, then you need to learn how.

Do you mean to say that you believe someone could compromise any of your Windows servers now? Shouldn't you look into fixing those issues? Otherwise, you should insist on switching all to Linux and not even entertain the option for a mixed environment.

basically, if you don't know how to secure your systems, whatever the platform, you should learn or hire someone who can.

You'll be lucky if your boss doesn't think of that before you do...

by derek silva

dpetrak, you have to read the posts these people make before responding to them. From what I've read, they have a network with Windows clients and Linux servers right now. Ian never said anything about Windows servers. The manager wants to switch to an all Windows environment because he thinks it'll save the company money and be easier to manage. Personally I would disagree with that statement.

Ultimately, I agree with the consultant who posted a few days ago. Read his post, follow his recommendations.

by cactus pete

"I ask because I'm being pressured by my manager to agree that we should revise our network infrastructure to completely eliminate any Linux servers. this would then leave only Windows machines which would then be 'easier to manage' and be more 'cost effective' in IT Support terms."

When reading "...pressured... to completely eliminate any Linux servers" I see that, coupled with the title of the post, as implying that there is currently a mixed environment.

Perhaps it would benefit you to see that this is not a linear posting site, and that the dates lower can actually be sooner thatn some of those above.

Also, I would point out that Ian has not posted anything again, so we can't really know all the details without his feedback.

That said, I will reiterate: Learn how to use the tools you have for the systems you must secure.

And I will also add: Common sense would benefit his whole company.

by jaqui

all linux, as windows is way to expensive to standardise on, and is far more prone to being down, destroying the system.

by derek silva

Do you have any evidence to back this claim, Jaqui? I personally find your argument very hard to believe, for either the Linux OR Windows side of it.

by jaqui

lets see the evidence that windows doesn't crash. ( Blue Screen of Death ring any bells? )
lets see the evidence that viruses do not take windows machines down.
( impossible, since several major companies ( cnn.com being one ) just went down from latest virus.

by o/siris

You're not going to win a general "Windows is better/worse, Linux is better/worse" argument. That's your manager's job, like it or not. To make that kind of decision.

If you're going to get your side heard, you have to get specific. Linux better than Windows for CRM? Why? Because the app you use is on Linux/Windows and migration would add $15,000 to the cost of standardizing? Windows better than Linux for directory services? Why? Get it ON PAPER. Yeah, I mean hardcopy, and put your signature and date on it. Be specific. Point to specific uses of your network, and why that system is better than moving or not moving it.

You're not the manager. Don't pretend to be one. You're the admin, I presume. It's your job to examine the technical side of things. It's that of your manager to equate that to the pocketbook. So be specific, and be willing to talk dollars.

And get your manager to sign AND DATE every document you write up about this. Let him have the copies, and keep the originals.

by djameson

I would take the black box approach, Converting to windows internally shouldn't be that big of a concern, you can make an internal network reasonably secure, but when it comes to the edge, vpn, external web and mail server, I wouldn't do it. The blackbox approach is what would it cost you to replace your Linux boxes in strategic areas with blackboxes. ie your mailserver is replaced with a baracudda, your linux firewall with a netscreen, I would send a very detailed email to him about the risks involved with exposing an IIS based server to the real world, even through a firewall. offer a compromise, Convert everything internal to windows and ask to convert everything external to BSD, thats the way we work.

by adrian_curiosu

It all depends on the business. No OS (Windows, Linux, Unix, etc.) is unbreakable. If your team can secure Windows OS & apps, but the manager has to hire a consultant to do the same thing to Linux and the apps running on it, well, he may be right.
Do a cost/benefit analysys from the business perspective, factoring all costs of the day to day operations, licensing, and so on. Take into account the risks involved in running both Windows and Linux and do your best to express them in financial terms. Consider the experience you and your team have with both OS, the availability of more experienced technical support people and so on.

Do the math and compare the figures. If they differ by more than 20% (just an example), then you have a clear winner. If they are pretty close, then the manager is right.

It is quite easy to find examples of that calculations. Both Microsoft and Linux advocates have published examples of such calculations. Just get one of them, put in your actual values (I assume those published on the Internet may be a little biased :) and do the math.

Present your results to the manager, as a formal report. No mather what the final decision will be, this is a good exercise for you. It could prove helpful when you will be promoted to a management position.

by newby7718

Security?
There is no such thing as security. Any qualified hacker can break into any system (including LINUX) that they target as evidenced by kids breaking into FBI, CIA and Pentagon computers. The only real security is an educated user and network administrator who does a well thought out daily backup.

CPM? DOS? OS2? AIX? UNIX?
Remember those LINUX predicesors? They all promised to be the CHAMPION operating system of the Century. Today, they are "gone with the wind," or little known and little used.

I have seen them come and I have seen them go --since 1986, the only one that has been a consistent producer of "user-friendly" OS and Apps is Microsoft. As the "defacto-standard," it is no wonder that hackers target it. And, Microsoft is diligent enough to have a patch within hours of a security breach or known issue.

Microsoft certainly has my vote of confidence(as an old gezzer who has been an IT professional since 1959) until something better comes along --and LINUX just ain't it!

by tuxuser

The only TRULY secure Windows machine is one without floppy/cdrom drives no modem/nic and no keyboard/mouse.

And if by "user-friendly" you mean you will use our OS and apps since we bully pc makers into pre-installing it.....then you are right Microsoft is it. And "defacto-standard"?...put out broken software of poor quality and let the common-folk find the problems then we'll fix it. Yep again Microsoft wins.

If you want freedom of choice and better control then look elsewhere..Linux. With all the addins available for just about anything you can imagine for control, config etc...and most are free...remember free does NOT mean JUNK or garbage.

by jgaskell

So, as seems to be the case with the majority of discussions around here, this one has degenerated into a Windows vs Linux name-calling session. Can't we all just get over it and start discussing the actual topic at hand? dpetrak's response is the best one I have seen to this topic.

by fizquierdo

I have to disagree with you on your statement of UNIX or AIX. AIX, though "little known" as you stated, has been gaining marketshare steadily over the past few years. Also, because it is an Enterprise class OS, it does not run on commodity (read PC based) hardware. It is an OS that keeps on evolving, even though not as fast as others. It is an OS you will only find in large IT shops, such as utilities, banking and government agencies at both the local and federal levels.

As far as UNIX (in its many flavors) is concerned, it has been around for over 30 years, running on everything from PC's to mainframes. If UNIX/Linux is so irrelevant, why would Microsoft decide to include their UNIX based services as part of the OS on their next server level release (Longhorn Server/Vista Server?).

by jmgarvin

*nix holds 50% or so of the current server market. Unix holds about 28% while Linux (not LINUX) holds about 22%.

As far as MS being targeted because it is "the defacto-standard" how do you explain Apache?

by derek silva

Just the audacity of a statement like "Microsoft is diligent enough to have a patch within hours of a security breach or known issue" is hilarious and honestly made me laugh out loud. Hours? Try DAYS. If you switched "Microsoft" to "Linux programmers" instead, then you'd actually have a statement that's true.

And please, by all means, prove me wrong. Please find the last time Microsoft released a patch within HOURS of a security hole being found. We're still finding exploits that have been around since Windows 98 was released... a lot of these exploits are inherited OS to OS. How you can possibly sit there and say that Microsoft is "diligent" by any means of the word is rediculous.

by mikael_bm

I can say a mix solution is the best, easy to manage and also cost effective. From 5 years I made Linux/Windows networks and nobody complain until now. To have only Windows I think is a bad idea. One idea: how many people has protection inside with windows? How windows can protect from inside attacks? With patches, hundred and hundred. Windows server is like a bate for fish and, for sure, a potential hacker is fisherman.

So, my advice is to make a report where you should mention strong/weak point for Windows/Linux environment and strong/weak points for Windows environment.

By the way, I have an mail server on Linux and is working over 4 year with minimum maintanance. I want to know if Windows has one of this solution.

Good luck!

by jeff

I have been running Exchange since 1999 and haven't had any issues besides updating and patching. I guess I did have to move it to a new box but that because I added 50 users and they added 10GB to the database.

Linux is good but when done right Windows can be just as good. Not to mention that Exchange gives my users a lot more than smtp, pop, or imap.

by charliespencer

Your first question is irrelevant. You're not getting paid to make that call; your boss is. Your job is to implement his choice.

I'm not sure why everyone else thinks you need to cover your @$$ for his decision. If a subordinate asked me to sign paperwork showing he disagreed with my legal decisions, he wouldn't be around to worry about the repercussions.

Only you can answer your second question.

by o/siris

"If a subordinate asked me to sign paperwork showing he disagreed with my legal decisions, he wouldn't be around to worry about the repercussions."

Well that's just one of the difficulties of hiring professionals. They will provide their opinion, because that, too, is their job. And the documentation serves to prove they did theirs.

Far too often, I.T. workers find themselves on the wrong end of a claim that they didn't do their job, causing a project to run over, overbudget, or over schedule, it's still been the same.

May I ask, what problem do you have with documenting that such a discussion occured? It's not your job to worry about the efficiencies of tasks in Windows vs those of Linux. Why would your subordinates *not* have the option to tell you that you're losing these?

I'm no labor lawyer, certainly, but I have a suspicion that firing someone for asking you to document that you've heard an alternative viewpoint is not something you'd be comfortable explaining should your project go wrong (meaning if you were the manager in the original post). Absolutely, the decision is yours to make. But refusing to discuss alternatives, *and* to document that discussion, that's assinine.

by charliespencer

If I didn't feel their opinions were worthwhile, I wouldn't have hired them. If they want my signature showing I support a decision they made, I'll be happy to sign.

I don't see the value in what appears to me to be getting my subordinate's approval when my decision disagrees with his advice. I don't someone working for me who feels they need my signature to cover -their- ass on a decision -I- was responsible for. This implies the employee is concerned I will stick him with the responsiblity for my mistake. I don't play that game, I don't want someone working for me who does or thinks I do, and I won't work where my bosses do. I trust my subordinates to give me informed advice, but I expect them to remember it's my decision, to implement what I decide, and to trust me to take the heat when I'm wrong. There's a saying in the military, "You can delegate authority, but you can't delegate responsibility." This strongly colors my philosophy.

If I was a contractor, and the customer went against my advice, that would be a completely different kettle of fish. But that's not the original scenario.

I'm no labor lawyer either, but if I refuse to sign and the employee quits, then he's not around to worry about the consequences, is he? Sorry if my original posting made it sound like I would fire someone.

by havacigar

Have the employee sign a form stating that he disagreed with the manager's decision and doesn't think it will work. Then if anything goes wrong, you have proof HE sabotaged it. If it works, the employee looks like a dumb ass. Works both ways against the employee and for the manager.

by charliespencer

I'm not interested in intimidating subordinates. If I make them sign off when they disagree with me, they'll stop disagreeing and just tell me what I want to here. Then we wind up with the Cheney administration. (I'm sorry. I don't know what came over me. Please forget I said that.)

If it goes wrong, it could be because I was wrong to begin with. If it works, I'd like to think it was because the employee swallowed his disagreement and helped make it work. I'm not interested in things that work against my subordinates.

by stress junkie

... proof that the employee sabotaged the project? If anything it shows that the employee was probably correct.

Your whole attitude stinks.

by o/siris

"Have the employee sign a form stating that he disagreed with the manager's decision and doesn't think it will work. Then if anything goes wrong, you have proof HE sabotaged it. If it works, the employee looks like a dumb ass. Works both ways against the employee and for the manager."

Every little facet of what you said illustrates why I recommended that the employee document everything. Every phone conversation, every email, every reference as they passed each other in the hall. That is NOT what the employee the original post was saying. The employee *did* feel there was a better option. As an I.T. professional at a presumably NetAdmin level, that's his job.

What you want to do with that is what has far too often been done in absentia to I.T. employees. If an I.T. employee does *not* express disagreement in documentation, then they are held to be in complete agreement, and thus responsible for the success or failure of the project. Likewise, if unethical managers try to "turn" the documentation into a case for sabotage, as in the quote above, then the more documentation, the better. That way, the unscrupulous manage would suddenly have a lot of explaining to do.

by fadiyaser

currently at work we are using all Linux, and we are very satisfied, even the desktop machines are Linux Fedora...

Cheers,
Fadi

by cweb

Are you asking whether you want to stay working for a Boss because he wants a single platform or are you asking whether you should stay working for a boss because you don't agree with him?

First)If he makes the decision to go all Microsoft, then you have to either live with it or move on. If you don't approve of that decision, can you live with it? I may have my heart set on working with a certain size monitor, but if the company only provides a different size from what I want am I going to quit over that? Probably not
Second)he's your boss! You don't have to agree with him on every decision. In fact is there any interpersonal relationship that you agree 100 percent all the time with someone? I think not.
Now as for going with a single Microsoft platform that isn't as unsecure as it sounds. I have worked as sys admin on a purely MS network for 3 years and never once was anything compromised. As long as everything is updated and done on time and set up properly there isn't really a problem. Most networks that are in the news for being cracked almost without exception show there is a lack of regular updates being installed and shortcuts taken with security updates.
Now let me say this first, I am in no way a MS supporter and really have the same dislike for the monopoly most others do. But that doesn't mean a properly set up and maintained network isn't secure and definitely cannot have its security compromised in minutes.

by ian lewis

Here's some feedback.

Since my first posting my manager has arranged some Microsoft training. Specifically, how to secure servers. This is good, I like to learn and it can't really do me any harm.

The point about understanding how to secure a Microsoft server is actually a good one. I'd prefer to understand as much as possible about it since it looks as though I'll be working in a Windows only environment.

My initial comment about pressure was based on the fact that my manager has undertaken a lot of discussions with external consultants and contacts without actually including me in any of them. So, when the decision to "eliminate Linux servers" and "standardise" with Microsoft was presented to me I did feel rather insulted. I got over that.

by cactus pete

Management has a way of making decisions like that. It's always a little insulting when they don't even include you in the discussions, whether there is agreement or not. Having a voice, or being offered the opportunity to listen to others' voices, is a nicety seldom permitted.

by ian lewis

'I told you so' is very bad news I agree. Whatever the system is I'm responsible for its security so I'd look a fool if I couldn't maintain it.

As for reduced TCO my manager is a 'spend more, get more' type. His perception at the moment is that standardising on Microsoft products is good for our organisation, good for me (in career terms) and will ensure that there is nothing that can't be supported by someone coming in from outside.

I'm not going get involved in the Windows vs Linux argument, I have to develop my career and it's no bad thing to get the training.

I wouldn't want any system I was administering to be 'compromised in minutes' as I take network security very seriously. Better to keep my eyes open and learn Best Practice. That way I'll be able to say 'we need this [widget]' and why and my manager won't be able to disagree.

This discussion is closed to new replies.