in the UK two years ago.
I did lose a bit in theoretical salary.
When I added back in sick pay, paid holidays, employer pension contributions, no longer needing an accountant, indemnity insurance, 'free' training, transport savings, interview costs ( moved about a lot as a contractor), it became a very attactive deal.
US conditions are going to be different and I was getting marginialised from not earning enough to stay up to date, so as you've spotted it's not just money.
I can say I personally am getting much more job satisfaction as I get a much bigger say in what to do and how to do it. As a contractor those decisions had usually already been made, quite often badly.
I'm more suited to fire prevention, than to simply putting them out.
Course on the downside there is office politics and SSDD.
I got a lot out of contracting, including a much better job than I might have had if I'd stayed permanent. I may even go back to it at some point, but I'm enjoying the stability of knowing where I'm working from one month to next. Given of course I don't lose in value to my employer.