34 replies
by chanda_cole
I recently completed a comparison review of about 10 products for IT service and support management. My primary goal was to find a product that offered options for help desk service support, inventory management and procurement process support. You may be looking for something with a broader focus, however if it helps below are the criteria that I used for evaluation:
End User Support
-Self service to allow the end user to enter and review the status of their own trouble tickets
-Notification capabilities to notify the end-user via email when a change is made to their ticket by help desk staff
-Notification capabilities to notify the help desk staff via email when a change is made to their ticket by the end user
-The ability to create trouble ticket "templates" to speed the entry of common problems and routine requests
IT Staff
-Multiple methods of notification when a new trouble ticket is entered
-The ability to manage both "internal" and "external" information within a ticket so that the end-user views only specific fields
-Automatic time-stamping of each modification to a ticket by either the end-user or IT staff
-The ability to attach electronic files to a trouble ticket for additional information and reference
-The ability to create a trouble ticket on-the-fly from an email message
-The ability to automatically assign a ticket to IT staff based on criteria
Setup & Administration
-A web-based interface for both end-users and IT staff
-The ability to utilize MS SQL Server as the database engine behind the application
-The ability to integrate with Active Directory for authentication and permissions
-The ability to create and manage user-defined fields within the trouble ticket
-The ability to set up workflow and routing rules for processing different ticket types
Management Tools
-The ability to track costs and time associated with a trouble ticket in order to measure SLA outcomes
-A multitude of canned reports as well as the ability to use a reporting software such as Crystal Reports to created additional reports
-The ability to survey the end-user as to the quality of the service they receive
-The ability to manage assets and inventory, including scanning the network to identify machines, scanning those machines to identify software installed, auditing installed software to notify of changes, and software license management
-The ability to manage procurement activities by tracking the initial request, quote, purchase request and purchase order, and adding the item directly to inventory once it is received
-The ability to create a knowledgebase accessible to both IT Staff and end-users, including solutions to common problems and user manuals
by peter spande
by todder
I would like to know if anyone has used/is using BOSS Solutions DiagWin or U Win.
I would also like to know what products were evaluated in the previous post.
by welshbilly
I've worked with quite a few Management Tools on a helpdesk and I have found that Heat to be the best. It meets most of the requirements in chanda_cole's post.
Like all tools, if used to it's full potential and installed correctly, it does work really well. It can be expensive when you add up all of the modules you would need to meet the requirements. But it is the best I have seen and I have worked with an inhouse tool and also Track-IT.
But you could look at saving money from the Web side of things by developing a web front yourself, if your able to.
by jenni_baker
by chanda_cole
I evaluated the following products against the above criteria:
cSupport
Track-IT
Heat
Footprints
HelpBox
Revelation
HelpStar
Magic
Parature
Maximo
I have narrowed the list down to four: Track-It, Heat, Footprints and Magic but have not yet scheduled demos so that the rest of my staff can see the products and provide their feedback. I do have a limited budget which may knock Heat out of the running (I haven't requested pricing from the last two vendors yet). I do have staff that are capable of building the web-based front-end but unfortunately I can't afford to have them focus on that due to our current workload, which is why I've decided to move away from our in-house solution (which does have that type of front-end already).
by babac
by breadtrk
by david_scott
by brad mankoff
by babac
by drnz_54
What toolset is best for your Service Desk and/or your Desktop Management is completely dependent on what your business needs it to do. To define a set of business requirements, start by speaking to stakeholders from Management, Tier 1 and Tier 2+ analysts and ask them to tell you "What do YOU need a tool to be able to do?" All requirements should be stated as "The ability to..." and should list a feature or functionality that will enable them to a) do their jobs efficiently and effectively and b) add value to the business. Be careful NOT to get technical here and simply focus on what you need it to do. Do not forget the definition of the metrics and reports required to manage support. Once you have all this down, weed out the ridiculous and assign a weighted importance to each requirement that remains. Send this out to vendors as a "Request for Information" (RFI). Ask them to respond on a scale of 1-5 (1 being "with massive customization" and 5 being "Out of the box") how well their product meets the requirement and also to explain HOW their product does this. Once you compare these scorecards, you will know whom to invite to a demo. Look for vendors who can integrate with Service Desk programs as well.
BTW: LANDesk is a fantastic product if it has been properly configured. A good many of those who own LANDesk have not invested well in the implementation and training to use it as the very powerful tool it is.
For Service Desk/ITIL processes for a small business, look at FrontRangeHEAT and Magic...large business, look at Frontrange ITSM and Remedy ITSM
by gvossos1
LiveTime is a web-based service desk application that integrates
with all industry standard asset management tools, including
LanDesk. Well worth a look.
by bfilmfan
What IT process methodology is the organization using? ITIL? CIMM? ISO 9002
The tool should meet the business requirements as has been stated earlier.
I am CTO of NetworkD the largest global partner for LANDesk and also a top global partner for Frontrange solutions (mentioned by other posters here). We provide the ability to link these systems (or LANDesk into many other systems) to support the service desk and associated processes.
The presence of LANDesk is a benefit simply because it is currently owned so the comparison with other products should be performed to confirm it is still what you need but investment in another product may be prohibitive. Usual suspects would include:
Altiris
HP/Novadigm Radia (if you are VERY big)
Symantec
Microsoft SMS
+Many others
The other posts seem to be missing the actual question for the most part and looking at the servicedesk products rather than providing data for the desktop management needs but they have valid points that the service desk application is also important.
I can provide extensive analysis on these products if required but there is no way that this can be posted here because everything mentioned has depth and breadth and deserves better than a 3 line synopsis. It needs to be applied to your business needs, the environment conditions, and the processes currently in place/required. Only then can an accurate comparison and recommendation be provided.
I wouldn't normally add this but our website is http://www.networkd.com. My name is Mark.McGinn - add this to the domain name and you have my email address.
We have little to gain because you already own software but what we have to offer is sound industry advice.
If you need info posted here only then please add detail of how large the environment is (numbers of systems/sites), primary support requirements/projects, current servicedesk system, current version of LANDesk and whether software maintenance is present, supported system types such as % desktop/laptop/truly mobile user, operating systems, network operating systems e.g. Novell/MS.
With this I might be able to offer some more focussed advice.
At my previous company, we used the Touchpaper ITSM suite and partnering that as a management tool, LANDesk.
Both are really good products but if I'm being totally honest, they are pretty much the same as most of the other HelpDesk/Management tools available on the market.
When a decision is to be made, rarely does it come down to some unique feature, as most of the big players have a comparable feature set.
LANDesk is a huge application, very powerful and very capable of carrying out the sorts of tasks that help you instead of hindering you, but it is a bit of a beast. If you lose sight of the initial requirements, then it becomes very difficult to implement properly.
Before you start evaluating any products, I'd suggest you look at the business requirements behind it. Look at what you want it to do in real world terms.
by mederle
by da.fournier
by anne.powel
Got to Pink elephant, the message was
"The resource you are trying to access does
not exist"
by james speed
Landesk is ok, i've used it. I am the Network Admin at another hospital now. I decided up Desktop Authority as our management tool. The scripting (ScriptLogic) is GREAT!
J Speed
by jsamuelson
by llaratte
My advice is to first create the processes you are going to use to manage service support and delivery. Once you have mapped out these processes and then placed a "technology overlay" onto them ("technology overlay", by the way, is the term that I use to descrive what I consider to be the second major component of creating a process: mapping how technology can automate it and make it more efficient), you will want to use that as your basis for documenting business requirements and functionality.
As a final "to do" before looking at vendors, you may want to create hypothetical scenarios (or real scenarios) for each process. You can use these during vendor demos to see if, indeed, their product can meet your needs.
I have done a lot of work in the area of implementations and software evaluation; check out my blog: www.thebridge.laratte.net .
by ivanerdos
I fully agree with your approach.
If you calculate the total investment in the implementation of a new (in this case centralized) service desk the majority of the expenditure is related to the BPR and moving/changing/training of your people.
This is something you cannot do very often, do it right. If your processes are well aligned with your customer's need (I'm also suggesting to consider using ITIL or any flavor of it like MS MOF or HP ITSM), software platform choice will not so important any more.
By the way, did you consider not to buy software but subscribe for services like Everdream's?
by bfrankenhoff
Check out Vertical Solutions:
http://www.vertsol.com/products.asp?x=products
by bill.affeldt
We wnt throught quite a lengthy and formal process for choosing a tool. We defined our requirements. Created weighted score sheets and invited about 8 different companies to bid and demonstrate. We cut down to a final 3 based purely on score. It was close as all of our finalists had some really great features.
We chose Aldon because it supplied us with a very robust system that integrates with our change control process and integrates with their proprietary configuration management tools.
We can now tie our incoming issues to our code and process changes and enhancments in both the maiframe environment and the distributed environment.
An amazing thing happened after IT started using this.... our internal customer departments have come to us and said...'Hey can you set us up so we can manage some of our internal issues like you guys in IT are doing' The Aldon solution has allowed us to set up our IT help desk to be state of the art. It has also allowed us to integrate a sales tracking system, a small help desk solution for our accounting department and several other projects are pending.
I would highly recommend that you contact Aldon if you want a robust tool that track issues, manage change, integrate with data on legacy systems and provide the capabilities to manage configuration on your systems.
NO I DO NOT WORK FOR ALDON. NO I AM NOT GETTING ANY THING FOR SINGING THEIR PRAISES. I JUST REALLY LIKE THE TOOL, BECAUSE IT IS THE BEST LEVER WE COULD FIND TO BRING OUR ORGANIZATION UNDER CONTROL AND PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR OUR INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL CUSTOMERS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
As a side note / soft side recommendation... Every interaction I have had with sales, technical support and training has been nothing short of fantastic.
by helpdeskguy
Just my thoughts on Magic...
Magic is based on the ITIL Framework;
Can be incorporated into your intranet;
Good for small to medium-size businesses;
Can do asset/change/crisis management, as well as purchases and work orders;
AD integration, can use SQL or Oracle;
Reasonably priced;
Uses Crystal Reports for reporting;
Used it years ago when they were independent and called Magic Solutions. Since were bought out by Network Associates, and now settled nicely under BMC's small to mid-size business area. Good support through BMC and upgrades/install etc. through third-party.
by jsamuelson
by helpdeskguy
We are a small shop, supporting around 1600 users so it works for us. BMC is doing all support...very responsive wether over the phone or support through their website.
For licenses, upgrades, installs, customizations we use a third-party certified Magic firm that seems to meet our needs.
Yes, still a bit awkward to navigate...version 9 s/b coming out early in 2006 (the first major release from BMC) so we'll see what that brings.
by augs
by mark.black
We utilise a product called InfraEnterprise and find it to be extremely useful. It can be customised to suit your needs, is ITIL certified and has some fantastic Change Management and service availability features. The new version about to be released also contains an updated Knowledge feature.
Go to www.infra.com.au for more information, although Australian based, they have offices in USA and UK.
by zaferus
And are waiting for SP1 to come out before upgrading.
Track-IT isn't too bad for help desk. The inventory is a little rough around the edges.
by dugadugdug
Try the following:
http://www.pinkelephant.com/en-US/PinkVerify/PinkVerifyToolset.htm
by jpietras
We are looking into a desktop mgmt and help desk mgmt software. We are looking at Diagwin & Boss Assist along with Track-IT and Footprints.
Do you have any advice or experience with these? Please email (jpietras@spscc.edu) to me or post here.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending