Discussion Locked

When good companies go AD, spyware

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Yahoo news article states that mainstream companies like JC Penny, Capitol 1, Dell (and even Yahoo!) are using spyware that installs via browser flaws

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20050624/ap_on_hi_te/spyware_s_advertisers;_ylt=ArzpIjdH55SHTa7oLhY4LH8jtBAF;_ylu=X3oDMTBiMW04NW9mBHNlYwMlJVRPUCUl

http://www.benedelman.org
shows that google does this too!

no wonder people go on rampages! look what these companies are doing. we need laws or more enforcement as we can at least stop US companies from doing this

10 replies

by mjd420nova

I think that most ISP's have some kind of tracking software to collect urls that the user has visited. The ISP's have the power and
capabilites to stop all pop-ups and spyware, but because they are looking for more money, they let companies load anything they want as long as they pay.

by deepsand

Hosts provide the content, the net transmits it, & ISPs deliver it.

The i-net functions in a manner similar to the postal system. A Host sends a letter, various transportation companies move the letters close to their intended destination, & your ISP completes the delivery.

It is neither the responsibility nor within the capability of ISPs to police content.

Furthermore, we should not want them to do so. By way of analogy, would you want the USPS to read all of your mail, and decide what should & should not be delivered to you?

And, no, the ISPs do not to maintain a history of your online activities; they've neither the need nor the resources for such.

by desktroll

Just don't use those companies or services.

I know that they should know better but if the message gets back to them that their methods are decreasing the bottom line, not increasing it they will change tactics.

by jaqui

but that also applies to windows itself.
a collection of spyware, adware and wastefull bloat being msinamed an operating system.

operating kludge.. maybe
system...never. ;)

by deepsand

See
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11193-0.html?forumID=4&threadID=176807&messageID=1797499[/v]

by roger99a

Ignorance is no excuse. Companies need to learn that they are responsible for how their advertising dollars are spent.

by deepsand

Firstly, it important that one recognize that pop-ups/pop-unders are [b]not[/b] themselves malware; they are nothing more than temporary video images.

The fact that some malware does use them, or that many people find them annoying, does not make them malware. Furthermore, research has found their use to be on the wane, simply owing to the fact that viewers have become [b]less[/b] likely to do business with a firm advertised via such means.

More importantly, few "big name" businesses [b]knowingly[/b] engage in the use of malware, either directly or indirectly, as a means of advertising.

The marketing channels are so layered & convoluted that it is quite easy for a company to find its name/brands/products promoted via means that it itself would never have sanctioned. Unless a company engages in in-house advertising only, it has neither the knowledge nor the power to control necessary to ensure that its name never be served up through unsavory means.

by dr dij

because they (whether intentionally or not) quite literally crashed IE for me.

the xoff in particular. I could not even start IE or my computer would hard freeze.

And I think many popups send info back home so they can figuree out what ads to push. so that's spyware even if not keylogger / id theft malware

by absolutely

http://everythingisnt.com/hosts.html

Easily re-direct adware to loopback interface! Too simple to be profitable, unfortunately, but still effective. Because of the ease of blocking traffic from unwanted domains, and other issues, I oppose legislation aimed at addressing malware or adware specifically.

What would be more ethical is to prosecute under existing laws in cases where actual damage or degradation of performance occurs, using existing property protections such as fraud and vandalism laws. Negligent, reckless or callous abuse of people's computer via adware is vandalism just as sure as spray-painting my car would be. The last thing my country needs is more clumsy laws, addressing every specific possible action, instead of protecting individual rights on principle.

I haven't read all of benedelman.org's complaint with Google, but I did notice and investigate the observation that Ask Jeeves toolbar is installed with iMesh, a peer-to-peer program, and notice is only given on page 27 of an EULA or some such document. Stated as benedelman states it, this does seem sleazy. But in the context of the types of software involved, I really see no grounds for end user complaints. The Ask Jeeves toolbar is described as a "search bar", which to me is clearer application of everyday language to computerese than toolbar, and impressive, not suspicious. There is also the questionable legality of P2P software in the first place, as well as its role in getting something for essentially nothing, so even a casual user should expect some advertising to pay for this "free" service.

Children who believe in the tooth fairy should not be browsing unsupervised, and people old enough to browse unsupervised should know better than to expect something for nothing. If they are not technically knowledgeable enough to be cautious and proactive about the specific threats such behavior entails, they ought to at least be wise enough to know that they are in questionable ethical territory, and accept the risk inherent in black market activity, just like any other consumer of contraband.

Users of P2P software have no right to expect government protection from companies whose ethics are identical to the user. End users download iMesh and other P2P software for a [b]reason[/b]--which is primarily acquisition of music and video files without the burden of purchase--and end users don't need a computer science degree to understand that the makers of that software have their own bills to pay. However courts finally define theft versus free use for each specific P2P program, it is common knowledge that ownership of one computer and access to the Internet does not equal ownership of all intellectual property that can potentially be digitized and transmitted. It is a simple deduction that software that provides such access must involve some departure from traditional business, most likely involving questionable ethics. In summary, if users download software that is likely to violate others' rights to intellectual property, and their greatest complaint is that they also receive the useful Ask Jeeves toolbar, they really are getting something for nothing, and should be grateful.

by deepsand

Companies are responsible only for the acts of their agents to the extent that such agents act within the scope of their assigned authorities.

Marketers quite frequently act well outside said scope.

This discussion is closed to new replies.