Discussion Locked

Who do you think is the better boss?

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
One who leads by example or one who walks through the area and tells you to work smarter? By leads by example I mean he will ask who needs help ( this Presupposes he is good at what he is helping with) and stops to help where he can. The other is a type of boss that when he passes through a work area and see's that some one needs help. He will tell them to read up on the subject and work smarter.

39 replies

by jaqui

the one that stops to help.
imho an it department is a team effort.
this includes the boss.

by degwell

i had a boss who if he did not know how to do something always clicked around and the said yes, like that, go do it, no one can know everything and at the same time we do not need guy shoving the fact that we do not know down our throats i would think we should like to learn on our own without have thew presure to do so.
a little bit of both is what i think

by tony hopkinson

The best boss is the one who makes sure you can do your job.
Leaving someone to struggle or taking away their very desirable initiative isn't best.
I don't think there are hard and fast rules on this, it all depends on the team member and their needs at the time. In something like this sticking to one approach or the other is going to fail 50% of the time.

by hal 9000

Personally I have always lead by example but that by no means meant that I ever showed off but more like all my staff knew that I would never ask them to do something that I was not prepared to do myself.

Sure if I was asked for help I would help out but at the same time I would first take the person away sit them down over a smoke and ask what was going on, what they had done to attempt to fix it and so on. Sometimes I might have thrown in an idea and about 95% of the time that was all that was required the other 5% where the real problem jobs which when the others had racked their brains over and got no satisfactory solution dumped it on my work bench and said "FIX!" And then tell us all how and what you did to it. :(

Col

by tony hopkinson

Need to get them to rely on themselves first, then me.
Sometimes I can tell people what I did to fix a problem, when they ask me why I tried that though, I can't always say until I have had a good think and justified the hunch.
Used to drive one of my bosses wild, how do you know it's the best solution?
It works doesn't it? used to put his wig in orbit.
Intuition, useful to have, impossible to teach.

by dafe2

I agree that the role of a 'boss' is to support...

At least for me, I like the approach "don't call me I'll call you". In other words, let me do my job and if I need something you better answer the phone. LOL

My guys are given their jobs and left to do them as they see fit. If they need something or have concerns I make damn sure they (or) their issues are looked after immediately. I find that if I do things that way......they make sure our customers are looked after in the same fashion. Professionally & with respect & courtesy.

With this approach, it's very SELDOM I have to do the reverse. :-)

by tomsal

1. Knows his subject matter. (ie. if you are talking a CIO -- he knows technology well, if you are talking a Sales Executive...well he knows sales, etc.) After all how can you lead a team if you don't know anything about what your team does?

2. Communicates well. Its a bit "boring" to hear but its true...I think good leaders are good communicators. This means not only dishing out the information his/her team needs to be successful, but also having a personality that is appreciated and respected.

3. Checks the ego at the door. As its been said, there is no "I" in team. A good boss doesn't picture him/herself as someone "who commands and tells folks what to do", rather they should be "leading, helping, directing" what is done.

4. Strict, but fair. I don't think you can be overly nice and be an effective leader - this is more true the larger the group is that you are in charge of. People take advantage of the overly nice. Yet at the same time a tyrant dictator approach will work against your team, and will make many folks secretly plan your demise with a smile on their faces.

Be strict -- stand by policies, what is the "rule" is the "rule" or what is the "procedure" is the "procedure"...but be fair -- what is good for one is good for all, never play favorites.

5. Reward your performers. Reward your highest performers each month, with a comp day, a free lunch, something.

6. Have manners and treat your people with the respect we all deserve as human beings. Its a job, just because Sally is just out of school and is your only $8/hr employee doesn't mean you are above her or she doesn't deserve to be spoken to with respect.

7. Now and again...its ok to have a little humor! Why so many bosses look down on an occassional joke sharing session, or non-work related story session with their employees from time to time...totally evades my logic.

Trust me follow those guidelines well and folks will respect you and work hard for you too.

by anita.navkal

I think, In addition to rewarding, giving them recognition in the group is just as important. Personally I prefer recognition to reward and will take both. But then again would the boss be playing favorites?

by tony hopkinson

The only reward I'm interested in for being good at my job is more salary, if that's coupled with more responsibility fine. Out in front, for a pat on the head doesn't do anything for me, besides it increases the perception of brown nosing and favouritism if not the fact. If there's a 'bonus' on offer it needs to be based on hard numbers on a level playing field, otherwise it's counter-productive. Personally I'd rather see the team given a night out less frequently that the best performer once a month, cutting individuals out of the pack for special treatment does not help team building. That's leading vs managing again though.
A team is only as strong as it's weakest member, so you should put effort into improving them, not keeping your best member sweet.

by system sitter

Ever heard of Maslow's pyramid ?
Some like cash... some like credits... some simply want more works (it'll make sense if you substitute works with challenges *smile*)

The official term for this is - motivating.

by system sitter

Easier said than done isn't it ?
Why ?
Cause it's ideal.
I didn't say it's wrong.. but you know what ideal means...
And there's an assumption there you forgot to mention now isn't there ?
*wicked smile*

by tony hopkinson

Two completely different talents but often confused.
Got interviewed for a Team Leader position and was asked how I'd discipline poor performance in the team.

Told them I'd give myself a good kicking for not leading them to perform better, didn't get the job.

Now ask them to define Leader before I answer any questions.

by system sitter

When you're on the top (not when you lead... when you no longer have boss) you have the luxury of being a leader period. But everybody under don't have the luxury to be JUST manager. When you are in the 'middle' you have to be both a leader AND a manager. The former in my opinion is much much harder task than the later...

by awfernald

I used to have a boss who was extremely knowledgable in technology.

However, he didn't know and didn't care about the details, as he has several hundred people working under him to take care of that.

He was excellent at comprehending the impact of different software/systems and how we could utilize those systems to improve our business processes. Revolutionary software which other people would overlook because "well, what can it do for us?", he would look at, play with a bit, then say, "Hmmmm, this can be used for 'x' and 'y'. Why don't we put it in?"

Then he would call in one of us (the network/system admins), and say basically, "Have you ever heard of this product?"

The answer more often than not was, "No."

He would then give you a week, two weeks, a month, or even two months, depending on how long he thought it would take, to learn and implement a full fledged production quality system in a development environment.

At that time, we would "present" the system to him, and have to go through a basic interrogation of the capabilities, tech specs, requirements, etc... and most importantly, how much it would cost to provide an actual live production system, specific ways we could improve the business processes with it, and an ROI covering various scenarios.

He never taught me anything technical, however, this boss taught me how to think, and even now, I look back across the many years since I worked for him, and thank him for helping me learn how to think around the issues to get at the solution, and how to see a products possibilities as a business solution rather than a techie play toy.

by jessie

Sounds like a wonderful boss, and still sounds like one who led by example. Having "several hundred people working under him to take care of that" his example had to be somewhat more "hands-off" but still, the simple fact that you learned so much BY his example, means he was definitely leading by it.

by pjparikh

The boss has to be aware of the activities carried by his teammates and visualise the problems they will be facing and be ready with proper guidance.

by tony hopkinson

Depends on the composition of the team. I don't think I've ever had a boss who was more capable than I in all my areas of technical expertise, may be I'm just a bighead though LOL.
I'd much rather have a boss who trusts me from technical point of view and manages me from a business one. A boss who can't facilitate isn't worth the desk space they take up in my opinion. Course you've got to help them, sitting at your desk waiting for your boss to realise you have a problem, means he has a problem, you.

by system sitter

I wish all of my team members have this kinda attitude. Most of them stop at thinking they know better technically. I'm not even debating that cause most of the time it's true. It's why I hire them int he first place !
But they somehow seems to have this idea that when you know things technically you know it all. And they start justifying the compromize they make on everything including the company policy.

As a leader I respect them... as a manager unless the company change the policy, I got zero tolerance.

by tigerbright

Of the two types of bosses that you cite, I would say the the lead by example one. I haven't gotten the "work smarter" ones for very long because I've "trained" my bosses to realize that I do work smarter. One way is to send (and keep sending him) e-mails with hyperlinks on the latest hot topics (some hot topics are his, some are mine) from TechRepublic, Gartner, and other experts along with suggestions on reading the article. Worker smarter? "Oh, you're right. By the way, did you read that article I sent you last week on wireless lockdown ?" Do that enough and you put the burden of proof on him to work smarter. That's one strategy. I'm sure others have their favorites...

by tony hopkinson

You have to break them in gently. My usual tack with a bad boss, is if you can't help me do my job, f'off and stop hindering me then. Only works in certain areas though, south of england you have to be a bit more tactful.
Probably why most of my work has been in the North.

by system sitter

"... if you can't help me do my job..."
There's no I in a team means no "my" or "mine" either...

To me, when team member starts to define what is and is not his job, is a sign of problem. That's why we have meetings. If a team member decide to do something out of what the meeting has decided he better has a great reason or I will "communicate" with him.

by house

1) leads by example
2) is open to positive and negative views
3) consults with those underneath him on various issues
4) humbles himself, yet retains the image of authority - a difficult task indeed
5) holds weekly meetings in order to keep everyone in-tune with the corporate flow

by joe.canuck

Ine of the hardest things for a boss to do is let their employees fail. As a Parent I know this feeling. My children often struggle with things I can do for them readily, but it is by struggling that they learn and grow. Most Managers have been there, done that. But they left the techy stuff behind to focus on strategy and budgets. Most people learn though experience so it's best if the boss offer direction but leave it to the tech to research and implement.

by house

Give those underneath you tasks that will promote their self regard.

Quote the Sopranos - "Sometimes, it is better to give them the illusion that they are in control"

Chris

by rnmpleasant

First, let me say that I once was a programmer who changed his direction to focus on leadership and management. While I still enjoy the technical problem solving aspects, I became burnt out on coding so I shifted my focus.
A good manager will know that his success is the result of productive employees which results from job satisfaction, which results from recognition (public/private verbal, written and award types), rewards (bonus/pay raise money, and comp time or prizes), opportunities (for advancement or in building other/new skills), challenges (creating variety instead of a daily grind) and stability (knowing a mistake can be forgiven, information about where we are and are going is easily available, our jobs will be here tomorrow, there is a place and manner for me to voice my opinions without retaliations) . Many companies can not offer all of these options and many employees do not respond to all of these either. So the challenge is to create fairness and satisfaction in an environment where typically the employees are brilliant, self assured and outspoken and always have opinions about how a manager should do their job (not to mention that the IT/IS organization is also the most ethnically/racially/sexually diverse work force in most US based companies which further increases the challenge since employee expectations also show that diversity). If you think about it, most other business organizations are not made up of people like that which probably explains why I have noticed non technical back grounded managers in IT/IS are not usually that successful. One other challenge to being a good IT/IS manager is that most companies offer little or nothing to the IT/IS manager ?newby? on how to be successful or how to be a good leader. The choices that are being discussed here are not always good either. Since the manager is managing, it is not usually a good thing to have him get into the nitty gritty since he will probably make it worse. How many of us have developed a policy with certain managers that we always tell them everything is fine instead of sharing any actual problems for fear that he may offer to ?help? us make it better. The ?work smarter? approach is not good because it assumes the employee is working stupidly now and if they only stopped being a dumb a@@ then the job would be done. Not a very motivational approach.
In the end, the best boss is one who you believe in and can trust and one who is doing the ?right things? for you as best he can. One who knows your value and isn?t afraid to recognize it publicly. One who is approachable when you have questions or concerns. One who takes time to understand your perspective and to share his with you. One who will allow you to disagree without fear, in fact one who will encourage you to do so if you are not in full agreement. One who shows respect for all his team members and insists that others do as well.

by system sitter

As the boss you do not only may reward people for their accomplishment (this should kill the favourite thing) you MUST.

But again... this is no longer depend to the boss alone... this is how the team member look at themselves and their team mates.

Can or can they not acknowledge their peers ?
Do they see it as insult or challenge ?

Strangely to my experience the idea to give rewards often come from the members...

by system sitter

The question of which is a better boss is a flaw.
I've seen great leaders fail simply cause they have 'wrong' members.

Granted it is the job of a leader to motivate the 'wrong' member to be productive and etcetera...etcetera ... but in the end... the decision to be productive is not his to make. The members must decide are they going to be productive in a "proper way (I know this could spawn another thread of discussion but it is overlooked far too often)" or not.

And yessss... of course it works the other way around too bad boss makes the entire dedicated and talented group look like idiots... that's my whole point.

The minimum prerequisite for a good team is a decent boss and decent team members.
I uh...
I think ?

by maxwell edison

.
In my opinion, a good boss has the ability to recognize good people in the first place, and will give those people tasks that might always be slightly above their ability to achieve with their current level of expertise, and then get out of their way and let them achieve. A good boss will provide an atmosphere that allows good people to either succeed or fail on their own, will publicly recognize those achievements, and not always consider failure something bad, but rather an opportunity to learn from one's mistakes.

A good boss will always have an open-door policy and be available to provide help if necessary and/or if asked, but will not micro-manage someone every step of the way (or any step of the way). A good boss will always praise someone publicly, but reprimand and/or correct people privately. A good boss will always be aware of how someone is progressing, generally speaking, but without giving the impression that they are constantly being watched. A good boss will recognize when someone is struggling, and then offer help without being critical or condescending.

A good boss will delegate responsibilities to others, including decision making responsibilities, not necessarily having to make the final decision on each and every little thing himself. A good boss will recognize those who might know more in certain areas than he does; so a good boss is not afraid to hire people smarter than he is. A good boss knows how to identify individual strengths, and collectively build on those strengths for the overall benefit of the whole. A good boss will make people feel as though they are a vital component of the whole, not as someone who is "lucky to have a job". A good boss never talks down to a person, but rather with deserved consideration.

A good boss is steadfast in the convictions and direction of the department/company, not giving "mixed signals" that cause confusion, uncertainty, and inconsistency. A good boss will always give credit to others for the achievements and successes of the department/company, not taking the credit himself, but will generally accept the blame for the failures, at least publicly. A good boss will trust good people to do good things, and will always give the benefit of the doubt instead of suspicion. A good boss will recognize that people have lives outside of work, and will consider those lives more important than work.

There ya' go.

by dc_guy

This thread has suffered the fate of so many good threads. There are already so many postings, the first time I encountered it, that I can't read them all. But I'll add my ideas and hope that I'm not duplicating too much of what's already been said.

A good boss knows which skill is going to work in a given situation and uses it. There are plenty of people who are motivated by being told to "work smarter," it validates their instinct to find their own "dao" through an assignment. But there are plenty who would rather have a guide than find their own path. A good boss knows which is which.

But as for being able to help, that is simply not always possible. I once had people working for me who supported the OS software on three different brands of mainframes. I was a former expert on one of them, but I knew nothing about the other two. Probably no one in the world had experience on all three.

I would say it's mandatory that a good boss can manage work that they couldn't personally perform. Now that's not the same as being ignorant about it!

by anshul.pal

Quite often we say that boss is not good. But it highly depends on his expertise, If he is expert in mission critical applications and you ask him to lead a team for a maintenance stuff, he definitely will not be able to do so. So While rating our BOSS we should keep in mind these facts :
1. Is he properly utilised according to his expertise.
2. Does he possess the right people to work with him.
3. How much experience does he have.

If the people around him are experts in embbedded systems and they are there for maintenance stuff then nobody can help.

So we should take care of many things before arriving on a conclusion regarding our BOSS.

Hope to get responses on this soon.

by zentross

Leading by example is not the same as jumping in and assisting however. The better leaders that I've delt with had differing responsibilities bet consistently demonstrated these traits and their importance :

Committment to the task at hand
Understanding of hindering factors
Did not apply double-standards (e.g. tardiness is not acceptable in subordinates while their 2 hour lunch is completely legit)

The ability to coach and boost staff moral is by far the most important to me. Seeing what needs to be done and makinig sure that the needed tools and skills are available creates a much more productive and satisfying environment instead of breading a nest of back stabbers.

by angry_white_male

I'm a self-taught person with very little formal training and not a single certification. If you don't know the answer - sit down and figure it out (Google can be your best friend). You can show someone how to make something work til you're blue in the face, but if they don't actually do it themselves (in a test environment of course!), they won't learn a thing. By and large, IT is a problem solving environment that requires a level of analytical skill and the ability to think on one's feet.

On the other hand, if you find you have a lot of people who are always in need of help or remedial training - then you need to rethink your hiring process and make sure you're bringing qualified people on board rather than being a glorified vocational training school.

by pr0x1

In reading all the posts, some answer your question, others give you a better way to look at it. And while both are good, here is the skinny:

To answer your question, I place no value (or respect) in someone who tells me to work smarter and to learn the job at hand if they don't know how to do it themselves or cannot explain why. It makes me question why they got the job in the first place, and throws a yellow flag to not only how the manager got the position, but how the company is being run (I won't say more). A manager who leads by example proves he has "been there, done that..."

HOWEVER, there is much more to being a manager than these two traits... MUCH more. And without re-hashing what all the other respondants have stated to this fact, I suggest either reading all the responses, or asking another question: What makes a good manager (and be specific to your industry, role, title, skill, responsibilities, etc.).

Good luck!

by tony hopkinson

A lot of managers seem to confuse leadership and management as though they were one and the same thing. You can be a good one of either without being good at the other. Those with both of course tend to do quite well. You can only lead someone to follow their own best interest and that's been known to conflict with management on more than one occasion.

by cdmushakwe

Hey Zlitocook

I think both bosses are good in their own way. The 1st leads by example because he intimately knows the work he is leading. But bosses are not expected to know everything in detail. The 2nd boss has no detailed knowledge of particular areas under his responsibility but instead of blaming his team, he encourages them to read further or maybe he may send you for training.

This discussion is closed to new replies.