Discussion Locked

Why antispam laws may make things worse

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Do you agree with Jonathan Yarden that antispam laws will be mostly ineffective? What do you think is the best method to stop junk e-mail? Share your comments about the potential of antispam laws, as discussed in the Nov. 10 Internet Security Focus e-newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Internet Security Focus e-newsletter, sign up today!
http://nl.com.com/acct_mgmt.jsp?brand=techrepublic

36 replies

by maxwell edison

Why does Jonathan Yarden think that antispam laws will be mostly ineffective?

Why do you assume that everyone receives that particular e-newsletter?

Why don't you post a link to the article?

Why do you keep doing this even though numerous people have requested that you include a link?

Why don't you EVER address this question?

Why doesn't debate@techrepublic ever answer my emails suggesting they include links to the articles referred to in these discussions?

Why do I even care?

by debate

These articles are in the Internet Security Focus e-newsletter only, so it is not possible to post a link to the article. We do not assume every TechRepublic member receives this e-newsletter; this discussion post is merely a means to give subscribers of this e-newsletter a chance to weigh in with their opinion and discuss the topic with other members.

by mrbill-

If we chose not to receive the newsletter how are we supposed to know what is being discussed. A link would just even the playing field a little. More folks would be able to knowledgably participate, making it a better discussion.

by maxwell edison

It is too bad there's no way to access the article. Some of these discussion topics are interesting enough to make someone (me and/or others) want to participate, but without knowing the exact points being made, any comments may be way off on their own tangent.

How about a suggestion: Start the discussion as you usually do, and then post a first reply as a cut and paste of the newsletter article?

THanks.

by gerra

I had a discussion just the other day where-in a friend was asking if legislation could stop this spate of junk E-Mails. I suggested the same set of arguments that Mr. Yarden has brought forth.

I suggested to him that the only answer for him personally was to get an effective Spam Filter for his computer, and sign up with an ISP who will take a proactive role in the filtering and elimination of Junk E-Mails.

While I am certain that I would not agree with everything Mr. Yarden states every week, I am certainly behind his statements today. Legislation could make things a lot worse than they are already.

by gerra

I had a discussion just the other day where-in a friend was asking if legislation could stop this spate of junk E-Mails. I suggested the same set of arguments that Mr. Yarden has brought forth.

I suggested to him that the only answer for him personally was to get an effective Spam Filter for his computer, and sign up with an ISP who will take a proactive role in the filtering and elimination of Junk E-Mails.

While I am certain that I would not agree with everything Mr. Yarden states every week, I am certainly behind his statements today. Legislation could make things a lot worse than they are already.

by steve.thornburg

I agree with Jonathan that anti-spam laws will be mostly ineffective.
Current planned anti-spam legislation is not based in reality. Of course, that is so often true with various "control" laws here in America.
The worst idea I've heard regarding anti-spam legislation is the "do not email" list. Every spammer is salivating at the very thought of it.
Anti-spam legislation, of all I've read about so far, seems to me to be very much akin to gun laws and drug laws. Neither of those areas are affected much by legislation, because only law-abiding people will follow the laws. And let's face it; it is NOT the law abiding people who are spamming. Most spam is fraud, has forged headers, and a huge percentage of it eminates from servers in countries where it is legal. Those countries will not do anything to help curb the problem.
I believe we need "smart" firmware that will weed out messages with forged data.
Soon, the government here in America will start taxing connection usage. Before many years pass, there will be layers of taxation that will impact all legitimate users - both corporate and personal - while leaving spammers untouched. It makes me angry that I will have to pay a tax on the bandwidth I use to manage spam. But unless a very large number of people apply political pressure in conjunction with financial stipends, our illustrious legislators will never get it right. They see only another cash cow here, and could not care less about the impact of spam.
One possible start would be to obtain and publicly post the email address of all members of congress and the senate, and have people make an effort to place those addresses in newsgroups for spammers to harvest. Maybe the ensuing flood will motivate them to seek advice from people close to the battle.

by camjes

Start charging users for anything over x amount of emails per day sent, ( just like fax, sms or paper mail) and the drones will be forced to be patched, and the problem disappears or at least shrinks markedly almost overnight.
There will still be some advertisers prepared to pay, just like in your conventional mail box.

Yes the myriad internet access plans available get more complex and yes, cost more.
I for one would be happy to pay another couple of dollars/month for the problem to go away, but hey I only send 10-15 per day, and receive about 5 times that in spam. Many ISPs are now offering spam filters as an add on cost, so whats the difference.

And yes it means that newsletters such as Tech republic will probably no longer be able to be free.
Unless perhaps "subscribers" log into a site and download the newsletter content. Seems less hassle than scrolling through the spam in my spam filter every day just to check if there are any legitimate emails in there.

by peteg

Jonathan,

I agree with you that they won't work mainly because most of the spammers aqre located outside the US where there ARE NO antispam laws. Right now about 98% of my email is spam and my antispam program blocks about 95% of THAT. My biggest gripe about spam is that WE have to pay money for software to block this crap! Also, I believe that the ISPs and Network providers should be the first line of defense. I think mail from KNOWN spammers should be blocked by them using the routers themselves. Then the US government should require fines for ISPs that DON'T block spam, especially if someone complains to them. Unfortunately there is too much money at stake.
Also, why can't the government use the existing drug and electronics laws to block the advertising of online pharmaceuticals and cable tv decoders?? I'll tell you why, because spammers are too low a priority!

by rjw1

Agree. Anti Spam laws should be targeted toward ISPs who are to blame for all the junk that goes through their services without enforcing users comply with the service contracts.

If you mail abuse@att.com most likely nobody is on the other side

by oz_media

Offshore ISP accounts will work around the ISP resposibility. In some country's there are NO restrictions regarding mail or sales delivery.
If a user wa to use this ISP for sending SPAM, you cannot really hold the ISP accountable if they haven't broken any laws.
Even if the SPAM into a given country is banned, the SPAMMER can just claim ignorance as an internet address (.com.org or W.H.Y.) could be anywhere in the world.

This would only cause negative financial impacts on the foreign countries that do not have restricting laws and would impact their economy, just because they are breaking OUR laws, doesn't mean they are breaking THAT country's laws. World war III?

If you have a decent set of well balanced Anti Spam tools that have multiple evaluation methods for each form of mail, it isn't a problem, as I've recently discovered.

You just need a better lock on the door than the piece of wool you are using now.

by rick

Your article is right on target. Hold the ISP's financially responsible for each piece of junk email. Spam and Porn (SPORN)? does no one any good with any shread of morality. Direct Marketing has absoultely no right to push there media upon people whom don't want it. Opt-out bogus promises to remove an email address never will work.

The end solution is to twart the SPORN at the source. The ISP's have the power to shut off the spiggot of anyone they choose. The trick is to make it more of a financial gain - or savings - for them. After all in an immoral society where evil cries and hides under the twisted 1st ammendment rights one must realize that evil thrives on the green back.

by drmemory

The only practical enforcement vehicle available is through DNS. If you take away the reply channel, you take away the economic incentive. Policing the send side of the equation is intellectually competitive and not sufficiently expensive to be a deterrent. This shifts the whole effort to policing ISPs and not users, substantially narrowing the span of control required as well as creating a powerful economic incentive.

by getsteppin

The only real concern my ISP has is to unplugg ports to coral national virus disasters...there by shutting down the RPC..thus killing my auto updates from Syamnatech. The spam issue has to rest with them, too. As the end users can use CFS and scrubbers..i.e Benign and MailWasherPro to be reported into a data reporting pool, thus circumventing spam before it gets to your desk top, after viewed on the server...or let the data base sort it out for you and delete..Novel idea...plus it works like a champ..my spa it as does "FirstAlert"..new version of MailWasherPro by FireTrust.My spam has gone from 50% to 1%..the data base is catching up. Benign (.b9) handles the wacky domain and HTML embeds and endcoded changes then re-encodes...and MailWasherPro deletes..not bounce..BUT deletes..
So, ya, for the forseeable future, I have no compalints...unless the MS geeks turn the tables and turn my XP Home version into DOS only..then I would be in a world of hurt. The ISP's tho, have got to be the front line..why dont they plugg into the data bases of "known Spam"? Prehaps the ISP's would want a monthly "cleaning" bill attached to our internet bill, then, too...? Hmmmm!!! As a Tax..or Usage fee.../ I garontee if they could,,they would.

by chuckr314159

Until all the spam-dimonium, I never thought I'd argue for adding a tax or cost to email, but I agree that it is the only solution, along with some kind of technology that tightens up how you send email.

First, I'd like to see some kind of "digital certificate" type setup where email can only be sent from an identifiable source. Nobody should be able to send email that looks like it comes from me, unless it is me.

Then, I suggest that *all* sent email have a nominal fee charged to the identifiable source. Use that money to manage this whole affair. If anything is left, apply credits to those who receive each email so that those who send few and receive many get a net gain for their troubles.

This would seem like a business opportunity for some major internet provider, or technology company, or perhaps a Verisign, to build such a "closed, secure" email environment that individuals and corporations opt-in to. As an individual, you announce to the world that you will only accept and send email through this "secure" environment. I would think then that it would then be easy to somehow filter out all email that doesn't route through the "security checkpoint".

Spam and viruses are gradually making email worthless. I think that something like this could work to save it, while still allowing reasonable e-commerce thru email.

Chuck

by jimhm

These's laws will only be for American or some European countries. Others will still spill out the spam.

If someone could come up with a software to control 90% of SPAM they would be worth billions. Even selling it at $10 a copy.

by oz_media

"If someone could come up with a software to control 90% of SPAM"
They did but it's not $10 it's $3200.00

The two heaviest days for my spam are Sat and Sun. This weekend I received NONE. ZIP, Nil, nada, squat. Big buck but well worth it.

See: "Complete waste of time and money" below

by oz_media

LEARN WHY ANTISPAM LAWS MAY MAKE THINGS WORSE

Anyone who's worked with the Internet for more than 10 years may recall
a time, perhaps with some nostalgia, when junk e-mail didn't exist. But
as the Internet's popularity grew, the de facto rules of conduct went
out
the window.

Almost 10 years ago, the infamous "Green Card" message that made the
rounds on Usenet was the first shot in a battle that continues today.
Worldwide outrage over this incident didn't deter others from taking the
same
approach.

These days, by some counts, junk e-mail accounts for more than half of
all e-mail. In my opinion, the number is horribly low for some people;
about 92 percent of my current e-mail is junk.

How do junk e-mailers obtain your e-mail address? In my case, one reason

is that I was an early, frequent user of Usenet newsgroups, a resource
that existed long before the now ubiquitous World Wide Web.

It also didn't help that a rogue subscriber to the ISP I used in 1992
downloaded the list of users from a poorly secured system. Once you end
up
on one of those "30 million e-mail addresses on CD-ROM" deals, you might

as well just change your e-mail address.

Junk e-mail comes from thousands of different locations, with thousands
of different subjects, but it usually focuses on a topic of sex, money,
drugs, or a combination. But since many of these offers are illegal in
their own right, how can laws prohibiting junk e-mail really have any
effect?

The net effect of more legislation instead of direct action is that junk

e-mailers will devise even more desperate methods or move to areas that
don't have antispam laws. Principal junk e-mailers are already primarily

offshore, using leagues of hijacked broadband computers all over the
world to send their unwanted e-mail. So antispam laws will likely leave
them
unaffected.

In addition, there's the so-called "legitimate" e-mail marketing issue,
which is already creeping into legislation. Direct marketing lobbyists
in
Washington are keeping a close eye on the "anti-junk" legislation.
Campaign donations and swanky parties have a way of changing
legislation, even
if the public is behind it.

Do we really need federal antispam legislation? Technically, it makes no

difference if we do because it won't stop the flood of junk e-mail. A
number of state antispam laws already exist, but they're grossly
ineffective. In addition, many have specific provisions to allow legal
advertisements.

Have these state laws made any headway with stopping spam? Not
really--in fact, the opposite is occurring. Legislation has no bearing
on the
hundreds of thousands of "spam drones" on broadband networks, regardless
of
the state.

What will make a difference? Broadband ISPs can start by shutting off
cable modems for spam drones that their customers refuse to secure and
enforcing acceptable use policies.

I've personally reported thousands of spam drones, yet companies such as

Charter, AT&T, and Road Runner have taken little if any action. They
just don't care.

Make a law that requires ISPs to care, and then you'll have a real
solution. The few companies and individuals running relay block lists
(RBLs),
which are actually quite effective in stopping junk e-mail, are the ones

at the front lines of the spam war. But these companies are constantly
under attack from both the junk e-mailers and people who haven't
properly
secured their e-mail systems.

Jonathan Yarden is the senior UNIX system administrator, network
security manager, and senior software architect for a regional ISP.

by mrbill-

I appreciate your help man. I don't receive all the emails from TR so when a topic comes up on one of them I feel left out. I'll stop whinning now. Thanx again.

by oz_media

This is very typical of someone who has only faced this issue with a Microsoft server.

With Novell's GroupWise it will by default ACCEPT relayed mail but will not actually process the relay command and propogate the email. It is a simple feature to close or patch but it is this way by default for tracking purposes so many admins don't know until too late. The server recieves and accepts the email, the sender reports it to an RBL, the RBL starts blocking mail from your server. THe worst pat is that Npvell's GroupWise is usually generally used in large organizations or those with high security needs.

As an MCNE I have run into at least 5 cases where a business has been literally shut down due to improperly reported RBL's. These guys have a nice idea but getting action to be removed from the main lists is timely (up to a week) and costly.

In MY experience RBl's are poorly managed, unprofessionally operated and are have a terrible record of acting upon a false positive.

Good concept, poorly implemented.

by oz_media

To bring legislature into Anti Spam is overkill. Spammers chuckle at the idea and await the fun of rerouting and burying origins in order to cross a new stepping stone. It will probably even give the first few some bragging rights.

SPAM cannot really be controlled by the ISP either other than ensuring it's users have properly patched and shutdown relays.

I have just done about 6 weeks research into different forms of SPAM protection/RBL's/Heuristics etc. and have found MANY products available for the servers I manage with pricing from FREE to $4000.00.

Unfortunately the software I chose in the end was only just shy of top dollar at $3200.00 for a single server and upto 200 users.

The protection I chose (GroupWsie Guardian), is excellent at filtering with an almost undetectable number of false positives. It uses a fier and forget updating system, heuristic, RBL, adress blocking at the MTA, the Web Access portal as well as internally.

My email this weekend has dropped from over 450/day to 65/day (which were all relevant by the way). After checking the filtered mail, not a SINGLE false positive was identified.

I tried many others that offered similar results but each had a weakness that I couldn't live with.

a)End user filtering based on address - Useless these days, becuae it requires user intervention and addresses are always changed

b) No scanning on the MTA, only at the desktop level - servers are still bogged with junk and/or a virus

c) No heuristic scanning - Clever message titles will work around key-word blocks.

d) RBL scanning - on it's own will generate too many false positives

e) No web mail scanning - users still open themselves up to SPAm and viruses when checking webmail.

All of the above and more are covered in my software now, it is nice to not spend 30 minutes/day sorting and filtering mail!

You get what you pay for, I guess.

by rabbit_runner

From the above threads, I tend to see 4 possible things that can be done.
1. Legal - Enact new laws (seems that all aggree that this will not work)
2. Have the ISPs create some spam filter at their end before e-mails are received by the user.
3. User should obtain spam filtering software.
4. Charge for each email being sent.
There are various flavors of these four. But I would like to make an observation.
In all of these possibilites, the ultimate cost will be put upon the end user. If #2 is used, the costs incured by the ISP will be passed along to their subscribers.
If #2 is used, we will be forced to spend our own money to protect ourselves.
If #4 is used, well this is a 'pay-per-use' cost.
In all, the ultimate cost will be us, individuals and corporations. This problem will not go away, until we, the user, are so fed up with the hassle of SPAM or SPORN, that we are willing to fork over the cash to end the abuse in our email.

In all of the answers above, and probably below, there are different ways that the solutions can be implemented. But even then, we will have to be the ones to clear up this problem. At least for our small portion of the internet. The part that we use and are protecting.

What ever happens, I will be expected to pay to stop the SPAM and email abuse.

by alfy451

They need to issue some special code that only allows those co's approved, and kills those that decide to go roag. When you hit these clowns in their pocket book, is when all will play fair.

by oz_media

SPAMMING like telemarketing is tstrictly a numbers game. Those who play it well and with some skill (yes, skill)will make a LOT of money. Many are simly nutbags that try to make some dough but fail, these are the come and gone SPAMs that many SPAM protection systems will block, however needlessly.

EG: I send 50, 000 emails for a 10 toy I'm trying to market.
30,000 are deleted or blocked.
20,000 are opened, either intentionally or by the Outlook preview pane not being disabled.
Even if 5% are responded to (not a big number in marketnig standards), that's 1000 responses.
If 5% of those responses (again NOT an unreasonable response rate). That's 50 sales at $10.00 = $500.

$500.00 is chump change, but when you reverse tha math. $500.00 X 30 DAYS/Mo = $15,000.00/mo

Now these figures are just a rough example yet they are NOT by any means unrealistic.

And you think that hiting them in the pocket book will resolve this? It just means they ahave to send twice as many emails now.

As for approving or disproving SPAM by the company, that is not going to be effective when people use alias to/from addresses. It will result in MANY false positives resulting in MANY lost accounts for the ISP.

I have received SPAM from myself as a result of WEB crawlers that search for email addresses on websites. If I was approved as a Company and this person used my address to send mail, the ISP would disconnect ME and I in turn would lose THEM.

This is a multi-billion dollar enterprise tha has swept the globe with no abandon. If you can't stop the SPAMMERS, you CAN get decent SPAM protection, for the right price of course (probably a VERY high one too, as I've found out).

by pgm554

This amendment allows you to go after the manufacturer of that product.
If some idiot keeps on sending spam for a radio controlled car toy(remember that one?).
Guess what?The government can go after the company for fines and criminal prosecution.
It will make them think twice about spamming.

I like that boy's way of thinking.

by brianc861

If you are tired of spam , the best thing you could do is this , change your email address ie bob@spam , usser code 123 123 change everything you will not get spam as long as you don't subscribe to all the new subscriptions , don't give out any info , Most of all get a Firewall that works , with yous sys, and Most important run a good antivirus software progrem

by oz_media

But blocking SPAM from a residential account is easy, as you've noted.
This won't work with a 250 seat organization. The biggest issue with SPAM I feel is the cost to large companies. THese are business mail servers that are being hemmaered due to a lack of worthwhile SPAM protection products for servers that actually work and trap mail BEFORE it is processed by the Email server.

by 94yearoldpro

I?m going to keep it simple...

Don't make SPAM a legal problem. Make the ISPs morally (and financially) responsible.

The users can change ISPs which will hurt the ISP in the pocket. On top of that, I can only imagine that this much SPAM must require extra hardware costs and the associated costs in usage and administration. The ISPs should be happy with less SPAM.

1) The big ISPs disconnect hijacked broadband machines.
2) They adopt a boycott policy on ISPs that don?t also implement similar restrictions.
3) They make use of RBLs and other anti-SPAM techniques.

The bottom line is that we keep the internet free while squashing this worldwide problem. The flood would soon become a trickle. At that point, who is going to financially back a system that can?t reach the masses anymore?

by oz_media

What about the countries whee SPAM is a completely legal advertising medium?
1) Why should these ISP's be shut down for not breaking their country's laws?
2)
a)) Will this not impact some country's economy?
b)) Is this not a form of repression on another coubtry's freedom of communication?
c)) What would happen if SPAM was legal in America and France wanted to fine and shut down Amwerican ISP's for not adhereing to French laws?

3)SPAM can originate from the USA but use offseas servers for transmission. How and WHO should be shut down?

4) RBL lists are inaccurate and poorly managed at best, how will they benefit us if there are so many false positives already from RBL lists?

5) How is an ISP to determine if someone is breakinh US laws or sending SPAM to a user in Germany if they use common URL's such as .com or .org?

Any screening used would degrade internet mail performance and unjustly slow down developers software.

Really, I think if it was THAT easy, it would've been done. What's wrong with investing in EFFECTIVE Spam protection and stopping it before you see it?

by jimhm

In the same vain - should there than also be laws fo r the US and other mail delivery systems "morally (and financially) responsible". As well for delivery of all that paper junk mail that comes to my door.

You will never get the world community to accept laws for anti-spam... Hell you can't get the world internet community to have a common law on CHILD PORN - if you can't stop something as nasty as Kiddy Porn world wide - do you really think that Anti-Spam laws will be written and enforced...

It just will not happen, do you want to pay $60 a month to access the internet - because of the software and fines that an ISP would have to cover ? How about your employer (they are considered an ISP if they give you Internet Email)? Where does the Liberal ideals end - Laws will not change what is occuring with Spam mail - anti-spam filters will have to be developed just as Anti-Viruse and Pop-Up blocking ...

by davidnix71

Spammers are mostly criminals to begin with, so why should they care if it's "illegal?" My ISP's (BellSouth) spam filter works well and so does MSN's Hotmail if you use it correctly. The only thing that will actually stop spam is a change in e-mail protocol(such as requiring a "white list" on every e-mail account) or taxing the senders upfront before accepting the message.

by server-natzi

In my opinion there is going to have to be a change in email routing for this to come to an end. There is always going to be issues that will be technically challenging. For instance the SMTP email gateway can be dropped in over the internet on almost any network and allow for email spam to flood the net. In saying that, we have the answer to the problem. Email systems shouldn't be as easy to create and activate as real time email systems should. The process requires change with Tier 1 ISP's along with some Federal Management adoption that would police the email community.
This may seem heavy handed but if you are going to stop the abuse you have to set higher standards.
Point in case: I can register a domain name, get a third part hosting service to create a DNS zone and create a mail record(mx)and within 72 hours I can have a real world Email system tossing email anywhere. I can also use dynamic services from Cable vendors or any DSL provider to obtain an IP address that will be used for this email system then disappear at my own discretion when I feel it necessary.
If you ask me, this is the root of the problem. The email systems today do not have enough history or legitimate existence. There needs to be a means of registering what I would call an International Secure Email Delivery System (ISEDS). If you tighten up the policies that allow for email delivery then you have just threatened the vehicle in which the current problem exists. In the long term, this maybe the future to which secure communications could now be considered for legitimate businesses that are hesitant in using email for this that comes at a current cost for securing. In a nut shell, the design requires change, or we except what we have and leave the Internet as it was created. Free Space.

by pgm554

I caught an NPR discussion on the new spam
legislation in San Francisco a few weeks ago.

A few of the problems were related to state laws
and their inability to cross state borders.
Washington state and Ca have some nice spam bills, but unless the spammers are coming from the same state and you claim residency in that same state, the laws are ineffective.

Florida has very lax laws on spam and one of the
commentators said that if they got rid of Boca
Raton, a great deal of the spam would go away(about 40 of the top 200 reside there).
According to the Gardian,these 200 are resonsible for about 90% of the spam in the US and Europe.

These folks referred to them as "chicken and
biscuit" spammers. Low rent, living in trailer park types.Maybe jail for these folks would be a step up?

Look,for the most part,you need a brick and morter shop to sell product.Going after the manufactuers of the products is a good idea.
They want to sell there products legitamatly,go to a registered and above board marketing company.
Otherwise ,see you in court.

by oz_media

There is a long white paper on Stopping AntiSpam and what legal actions you can take(I'll try to find you a link another time) and legality in different states.
eg:
If your computer is connected to a printer, your computer is considered a fax machine. In which case spam is breaking fax laws. Too much money for most people to persue action.

Now you're saying that people would take a LOT of time and spend a large amount of money to try and sue an overseas manufacturer of some 50,000+ different toys and an annual revenue of over 420 mil.
...and this is opposed to simply spending a few bucks for a worthwhile SPAM detection system?

I don't think so. It's a nice idea but not realistic.

by bis

Youo may be right in the long haul but I'm still rooting for the spam laws. Many of these business that spam sell a product or service that require a point of contact which means there's a possibility of tracing them. I'd give my left nut to be able to prosecute just one of these jerks.

This discussion is closed to new replies.