LEARN WHY ANTISPAM LAWS MAY MAKE THINGS WORSE
Anyone who's worked with the Internet for more than 10 years may recall
a time, perhaps with some nostalgia, when junk e-mail didn't exist. But
as the Internet's popularity grew, the de facto rules of conduct went
out
the window.
Almost 10 years ago, the infamous "Green Card" message that made the
rounds on Usenet was the first shot in a battle that continues today.
Worldwide outrage over this incident didn't deter others from taking the
same
approach.
These days, by some counts, junk e-mail accounts for more than half of
all e-mail. In my opinion, the number is horribly low for some people;
about 92 percent of my current e-mail is junk.
How do junk e-mailers obtain your e-mail address? In my case, one reason
is that I was an early, frequent user of Usenet newsgroups, a resource
that existed long before the now ubiquitous World Wide Web.
It also didn't help that a rogue subscriber to the ISP I used in 1992
downloaded the list of users from a poorly secured system. Once you end
up
on one of those "30 million e-mail addresses on CD-ROM" deals, you might
as well just change your e-mail address.
Junk e-mail comes from thousands of different locations, with thousands
of different subjects, but it usually focuses on a topic of sex, money,
drugs, or a combination. But since many of these offers are illegal in
their own right, how can laws prohibiting junk e-mail really have any
effect?
The net effect of more legislation instead of direct action is that junk
e-mailers will devise even more desperate methods or move to areas that
don't have antispam laws. Principal junk e-mailers are already primarily
offshore, using leagues of hijacked broadband computers all over the
world to send their unwanted e-mail. So antispam laws will likely leave
them
unaffected.
In addition, there's the so-called "legitimate" e-mail marketing issue,
which is already creeping into legislation. Direct marketing lobbyists
in
Washington are keeping a close eye on the "anti-junk" legislation.
Campaign donations and swanky parties have a way of changing
legislation, even
if the public is behind it.
Do we really need federal antispam legislation? Technically, it makes no
difference if we do because it won't stop the flood of junk e-mail. A
number of state antispam laws already exist, but they're grossly
ineffective. In addition, many have specific provisions to allow legal
advertisements.
Have these state laws made any headway with stopping spam? Not
really--in fact, the opposite is occurring. Legislation has no bearing
on the
hundreds of thousands of "spam drones" on broadband networks, regardless
of
the state.
What will make a difference? Broadband ISPs can start by shutting off
cable modems for spam drones that their customers refuse to secure and
enforcing acceptable use policies.
I've personally reported thousands of spam drones, yet companies such as
Charter, AT&T, and Road Runner have taken little if any action. They
just don't care.
Make a law that requires ISPs to care, and then you'll have a real
solution. The few companies and individuals running relay block lists
(RBLs),
which are actually quite effective in stopping junk e-mail, are the ones
at the front lines of the spam war. But these companies are constantly
under attack from both the junk e-mailers and people who haven't
properly
secured their e-mail systems.
Jonathan Yarden is the senior UNIX system administrator, network
security manager, and senior software architect for a regional ISP.