Discussion Locked

Wikipedia in a Death Spiral?

0 helpful
29 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This fellow seems to think wikipedia is doomed by its core open-access architecture, that it will fall prey to marketers / spammers like the Open Directory Project.

http://informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=196601766

I think Apotheon works there, anyone else have any opinions how this can be avoided? It must be a worthwhile site if Iran has now banned it. I have noticed on my occasional references to it that articles have been restored and locked to prevent vandalism.

29 replies

by oz_media

Email has been in a downward spiral for many years now. It is abused and misused to the point that people get very frustrated with it, BUT, they still use it and rely on it every day.

Wikipedia is one of the best online tools and global projects ever created. A true collaboration of global information from around the globe, not just a singular viewpoint.

If many people get too frustrated by questionable content and spam, then it will no longer be a place for these attackers to prey sucessfully, thus it will return to being a small open source project.

by fractalzoom

Sorry to sound the cynic here, but I don't agree that after Wikipedia collapses it will be "safe" from spammers - it's a naive assertion that doesn't reflect the way these things work in the real world. It's not the nature of malware or spam for threats to go away after they've peaked. And with its existing architecture, Wikipedia will *always* be vulnerable to abuse once its vulnerabilities are known. The "Big Kids" of the spam world may move on to other targets newer and more enticing, but the "Little Kids" will continue to push Wikipedia around.

by apotheon

I quit my job with the Wikimedia Foundation in August 2005 when I moved more than a thousand miles away from the data center -- but I did work there before that.

I rather suspect that Wikipedia will be able to resist marketers, simply by keeping up with the state of the art. It's the single largest online open content project in the world, as far as I'm aware, not only in terms of sheer content volume, but in terms of the tremendous number of contributors and regular volunteers. Many of them are some really impressive intellects, and they've kept up with some surprising twists in the maliciousness and general not-playing-well-with-others-ness that has cropped up over the years, pretty much without missing a beat.

The biggest threats to Wikipedia are A) some of the core volunteers and employees, who occasionally do something like type [b]shutdown -h now[/b] into the wrong terminal (I'm kidding, mostly) and B) jackasses who have an axe to grind, and end up spending more time than can really be healthy running around prognosticating doom for the project as a whole and otherwise trying to discredit it.

Goldman has been talking about the shortcomings he sees in Wikipedia's operational model for an awfully long time now. I'm not sure whether he has hidebound notions of what does and does not work based on years of precedent set by massive bureaucratic organizations like ivy league universities, cannot imagine how a large project can be flexible and light-footed enough to meet the challenges that face it in the future, or is just jockeying for blogger fame and instant Internet reputation by attacking high-profile targets. Whatever the case, his positions on all things Wikipedian are pretty predictable in their negativity at all times.

Don't take anything he says about Wikipedia at face value. Reason through it for yourself, come to your own conclusions, and don't take his statements as any kind of authoritative analysis to support your conclusions (unless, perhaps, they relate to his core competencies in law somehow).

What the heck does a law professor -- an academic dedicated to a field entirely unrelated to the factors in Wikipedia's potential success or failure -- know about it, anyway? While you shouldn't disregard what he has to say just because his core professional skillset is not related, the fact that the article in question (along with other, earlier articles about him in relation to Wikipedia) uses his position as a law professor to try to impart a sense of authority on him is just absurd and, frankly, dishonest.

by dr dij

Didn't sound like it was going to happen, the spam / marketers arms race continues, and orgs, companies figure out how to cope.

This discussion then ends up being a kind of wiki-like consensus of whether this guy was out in left field. Even more bizarre predictions have happened such as 'demise of the PC', and Gartner's rant about old people in IT.

Thanks for the reply

by apotheon

Predictions of the imminent doom of Wikipedia keep sounding suspiciously like the legendary IBM prediction that there would one day be a world market for five computers. Five.

Yeah. I'm not too worried about Wikipedia right now.

by hhall1001

I just looked up the current rankings for Wikipedia. It is the 11th most popular site on the web. It has climbed to 11 from 15 in just the last three months. Death spiral?

DMOZ is being made irrelevant by it's own editors. Its traffic rank is trending downward but it is ranked as number 220 and that is still a super star.

by dr_zinj

Oh, don't get me wrong, there is a core of correct information on it, and it's not bad as a site that gives you a condensation of things to research a topic on.

But that's just it. It should NEVER be your end source for the information. Everything you find there MUST be independently confirmed elsewhere.

The nature of Wiki is that anyone can add junk, spam, errors, etc to a posting. A thousand opinions do not equal a single fact. And worse, actual facts entered by authoritative sources mysteriously disappear from Wikipedia. Don't beleive me? Go ask Dr Jerry Pournelle about corrections he's submitted on a post about his Pournelle Chart political model.

by apotheon

"[i]It should NEVER be your end source for the information. Everything you find there MUST be independently confirmed elsewhere.[/i]"
. . . just like any other encyclopedia in the world. So?

"[i]The nature of Wiki is that anyone can add junk, spam, errors, etc to a posting.[/i]"
The nature of Wikipedia is that the vandals are greatly outnumbered by well-meaning editors and built-in tools for monitoring large numbers of pages for POV and malicious edits make it trivial to counteract the negative effects of edit access by the general public.

by ejayhire

Rumors of Wikipedia's Death have been greatly exaggerated.

Please forgive me for borrowing Mr. Twain's quote, but Wikipedia is far from the sorry state of a "death spiral". Wikipedia has consistently found ways to address the problems they face and simultaneously maintain or increase their openness. ODP responds in the opposite manner by reducing the power of the public at large. This is a fundamental difference. Automated tools and human effort will continue to drive the usefulness and utility of Wikipedia.

Eventually this approach will be borrowed by a commercial search engine, and tiny "this is junk" and "this is irrelevant" buttons will appear next to search listings. Enough clicks will drive a page out of the top ranks.

by danno3

Adding 'this is junk' or 'this is irrelevant' options to listings would fail. Imagine a competitor simply auto-generating 'this is junk' or 'this is irrelevant' clicks against a higher-placed listing. Even if the search engines had a way of detecting such automation, then spoofing the IP would probably defeat that.

Does Wikipedia have any automation protection, such as requiring manual confirmation of a obscured text-image code, common on many secured sites? If not, then the spammers will win even sooner than than the predicted time.

So far, I have found Wikipedia to be quite useful and the spam content somewhat minimal, but unfortunately, on the increase. I agree with others who have posted that one must independently verify info.

by apotheon

"[i]Imagine a competitor simply auto-generating 'this is junk' or 'this is irrelevant' clicks against a higher-placed listing.[/i]"
Imagine that registered accounts might be necessary to view and use the junk button.

"[i]Does Wikipedia have any automation protection, such as requiring manual confirmation of a obscured text-image code, common on many secured sites? If not, then the spammers will win even sooner than than the predicted time.[/i]"
Right . . . because of course it's impossible that things might actually change at Wikipedia, if such is needed. The way things are now is the way they'll always be. Of course. In four years, when Wikipedia is predicted by Goldman to "collapse", it will still have made zero changes to the way it handles spam. Wikipedians are incapable of learning from experience and developing new ways of countering malicious use.

Oh, wait, that's not right. Maybe you just lack the ability to project forward about the possibility for the "good guys" to do good things.

"[i]I agree with others who have posted that one must independently verify info.[/i]"
. . . just like any other encyclopedia. What, you believe everything you read?

by vetch_101

I've got two Firefox plug-ins that do just that...
WOT (Web of Trust) - which works on the basis of users abilities to rate a page as safe or not... It finds all the links on a page and displays green, orange or red images next to the link so you know if you should click or not...
I'll be honest, it's still in beta and doesn't work that well as yet - but then that is probably because it needs more people supporting it - the more people, the better the data...

The other one is proprietary and McAfee SiteAdvisor. They run a load of tests on pages, and come to an arbitrary decision as to whether it is safe or not. Currently it is a better system than WOT, but WOT has more potential, if you ask me...

Just IMHO...

Jx

by zaferus

That those of us in the technology field adapt to change - both good and bad. The problem they have today bring in solutions, and counter threats of tomorrow.

Wikipedia is popular, as long as this continues it will survive.

Law changes slowly, and so do law professors.

by gsg

I love nothing better than surfing, and finding information on just about anything that pops into my head. I was ecstatic when I found out about Wikipedia, finally, I thought, here's a place with some good information. So, I start using it, and realize that it's the biggest piece of nonsense. Information is dead wrong half the time. Dates are wrong, people who died were listed either alive or with dates of death 5 years after they really died. If someone cites Wikipedia as a source, then to me, that's the same as saying, "My brother's wife's cousin's best friend's brother said so." It means less than nothing.

by apotheon

"[i]Information is dead wrong half the time.[/i]"
Let me guess -- you've used it twice, and found one error.

by noelrd

I found numerous mistakes, erroneus facts, wrong spellings, etc. Some were up for days before the assigned watchdog for the topic changed them. You really can't trust Wikipedia for accuracy!

by vetch_101

... Did it not occur to you that you could change them?

That's the whole point... No one knows everything, but everyone combined knows as close to everything as we can get...
If you believe you know better, then update it... You can certainly fix the spelling errors...

by rgeiken9

I have found a lot of valuable information on the Wikipedia site, and am considering contributing to help it stay operational. Probably the vast majority of the information that they have available is fairly accurate. There are always "Trash" merchants out there that who will try to destroy things. I personally would never add anything to a site like that unless it was truthful. Obviously when humans are involved, errors will be made. Some people will subvert the access to factual information through "peevishness", but if even 95% of what is out there is correct, it is valuable. If you have some concern about things that you find there, you can use Google or another search engine to verify information that you find at Wikipedia.

by urbanpagan

One thing I've learned from 12+ years playing on the net is that research on the net is probably the most useful thing as a starting point, or for confirmation of information, but not as a primary source. While I've used wikipedia, I have never relied on it as a primary or secondary source, simply because it is far too easy to slant any information on the site to the point where it becomes completely erroneous. Will it collapse? No. Will its use be encouraged? No. Will it be relevant? Only transiently at any one point in time, because the information it dispenses can change to quickly for it to be considered reliable.

by apotheon

Definitive source? You're kidding -- right?

One thing I've learned from 30+ years of playing around in the world is that there's no such thing as a "definitive source", and anyone pining for the halcyon days of perfect accuracy and reliable source material that doesn't need to be double-checked just because it was in print form is full of it.

"[i]it is far too easy to slant any information on the site[/i]"
Betcha there's more subtle slant on average in Encyclopedia Britannica than in Wikipedia.

"[i]the information it dispenses can change to quickly for it to be considered reliable.[/i]"
(sarcasm alert)
Don't you just hate it when something is up to date?

by rgeiken9

If what you want to know is factual information about non political things, then Wikipedia is a good source. The things that I have looked up at Wikipedia seemed to be accurate and well organized to provide me with the information that I want. Political information will always have a slant to it. If you want to know information about some locale, I would probably trust a lot of information that is given on the site. The question is whether there is any reason to slant the information. If anyone can edit the information there, then it will become more unreliable since some people are so sleazy that they would do things like that. I think that they are trying to make sure that people don't put false information there.

by apotheon

Wikipedia has a Neutral Point Of View policy within its community. The way that manifests is in a bunch of people patrolling the political and otherwise controversial topics, ensuring that when slanted opinion gets edited in it ends up A) clearly identified as a point of view that some people hold, but is not universal, and B) sourced to someone or something other than the person who edited it into the article.

by noelrd

First, not all knowledgable people use Wikipedia. Therfore, there is no "everyone combined". I cannot correct all the articles myself, even if I had all of that knowledge. I can't recommend or trust the accuracy, because other fools are out there distorting history, adding errors, violating copyrights, etc.

by vetch_101

I'm suggesting you edit the page that you came across that you know about, so that the next time someone gets to the page, they don't get incorrect info...
If everyone did that, then wiki would be more reliable than it already is. I personally think that wiki is pretty good for most technical articles I've come across. Less so for articles on things that people can have an opinion on... Still, as an encyclopedia I'd use it before I'd go looking anywhere else...

by benevolence

The point is, Wikipedia allows for the accumulation of shared knowledge, and as such provides us with yet another useful way to gather, compare, and improve knowledge.

If anyone sees an error, they should try an correct it... And everyone should just keep in mind that it is a changing and developing knowledge base.

by turnier

The Wikipedia concept to me was such a thing of beauty that I seriously considered dedicating a chunk of my time every week to research and then provide new or to update existing content (being a proofreader for Project Gutenberg is another example of an effort that I think similarly worthy).

I immediately despaired since it was obvious even from the start that a full gamut of abusers (from simple childish pranksters, to spamers, to dark perversly twisted souls... human nature being what it is) would be subverting the efforts of those as eager as I to collectively build this great resource. Although sadly restrictive, the evolution of "locking", the control by moderators, and future use of other features as discussed in this thread are what I think will allow this noble endevour to keep going in a maybe somewhat hampered but still positive direction.

The other thought that gave me pause was the consideration of keeping such a thing running over the long haul -- the needed resources would eventually grow (especially if integrity could be maintained and people really started to use it) to the point that something comercial (literally -- embedded commercials) would have to "creep in" in order to sustain something like this over the long term. I'm glad to see the donation approach has so far kept this bit of ugliness out of the picture... but for how long?

Real life has intervened and my original dreams of making significant contributions has had to take a back burner for a few years (and at this rate will probably not happen until retirement). What little time I've been able to devote has been mostly correcting or just adding a line or two to existing content. But hey -- drop by drop... eventually we have an ocean. I challenge all of you that have time to read and contribute to these forums to do the same.

by apotheon

"[i]the needed resources would eventually grow (especially if integrity could be maintained and people really started to use it) to the point that something comercial (literally -- embedded commercials) would have to "creep in" in order to sustain something like this over the long term.[/i]"
Actually, the Wikimedia Foundation gets tens of thousands of dollars in donations during funding drives -- more than $100k, typically. This money is all put to good use. As the number of users increases, so too does the number of dollars donated. Additionally, as Wikipedia grows, the number of other organizations offering free servers, bandwidth, and other services to help prop up Wikipedia with no strings attached also grows. I don't recall off the top of my head which organizations' offered donations were "secret" when I was working for the Foundation, so I won't name names in case of accidentally running afoul of promises to keep my yap shut, but suffice to say you'd definitely recognize some names if I did list them. Resources available to the project are not, in fact, a big problem. There's also the fact that the Foundation's founder, Jimmy Wales, benefits from spillover of Wikipedia fame to his private commercial endeavors, and a lot of money from those business enterprises gets stuffed back into the Wikimedia Foundation, and he still has a tidy profit left over.

by turnier

Great to hear! Let's hope this will allow a substantially long and healthy life for the project.

SoB: are you going to put a hoop over that trashcan? :-)

by apotheon

Another reader! Thanks for tuning in.

I probably won't put a hoop over the can, but who knows -- if someone gives me a trashcan basketball hoop for Christmas, I'll definitely use it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.