Discussion Locked

Will [u]My Workspace[/u] > [u]My Updates[/u] ever get fixed?

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The only time that "[u]All of your updates for the past 90 days[/u]" shows activity over any appreciable time span is when such activity on those Discussion/Questions to which one has subscribed is sparse indeed; at the present, it shows no more than 72 hours worth.

This problem was brought to TR's attention many, many moons ago, with the assurance that it would be fixed. Well, it still remains.

As is, it's of little use most of the time, making it difficult to locate Discussions/Questions with recent activity if one does not jump on them quickly.

While this may be of no great import to those who have the time to visit the site every day, and promptly respond to the post of others, there are those of us who do have other matters that require our attention.

For the sake of those of us who fall into the latter group, when can we expect this problem to be fixed?

45 replies

by nonapeptide

...in fact, I mentioned it in a previous post just a few hours ago ( https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=251270&messageID=2407254 ). Here goes... ::inhale::

Does the TR forums seem a bit clunky? Maybe even to the point of being detrimental? Before I go any further, let me say a few things:
1. The TR forums seem to have been doing just fine for quite some time now, so they can't be terribly broken.
2. TR is much more than just a forum for IT people (although I believe that that could be a much more valuable resource than it currently is).
3. TR staff have probably heard this before and have a good reason to be doing things the way the are being done right now.

It strikes me that there could be a significant improvement upon the intrinsic value and possibly monetary worth of the forums if it was a bit more, shall we say, traditional in its form (E.g. vBulletin, YABB, et. al.). As it stands now, its not very good at organizing new posts, or searching through past posts (unless I'm missing something; quite possible). We could discuss this topic further if need be.

Just thought I'd bring it up and see if I was the only one.

Of course, we could revert back to the Blue Board BBS system just for kicks. ;)

by deepsand

Nope, you've missed nothing. Sadly, you are spot on.

This, too, is an issue that has been previously discussed here, with both the particpation of TR staff and, at the least, their tacit agreement that such needed to be improved, with the result that ... nothing's really changed.

From those discussions I would to say that the ultimate PTB decided not to effect the changes that even the TR staff seemed to support, but to devote its resources elsewhere.

by absolutely

Something like this?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=251364&messageID=2407345

Me? Yes, I think the TR Forums are clunky. I have difficulty imagining method to this madness, but my impression is that the techrepublic pages [i]deliberately[/i] look like they a bit of something for everybody, tossed together without much attention to presentation, except to keep advertising and content separate but also arranged so that one cannot be accessed without viewing the other.

"It strikes me that there could be a significant improvement upon the intrinsic value and possibly monetary worth of the forums if it was a bit more, shall we say, traditional in its form (E.g. vBulletin, YABB, et. al.)."

Are you volunteering?

"2. TR is much more than just a forum for IT people (although I believe that that could be a much more valuable resource than it currently is)."

That looks like more than a suggestion to do the same things, only better. New product/service suggestion?

by nonapeptide

:: but my impression is that the techrepublic pages deliberately look like they a bit of something for everybody, tossed together without much attention to presentation, except to keep advertising and content separate but also arranged so that one cannot be accessed without viewing the other. ::

Yeah, I kinda thought that the layout was more for the advertisers benefit than the user's. Although, I've clicked the "Simply Hired" featured jobs about two dozen times in the last few months, so I guess it's working.

:: Are you volunteering? ::

To set it up single handedly? No. I've never done such a thing before and trying to do it for the first time on an Alexa top 500 site (rather, cnet is the top 500 site, but TR is affiliated) would be... unwise. I could be a beta tester though (that shouldn't be too tough). :)

:: That looks like more than a suggestion to do the same things, only better. New product/service suggestion? ::

If the forums were easier to use and had a more "forum" atmosphere I would think that that would encourage more participation and have the possibility to create an even better atmosphere thusly bringing more viewers and driving up ad revenue. However, I don't know how you would put ads in a forum to the same degree that the ads are included on the site right now. As I type, I'm staring at quite a number of ads that probably wouldn't elegantly translate into a forum. Unless an ad-bot was made that posted adds into a thread every 10 posts or so.

Of course, more viewers / participants means more password recovery questions... where'd I put that template...

by nonapeptide

Other forums treat links / mentions of their competitors sits with 'userdel'. With that in mind, trepidatiously mention:

Experts-Exchange.com

Wow. Their site is great. Lotsa admins / programmers / whatever there to answer questions. The points system would be pointless (pun only vaguely intended) for TR. However, the site layout is nice and it affords plenty of add space (I think). I don't know what forum software they use (never seen it before, might be in-house) but the general idea and layout is the best IMO. I've been to quite a few forums, and Ex-Ex, to me, stands above them all.

(edited for grammar)

by danlm

And scroll through each looking for responses.
My complaint.... Is this forum slowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww. Christ, I can hit any web site and have instant response... I hit TR, and it takes forever to change pages...

I always check by hitting other sites in a different tab... And they always load instantly... TR is dead dog slow.

Dan

by deepsand

Back then, they were strictly text, and were generated every 3 hours.

With the advent of the HTTP alerts being the default, the inability of the member to set the defaults for either the type of alert or its frequency, along with the shear uselessness of the function for managing ones subscriptions - search for a given Discussion/Question manually, from an ever changing randomly ordered list, make change(s) to 1 subscription only, do it all over again for another, etc., etc., etc. - even the e-mails are now of little use.

Truth be told, I'm becoming increasing pissed off with TR, with the result that I now generally visit here no more than 2 or 3 times per week.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

gods but those things stopped making any kind of sense. And Thunderbird doesn't like the links in them for some reason.

I now cruise via My Posts. But that's no good for returning Forums in which I'm interested in reading, but don't post to, and then die out. So then I have to cruise the posts of My Contacts.

Dang, but TR is not always user friendly. Too bad as it is one of the best sites for easy to understand information, interesting reading, heated discussion and great jokes.

by beth blakely

My best advice for you, Boxfiddler: Use the "Subscribe to this Thread" link to subscribe to any thread you want to track. (YOu can also subscribe by checking the "Notify me via email when new posts are added to this thread" box when you are posting to a thread.) Then use the "Discussions Subscribed To" & "Questions Subscribed To" filters on the "My Forum Posts" page to check on them. By default, you'll receive one email Alert daily with combined updates on those threads.

As for the other constructive criticism going on here, keep it up! I'll go ahead and tell you that there are significant changes coming to that area in the very near future. It's a project big enough that, when working at a large company like CNET who shares resources across properties, is coming right at the "speed of business." I humbly ask for your patience--and thoughts on what would make the site more useful to you--as we head into this project.

And now, back to my regularly scheduled weekend activities. ;-) Thanks and goodnight!

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I griped a bit, but obviously I like it here. Were it not for the kind folks here I would be a slave to Windows! And significantly less entertained. ;)

Thunderbird doesn't like the links in the 'Subscribe' and/or 'Email Alerts'. Won't open them. Yes, I can copy and paste and sometimes do.

The last format change to the email alerts was awful. Something got lost in the organizational format somehow. But I will check into them again to see if they 'make sense' these days.

It's not likely that I will go away anytime soon. Love it here!

Good night, and enjoy the rest of the weekend!

by jaqui

the biggest problem with the forum navigation started when TR did away with the category separation in the forums and went with the tags.

I'm sorry, but tags just do not work for getting RELEVANT content.
[ try hitting the linux tag, content in the result set about setting up MS Server???? for a windows only network is linux related or relevant??? ]

The multiple category aspect is occasionally useful, such as when an article about a security issue is cross platform, but generally one category is all any discussion needs.

danged typos. I really shouldn't post when it's the end of my day like this I guess.

by deepsand

the redesign of the site, and where reportedly going to be fixed as part of such redesign.

But, rather than simply and truely being fixed, they were replaced with similar functions that were even less user friendly!

This was clearly a redesign that put Form before Function. And, looking a many other web sites, I can't say that I'm surprised. But, considering that the PTB have long been involved with IT, I had expected much, much better than we got.

by beth blakely

Ha! Don't think it escapes my attention that you've started this nasty little discussion! That's it! *Writes "Deepsand" on bad list in red ink*

(Kidding, of course. You know I am intimitely aware of the good/bad about TR. It's very helpful to hear what parts of the site frustrate you but, more precisely, EXACTLY WHAT you're trying to do when you get that way.)

by deepsand

Between that and the show of affection, I feel redeemed. :8}

Now, go curl up with your favorite other, and have a pleasant night.

by absolutely

Ask The Management to tell you what IP Beth is posting from, and whether it matches mine. I'm sure they'll be racing one another to be the first to answer your question!

by beth blakely

Well, that was it. The post that finally pushed me over the edge. I am sitting here laughing my tail off at 2:11am. I have GOT to go to bed. 'Night y'all!

by deepsand

I thought perhaps you'd been transplanted to another time zone, but now, knowing that you're still in the same zone as am I, see that you're simply as insane as some of the rest of us.

Enjoy your down time.

by absolutely

what impression you've been trying to give the impressionable readers on Monday. Shame on you, deepsand!

by ontheropes

I use Thunderbird and have no problem opening the links in my email alerts. The current format of the alerts isn't an issue for me. I'm using the default settings in Thunderbird.

I'll just slide my gripe in right here:
The thing that irritates me the most about TR is when I use "Print/View all posts" and the whitespace disappears except for the first post in a discussion. For short posts it's not a problem. Longer posts turn into one big blob of words and I have to go back to regular/normal view to get the full benefit of the formatting in the reply.

by danlm

I just came here via the links in my email alerts.... Which I have set to text only.. Even though I know there is some html in there.

Don't know... Just an fyi.

Dan

by boxfiddler Hot topic

thanks. I probably have something set funny. And that usually happens when I am 'playing' at something new with computers.

edit: PS I agree with OTR re: Print/View All Posts. Can be very difficult to read sometimes. I usually have to increase the text-size to the point that titles run 2 lines and overlap member names.

by absolutely

or the south wall, of a building without an intercom system, smart-@ss!

Seriously, you might as well be talking to a wall. Oh, hey, same for me.

by tig2

And fairly steadily for some time. But there are other things that are first in line.

The site is engineered to be similar to the other sites that CNET owns and operates. There are good things, there are bad things. *sigh* Just like anything else.

Be patient with them. They're working on it.

by absolutely

In the past couple of weeks, I've come to the realization that I am not interested -- at all -- in a "forum" which relies on side banner advertisements. Quality products can prove their reputation and be sought by people who want the best. Shite needs to advertise.

by charliespencer

The Geek would just use them as source material for his next column; something like "Bambi eyes (ears, nose) an Ewok?"

sMoRTy would probably keep them in a jar of alcohol on his desk, or offer them as swag next time he's trying to con the membership into doing his work for him.

Beth might just like them if you served them soft boiled over toast, or maybe dipped in chocolate.

by absolutely

bitterness -- not to TR

Some good people drop by here.

TR software is crap, but the text of the members is pretty much all that matters to me, and that [apparently] is transmitted faithfully. However, TR's unresponsiveness to user feedback is typical of corporations paid by advertisement, not by customer. It's shite.

I call that realism, not bitterness.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

The 'Start a Discussion' and 'Ask a Question' links at the top of the Forums page quite likely appear to many people to be 1 button. They do to me.

It might be helpful to separate them and/or define the difference between them more noticeably. IOW, make them look like 2 different buttons so that deepsand can take a break from his dedicated endeavor to direct questioners to the questions forum. :)

by absolutely

I wonder if he's jealous of the scenario he invented. Nah, probably just the persistent server errors.

:-(

This discussion is closed to new replies.