Discussion Locked

Would you hire a reabilitated cracker?

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Would you hire a rehabilitated cracker?

Suppose you want to hire a security specialist, but he or she was convicted for using his or her skills for illegal purposes. Now lets suppose that was a long time ago and he or she claims to be rehabilitated. Would you hire him or her?

Now if you do, how would you make sure this acquisition doesn't backfire? I once read an article about a cracker that after he was behind bars more than once he used his second and third chance, and the equipment to do his work, to go back to illegal activity such as hacking into accounts to transfer large amounts of money and stuff like that. How would you prevent something like this from happening? Would you monitor every muscle is his or her body? Would you stand besides him or her and watch his or her every move? Or would you trust your new employee?

12 replies

by tech_wiz03

Why do you need to ask?!! In todays market with the number of honest professionals around, one would be a fool to think they can check and monitor the activities of a former convicted person. It's difficult enough to track the inadvertant actions of a honest person that just makes a mistake in proceedure. Go back to the basics: A computer is fast idiot! It does whatever the proceedures allow and faster than we can react or comprehend. In the hands of an idiot it does idiotic things fast .... remeber the old DOS command Format c:/s/u/v and erase *.* !!!

regards
rick

by cg it

I wouldn't. People of that ilk I lable "sensation junkies". They just plain love the sensation of whatever give em the rush [like hacking][I would venture its 99% control related] and have 0 impulse control over it. Sooner or later they will do it again.

by didikai

The question revolves around the position they were hired for.

To manage your corporate security?
NO. There are several issues:

1. Who says they are rehabilitated? How do you monitor the person you hired for their expertise at circumventing security. There is an old saying about setting the fox to guard the henhouse that comes to mind... You don't want to give out the keys to the kingdom.

2. Suppose, for a moment, that they ARE rehabilitated. Will they be treated the same as other employees? Or will management be reluctant to hold them to the same rules as other staff for fear of reprisals - even though the employee has never given them cause for concern and the fears are unfounded. Other employees will sense the inequality and resent it.

To train staff on hacking methods and countermeasures?

YES (probably). In this scenario, you can exercise much more control oover the employee. A training|test network should be set up that mirrors the actual network but is isolated from it. New security measures should be tested on the training network before implementing. Your "ethical hacker" should be given full access to the training netowrk but restricted access to the production network.

There would have to be over-riding security concerns before I would hire a reformed hacker, and I would constantly review the need. It would all depend on my assessment of the individual.

by howard_nyc

#1: he/she will know that their name will be the first spoke aloud in the event of anomalous events...

#2: if reform is genuine, he/she will be eager to prove it by reporting every infraction noticed

#3: although I would be uncomfortable working with such an individual if they have paid their debt to society, then you have to consider 'em just like everyone else... which means you cannot announce their criminal history at a staff meeting...

#4: how do you know that current staffers are not child molesters, money launders, drug dealers or hackers... who just haven't been caught as yet?

#5: ask HR for the enterprise policy on hiring convicted felons... if there is one and it forbids it, then the decision has been made for you... otherwise, you will now need to sit down with HR and write one prior to this hire... so it is ready for use...

let me know how it turns out...

by kimberly.henderson

Aldanatech,

We asked the experts to answer your question. We talked to Bill Wall, Chief Security Engineer at Harris Corporation; Christopher Faulkner, CEO of C I Host; Eric Schultze, Chief Security Architect for Shavlik Technologies; and Dave Bixler, Information Security Officer at Siemens Business Services. All four managers had very interesting takes on the subject. Their responses are here: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5100-6314_11-5278054.html.

Sincerely,

Kimberly Henderson
TechRepublic

This discussion is closed to new replies.